FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL4E World Religions and the Theology of Religions: Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Secularism

Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case

Contents 31
STEL4E World Religions and the Theology of Religions: Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Secularism
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Understanding Before Answering
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Understanding Before Answering
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Meeting a Neighbour's Faith
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
  2. Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
  3. Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
  4. Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Islam
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
  2. Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
  4. Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Buddhism
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
  2. Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
  3. Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
  4. Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Hinduism
  1. Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
  2. Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
  3. Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
  4. Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Secularism and the Argument over Evidence
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
  3. Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
  4. Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Theology of Religions and Life with Neighbours
  1. Lecture 6-1: Exclusivism, Inclusivism, Pluralism: Reasons and Weaknesses
  2. Lecture 6-2: The Uniqueness of Christ and the Question of Salvation
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Ethics of Dialogue and Witness
  4. Lecture 6-4: What Remains Open: Conviction and Humility
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Page for Neighbours

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

A thoughtful neighbour without religion usually has reasons. They are not usually rude or shallow reasons. They are the same questions that serious believers have asked, in sleepless nights, for as long as there have been believers. This lecture sets out five of them in the form that a careful secular person would recognise: the problem of evil and suffering, the question of what counts as enough evidence, the fact of religious diversity, harm done in the name of religion, and natural explanations of belief. For each we give the strongest case first. Then we describe how believers have answered, and where each answer is weak.

The aim is not to win. It is to be able to say, to a neighbour who holds one of these arguments, "I understand why you think so, and I can state your reason as well as you can." Whether the argument succeeds is a larger question, and a course on apologetics, Christian Apologetics (STEL1E), takes it up in depth. This lecture is about hearing.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • State each of the five arguments in a form a secular neighbour would accept as fair.
  • Describe at least two kinds of answer that believers give to the problem of suffering, and the weakness of each.
  • Explain why "what counts as enough evidence" is itself a disputed question, and give each side.
  • Explain why harm done in the name of religion is an honest question for believers and not only an attack.
  • Say what the course requires of a Christian in these conversations, in the paragraph on points where readers will not agree.

Then Yahweh answered Job out of the whirlwind," — Job 38:1

World English Bible

Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth? Declare, if you have understanding." — Job 38:4

WEB

Yahweh, how long will I cry, and you will not hear? I cry out to you “Violence!” and will you not save?" — Habakkuk 1:2

WEB

Now faith is assurance of things hoped for, proof of things not seen." — Hebrews 11:1

WEB

The Bible does not hide the questions. Habakkuk puts the cry of the sufferer into the mouth of a prophet and leaves it there. Job asks for an answer and is met with a question. Hebrews 11:1 names faith as assurance and conviction about what is not seen, which is not the same thing as having no questions. A Christian who reads these passages honestly cannot tell a secular neighbour that her questions are forbidden.

1. How to read this lecture

For each argument we keep four parts apart. First, the strongest case, as its holder would put it. Second, the answers that believers give: Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant voices differ, and we do not name one as correct. Third, the weakness we honestly see in those answers. Fourth, what the argument asks of a listener. Parts one and three are description. Where we say "In Christian understanding", we are describing what Christians hold, not what a neighbour must accept.

2. The problem of evil and suffering

The strongest case. A neighbour might say: "If there were a God who is all-powerful and entirely good, there would be much less suffering than there is. Children are born with terrible illness. Whole communities are destroyed by floods and famines, and no person did it. A loving parent who could stop the suffering of a child and did not would not be called good. So either God cannot, or does not wish to, or is not there. The simplest explanation is that there is no such God." Some who say this are not arguing but grieving: they have watched someone they love suffer, and the old words no longer hold. An old form of the argument is sometimes linked to the ancient Greek thinker Epicurus, though scholars doubt that he put it in the form usually quoted.

Answers believers give. There are several, and they are not the same.

Free will. God gave human beings freedom, and a world in which people can truly love must be a world in which they can also truly harm. This answer is widely held among Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant Christians. Its weakness is that it speaks to harm done by people, and less clearly to illness, earthquakes and the suffering of animals; and some ask whether any freedom is worth the price of a child's pain.

A world in which persons grow. Some Christian thinkers hold that a world with real stakes lets persons grow in character, courage and love. The weakness is that suffering often seems to crush people instead of building them, and it is hard to say this to a person who is in pain without insult.

Mystery. Some answer that we do not know God's reasons and that a finite mind should not expect to. Job is often read in this way. The weakness is that this can sound like a refusal to answer, and a neighbour may hear it as a way of closing the question.

God suffers with us. In Christian understanding, God in Christ has entered human suffering and has not stood far off. This is not offered as an explanation but as a presence. The weakness, for the neighbour, is that it does not say why suffering exists at all; and for the sufferer it may not feel like help until someone has been kind.

Hope of a final healing. Christians hold that suffering and death do not have the last word, and that God will make things right. The weakness is that it asks the neighbour to accept a promise she cannot check.

What the argument asks of a listener. Do not answer too fast. Many of the people who raise this argument are carrying a grief. The first reply is not a theory; it is to sit down and hear. Anyone in distress should be pointed to a trusted pastor or priest and to local help (your local emergency number if there is danger now). This course gives no method for any self-harm.

3. What counts as enough evidence

The strongest case. A neighbour might say: "In every other part of life I ask for evidence that can be checked. I do not accept a claim because it is old, or because many people believe it, or because it feels right to me. For an extraordinary claim, such as a being who made the universe or a man who rose from the dead, I want strong evidence that others can test. The reports we have are from believers writing long ago. I do not say they lied. I say that this is not enough to build a life on." Some philosophers, among them the eighteenth-century thinker David Hume, argued in this way about reports of miracles.

Answers believers give. Some say that the world itself, the order of nature, moral awareness and the existence of anything at all are evidence for God; the argument continues in STEL1E. Some say that the evidence for the resurrection of Jesus is historical and can be weighed like other history. Some say that the demand for a certain kind of proof, such as a laboratory test, does not suit a question about a person, since we know persons by trust and acquaintance and not by measurement. Others, including many Pentecostal and Orthodox voices, speak of experience of God in prayer and worship as a kind of knowing that comes first.

The weakness is different for each. Arguments from nature are weighed differently by different thinkers. Historical arguments depend on how one weighs ancient sources. The reply that God is known as a person can seem to place the claim out of reach of any test, so that it cannot be wrong. Experience differs from person to person, and people of other faiths and none report experiences that point in other directions.

What the argument asks of a listener. Ask what sort of evidence the neighbour would accept, and listen to the answer. Notice that both sides are making a choice about what counts. The neighbour is not wicked for asking; the believer is not foolish for holding that some things are known by trust. Hebrews 11:1 says faith is "assurance of things hoped for". Faith in the Bible is often trust in a person, not agreement with a theory.

4. Religious diversity

The strongest case. A neighbour might say: "There are many religions, each sure that it is right. Most people hold the religion they were born into. If I had been born in another place, I would probably hold another faith with the same confidence. This makes me doubt that any of them has special access to the truth. It looks like geography."

Answers believers give. Some Christians reply that the origin of a belief does not decide whether it is true; a person may learn a true thing from her parents. Some say that the fact of diversity is one reason to look carefully, not to give up. Some hold that God is at work among all peoples, and that no one has a monopoly on seeking him. Some hold that the question is a real one and they live with it. How Christians understand other faiths is the subject of week 6.

The weakness of the first reply is that the same argument could be used by a person of any faith, and it does not tell us why this faith. The weakness of the others is that they may seem to dissolve the question or to postpone it.

What the argument asks of a listener. Admit that most of us received our faith through a family and a place. That is true of the neighbour too: she received her doubt through a family, a school and an age. Neither of us has a view from nowhere.

5. Harm done in the name of religion

The strongest case. A neighbour might say: "Religion has been used to justify persecution of those who disagree, forced conversion, the silencing of questions, contempt for women and for people of other races, and the protection of those who did harm. Believers say their faith makes people good. If so, why does it so often fail to? I do not want to be part of something with that record."

Answers believers give. Some Christians reply that these acts betray the teaching of Jesus and are not an expression of it, as when the prophets rebuked God's own people. Some say that every large human movement, secular ones included, has also done harm. Some say that the faith has also inspired hospitals, schools, care of the poor and the end of cruel practices, and that the record is mixed.

The weakness is that "that was not real Christianity" can sound like a way of never being answerable, and that the comparison with secular movements, though true, does not remove the harm. It is also a poor reply to a person who herself was hurt in a church.

What the argument asks of a listener. Do not defend what cannot be defended. Christians have done real harm: they have persecuted, coerced and held people in contempt, and in some cases protected those who abused others. A listener who can say, "You are right that this happened, and I am sorry," is not weaker. She is more credible. The ninth commandment forbids false witness, and that includes a false account of our own history.

6. Natural explanations

The strongest case. A neighbour might say: "Many things once explained by gods, such as storms, disease and the origin of species, now have natural explanations. Scholars of religion also offer natural accounts of why humans believe: we look for purpose and for persons behind events, we fear death, we want comfort, and we live in groups that hold beliefs together. These explanations do not need a God. When a natural explanation is available, I prefer it."

Answers believers give. Some say that a natural account of how a belief arises does not show that the belief is false; the same could be said of our trust in our own senses and in mathematics. Some say that God works through natural causes, so that an explanation of the process does not remove the Maker. Some say that natural science answers how and the deeper question is why anything exists at all, a question no natural explanation reaches.

The weakness is that these replies can seem to protect belief from any test. If every natural explanation is welcomed as the way God works, the neighbour may fairly ask what would count against belief. And the history of "a god of the gaps", of placing God only where science has not yet looked, has been a poor one for faith.

What the argument asks of a listener. Do not say that science is the enemy. Most branches of the church have long accepted the work of scientists, and the next lecture considers how believers have thought about it.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians differ on how to receive these five arguments. Some hold that Christian faith can and should be defended by reasoned evidence, and that to refuse to give reasons is to leave the neighbour alone with her doubt. The strength of this view is its respect for the neighbour's mind. Its weakness is that arguments can win a point and lose a person, and the best evidence may not move someone whose trouble is grief. Others hold that faith rests first on God's gift and on trust, that argument has a limited place, and that the main witness is a life. The strength of this view is that it matches how many people actually come to faith or leave it. Its weakness is that it can seem to say that faith needs no reasons and it can leave an honest question unanswered. Catholic, Orthodox, Pentecostal and Protestant Christians are found on both sides, and many hold a little of each. What this course requires is only this: that you can state each of the five arguments fairly; that you do not claim to prove what you cannot; that you do not pretend a neighbour's argument is a sin; and that you hold your conviction with humility and your listening with patience.

7. Where these five arguments overlap

The five arguments are not separate. A neighbour who is hurt by suffering may also say that the evidence is poor. A neighbour who is troubled by religious harm may also ask why belief is so uneven across the world. It is usually the mix that moves a person, and her story will not look like a debating table. Listen for the thread that matters most to her: is it sorrow, a lack of proof, anger at a church, or simply that the question never took hold?


Diagram 1. Five arguments: the case, the answers, the weakness

Hear the case first, then the answers, then the weakness One example of each; the lecture gives more Argument Strongest case, in a line A common answer and its weakness Evil and suffering A good and powerful God would allow less suffering than there is. Free will. Weak on illness and disaster, where no person chose. Enough evidence Big claims need evidence others can test; old reports are not enough. God is known by trust, as a person. Weak: it can seem beyond any test. Religious diversity Most people hold the faith of their birthplace; that looks like geography. Origin does not decide truth. Weak: any faith could say the same. Harm done in religion's name The record of persecution and abuse is a reason to stay away. It betrays the teaching. Weak: that can sound like never being answerable. Natural explanations: a fifth argument, treated in the lecture. In all five, listen for the story behind the argument before you answer the argument.

In short

  • Five serious arguments: suffering, enough evidence, religious diversity, harm done in religion's name, natural explanations.
  • State each in its strongest form before you reply to it.
  • Believers answer in several ways, and every answer has a weakness.
  • What counts as enough evidence is itself disputed, and both believer and neighbour must say what they accept.
  • Christians must admit real harm done by Christians; to do so is honesty, not weakness.
  • Christians differ on whether to defend faith by evidence or to witness by trust and by life; the course asks for conviction held with humility.
Front Back
The five arguments Suffering; enough evidence; religious diversity; harm done in religion's name; natural explanations.
How to treat an argument Strongest case first; then the answers; then their weakness.
Hebrews 11:1 Faith as assurance of things hoped for; often trust in a person, not a theory.
What the course requires State the arguments fairly; claim no proof you lack; hold conviction with humility.

One sentence to remember Listen for the story behind an argument before you answer the argument.

This week's action Write one of the five arguments in your own words as fairly as you can, then give it to a trusted friend and ask: "Would a person who holds this say yes?"

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Choose one of the five arguments. Can you state it in a form that its holder would call fair? Try it aloud.
  • Of the answers to suffering in the lecture, which have you heard offered to a grieving person? What did they do to the listener?
  • Why is "what counts as enough evidence" a question both the believer and the neighbour must answer?
  • A neighbour says that she cannot belong to a church with a history of harm. What is the first honest thing to say?
  • The lecture says an argument can win a point and lose a person. When have you seen that happen, on any subject?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.