Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
- Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
- Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
- Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
- Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
- Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
- Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
- Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
- Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
- Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
- Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
- Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
- Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
- Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
- Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
- Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
- Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
The first three lectures gave us eyes: the dignity of persons, and the habits of three traditions. This lecture gives a method: five plain questions that can be asked of any case in a few minutes. They do not produce an answer by themselves. They make sure that we have looked at the people before we decide.
The method is a tool for wisdom, not a replacement for it. It is also a way of holding a judgement with humility, which means being honest about what we do not know and ready to be corrected.
What these 14 minutes give you
- State the five questions in order and say what each protects.
- Apply the five questions to an invented case and write a short judgement from them.
- Distinguish a question that can be answered now from one that needs more information or other people.
- Explain how to hold a judgement with humility without falling into indecision.
- Say why a judgement is best made with others.
But if any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask of God, who gives to all liberally and without reproach; and it will be given to him." — James 1:5
World English Bible
Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory." — Proverbs 11:14
WEB
For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us, to lay no greater burden on you than these necessary things:" — Acts 15:28
WEB
James says that a person who lacks wisdom may ask God, who gives generously. Proverbs says there is safety in many counsellors. Acts 15 describes a decision reached by the church together, and the leaders could say "it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us". These texts do not give a method for AI. They give a principle: wisdom is asked for, and judgement is made in company. The five questions below are our own reasoned tool that serves that principle. They are not in Scripture, and they are not the only possible tool.
1. Why a method at all
When a case is hard, two mistakes are common. One is to decide quickly by feeling: "this seems wrong" or "this seems fine". The other is to sink in detail and never decide. A short list of questions guards against both. It forces us to look at people, and it gives us an end: when the five have been asked, we judge.
2. The five questions
1. Who has been given this task? Start with the task itself, not the tool. Who is supposed to care for this person, make this decision, keep this record, answer this letter? A task belongs to someone: a pastor, a manager, a parent, a teacher, a volunteer. The first question asks whether the person who holds the task is still the one doing it, and whether they can still answer for it. This question protects responsibility, which week 2 takes up.
2. Who might be hurt? Name the people the case touches, one by one, and ask how each could be harmed: by an error, by being left out, by being watched, by losing work, by being deceived. Ask also who might be helped. The question is not "will anyone complain?" but "who, if wrongly treated, would have no easy way to say so?" This protects the weak.
3. Who is not seen? Some people never appear in the case as it is first told. The one who does not use the tool. The one whose language is not the one the form expects. The one who cannot come to the meeting. The person whose records are thin, so that the system knows little of her. This is the question of the stranger, the widow and the orphan from lecture 1-2. It protects the unheard.
4. What do I not know? Write down honestly what you do not yet know. How does this tool reach its result? Has it been checked with people like these? What does the law of this place say? What would the people affected tell us if we asked? This question protects humility. It also tells us what to find out, and sometimes it tells us that the right step is to wait.
5. With whom shall I judge? Name the people you will consult: a colleague, a pastor, someone from the group affected, a person who sees things differently, someone with the skill you lack. Proverbs 11:14 praises many counsellors. Acts 15 shows a community deciding together. This question protects the judge from his own blind spots.
3. The questions in order
The order matters. We start with the task and the person who holds it, because that is where responsibility is clear. We then look at the people at risk, then at those hidden from view. Only then do we ask about ourselves: what do I not know, and who will help me see? A person who begins with question four, and decides that nothing can be known, never reaches the people. A person who begins with question five, and calls a meeting, may avoid the fact that no one has been asked to look at who is hurt.
4. A worked example
Here is a case (an invented example). A church has a youth leader who is overworked. A volunteer suggests using a program to write the first draft of the weekly message sent to every family, and to sort replies into "urgent" and "not urgent". The youth leader would then read only the urgent ones.
1. Who has been given this task? The youth leader has been trusted by the families to care for their young people. If she reads only what the program marks urgent, she is still the one who holds the task, but she no longer sees the whole.
2. Who might be hurt? A young person who writes quietly, in plain words, about something serious might be marked "not urgent". A family whose message is long or confused might be passed over. Families who feel their message was not read by a person might feel unwelcome.
3. Who is not seen? The family who does not reply at all. The family that writes in a second language. The young person who would never put the thing in writing.
4. What do I not know? We do not know how well the sorting would work with these families. We do not know how the families would feel. We do not know what the church's written rules say about children's information and where it may be kept.
5. With whom shall I judge? The youth leader, the pastor, a parent of a young person, someone who handles the church's safeguarding rules, and, if possible, a teenager.
From these answers a judgement can take shape. One careful judgement might be: use the program, if at all, for a first draft of ordinary announcements, and not to sort messages from families; the youth leader reads every reply herself. Another careful person might judge that the program can help sort if a human also reads a sample each week. A third might say the church should wait until it knows more. Notice that all three have asked the same five questions. Where they differ is in how much risk they accept and how they weigh the unknowns. That is why the course speaks of judgement, not of correct answers.
5. Holding a judgement with humility
Humility does not mean having no view. It means holding a view in a way that allows correction. Four habits help.
Say what you based it on. "I judged this because the youth leader will read every reply" is a judgement others can test. "It just seems wrong" is not.
Say what would change your mind. "If we find that the program misses quiet messages, I would stop." A judgement with a condition is easier to revisit.
Set a time to look again. A decision made today should be reviewed. What was reasonable under uncertainty may need revising when more is known.
Do not use humility as an escape. Sometimes "we do not know" is the honest answer. But it must not become a reason never to protect the person in front of you. If someone may be hurt now, the caution goes to the side of the person who could be hurt.
6. The method has limits
The five questions are a net, not a law. They will not tell you which side to take where Christians disagree. They will not guarantee that you see everyone. They do make it harder to decide without looking at the people, and that is their purpose.
Diagram 1. The five questions
In short
- The five questions: who has been given this task; who might be hurt; who is not seen; what do I not know; with whom shall I judge.
- They protect responsibility, the weak, the unheard, humility and the judge from his own blind spots.
- The order matters: start with the task and the people, then turn to yourself.
- The method does not give the answer; reasonable people who ask the five may still differ in how much risk they accept.
- Hold a judgement with humility: say what it rests on, what would change it, and when you will look again.
- Humility is not an escape: if someone may be hurt now, caution goes to the side of the person at risk.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The five questions | Task; hurt; unseen; unknown; with whom. |
| What question 3 protects | The unheard: those absent from the case as first told. |
| Holding a judgement humbly | Say what it rests on, what would change it, and when to review. |
| Why judge with others | Proverbs 11:14 and Acts 15: wisdom grows in company and corrects our blind spots. |
One sentence to remember Ask about the task and the people before the tool, then judge with others and hold the judgement humbly.
This week's action Pick one decision you face and write the five questions with one honest line under each.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a recent decision in your place. If you had asked the five questions, which one would have changed the decision?
- In the youth leader case, what other person is not seen that the lecture did not name?
- Which of the five do you find hardest to ask honestly? Why?
- When is "we do not know" an honest answer, and when is it an escape?
- Name a person who sees things differently from you whom you could ask to help you judge. What stops you from asking?