Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
- Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
- Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
- Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
- Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
- Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
- Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
- Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
- Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
- Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
- Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
- Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
- Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
- Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
- Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
- Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
- Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
- Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
When someone says "Buddhism teaches ...", we should ask: which Buddhism? In more than two thousand years the Buddha's path has spread across Asia and, in recent times, across the world. It has grown into schools and movements that differ in texts, practice and emphasis, as Christianity has grown into Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant families with many branches.
This lecture gives an outline, and only an outline. A short lecture cannot do justice to any one school, and we should not let an outline make us think we know a neighbour's faith. The aim is to learn the main names and ideas so that we can ask better questions. We will also notice a gap that every religion has, the gap between what its scholars write and what ordinary believers actually do.
What these 17 minutes give you
- Name the main streams of Buddhism and say, in a sentence each, what they emphasise.
- Explain the bodhisattva ideal in plain words.
- Describe meditation as practised in Theravada and Zen, and devotion as practised in Pure Land.
- Explain why philosophy and ordinary lived Buddhism can look different.
- State fairly the disagreement about comparing Pure Land devotion with Christian grace.
for by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God," — Ephesians 2:8
World English Bible
not of works, that no one would boast." — Ephesians 2:9
WEB
Christians often hear the word "grace" when they first learn that some Buddhists rely on the help of a great Buddha. The resemblance is striking, and it is the reason for caution. This passage states what grace means in Christian understanding. We read it here to keep the Christian meaning clear while we study another tradition, not to decide that the Pure Land idea is the same or different. That question comes at the end of the lecture, and readers disagree about it.
1. One tradition, many ways
Most Buddhists share certain foundations: the Buddha as the awakened teacher, the Four Noble Truths, the Three Jewels, impermanence and the hope of release from suffering. Beyond these, the streams differ. A common outline speaks of three large streams: Theravada, Mahayana and Vajrayana. The outline is useful and also rough, because within each stream the schools differ again, and people in the same temple may practise differently.
Think of this lecture as a map drawn on a napkin. It will help you find your way to the right door. It will not tell you what is inside the house.
2. Theravada: the way of the elders
Theravada means "the way of the elders". It looks to an early collection of texts written in the Pali language and to the example of the early community. It has been especially strong in Sri Lanka and in Southeast Asia, and today it is found well beyond them.
Many Theravada Buddhists emphasise the Buddha's own path: moral discipline, meditation and wisdom, aiming at nirvana. The ideal of the fully released person is the arhat ("worthy one"). Monks and nuns hold a special place, since their whole life is arranged for practice, and lay people support them with food and other needs. In return, lay people receive teaching and are said to gain . In many communities, young men spend a period of time as monks, and the temple is the centre of village life, with festivals, teaching and counsel.
Meditation is central in many Theravada settings. Two forms are commonly named: calming meditation, which steadies and quiets the mind, and insight meditation, which watches body, feelings and thoughts as they arise and pass, in order to see impermanence and no-self directly. In recent times, forms of this mindfulness practice have been taught widely outside Buddhist settings, often without the religious context.
3. Mahayana: the great vehicle and the bodhisattva
Mahayana means "great vehicle". It began to appear in the centuries around the start of the Common Era. It honours many additional texts, and it has been especially strong in East Asia. It is not one school but a wide family.
Its best-known ideal is the bodhisattva: a being who, out of compassion, chooses to seek awakening for the sake of all beings, and who delays final release in order to help others. A Mahayana Buddhist who takes the bodhisattva vow promises to work for the liberation of everyone. Many Mahayana Buddhists honour great bodhisattvas, figures of compassion and wisdom, who are thought to help those who call on them. Some Mahayana teachers describe the earlier ideal of the arhat as too narrow, as concerned with one's own release; Theravada Buddhists generally reply that this misdescribes their path, which includes compassion for all. A fair listener hears both and does not decide the dispute.
Mahayana thinkers developed deep philosophy. A famous teacher, Nagarjuna, who lived around the second century CE according to the usual dating, argued for emptiness: that nothing exists on its own, with its own independent nature, since everything depends on conditions. This extends the older teaching of dependent arising. Some Christians mishear "emptiness" as "nothingness", but for Mahayana philosophers it is closer to "nothing stands alone", and it is meant to free the mind from clinging.
Vajrayana, often called the "diamond vehicle" or Tibetan Buddhism in a broad sense, is usually counted as a form that grew out of Mahayana, with its own rituals, teachers and meditation practices. Some count it as a third stream, others as part of Mahayana. We name it so that you will recognise the word, and say no more here.
4. Zen: sitting and seeing
Zen is the Japanese name for a school that began in China, where it was called Chan, and in Korea it is called Seon. It stresses meditation and direct experience over study of texts. Its form of sitting meditation is simple: sit, breathe, and watch the mind. Some Zen schools also use a koan, a short riddle or story from a teacher, that cannot be answered by ordinary reasoning, in order to loosen the habit of grasping at concepts. Zen is known for its sparse art, tea ceremony, gardens and calligraphy, which grew from the same attention to the present.
Be careful with popular ideas of Zen. In the West, "zen" has become an advertising word for calm. A Zen practitioner may find this strange. Zen training is a demanding discipline, often within a community and under a teacher, and it is part of a Buddhist way, with ethics and vows. Many people who say they "like Zen" have not met it as a practice.
5. Pure Land: trusting a Buddha's vow
Pure Land Buddhism is a devotional stream of Mahayana, strong in East Asia. It centres on a great Buddha called Amitabha (in some languages, Amida). The teaching says that this Buddha made a vow long ago to receive into a "Pure Land", a realm of peace and clear teaching, those who call on him with trust. In such a place, the stories say, it is much easier to continue on the path to awakening. The usual practice is to recite his name, often in a short phrase, with a mind turned toward him.
For many ordinary Buddhists, this is a path of simple trust. One need not be a monk, a scholar or a master of meditation. Some Pure Land teachers speak of relying on the power of the Buddha's vow rather than on one's own strength. (A term sometimes used for this in Japanese is other power; the details differ among the schools.) For people who feel they cannot succeed by their own effort, this path can bring great comfort.
6. The gap between the book and the village
In every religion, the writing of scholars and the life of ordinary believers differ. This is true of Christianity too: a seminary lecture on grace is one thing; a woman lighting a candle for her sick son is another.
In Buddhist lands, many people do not spend their days studying no-self. Their Buddhism is the festival at the temple, the offering of flowers and incense, the visit to a monk for a blessing, prayer for a sick child, the funeral rites that carry a family through grief, and the merit one hopes to share with the dead. In some places, Buddhist practice is joined with older local customs and with other traditions, and the people themselves do not feel they are mixing separate things. Scholars may call a practice "folk" or "popular", but the words can sound condescending, and a believer may well say, "This is simply how we are Buddhist."
A Christian listener must therefore avoid two errors. One is to take a philosophy book and say, "This is what all Buddhists believe." The other is to take a visit to a temple and say, "These people do not understand their own religion." Ask, instead, "What does this mean to you?"
7. A caution about Pure Land and Christian grace
Here the Christian listener is tempted. Pure Land seems to say: you cannot save yourself, trust in a great being whose compassion rescues. That sounds like the gospel. Some Christian writers have noticed this, and some Pure Land followers have noticed it too.
This is a point where readers will not agree about what the resemblance means.
- Some hold that the likeness is real and important. They see in Pure Land trust in a compassionate power outside oneself a genuine echo of grace, perhaps a sign that people everywhere long for rescue by love, and they find it a good place for conversation. The strength of this view is that it honours a real feature of Pure Land devotion and opens friendship. Its weakness is that it can overlook what the devotion is trusting: not a creator who forgives sin, but a Buddha whose vow opens a way to awakening, within a Buddhist understanding of suffering and rebirth.
- Others hold that the resemblance is largely misleading. In Christian understanding, grace is God's own act in Jesus Christ, who died and rose, and its centre is forgiveness of sin and union with God. Pure Land devotion has a different object, a different problem and a different goal, and to call it "Buddhist grace" is to impose a Christian word. The strength of this view is that it protects both meanings. Its weakness is that it may ignore the real faith of Pure Land believers, who might say, "Of course our trust is a gift, and we are grateful."
- Many Buddhists themselves may say that they do not use the word grace and would not wish their devotion to be explained in Christian terms.
Again the requirement of this course is smaller than any single view: say what each tradition says in its own words; do not claim that they are the same; do not claim that they are unrelated; and ask the neighbour.
Diagram 1. A napkin map of the streams
In short
- Buddhism is one tradition with many streams; the main outline names Theravada, Mahayana and Vajrayana, and the outline is rough.
- Theravada stresses the early path, the monastic community, and calming and insight meditation; its ideal is the arhat.
- Mahayana honours the bodhisattva, who seeks awakening for the sake of all beings; Zen stresses sitting, and Pure Land stresses trust in Amitabha's vow.
- Ordinary Buddhist life often centres on festivals, offerings, blessing and funeral rites, not on philosophy.
- Readers disagree about whether Pure Land trust resembles Christian grace; in Christian understanding, grace is God's gift in Christ.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Bodhisattva | One who seeks awakening for the sake of all beings and helps them on the way. |
| Zen | A Mahayana school that stresses sitting meditation and direct experience; called Chan in China and Seon in Korea. |
| Pure Land | A devotional stream centred on Amitabha, whose vow receives those who trust and call on him. |
| The book and the village | In every religion, what scholars write and what ordinary believers do can look different. |
One sentence to remember Ask "which Buddhism, and what does it mean to you?" before saying what Buddhists believe.
This week's action Pick one stream from this lecture and write three questions you could ask a neighbour of that stream, none of which compares it with Christianity.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why is "Buddhism teaches ..." a risky way to begin a sentence? What would you say instead?
- A Mahayana friend says the bodhisattva chooses to remain in the world to help others. How would you ask about this without turning it into a comparison with Christ?
- What is the difference between hearing about Zen in a book and a person who sits every morning in a Zen community? Why does the difference matter for listening?
- The lecture gives two fair accounts of what Pure Land trust and Christian grace have in common. Say each in the form its defenders would use, and then name its weakness.
- What is one question you could ask a neighbour about what a festival or an offering means to her?