Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
- Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
- Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
- Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
- Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
- Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
- Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
- Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
- Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
- Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
- Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
- Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
- Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
- Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
- Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
- Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
- Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
- Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
Lecture 1-1 gave the reasons for studying our neighbours' faiths. This lecture gives the method. The method has one rule: listen first, in the neighbour's own terms, and take the tradition at its best. Only after that do we compare, and only after that do we say what Christians believe in reply.
The skill is old, but it has a modern name: steel-manning. A "straw man" is a weak copy of a view that is easy to knock down. A "steel man" is the opposite: the strongest, fairest form of a view, the form its best defenders would recognise. To steel-man a faith is to describe it so well that a thoughtful member says, "Yes, that is us."
The lecture also teaches four cautions. Every tradition has many voices inside it. What a tradition hopes for and what its members actually do are not the same. The English word "religion" fits some traditions badly. And not every source we might read is equally reliable.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain the difference between a straw man and a steel man, and apply the test "would a thoughtful member say yes, that is us?"
- Explain why a faith should be described first in its own terms, and why compare comes second.
- Describe the inner diversity of a tradition and the difference between its ideal and its lived practice.
- Explain why the word "religion" does not fit every tradition equally well.
- Weigh at least four kinds of source about another faith, naming a strength and a weakness of each.
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
World English Bible
He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17
WEB
But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear: having a good conscience; that, while you are spoken against as evildoers, they may be disappointed who curse your good way of life in Christ." — 1 Peter 3:15-16
WEB
Proverbs 18:13 warns against answering before hearing. Proverbs 18:17 observes that the first account of a matter can sound right until another person asks questions. This is a reminder that our first account of a neighbour's faith, which we got from one source, needs testing. First Peter 3:15-16 speaks of answering those who ask about our hope with humility, and elsewhere in the same passage with a good conscience. It describes the manner in which Christians are to speak, which matters as much as what they say.
1. The first rule: let the neighbour describe the faith
Suppose someone who has never met you describes your faith to a room of strangers. They use their own words and their own categories, and they compare your faith with theirs. Even if they mean well, you are likely to hear a number of small errors. They stress what seems strange to them. They leave out what you find most important. They explain you by what they think is the cause, not by what you say is the reason.
This happens whenever one group describes another from the outside. It does not require bad will. It is the natural result of standing in a different place.
The first rule of this course is therefore simple: before we describe a faith, we ask how its members describe it. We call this the faith's self-understanding. When a Muslim says what Islam is, when a Buddhist says what the path is, when a Hindu says what the tradition holds, when a secular neighbour says what they live by, we begin there. We do not begin with how it appears to us, or with how our own tradition would classify it.
This does not mean that the self-understanding is the last word. Outsiders can see things that insiders overlook, and a scholar's account may be fuller than a member's. But the self-understanding is the first word, because without it we do not know what we are looking at.
2. Straw man and steel man
A straw man is a weak version of a view, made so that it can be defeated. People do it with other faiths often, and often without knowing. Here are four common ways (an invented example in each case).
- The worst against the best. A speaker holds up the best of Christian life (a saintly nurse, a generous pastor) against the worst of another faith (a crime, a harsh custom) and concludes that Christianity is better. This is unfair in either direction. It is just as unfair when someone holds up the best of another faith against the worst of Christians.
- The one voice. "Muslims believe..." as if every Muslim believed it. "Christians believe..." is often a similar overstatement, and Christians dislike hearing it.
- The odd detail. A speaker picks the most unusual practice and offers it as if it were typical.
- The wrong question. A speaker explains a Buddhist or Hindu idea as if it were answering a Christian question, such as "Who is your god and how do you get saved?", when the tradition may be asking a different question.
A steel man does the opposite. It states the view in its strongest and fairest form: the form that its most thoughtful defenders would give, with their reasons. Here is a short (invented example) of the difference. A speaker is describing why many people in a neighbour's tradition take a daily practice seriously.
Straw man: "They go through empty rituals because they think it earns points."
Steel man: "Many members say the daily practice is how they keep in mind what matters most. It is the shape of their day, as well as an act of devotion, and it ties them to their family and to those who have gone before."
The second version may not be complete. Yet it is the kind of sentence a member could read and say, "Yes, that is part of it."
3. The test: would a thoughtful member say, "Yes, that is us"?
This test is the heart of the method. After you have written or said a description of a faith, ask: if a thoughtful member heard this, would they say, "Yes, that is us," even if they would add more?
Notice what the test does not ask. It does not ask whether the member would agree with your conclusions about the faith. It does not ask whether they would find your description complete. It asks only whether they would recognise it as an honest account.
If the answer is no, then you have either made a mistake or you have described the faith in terms the member rejects. In both cases you should change the description before you go on. The test may be applied in practice, if the member is willing to read what you have written. It may also be applied in imagination, by thinking of a particular person and asking how they would take it. When you cannot imagine a member recognising your description, treat that as a warning.
There is a second point. The test works in both directions. Christians should ask the same of how their neighbours describe the Christian faith. We can only fairly ask others to meet this standard if we meet it ourselves.
4. Steel-manning is not agreeing
Some readers will worry that to describe another faith at its best is to praise it, or to give up one's own. It is neither.
Understanding is not agreement. A teacher can explain a view she does not hold, in a way its holders accept, and still disagree. Disagreement after understanding is a more honest disagreement than one before it. Both sides know what they are disagreeing about.
Steel-manning is not hiding difference. In a later week we shall state where Christian belief and a neighbour's belief differ, sometimes sharply. We will not blur those differences. We will say them after we have listened, and we will say them in terms the neighbour can recognise.
Steel-manning is not flattery. It is not a pretence that every part of a tradition is admirable. Each week also includes the difficulties and the criticisms that members themselves raise. Taking a tradition seriously includes taking its internal arguments seriously.
5. Inside every tradition there are many voices
A tradition is not a person. It is a very large conversation across centuries and countries. Within it you will find scholars and ordinary believers, reformers and defenders of old ways, people who stress one text and people who stress another, and people who belong in name or in culture but not in practice.
Because of this, we shall avoid sentences like "Buddhists believe X" when the truth is more complicated. We shall write "many Buddhists understand...", "some schools teach...", "many Muslims say...". These phrases are not hedges for the sake of caution. They are accurate. A sentence that hides the diversity is a form of straw man, however friendly its tone.
When you are talking with an actual neighbour, remember that one person is one voice. Do not ask a neighbour to speak for everyone who shares the faith, and do not assume that what one neighbour says is what the whole tradition says. At the same time, do not dismiss what they say as "only one person's view." For you, in that conversation, it is a first-hand witness of how the faith is lived.
6. Ideal and lived practice
Every tradition has an ideal, and every tradition is lived by people who fall short of it or interpret it differently. This is true of Christianity as well. A church may teach that all are welcome, and a visitor may feel unwelcome. A creed may state a doctrine, and an ordinary member may hold a vaguer belief.
When we study another faith, we should be careful to say which we mean. "The teaching is..." describes the ideal as the tradition's teachers state it. "Many people in practice..." describes how it is lived. And we should treat the two in the same way for every tradition, including our own. It would be unfair to compare Christianity's ideal with another faith's practice, or the reverse.
Regional and cultural difference also matters. A faith lived in one country, one language and one family may look different from the same faith elsewhere. A neighbour may be hearing the tradition through a grandmother's customs, which may differ from what a scholar writes. Both are real.
7. The word "religion" and its limits
The English word "religion" is a tool, and like any tool it fits some jobs better than others. In everyday English it often suggests a picture: belief in a god or gods, a holy book, a body like a church, a set time of worship, a creed to affirm. This picture has been shaped by the history of Christianity, particularly in Europe.
Many traditions fit this picture partly or not at all.
- Many Buddhists describe their tradition as a path and a practice for freeing the mind from suffering. They do not centre it on a creator god. We shall look at this in week 3. For now, notice that to ask, "Who is the Buddhist God?" may be the wrong question.
- Many Hindus say that their tradition has no single founder, no single creed and no single central body. Some prefer the word dharma, a word that can mean right order, duty, or the way of life. We shall look at this in week 4.
- Many Muslims say that Islam is not one part of life beside work, family and law, but a way that is meant to cover the whole of life. We shall look at this in week 2.
- Many secular neighbours would say the word does not apply to them at all, though they have deep convictions about how to live.
The lesson is not to throw away the word. It is to hold it loosely. When we say "religion" we should remember that we are using a Western-shaped word, and that the person we are speaking with may not use it, or may use it differently. It is often better to ask, "How would you describe what matters most in your life and your community?"
8. Weighing the sources
Where do we learn about another faith? The sources differ in what they do well and what they do badly. Here are five. Use more than one.
| Source | A strength | A weakness |
|---|---|---|
| A practising member, in conversation | First-hand; shows how the faith is lived | One voice; may not know the scholarly background; may not wish to speak for others |
| A teacher or scholar who is a member | Knows the texts and history, and the inner view | May write for fellow members, or favour one school within the tradition |
| A scholar who is not a member but studies with respect | Wide knowledge; can compare; often explains clearly | May describe in categories the tradition itself would not use |
| A summary by Christians | Written with our questions in mind | Often shaped by what the writer wants to show; check it against a member's own account |
| A summary by those hostile to the faith | Can identify real difficulties | Usually fails the test of "yes, that is us" |
Add to this a sixth caution: material found online. It may be accurate and very good, or it may be written by someone angry. Ask who wrote it and why.
One more point. The first account of a matter can sound right until someone else asks questions (Proverbs 18:17). If you have read only one account of a faith, you have not yet heard it. Read, if you can, a member's account and an outsider's account, and notice where they agree, where they differ, and why.
9. A worked example
Imagine a church leader preparing a talk about a neighbour's faith (an invented example). She has three pages from a Christian pamphlet. She asks five questions of it.
- Who is speaking? A Christian author, writing for Christian readers.
- Would a thoughtful member say, "Yes, that is us"? She is not sure. She asks a neighbour she knows if he is willing to read a paragraph. He says two sentences are right, and one is not how he would put it.
- Does the pamphlet speak of one voice or many? It says "all of them believe..." She changes it to "many of them say...".
- Does it set our best against their worst? One page does. She removes it.
- What does she not know? She lists three questions to ask.
Her talk is shorter and humbler. It is also truer. That is the aim.
Diagram 1. The test: "Yes, that is us"
In short
- Describe a faith first as its members describe it; this is its self-understanding.
- A straw man is a weak copy made to be defeated; a steel man is the strongest fair form.
- The test is whether a thoughtful member would say "Yes, that is us."
- Steel-manning is not agreeing, not hiding differences and not flattery.
- Every tradition has many voices; separate its ideal from its lived practice; compare best with best.
- The word "religion" fits some traditions badly; weigh sources and use more than one.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Steel man | The strongest, fairest form of a view, the form its best defenders would recognise. |
| The test | Would a thoughtful member say, "Yes, that is us"? |
| Ideal and lived practice | What the tradition teaches, and how its members actually live; treat all traditions alike on this. |
| Why use several sources | Each source has a strength and a weakness; the first account can sound right until questioned (Proverbs 18:17). |
One sentence to remember Describe your neighbour's faith so well that your neighbour would say, "Yes, that is us."
This week's action Choose one sentence you have said or heard about another faith, and rewrite it so that a thoughtful member could accept it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time when someone described your faith or your community and got it wrong. What did they get wrong? What would a steel man of your faith have said?
- What is the difference between "I understand this view" and "I agree with this view"? Why does the difference matter for a Christian?
- Which of the four ways of making a straw man (worst against best, one voice, odd detail, wrong question) is hardest for you to avoid?
- How might the word "religion" mislead you about a neighbour's faith? What question could you ask instead?
- Where have you learned most of what you know about another faith? Which of the five sources in the table is it closest to, and what would you do to balance it?