Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
- Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
- Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
- Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
- Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
- Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
- Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
- Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
- Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
- Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
- Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
- Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
- Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
- Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
- Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
- Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
- Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
- Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
Most Christians who have heard of Buddhism have heard four strange-sounding words: no-self, karma, rebirth and nirvana. They are often explained badly, in a sentence or two, by people outside the tradition. This lecture slows down. It explains each idea as a thoughtful Buddhist would, in plain terms, and then asks, in separate paragraphs marked as the Christian view, where Christian ideas of the soul, sin, grace and resurrection meet these ideas and where they part.
The lecture has one task that matters more than the rest: to keep the two vocabularies apart. A Buddhist word and a Christian word may look alike (self, suffering, freedom, hope) and still belong to different systems of thought. Treating them as translations of each other is one of the most common mistakes, and it hurts both sides.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Explain impermanence and the Buddhist idea of no-self in plain words, and say what problem the idea is meant to solve.
- Explain dependent arising and how it connects to craving and suffering.
- Explain karma as Buddhists describe it, and say how it differs from fate and from a divine judge.
- Describe nirvana as Buddhists describe it, and name the ways Buddhists differ in describing it.
- State fairly the different views about how far Buddhist and Christian ideas can be compared.
Vanity of vanities,” says the Preacher; “Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.” What does man gain from all his labor in which he labors under the sun? One generation goes, and another generation comes; but the earth remains forever." — Ecclesiastes 1:2-4
World English Bible
That which has been is that which shall be; and that which has been done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun." — Ecclesiastes 1:9
WEB
For I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which will be revealed toward us." — Romans 8:18
WEB
For we were saved in hope, but hope that is seen is not hope. For who hopes for that which he sees? But if we hope for that which we don’t see, we wait for it with patience." — Romans 8:24-25
WEB
Ecclesiastes looks at a world where everything passes and asks what is gained. Many readers hear a note that a Buddhist would recognise: nothing here lasts. The Hebrew word translated "vanity" can mean a breath or a puff of vapour. But Ecclesiastes belongs to a different whole, in which God is the creator and the giver of life. Romans 8 turns from passing things to hope: suffering is real, and it is not the last word. We use these passages as a place to stand, not as proof that the two traditions are alike.
1. Everything passes: impermanence
Buddhist teaching begins with a plain observation: everything that comes into being passes away. Bodies age. Feelings rise and fade. Thoughts do not stay. Friendships, jobs, mountains, even the stars change. This is called impermanence. Together with suffering and no-self, it is one of the "three marks" that Buddhists say belong to all conditioned things.
On its own, the observation seems almost too obvious. The Buddhist claim is about what we do with it. We cling to things as though they would stay, and we are hurt when they do not. So the problem is not that things change; it is that we hold on as if they did not.
2. No-self
The idea that causes the most puzzlement is no-self (the traditional word is anatta, "not-self"). It is easy to misunderstand. It does not mean that you do not exist, that you have no name, or that nothing you do matters. Buddhists are not saying, "You are an illusion, so do not worry about your neighbour." Almost the opposite: the teaching is used to loosen the grip of selfishness.
Here is how many Buddhist teachers explain it. When we look closely at what we call "I", we find several things that change: a body; feelings of pleasure and pain; perceptions; habits and impulses of will; and awareness itself. The tradition groups these as the five aggregates. We keep looking for something permanent under them, a fixed core that stays the same from childhood to old age, and the teaching says we do not find one. What we call "I" is a flowing process that is real as a process, but is not a separate, unchanging thing.
A famous ancient dialogue, told in paraphrase, compares a person to a chariot. There is no "chariot" apart from its wheels, axle and frame; yet when they are put together, we can truly say a chariot rolled down the road. In the same way, a person is real as a pattern of parts and conditions, not as a hidden unchanging owner behind them.
Why does this matter to Buddhists? Because, in their account, clinging to a fixed "I" is the root of much suffering. If I think of myself as a permanent thing that must be protected, praised and secured, I will fear loss and strike out at others. Seeing that the self is not a fixed possession loosens fear and pride, and opens the way to compassion. This is what the teaching is for.
A fair listener will also hear that Buddhists differ. Some later schools speak of "Buddha-nature", the capacity for awakening that is in all beings, and they use more positive language. Others stress emptiness, the claim that nothing has a self-contained, independent nature. These are different developments of one concern, and the next lecture touches on them.
3. Dependent arising
If there is no fixed core, how do things happen? The Buddhist answer is called dependent arising (or "dependent origination"). Everything arises in dependence on conditions, and when the conditions change, the thing changes. A flame depends on fuel, air and a spark. A feeling of anger depends on a perception, a memory and a habit. Nothing arises out of nowhere, and nothing stands alone.
The Buddha is said to have set out a chain of links, in which ignorance leads to habits of will, then to awareness, craving, clinging and so on, down to birth, ageing and death. Buddhists often draw it as a wheel. The point is practical: because suffering arises from conditions, it can end when the conditions are removed. If craving is cut, the chain does not go on in the same way. So dependent arising explains both why suffering continues and why release is possible.
4. Karma
Karma means "action". In Buddhist use it refers to willed, intentional action of body, speech and mind, and the results that follow from it. A good intention and deed tends, over time, to bear good results; a harmful one tends to bear harm. Many Buddhists emphasise that what matters most is the intention behind the act.
Three points help to prevent misunderstanding.
First, karma is not fate. Buddhists commonly say that a person is shaped by past actions but is not locked into them; one can act differently now. Second, karma is not a god's judgement. No one sits in heaven keeping score and handing out penalties. It is described as a law of cause and effect, like the way a seed grows into its own plant. Third, ordinary Buddhist life uses the word in many ways. A person may say, "That is my karma" about a sorrow; a teacher may say it is a reason to be kind to someone suffering, and not a reason to blame them. Buddhist teachers themselves warn against using karma as an excuse for coldness.
In popular practice, many Buddhists also speak of : good deeds, such as giving food to monks, which build up goodness and may be shared with the dead or with the living. The details differ from country to country and family to family.
5. Rebirth
Most Buddhist traditions teach rebirth: the cycle of birth, death and , called samsara, driven by craving and karma. This raises an obvious question: if there is no fixed self, what is reborn? Buddhist teachers commonly answer with an image. A candle lit from another candle is not the same flame, and not an entirely different one. There is continuity of cause without a permanent thing that passes across. Some Buddhists, especially in modern settings, hold rebirth loosely or read it as a way of speaking about the continuing effects of our choices. Others hold it firmly, as a basic fact. Buddhists differ, and we should ask rather than assume.
6. Nirvana
The goal of the path is nirvana (in Pali, nibbana). The word comes from the picture of a fire going out. Buddhists explain that what goes out is the fire of greed, hatred and delusion. Nirvana is therefore the end of craving and of the cycle of rebirth that craving drives. Those who have reached it are described as being at peace.
Is nirvana a place? A state of mind? Nothingness? Here Buddhists are careful. The early texts speak of it as the ending of suffering and as the highest happiness, and they say it cannot be fully described in ordinary words. Buddhists generally deny that it means annihilation in the sense of a person simply being wiped out, and they also deny that it is a heaven where a self goes on enjoying things. Different schools describe it differently. For one reading it is the quiet end of an exhausting round; for another it is a freedom already present in every moment, when seen clearly.
7. The attitude to a creator
Buddhist teaching does not include a creator who made the world and rules it. Many Buddhists would say the question is simply not the point: they are not denying God by a long argument, they are saying that the path does not run through such a belief. Some Buddhist thinkers over the centuries did argue against the idea of a creator, and some Buddhists today say plainly that they do not believe in God. Others, beside Christian neighbours, say, "Believe what helps you to be kind." Again, we ask.
8. Where Christian understanding meets and parts
Now the Christian side, clearly marked. In Christian understanding:
- The person is created by God, known and loved by name, and bears the . A person is not a passing pattern but a unique someone, whose life matters in every part. Christians generally hold that human beings have lasting worth and are called into relationship with God.
- The body is good, made by God. The Christian hope is not an escape from the body, but resurrection: Christ rose bodily, and Christians hope for the renewal of their bodies and of creation (Romans 8:18-25).
- Sin is not only craving or ignorance. It is disobedience and brokenness before God and a wounded relationship with neighbours, and it needs forgiveness, not only insight.
- Grace is God's free gift. Christians do not save themselves by their own effort or progress. They are rescued, and they respond.
- Suffering is real and is not explained away. Christians keep a place for lament, and they believe God has entered the world's suffering in Christ, and that suffering will not have the last word.
Beside this, a Buddhist neighbour might point out, with justice, that Christians have sometimes spoken of the self in ways that make pride and attachment worse, and that Buddhist practice gives careful tools for loosening them. Some Christians will agree and will find in Buddhist writing a challenge to examine their own clinging. A word of caution: to learn from a neighbour's wisdom is not to change the other's meaning.
This is a point where readers will not agree: how far Buddhist and Christian ideas can be compared.
- One view holds that the traditions touch deeply. The letting go of the self in Buddhism, they say, resembles the Christian call to lose one's life to find it, and the Buddhist stress on compassion resembles love of neighbour. Thinkers who hold this see the traditions as complementary, even as two answers to the same human depth. The strength of this view is that it takes seriously real moral and spiritual overlap and encourages friendship. Its weakness, say critics, is that it can erase the different claims about God, sin and rescue, and it can ask each side to give up what it most cares about.
- A second view holds that the resemblances are on the surface. The problem, the goal and the means are different, so a Christian "love" and a Buddhist "compassion", or Christian "hope" and Buddhist "release", should not be treated as the same thing. Many Christians who hold this are concerned about faithfulness to the gospel; many Buddhists agree that the systems are not the same and prefer to be heard as they are. The strength of this view is its honesty about difference. Its weakness is that it can make the other tradition seem entirely foreign, so that no real learning or friendship is possible.
- A third view holds a middle path: some comparisons are fruitful for conversation, others mislead, and each pair must be tested one at a time, in the neighbour's own words. Its weakness is that it gives no simple rule.
Catholic teaching, as expressed at the Second Vatican Council, recognises that Buddhism in its various forms teaches about the changing nature of the world, and that the Church rejects nothing that is true and holy in other religions, while it continues to proclaim Christ. Protestant and Orthodox writers speak in a range of ways, from warm recognition of moral wisdom to firm warnings that only Christ saves. These are the voices of a real family disagreement. We will meet them again in week 6.
What this course requires is less than any one view requires. It requires that you do not call the two systems the same, and do not call them unrelated, before you have listened. When you use a comparison, say that it is a comparison, and offer it as a question, not a verdict.
Diagram 1. Same words, different systems
In short
- No-self does not mean a person does not exist; it means there is no fixed, unchanging core, and the teaching is meant to loosen clinging and pride.
- Dependent arising says things arise from conditions, so suffering can end when its conditions end.
- Karma is willed action and its results, not fate and not a god's judgement; rebirth is held in several ways.
- Nirvana is the ending of craving and rebirth, described differently by different schools.
- In Christian understanding the person is created and loved by God, sin needs forgiveness, grace is a gift, and hope is resurrection.
- Readers disagree about how far Buddhist and Christian ideas can be compared.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| No-self | The teaching that there is no fixed unchanging core in a person; used to loosen clinging and pride. |
| Dependent arising | Everything arises in dependence on conditions; so suffering ends when its conditions end. |
| Karma | Willed action and its results; not fate and not a god's judgement. |
| Nirvana | The ending of craving and of rebirth, described in different ways by different schools. |
One sentence to remember Keep the two vocabularies apart: a word that sounds alike may belong to a different system.
This week's action Choose one of the four ideas and explain it aloud, in two minutes, as a Buddhist would, without any comparison.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- How would you explain "no-self" to a friend without saying that a person does not exist? What problem is the idea meant to solve?
- Karma is not fate and not a judge. Why does this matter when a neighbour says, "That is my karma"?
- The lecture says nirvana is described differently in different schools. Why is it wise to ask a Buddhist neighbour how she would describe it?
- Which of the three views on comparison (deep overlap, surface resemblance, test each pair) is closest to your own? What is its weakness, in the strongest form its opponents would put it?
- Name one word that Christians and Buddhists both use (for example refuge, hope, self, freedom). What might the word mean in each system?