Lecture 6-4: Dignity at the Centre: Gathering the Course
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
- Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
- Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
- Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
- Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
- Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
- Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
- Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
- Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
- Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
- Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
- Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
- Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
- Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
- Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
- Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
- Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
This is the last lecture of teaching in the course. The next one is a lab in which you write your own page. Before you write it, it helps to look back across the six weeks and ask what has been the thread.
The thread has been the dignity of persons. In week 1 we chose the eyes we look with. In week 2 we asked who answers when a tool does the work. In week 3 we looked for the person who is missing. In week 4 we asked who is watching whom and with what right. In week 5 we asked who is carried when work changes. In week 6 we asked what the church keeps: truth, and presence. Each time the question was about a person, and each time a person who had less power was the one most easily forgotten.
This lecture gathers the course. It does not add a new topic. It also says plainly what the course has not covered, and where it asked you to hold your judgement with an open hand.
What these 20 minutes give you
- State in one sentence how each of the six weeks asked a question about persons.
- Explain from Psalm 8 why Christians say dignity is given and not earned, and separate what the text says from what we draw from it.
- Explain what humility about our judgements means, and how it differs from indecision.
- Describe what Colossians 3:12-14 adds to the course, and why the way we disagree is part of the ethics.
- Say what Christian hope does and does not claim about the future of technology.
When I consider your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars, which you have ordained; what is man, that you think of him? What is the son of man, that you care for him? For you have made him a little lower than God, and crowned him with glory and honor. You make him ruler over the works of your hands. You have put all things under his feet:" — Psalm 8:3-6
World English Bible
Put on therefore, as God’s chosen ones, holy and beloved, a heart of compassion, kindness, lowliness, humility, and perseverance; bearing with one another, and forgiving each other, if any man has a complaint against any; even as Christ forgave you, so you also do. Above all these things, walk in love, which is the bond of perfection." — Colossians 3:12-14
WEB
God created man in his own image. In God’s image he created him; male and female he created them." — Genesis 1:27
WEB
Scripture does not mention AI. We keep apart what the text says, a principle drawn from it, and our judgement today. The deep theology of the belongs to Christianity and Artificial Intelligence (PT8E); here we only use it.
1. The thread through six weeks
Look back at the questions the course has asked. We can state each as a question about a person.
Week 1, the eyes of ethics. What am I looking with? Before we judge a case, we decide that we will look at the persons in it, with the traditions we stand in and a few honest questions.
Week 2, responsibility. Who answers to the person who is affected? When a tool does the work, responsibility does not vanish. If it is blurred, the weak suffer first.
Week 3, bias and fairness. Who is missing? Unfairness in an automated system is often old prejudice made to look like arithmetic. We look for the person who is not counted.
Week 4, surveillance and privacy. Who is watching, for whom, with what right? To see a person is a power. Scripture teaches us to ask who holds it.
Week 5, work and livelihood. Who is carried, and who is left? Work is more than income, and change in work falls hardest on those with the least to fall back on.
Week 6, truth and presence. Is the person given the truth, and is the person given a person? A church keeps these when its tools change.
If you read the six questions again, you will see they are one question asked from six sides: how is this person, made in God's image, being treated, and who has the task of seeing that they are treated well?
The pattern behind the six is also the central claim of the course. The ethical questions about AI are not about machines; they are about people. We ask them from the conviction that every person bears God's image and has dignity.
2. Psalm 8: smallness and glory together
What the text says. The psalmist looks at the night sky and feels how small a human being is: "what is man, that you think of him?" The same psalm says that God has made the human "a little lower than God", has "crowned him with glory and honor", and has made him "ruler over the works of your hands". Smallness and glory are held in one breath. The question "what is man?" is answered by pointing to what God has done, not to what human beings have achieved.
A principle drawn from the text. Dignity is given by God. It is not earned by usefulness, intelligence, strength or success, and it cannot be lost by their absence. Genesis 1:27 is the text behind the phrase "made in God's image". Both passages place the worth of a person in God's act, not in the person's performance.
Our judgement today. From this, many Christians judge that a person's worth is not threatened by the cleverness of a machine, and is not reduced by a person's lack of cleverness, or speed, or output. Lecture 5-4 gave this a practical form: a person who cannot work, or who is old, or who is disabled, has the same worth as the one who can. This is our application. It is a judgement drawn from the text, and the full account of what the image of God means is disputed among Christians. We have not tried to settle it.
A caution is in order about "ruler over the works of your hands". Christians have read this line as a call to care for creation as God's steward, and some have warned that it has been read as permission to dominate. We have not built a rule about technology on it, and we should not. The point we use is the first one: the worth of the human is given.
3. What dignity does when we judge
We can say three things that dignity does in a hard case.
It makes us ask who the person is. A person is a someone, not a something. A system may turn a person into a score, a record or a category, and for some purposes that is unavoidable. Dignity asks that we remember there is a person behind the entry.
It makes us look at the least powerful first. In every week of the course, the person most likely to be hurt was the one with least say: the applicant who is not shortlisted, the resident who cannot complain, the elderly member who is deceived, the worker who has no other skill, the child who will inherit the choice. Not because they matter more than others, but because they are least likely to be seen if we do not look.
It limits what we may do to a person for a good end. Some things may be done to no one, however useful the result. Where this limit lies is partly a matter of judgement, and readers disagreed in this course about where to place it in particular cases. But the idea that there are limits is shared across the traditions we have studied.
4. Humility without indecision
The course has repeatedly asked you to hold your judgement humbly. It is worth saying what this means, because it is easy to misunderstand.
It does not mean that no judgement can be made. A person who says "who can say?" to every hard case has not been humble. They have left the weak without a defender.
It means that when you judge, you say what you are sure of, what you are not sure of, and what would change your mind. It means that you keep listening to the strongest form of the view you do not hold. It means that you act on your best judgement and stay ready to correct it.
In this course we met several places where thoughtful Christians do not agree: what fairness means, the future of work and what we owe those who lose it, how to weigh safety against liberty, how far a decision may be handed to automated help, where the line falls between help and care, and what authority a community's decision has. In each we asked you to state the other side fairly before you judged. That is not a technique to win. It is a form of love for a neighbour who sees differently.
Humility also means admitting where the course stopped. It did not explain how these systems work. It did not take up questions of medicine or of changing the human body; this course does not cover that. It did not treat the end of history or the final shape of the world. It did not evaluate any product, and it did not tell you whether you should or should not use any tool. It did not rule on any party, law or policy. Other courses take up some of those subjects, and some are not taken up here at all.
5. Colossians 3: how we judge together
What the text says. Paul writes to a community and tells its members to put on "a heart of compassion, kindness, lowliness, humility, and perseverance". He tells them to bear with one another and to forgive. "Above all these things, walk in love, which is the bond of perfection."
A principle drawn from the text. Christian ethics is not only a matter of reaching correct conclusions. It is also a matter of the character in which a community reaches them and lives with them. How a church disagrees is part of its witness.
Our judgement today. The questions of this course will be debated among people who must go on living together: the council member who wants the new tool and the one who fears it, the worker who has lost a job and the manager who had to decide, the member who thinks watching keeps children safe and the one who thinks it breeds fear. Colossians 3 suggests that the way we hold these differences matters as much as the answer. We may be right and still wrong the neighbour by how we speak. Lecture 6-3 gave a way of deciding together, and this passage gives the spirit in which to use it.
6. Hope that does not predict
Many people speak about the future of technology with great confidence, some in hope and some in fear. This course has refused to forecast, because we do not know. It has used the sentence "we do not know" often, and it was meant.
Christian hope is not a forecast that things will turn out well, and it is not a forecast that they will turn out badly. We have no word from Scripture about AI. Hope in the Christian sense rests on God and on God's care for persons, and not on the course of a technology. Because it rests there, it allows us to act without panic and without boasting. We can attend to the person in front of us, tell the truth, be present, and take our turn at the task we have been given, without needing to know how the whole story will end. This is a judgement, drawn from the way the New Testament speaks of hope, and the course does not teach any particular account of the end of history.
7. A test in plain words
A good test of what you have learned is whether you can say it simply to someone who has not studied it. (an invented example) A woman in a small group, a few weeks after the course, is asked by a neighbour what she thinks about AI. She says: "I do not know what will happen. But I know what I ask. Who is responsible when it goes wrong? Who is being left out? Who is being watched, and do they know? Whose work is changing, and who will help them? Is anyone being lied to, or left alone? And I ask it of every case, because every person is someone God made."
She has not said anything clever. She has said the course. That is the aim.
Diagram 1. Six weeks, one question
In short
- The six weeks asked one question from six sides: how is this person, made in God's image, being treated, and who has the task of seeing that they are treated well?
- Psalm 8 holds smallness and glory together. We draw from it, and from Genesis 1:27, that dignity is given by God and not earned.
- Dignity makes us ask who the person is, look first at the least powerful, and accept that some things may be done to no one.
- Humility means saying what we are sure of, what we are not, and what would change our mind. It is not refusing to judge.
- Colossians 3:12-14 teaches that the way a community disagrees is part of its ethics.
- Christian hope rests on God and not on a forecast. We can act without panic and without boasting.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The thread of the six weeks | The dignity of persons: each week asked how a person is treated and who answers for it. |
| Psalm 8 and dignity | Smallness and glory together; dignity is given by God, not earned by usefulness or cleverness. |
| Humility | Say what you are sure of, what you are not, and what would change your mind; still judge and act. |
| Hope | Rests on God, not on a forecast; allows us to act without panic and without boasting. |
One sentence to remember Every question about AI is a question about a person made in God's image, and the least powerful person is the one most easily forgotten.
This week's action Explain the course in your own plain words to one person who has not studied it, and listen to what they ask back.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the six weeks changed the way you look at a question most? What did you see before, and what do you see now?
- Psalm 8 puts smallness and glory together. Why does the lecture say this matters for how we think about machines that seem clever?
- The lecture says humility is not indecision. Describe a case where you were tempted to say "who can say?" when you should have said something.
- Which of the points where readers disagreed was hardest for you to state fairly? What helped you?
- Colossians 3 asks for compassion, kindness, humility and patience. How does this change the way you would argue about a tool in your own church?