Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
- Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
- Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
- Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
- Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
- Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
- Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
- Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
- Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
- Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
- Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
- Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
- Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
- Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
- Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
- Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
- Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
- Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
Two questions come up again and again between Christians and neighbours without religion. The first is about science: are faith and science enemies? The second is about goodness: can a person be good without God? Both are often argued as if each side had only one answer. In fact there are several honest answers to each, and a thoughtful neighbour will usually know that.
This lecture does not enter any particular scientific debate. It does not say how old the earth is, or how life began, or what a particular finding shows. That would be a different course, and it would pull us away from the person. We ask instead how faith and science have been related, and what a neighbour might fairly mean when she says that she gets her morals without a god. We end by asking what friendship with a secular neighbour looks like.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe four patterns for relating science and faith (conflict, independence, dialogue, integration), without ranking them.
- Explain why "science against faith" is one pattern among several and not the whole story.
- State the strongest argument that goodness needs God, and the strongest argument that it does not.
- Explain how Romans 2:14-15 and Psalm 19:1-4 are used by Christians in thinking about what believers and non-believers share.
- Describe what friendship with a secular neighbour might include, and what it should avoid.
The heavens declare the glory of God. The expanse shows his handiwork." — Psalm 19:1
World English Bible
There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard." — Psalm 19:3
WEB
(for when Gentiles who don’t have the law do by nature the things of the law, these, not having the law, are a law to themselves," — Romans 2:14
WEB
in that they show the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience testifying with them, and their thoughts among themselves accusing or else excusing them)" — Romans 2:15
WEB
Psalm 19 says that the created world speaks of God, and it speaks to all people, in every language. Paul, in Romans 2, says that people who have not received the law of Moses still show in their conduct that they have a sense of right and wrong. Christians read these two passages as a ground for hope that they and their neighbours share more than they sometimes think. They do not say how science works, and they do not settle the question of morals. They are a place to start.
1. Four patterns: science and faith
A well-known way of sorting the field was set out by the twentieth-century scholar Ian Barbour. He described four patterns in which people have understood the relation of science and religion. We use his sorting as a map, not as a ranking. Each pattern has thoughtful holders, believers and non-believers among them.
Conflict. On this view science and faith make rival claims about the same ground, and one must give way. Two kinds of people hold it. Some secular people hold that science has shown religion to be false. Some religious people hold that a scientific claim that contradicts their reading of Scripture must be rejected. These two are opposites who agree on one thing: that the two cannot both be right. The strength of the view is that it takes the claims seriously. The weakness is that it usually treats a particular reading of a text, or a particular scientific theory, as if it were the whole of faith or of science, and that the history is more mixed than the slogan suggests: many scientists have been believers, and many believers have welcomed the work of science.
Independence. On this view science and faith ask different questions and use different methods, so they cannot clash. Science asks how things work; faith asks what they are for and what they mean. A later scientist and writer, Stephen Jay Gould, proposed a version of this under the name of "non-overlapping" areas of authority. The strength is peace and clarity: each does its own work. The weakness is that real life does not divide so cleanly. Faith makes claims about the world, such as that it was created, that the sick are healed, that a man rose from the dead, and a person cannot keep these in a separate box from what she knows about the world.
Dialogue. On this view the two have different questions but meet at the edges: science raises questions it cannot answer, such as why there is anything at all or why the universe is open to our understanding; and faith can learn from science about the world God has made. The strength is that it allows each to correct the other. The weakness is that the questions at the border are not clearly answered by either, and that "dialogue" can mean little more than saying that each is interesting.
Integration. On this view the two are fitted into one picture, so that a theology is shaped by what is known about nature, or a view of nature is shaped by faith in a Creator. The strength is a unified view of life. The weakness is the danger of building a theology on a scientific theory that later changes, so that faith appears to fall when the theory does.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians hold all four, in various forms, and secular neighbours hold the first two most often. Some Christian traditions are wary of integration because they fear that faith will be bent to the science of the moment. Some are wary of independence because they hold that faith must speak about the real world. Others regard conflict as the honest description of certain points. This course requires only that you know there are four patterns and not one, that you can state a view you do not hold in a form its holder would accept, and that you do not suppose a neighbour is hostile to faith merely because she respects science. This lecture does not decide any particular scientific question.
2. What a neighbour may mean by "I trust science"
When a secular neighbour says she trusts science, she usually does not mean that she has a creed. She means that she values a method of testing ideas against the world, correcting mistakes, and accepting what survives the test. Many believers share that value. A scientist who is a Christian does not leave her faith in the car park, and a scientist who is an atheist does not usually believe that science alone tells us what to love. The line between "the science side" and "the faith side" is not a line between people.
3. Can a person be good without God?
This is the question many believers fear, and many secular neighbours resent. It is often put as an insult: "Without God, people have no morals." It is often answered as an insult too: "Believers are no better than the rest of us." Neither helps. Let us set out the strongest arguments on each side, as honest people have made them.
The strongest case that goodness needs God. A believer might say: "I do not say that atheists are bad people. Many are better than I. I say something about what makes goodness binding. If the world is only matter and chance, then why is cruelty wrong, as opposed to disliked? Why must I care for a stranger who gives me nothing? A moral law that applies to everyone, whatever they feel, seems to need a source beyond human preference. And if justice is never done in this life, what makes it worth the cost to do right?" Some philosophers who are believers argue in this way. Philosophers have long asked the old question first put by Plato: is something good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is good? Christian thinkers have answered it in different ways. Many say that God's own nature is the source and standard of goodness, so that the question presents a false choice.
The weakness of this argument is that it does not show that a person must believe in God in order to know what is right, as the facts of life show. It speaks of the ground of morals, and the secular neighbour may reply that a ground can be found elsewhere. It may also be heard as saying more than it says.
The strongest case that goodness does not need God. A secular neighbour might say: "I know that suffering is bad because I can feel it, in myself and in others. I can reason about how people should live together, and we have learned over time which rules help us flourish and which do not. Human beings are made so as to care for children, to cooperate and to be moved by one another's pain. Morals developed from this, and we can improve them. People of every religion and of none agree on much: do not murder, keep promises, care for the weak. If morals came only from one religion's command, we would expect them to differ much more. And consider how many moral errors, such as slavery, were defended from within religion and corrected partly from outside it. I need no god to tell me to be kind."
The weakness of this argument, a believer would say, is that it explains how people come to feel or agree about right and wrong without clearly saying why those feelings should bind someone who feels otherwise. A secular thinker might reply that this is a question about the foundations of ethics that believers have not answered either, since a command also needs a reason to be obeyed. And the point about moral errors cuts both ways, since religion has also been the source of much moral correction: movements against cruel practices have often been led by believers.
Where Christians find common ground. Christians find something to say here in Romans 2:14-15. Paul says that people who have not received the law of Moses still do by nature the things the law requires, and that their conscience speaks to them. Christians read this in several ways. Many hold that God has given all human beings a conscience, so that goodness in a non-believer is real and is a sign of God's gift, even if the person does not name the giver. Some hold that the passage says only what Paul needs for his argument in Romans, that all people are accountable, and should not be stretched into a general theory. Either way, the passage does not allow a Christian to say that a non-believer cannot be truly good. In Christian understanding, goodness among people of no faith is not a puzzle to explain away; it is something to be glad of. Psalm 19:1-4 adds that the heavens speak to all peoples, whatever their language, so that the signs of God are not kept from anyone.
What this lecture does not ask. Notice that this lecture does not ask the secular neighbour to agree that the Christian account of morals is true. It asks the Christian to describe the neighbour's account as she would, and to remember that the Christian's own conduct is also open to the neighbour's judgement.
4. Meaning and hope
Many secular neighbours speak of meaning with depth. They find it in love, in work, in raising children, in caring for the earth, in art, in helping the sick, in a lifetime's contribution to a field of study, or in the plain fact of being alive. They do not say life is meaningless. Some face death with courage and peace, and some with fear, as believers do. A Christian may hope, in Christ, for a life beyond death; a secular neighbour may hold that this life is all there is and gives it for that reason a greater weight. Each of these is a serious view of life. We should not suppose that a person who lacks our hope lacks hope altogether.
5. Friendship with a secular neighbour
What does it mean to be a friend to someone who holds a world view different from your own? It is not an exercise in disguised persuasion, and it is not a silence about what matters most. A few habits help.
Share life, not only opinions. Friendship grows through meals, shared work, favours and trouble. Many people who left or never entered a church have said that no one ever asked them to do something together except come to a meeting.
Be honest about who you are. A Christian who hides her faith in order to be liked, or who hides her friendship in order to convert, deceives. It is honest to say, "I am a Christian, and my faith matters to me. I would like to hear what matters to you." It is not necessary to say it in every meeting.
Be curious. Ask what she reads, what moves her, what she is afraid of, whom she loves, what she has lost. A person who is asked is a person who is respected.
Do not make the friendship a project. If your care ends when she says she does not want to talk about God, then it was not friendship. If she asks about your faith, answer her honestly and at her pace.
Keep your own convictions without needing to win. In Christian understanding, the hope that lies in Christ is a gift for everyone, and a Christian may wish her friend could share it. She may also hold, with humility, that she does not understand everything and that her friend may teach her. Both are true. First Peter 3:15-16 joins readiness to give a reason for hope with a respectful manner; lecture 1-2 treated this.
Diagram 1. Four ways of relating science and faith
In short
- There are four patterns for relating science and faith: conflict, independence, dialogue, integration.
- Each pattern has thoughtful holders and each has a weakness; none is named the Christian pattern.
- Respecting science does not make a neighbour hostile to faith, and many believers are scientists.
- Some argue that goodness needs God as its ground; others that human sympathy and reason are enough; each has a weakness.
- Romans 2:14-15 lets Christians recognise real goodness in people who do not believe.
- Friendship shares life, is honest about faith, stays curious and does not make the neighbour a project.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four patterns | Conflict; independence; dialogue; integration. |
| A caution about "conflict" | It often sets one reading of a text against one theory and calls it the whole. |
| Romans 2:14-15 | People without the law show a conscience; goodness among non-believers is real and is to be welcomed. |
| Friendship, in four habits | Share life; be honest about who you are; be curious; do not make a project of her. |
One sentence to remember State a view you do not hold so well that its holder says, "Yes, that is what I think."
This week's action Ask a secular friend, if you have one and she is willing, what she thinks gives life meaning, and listen without answering.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four patterns have you met in your own church or family? Which have your secular neighbours met?
- Why does the lecture warn against treating one reading of a text, or one scientific theory, as if it were all of faith or all of science?
- State the strongest argument that goodness needs God. Now state the strongest argument that it does not. Can you do both without a trace of mockery?
- What does Romans 2:14-15 allow a Christian to say about the goodness of a non-believer? What does it not allow?
- What is the difference between being a friend to a secular neighbour and making her a project?