FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL4E World Religions and the Theology of Religions: Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Secularism

Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation

Contents 31
STEL4E World Religions and the Theology of Religions: Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Secularism
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Understanding Before Answering
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Understanding Before Answering
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Meeting a Neighbour's Faith
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
  2. Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
  3. Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
  4. Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Islam
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
  2. Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
  4. Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Buddhism
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
  2. Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
  3. Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
  4. Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Hinduism
  1. Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
  2. Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
  3. Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
  4. Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Secularism and the Argument over Evidence
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
  3. Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
  4. Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Theology of Religions and Life with Neighbours
  1. Lecture 6-1: Exclusivism, Inclusivism, Pluralism: Reasons and Weaknesses
  2. Lecture 6-2: The Uniqueness of Christ and the Question of Salvation
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Ethics of Dialogue and Witness
  4. Lecture 6-4: What Remains Open: Conviction and Humility
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Page for Neighbours

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

Last time we saw that Hinduism is a family of traditions. Now we ask what many of them share about the human condition. Most Hindus, in most lines, speak of a self that is born many times, of actions that carry consequences, and of a final freedom from the round of birth and death. The three words are samsara, karma and moksha. They are not the only Hindu ideas, but they are the framework within which much else is understood.

The lecture first explains these three words as Hindus use them. It then describes the paths to freedom and the stages and aims of life that shape ordinary Hindu living. Last, it asks where this picture meets Christian understanding and where it parts. The Christian side is marked clearly as the Christian view. Comparison is useful only if both sides have first been described in a way the other would recognise. The course does not say that either picture wins.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Explain samsara, karma and moksha in plain words, as Hindus describe them.
  • Name the three classical paths to freedom (knowledge, action and devotion) and say what each stresses.
  • Describe the four aims and four stages of life as an ideal, and say why it is only an ideal for many.
  • State where Christian understanding of history, body and resurrection meets and parts from this framework, marking the Christian side.
  • State fairly the disagreement about whether the comparisons hold.

Inasmuch as it is appointed for men to die once, and after this, judgment," — Hebrews 9:27

World English Bible

So also is the resurrection of the dead. The body is sown perishable; it is raised imperishable. It is sown in dishonor; it is raised in glory. It is sown in weakness; it is raised in power. It is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body. There is a natural body and there is also a spiritual body." — 1 Corinthians 15:42-44

WEB

The first verse is cited by many Christians for the view that each person lives one earthly life and then meets God. The second speaks of the body: it is not thrown away but raised, changed. These two verses are not an answer to Hindu teaching. They are two places where Christian understanding speaks about the same questions that rebirth answers in another way: what happens at death, and what becomes of the body.

1. Samsara: the round of birth and death

Samsara means "flowing together" or "passing through", and it names the round of birth, death and rebirth. In most Hindu teaching, the true self, the Atman, does not begin at conception and does not end at the death of the body. It passes through many bodies, human and not human, in many lives. What we call a lifetime is one turn of a very long wheel.

For many Hindus this is not a theory to be proved. It is how the world is. It answers questions people everywhere ask. Why are some children born healthy and some ill, some into comfort and some into hardship? Why does death seem to cut off a life with so much unfinished? On this view, no life stands alone: each is shaped by what came before and shapes what comes after.

Samsara is usually not a happy thing. The Hindu traditions that speak of it generally see the round as a bondage that is to be left, not a gift to be repeated. Some Hindu texts also speak of vast ages of time, in which the world is made, goes on, dissolves and is made again. How literally these ages are taken differs. Many Hindus treat the large numbers as images of the greatness of time.

2. Karma: action and its fruit

Karma means "action" or "deed". It names both the doing and what follows from it. A good act has good results, and a harmful act has harmful ones, sooner or later, in this life or in a later one. The traditions differ about how this works.

Some Hindus speak of karma as an impersonal law, like gravity: it works by itself and needs no judge. Others, especially in devotional lines, say that God oversees the fruit of action and can, by grace, loosen the hold of karma on the one who loves him. Others stress that karma is not fate: what I do now can change what comes, and I am not the helpless prisoner of what I did before.

It is important to understand how karma is used in daily speech. A Hindu may say "it is my karma" about a trouble to mean "this is part of a pattern I did not choose and must bear well". The word is not usually meant as a rule that every hardship is deserved punishment. Hindu teachers, as well as outside critics, have warned that an idea of karma can be misused: it can make a person blame the one who suffers for the suffering, and it can be used to excuse injustice. Reformers inside the tradition have said so plainly, and we return to this in lecture 4-3.

3. Moksha: liberation

Moksha means "release" or "liberation". It is the end of the round of rebirth, and many Hindus regard it as the highest aim of human life. What exactly liberation is differs between lines.

  • In Advaita Vedanta, liberation is knowing that the Atman is not different from Brahman. The one who knows is freed from the ignorance that made the world of separate selves seem final. Some describe this as a state of being, knowledge and joy that is not dependent on anything outside.
  • In devotional lines such as those that follow Ramanuja, liberation is to live in the presence of God, in loving service and joy. The soul remains itself and is not dissolved.
  • In other lines, liberation is still different. Some Hindus speak of being freed while still alive; others look beyond death. Some, especially in popular devotion, pray for a good rebirth and the nearness of God without thinking much about final liberation.

Two points are worth noticing. First, liberation is not usually described as something one earns by alone. Many traditions speak of the teacher, of the grace of God, of the help of the community. Second, the language of freedom is rich and positive: the goal is not simply "escape", but joy, peace, light, knowing. A Christian who dismisses moksha as an "escape" has not yet listened.

4. Three paths

The Bhagavad Gita is among the texts that set out paths (often called yogas, "disciplines" or "ways of joining") towards liberation. Three are best known, and Hindus agree that people are suited to different paths.

  • The path of knowledge (jnana): study, thought and meditation that lead to seeing the truth about the self and Reality. It is stressed in the Advaita line.
  • The path of action (karma yoga): doing one's duty and serving others without clinging to the reward. The Gita teaches that one may act fully in the world while inwardly letting go of the fruit.
  • The path of devotion (bhakti): loving surrender to God, in worship, song, remembrance of the divine name and service. It is the path most followed by ordinary believers.

Many teachers say that the three belong together. A person may take one as the main road and still be helped by the others. The diversity of the paths is one reason why Hindus often say that there are many ways to the one goal. We take up devotion in lecture 4-3.

5. Aims and stages of life

Hindu tradition speaks of four aims of human life: dharma, right living and duty according to one's place and role; artha, material welfare and the means to live; kama, pleasure, desire and love, including marriage and the arts; and moksha, liberation. The first three belong to life in the world and are honoured. The fourth gives the whole its direction. It is a mistake to think that Hindu teaching despises ordinary life. A good householder, who earns honestly and brings up children well, is doing dharma.

Hindu tradition also speaks of four stages of life: the student, the householder, the one who withdraws from household duties as the children grow, and the one who renounces. This is an ideal pattern, found in old texts and addressed originally to certain groups. Most Hindus do not follow it as a strict plan. It remains a picture of a life that turns, in time, from duty in the world toward freedom from it. Some Hindus do take up the life of a renouncer, and they are held in respect.

Dharma deserves another word. It means more than "religion". It means the order that holds things together, and the duties that come with one's place in it, as son or daughter, parent, teacher, ruler or servant. The word is used in many ways, and later writers have linked it closely with birth and caste. We return to that hard question next.

6. Where Christian understanding meets and parts

Now we mark the Christian side. In Christian understanding, the following things are held. These are descriptions of the Christian view as Christians describe it, and they are not claims about what Hindus must accept.

History is a line with a centre. In Christian understanding, God made the world and calls it good. History moves from creation toward a goal, the renewal of all things. At its centre stand events that happened once, at a particular time and place: the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. They are not repeated and not one example among many. Hindu traditions have their own accounts of divine descents (avatara) into the world, especially of Vishnu as Rama and as Krishna. Hindus differ on whether to treat these as events in history, as stories that carry truth beyond history, or as both. Christians who compare an avatara with the of the Son of God should know that in Christian teaching the incarnation is a single event, once for all, and not one of a series.

One life, then meeting God. Hebrews 9:27 is read by most Christians to say that each human being dies once and then faces judgment. Many Christians understand this to rule out rebirth in this world. Christians also differ among themselves on what happens between death and the resurrection, on judgment and on the final state of those who have not heard of Christ; these questions belong to other courses, and lecture 6-2 returns to some of them.

The body is not a prison. The Christian hope is not the release of a soul from a body but the resurrection of the body. First Corinthians 15 says that the body is "sown perishable" and "raised imperishable", changed but still a body. In Christian understanding, the created world and the human body are good, wounded by sin but meant to be renewed. Many Hindus, especially devotional ones, also value the body and the world as God's. Others, in strict renouncer lines, regard the body as a limit to be passed. So here the Christian and Hindu views meet in some places and part in others.

The problem is sin and the answer is grace. In Christian understanding, the deepest trouble of the human being is not ignorance of the Atman but sin: turning away from God and neighbour, and guilt that we cannot remove ourselves. The answer is God's forgiveness and new life given in Christ, received by faith and not earned. Devotional Hindu traditions also speak of the grace of God, and of surrender, so the vocabulary overlaps. But in Christian understanding grace is bound to the person and work of Christ, and Hindus will, with reason, hold that other ways are open.

A fair account of what each can say about suffering. The Hindu teaching on karma gives an answer to the unequal beginnings of lives. A Christian should admit honestly that the Christian answer is less tidy: Christians speak of a world broken by sin, of God's justice and mercy beyond what we see, and of a day when wrongs will be set right, and they admit that the mystery is not removed. Equally, a Hindu thinker should be able to admit that karma, if used as a rule for every hardship, can lead to unkindness. Reformers in both traditions have said so. We do not compare the best of one with the worst of the other.

7. Do the comparisons hold?

This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is whether the Hindu words (karma, moksha, grace, avatara) and the Christian words (sowing and reaping, salvation, grace, incarnation) are near enough to serve as bridges.

Some Christians, among them many Catholic and Orthodox writers and some Protestants who engage in dialogue, say that they are near enough to be useful. The human longing for release from suffering and sin, for knowing God and for love, is shared. The Hindu language of liberation gives Christians words to hear their own gospel anew, and Christians have long used the words of the cultures they live in. The strength of this view is that it treats the neighbour as a seeker whom the Christian can understand. Its weakness is that it can lead to a false match: if karma "is" sowing and reaping and moksha "is" salvation, a person may think that the two faiths say the same thing in different words, and both Hindus and Christians would object.

Other Christians, many of them Evangelical, Reformed or Pentecostal, say that each word belongs to a whole system and means something different within it. Karma is bound to rebirth, moksha to a self that is already divine or already in need of knowledge. Salvation is bound to a Creator who forgives sin through the cross. To match the words is to blur the difference at the very point where the difference is the main thing. The strength of this view is that it takes both teachings seriously and does not make either a copy. Its weakness is that it can harden into a refusal to look at what Hindus actually say, and can turn the neighbour's faith into a foil. The risk is to describe the Hindu view only through the Christian question.

Many Hindus, for their part, are not interested in a match. Some say that all paths lead to the same goal, and that Christians who say their way is the only way make a claim that is hard to hear. Others, in lines that hold their own God to be supreme, make exclusive claims of their own. A Christian should not assume that Hindus are all of one mind on this.

What this course requires is less than either side asks. Use a comparison as a question, not an equation: "When you say moksha, is it near to what I mean by being with God, or is it a different thing?" Then listen. And say plainly which side of the sentence is your own faith.


Diagram 1. Two pictures of the human story

TWO PICTURES, SIDE BY SIDE Each described as its own followers describe it In many Hindu traditions Birth Action (karma) Death Rebirth samsara: the round Moksha: liberation by knowledge, action or devotion Lines differ: oneness with Brahman, or loving nearness to God In Christian understanding Creation, called good One earthly life Christ, once, in history Death, then meeting God Resurrection of the body Trouble: sin. Answer: grace in Christ. A comparison is a question, not an equation. Ask "Is moksha near to what I mean by being with God?" and listen.

Diagram 2. Aims and stages of life, as an ideal

The four aims The four stages
Dharma: right living and duty Student
Artha: material welfare Householder
Kama: pleasure, desire, love One who withdraws as children grow
Moksha: liberation One who renounces

In short

  • Samsara is the round of birth and death; karma is action and its fruit; moksha is liberation from the round, understood differently in different lines.
  • Hindu teachers describe three paths to freedom: knowledge, action and devotion, and many say they belong together.
  • The four aims of life include honoured worldly ones: dharma, artha and kama, as well as moksha.
  • In Christian understanding, history is a line with Christ at its centre, each person lives one earthly life, and the body is raised, not left behind.
  • Christians disagree on whether Hindu and Christian words are near enough to serve as bridges.
  • A comparison is used best as a question to the neighbour and not as an equation.
Front Back
Samsara, karma, moksha The round of rebirth; action and its fruit; liberation from the round.
Three paths Knowledge, action and devotion, often held to belong together.
Christian view, marked One earthly life, then meeting God; history is a line with Christ at its centre; the body is raised.
Why careful with comparisons Words belong to whole systems; use them as questions, not equations.

One sentence to remember Ask what your neighbour means by liberation before you say what you mean by salvation.

This week's action Pick one Hindu word from this lecture and one Christian word that seems near it, and write what a Hindu and a Christian would each object to in matching them.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • How would you explain karma to a friend in two sentences, so that a Hindu would say "yes, that is close"?
  • What do you notice in the way the lecture describes moksha that you did not expect?
  • In what ways does the Christian hope for the resurrection of the body differ from the idea of release from the body? Where might a Hindu devotional tradition be nearer to it than you expected?
  • Which of the three positions on comparison (useful bridges, words belong to systems, neighbours may not want a match) is nearest to your own habit? What is its weakness?
  • When someone says "it is my karma", what might they mean? What would it be to answer with care?
  • If you wish to say what troubles you in these comparisons, do so. If you would rather not, pass.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.