Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
- Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
- Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
- Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
- Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
- Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
- Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
- Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
- Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
- Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
- Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
- Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
- Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
- Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
- Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
- Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
- Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
When something goes wrong and a machine was part of it, a certain sentence appears very quickly: "The system did it." Sometimes it is said in anger, by someone who was hurt. More often it is said in relief, by someone who was close to the harm and would like to be a little further away.
This lecture is about that sentence. It argues that the sentence is almost never a complete description of what happened, and that its most common use is to make a person disappear. The central claim of this course is that the ethical questions about artificial intelligence are not about machines; they are about people. Nowhere is that clearer than here. A tool can sort, rank, suggest and draft. A tool cannot be asked to answer for what it did, cannot be forgiven, and cannot repair anything. Only people can do those things, so the work of ethics is to find the people.
We will name four roles that people may hold when a tool is used: the maker, the deployer, the user and the decider. Then we will look at the "gap", the place between those roles where everyone can say "not me", and at the reason Christians should be wary of that place. This lecture explains no technology. If you want to know how such tools work, AI for Ministry Leaders (PT737E) is the course for that. Here we only need to know that a tool was used and that someone was hurt.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Name the four roles of maker, deployer, user and decider, and say what each one answers for.
- Explain what is meant by the responsibility gap and why "the system did it" hides people.
- Read the first excuses in Genesis 3 and Genesis 4 as a pattern that still repeats.
- Say why the weak suffer first when responsibility is blurred.
The man said, “The woman whom you gave to be with me, she gave me fruit from the tree, and I ate it.”" — Genesis 3:12
World English Bible
Yahweh God said to the woman, “What have you done?” The woman said, “The serpent deceived me, and I ate.”" — Genesis 3:13
WEB
Yahweh said to Cain, “Where is Abel, your brother?” He said, “I don’t know. Am I my brother’s keeper?”" — Genesis 4:9
WEB
These are the first excuses in the Bible. Nobody in these verses is using a machine. Notice that each answer points away from the speaker, and notice that God keeps asking the question anyway.
1. What the text says, what we draw from it, what we judge
In every lecture that uses Scripture we will keep three things apart.
What the text says. In Genesis 3, God asks questions: where are you, what have you done. The man answers by pointing at the woman, and also at God, who "gave" her to him. The woman answers by pointing at the serpent. In Genesis 4, God asks Cain where his brother is, and Cain answers with a lie and then with a question that tries to turn the matter around.
A principle drawn from it. A person who is asked "what have you done?" is being treated as someone who can answer. Answering by naming someone else, in whole or in part, is an old human habit. The habit is not a new sin of the machine age.
Our judgement today. This is where we must be careful. Scripture does not mention artificial intelligence, and these verses do not tell us who is responsible in any given case. What they give us is a warning about our own speech. When we find ourselves saying "the system did it", we should ask whether we are describing the facts or doing what the man, the woman and Cain did.
2. The tool and the people around it
Think of an ordinary tool, such as a ladder. A ladder cannot be blamed. If someone falls, we ask who built the ladder, who put it against the wall, who told the man to climb it, and who was holding the foot of it. A tool that sorts people, ranks them or writes for them is far more complicated than a ladder, but the questions are the same ones. They are questions about people.
It helps to separate four roles. One person may hold several of them. In a small church, one volunteer may hold all four. In a large organisation, four different groups may each hold one.
The maker. The maker is the one who builds the tool and decides what it is for and how it behaves. The maker answers for the design: what was it built to do, what was it tested on, what did the maker know about its limits, and what did the maker say about those limits to others?
The deployer. The deployer is the one who chooses to put the tool to work in a particular place. A church office, a school, a clinic, a charity or a company may bring a tool in. The deployer answers for the choice: was this tool right for this use, who was told, who was asked, and what was done to check how it worked here?
The user. The user is the person who actually operates the tool day to day. The user answers for how it is used: did the user follow the instructions, did the user notice when something looked wrong, and did the user pass on a result without reading it?
The decider. The decider is the person who takes the tool's output and turns it into a decision that touches another person: a parcel given or refused, a letter sent, a place offered, a person turned away. The decider answers for the decision itself. Sometimes the decider and the user are the same person. Sometimes the decider is a committee that never sees the tool at all and receives only a list.
None of these roles belongs to the tool. This is the point on which the rest of the chapter depends.
3. An invented case: the parcel list
(an invented example) A charity that gives out food parcels in a mid-sized town works with a small team of volunteers. The coordinator, whom we will call Mrs. Adaeze, is told by the charity's board that a tool will help to prepare the weekly list. The tool was made by a company that sells to many charities. The board agreed to use it after a short demonstration. A volunteer called Tomas enters the week's names and reads off the ranked list. The coordinator signs it. On Thursday, a family who has come every week for a year is not on the list. A neighbour asks why. Tomas says, "That is what the system gave me." Mrs. Adaeze says, "I only sign what the volunteers give me." A board member says, "We only approved the tool." A company representative, if asked, would say that the charity chose how to use it.
Count what has happened. Four roles have each said a true sentence. The company made a tool for many charities. The board chose it. Tomas operated it. The coordinator signed the list. And a family is without food, and nobody has said "I decided".
That is the responsibility gap. It is not a gap in any machine. It is a gap between people, made by each person looking at the next one. Every statement in the story is honest, and the harm is still unowned.
Notice also who is in the gap. The family at the door cannot see the board or the company. They cannot ask the tool anything. They have only the volunteer, and the volunteer has only the list. The people with the least power to ask "why" are the people the missing name falls on. We will see in later weeks that this is a pattern: when responsibility is blurred, the weak are the first to suffer, because they are the ones with no other door to knock on.
4. Why the gap is attractive
We should be fair to the people in the story. Nobody in it set out to harm a family. The gap is not usually made by cruelty. It is made by several ordinary things.
Distance. Each person sees one small step, not the whole path. A volunteer who enters names does not see how the list is built.
Trust in the new. A tool that is presented as careful and consistent makes a person feel that checking is rude, or foolish, or a waste of time.
Relief. Making decisions about other people is heavy. To hand part of that weight to a tool is a real comfort, and it is easy to hand over more than was meant.
Shared names. When a result comes from "the system", there is no face to look at. It is much easier to be gentle, or to be firm, with a person than with a word.
Understanding why people drift into the gap is not an excuse for it. It is the first step in building ways to stay out of it.
5. The old argument: is a tool neutral?
There is a long argument about whether technology is neutral. One side says a tool is like a knife: it can cut bread or hurt a person, and the moral weight is entirely in the hand. The other side says tools are never neutral, because the people who make them build in purposes, habits and limits, so that a tool already leans toward certain uses before anyone picks it up. Each side has seen something real. The first sees that a tool has no will and cannot be punished. The second sees that choices made early may shape what later users find easy or hard.
This course does not need to settle that argument. It needs only what both sides accept: that a tool is shaped by people and used by people. If the tool leans, someone leaned it. If the hand is guilty, someone owned the hand. In both views, there is a person to ask.
6. What the gap does to a community
There is a quiet cost beyond the single case. When a community gets used to "the system did it", it loses something it needs: the habit of saying "I did it" and "I was wrong". A church that has lost that habit cannot do what the gospel asks of it, because confession and forgiveness need a person who can say who did what. We will return to this in lecture 2-4.
Let us be clear about what we are not claiming. We are not claiming that using tools is wrong. We are not claiming that every harm has one guilty person, because some harms have many causes and many people share them. We are not claiming that responsibility is the same for everyone: a person who built a tool, knowing its limits, answers differently from a volunteer who was never told. Lecture 2-2 takes up those differences. The claim here is smaller and firmer: when a tool does the work, the responsibility does not vanish, and the weak suffer first when we let it seem to.
7. Questions that close the gap
Before the next lecture, keep four plain questions beside you.
- Who chose to use this tool here? (the deployer)
- Who decided what to do with its result? (the decider)
- Who can the person affected actually speak to? (a named human being, not "the system")
- If this was a mistake, who will say so? (the one who owns the repair)
If the answer to the third question is "nobody", the gap is open, and the person at the door is standing in it.
Diagram 1. The four roles and the gap
Diagram 2. Four questions that close the gap
| Question | Whose role |
|---|---|
| Who chose to use this tool here? | Deployer |
| Who decided what to do with its result? | Decider |
| Who can the affected person actually speak to? | A named human being |
| If this was a mistake, who will say so? | The one who owns the repair |
In short
- A tool cannot answer, be forgiven or repair anything; only people can, so ethics looks for the people.
- Four roles matter: maker (design), deployer (choice to use here), user (operation), decider (the decision about a person).
- The responsibility gap is made between people, each pointing to the next, even when every statement is true.
- Genesis 3 and 4 show that pointing away from oneself is an old habit, not a new one.
- When responsibility is blurred, the weak suffer first, because they have no other door.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four roles | Maker, deployer, user, decider. |
| The responsibility gap | Harm that every person near it can say was not theirs to own. |
| Who suffers first when it is blurred | The weak, who have no other door to knock on. |
| Why the old excuses matter | Genesis 3 and 4 show the habit of pointing away; the machine did not invent it. |
One sentence to remember When a tool does the work, the responsibility does not vanish; it only becomes harder to find.
This week's action Next time you hear "the system did it", ask quietly, "Who chose to use it, and who decided?"
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the parcel list, which of the four roles would you have found hardest to hold, and why?
- Think of a time when "the system" or "the office" was given as the reason for a decision about you or someone you know. Who was the person you could actually have spoken to?
- Genesis 3 and 4 show three excuses. Which of them do you recognise in your own speech?
- The lecture says that the weak suffer first when responsibility is blurred. Do you agree? What reasons could someone give for disagreeing?
- Why do you think the gap is hard to see from the inside, even for honest people?