Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
- Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
- Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
- Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
- Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
- Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
- Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
- Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
- Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
- Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
- Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
- Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
- Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
- Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
- Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
- Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
- Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
Care and control often start in the same place. To care for a person, we have to know something about them: that they are ill, that they are alone, that they have stopped coming. To control a person, we also have to know something about them. From outside, the two can look very alike. A phone call, a list, a visit, a note. What is different is not always visible in the act. It lies in how the knowing is gained, who holds it, what it is for, and whether the person can say no.
This is a difficult point for the church. Scripture asks believers to look after one another, to correct one another gently, and to shepherd one another. These are forms of looking. The same church can slide into a looking that is one-way, hidden and harsh. This lecture asks how to tell them apart. It also keeps in view the people who are watched most and can object least.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain what Galatians 6:1, Matthew 18:15 and 1 Peter 5:2-3 say about the manner of looking after one another.
- Use five signs to tell care from control in a case.
- Describe how accountability among believers differs from surveillance.
- Name groups of people who are watched most and can object least, and say what that asks of those who help them.
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1
World English Bible
If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother." — Matthew 18:15
WEB
Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly; neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock." — 1 Peter 5:2-3
WEB
Three passages from different parts of the New Testament, each about how one believer looks at another. None mentions technology. All three speak about the manner of the looking.
1. Three passages about looking after one another
What the texts say. In Galatians, Paul writes that if someone is caught in a fault, those who are spiritual should "restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness", and then he adds a clause that is easily missed: "looking to yourself so that you also aren't tempted." The person who corrects is warned to look at themselves in the same moment.
In Matthew 18:15 Jesus speaks about a brother who sins against you. The first step is to go and show him his fault "between you and him alone." If he listens, you have "gained back your brother." The aim is stated in the verse: to regain a brother. The method is private, face to face, and begins with the person who was wronged.
In 1 Peter 5, an older leader writes to the elders of the churches. They are to shepherd the flock of God "exercising the oversight." Peter then says three things about how: not under compulsion but willingly, not for dishonest gain, and not "lording it over those entrusted to you", but as examples. The English word "oversight" is itself a word about looking. Peter tells us what kind of looking is meant.
A principle drawn from them. Looking after another person in the church has a certain manner. It is gentle, aware of its own weakness, private before it is public, aimed at restoring a person and not at winning against them, willing and not forced, and an example and not a command. In all three passages the person who looks is accountable for how they look.
Our judgement today. These are texts about and in the first century. They do not tell us what to do with an attendance list, a messaging group or a piece of software. They do tell us what a tool must not do to the care it serves. If a tool makes it easy to look at a person without first speaking to them, to report to many what should be said to one, or to treat someone as a case to be managed, it works against the manner these texts describe, however good the aim. That is our judgement drawn from the principle, and a reader may weigh a particular case differently.
2. Five signs: care or control?
When we cannot tell care from control by looking at the act, we can look at the way it is done. Here are five signs. A single sign does not decide a case. Taken together, they usually show which way it leans.
Five signs
1. Invited, or imposed? Care is usually offered, and the person may accept. Control is imposed and tells the person what they must show.
2. Mutual, or one-way? In care between believers, each may see the other. In control, one side sees and the other does not, or one side must report and the other need not.
3. Private first, or public first? Matthew 18:15 begins between two people. If the first thing that happens is a report to a group, a file or a leader, something has gone wrong.
4. Aimed at restoring, or at managing? Care wants the person well, and the measure of success is the person. Control wants the person compliant, and the measure of success is the record.
5. Free to say no? Care can be refused without a price. Control makes refusal costly: a mark, a withdrawn favour, a loss of standing.
These signs can be used on any setting: a family, a small group, a youth ministry, a staff team, a charity that gives help.
3. Accountability that does not become surveillance
Many believers value accountability: a friend, a small group or a mentor who knows their struggles and asks about them. Many traditions practise it in their own ways, in confession to a priest, in spiritual direction, in a group, in pastoral visits. We do not rank these. The point here is to ask what keeps accountability from turning into surveillance.
First, it is chosen. A person who asks a friend to ask the hard question has made themselves accountable. A person who has been told they must report to someone has been made accountable, and that is a different thing. A choice made under pressure, such as "agree if you want to stay in the group", is not fully a choice.
Second, it is mutual where it can be. Peers who each confess a weakness and each listen are in a different position from a leader who knows every weakness of the others and tells none of his own. The text says, "looking to yourself." The one who looks at another is also looked at.
Third, it is held by a person, not kept as a file. What one friend knows of another is held in trust, and a friend can be asked to forget. A record can be searched, copied, shared and kept. Where a church or a group chooses to write down what was said, that choice should be made with the person, and with the habits of the last lecture: collect less, keep less, share less, tell people.
Fourth, it has an end or a review. A season of accountability that began for a reason should be able to finish. A person should not be held for ever to a failing they have left behind.
Some programmes and arrangements send a report of one person's activity to another person. We do not evaluate any product, and we do not say they must never be used. We say that the five signs apply to them as to anything else: the person should have chosen it, the report should be known to them, and, if it only runs one way, from a person with less power to a person with more, it is closer to surveillance than to fellowship.
4. An invented case: the youth group agreement
(An invented example) A youth leader at a congregation is troubled by what some of the young people in his group are looking at online. He asks the young people, aged thirteen to seventeen, to agree to a plan in which a summary of each person's online activity is sent weekly to him. He says that those who do not agree "are welcome to stay but will not be able to go on the summer trip." Most agree. One of the older teenagers says she agreed because she did not want to be the one who was left out.
Apply the five signs. Invited? In form, yes. In practice, the cost of refusing is clear, and so it is imposed. Mutual? No. The leader sees; the young people do not see his activity. Private first? The summary goes to the leader, who may say what he pleases of it. Aimed at restoring? The aim is protection of the young, which is a good aim, but the means is a record, not a conversation. Free to say no? No.
This does not mean the leader is a bad man. His fear for the young people is real. It means the plan does not fit the manner of the passages. He could, for example, speak openly with the young people and their parents about the dangers, offer pairs of friends who check in with each other by choice, hold a conversation without any record, and invite those who want more help to ask for it. The young people are watched by many already. A church could be the place where they are not.
5. The powerless are watched most
One of the quiet facts of this subject is that watching is not spread evenly. The people who are watched most are often the people who can least refuse.
- Children are watched by parents, schools and others, and are in the weakest position to object.
- Workers paid by the hour, and those who cannot easily find another job, are measured most closely.
- People who receive help are often asked for the most. A person who needs food, shelter or money may be asked to show papers, explain their circumstances, and let a stranger decide whether they deserve it. They often cannot say no, because the help depends on yes.
- Migrants, people with no secure home and people with no secure legal standing can be watched by many and protected by few.
- The old and the sick, in care of other people, can be seen at all hours by people who do not ask permission.
For those who help, this is a challenge as well as a warning. A church that gives help holds power. The one who receives help is not in the same position as the one who gives it. The more a person depends on us, the more careful we must be about what we learn of them and what we do with it. A church should ask itself, of every question it puts to a person asking for help: do we need to know this to give this help? Is the person free to say no, and will help still come? Who will see the answer? A gift that costs a person their privacy more than it must is a heavier gift than it looks.
6. Being watched yourself
This lecture has spoken mostly of those who watch. Many readers are on the other side: they are watched at work, at school, in their neighbourhood or in their own congregation. A few plain things may help.
Being watched tends to change us. We perform for the watcher. We grow quiet. We become afraid of being misread. A believer in this position may remember that a person's worth does not come from the record. Psalm 139 says a person is known and is not abandoned; no score can say what that knowledge says.
Where the watching seems unfair, it is right to ask the questions politely and to ask them of a person who can answer: who is watching, for whom, and with what right? It is wise to seek counsel from someone you trust, and from a qualified person where a law or a contract is involved. This course does not give legal advice. If the watching is part of harm, such as threats or abuse, speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and if there is danger now, call your local emergency number.
7. Watching with love
If we gather these threads, what does love in watching look like? It is not a list of rules, but it has recognisable habits.
- Ask before you look. A visit is better asked for than sprung.
- Look with the person, not at the person. Let them see what you see and say what is wrong with it.
- Say what you saw. If you noticed something, tell them, and do not tell others first.
- Keep little. Hold in your memory and your prayers more than in your files.
- Let it end. Say when your looking will stop, and stop.
- Look to yourself. Ask what in you wants to know, and why.
The church that cares well is often better known by faces than by records. That is a claim with limits, and a church with many people will need some lists. But the principle holds: a person who is cared for does not need to be a case in a file in order to be seen. The God of Genesis 16 saw Hagar without a file. A church can try to see in that way too.
Diagram 1. Care or control? Five signs
Diagram 2. Who is watched most
| Group | How they are watched | What helpers owe them |
|---|---|---|
| Children | By parents, schools, leaders | Watching that grows lighter as they grow; explained openly |
| Workers paid by the hour | By measures of pace and time | Proportion; a way to explain and to object |
| People who receive help | By questions that decide who "deserves" | Ask only what the help needs; help does not depend on yes |
| Migrants and those with no secure standing | By many, protected by few | Keep little in writing; ask what a list could do |
| The old and the sick | By carers, at all hours | Ask permission; explain what is seen |
In short
- Galatians 6:1, Matthew 18:15 and 1 Peter 5:2-3 speak of the manner of looking after one another: gentle, private first, aimed at restoring, willing, not lording it over.
- Care and control may use the same act; five signs show which way a case leans: invited, mutual, private first, aimed at restoring, free to refuse.
- Accountability among believers stays accountability when it is chosen, mutual, held by a person rather than a file, and able to end.
- The people watched most are often the ones who can least refuse: children, hourly workers, people who receive help, migrants, the old and the sick.
- Those who help hold power and should ask only what the help needs.
- Watching with love asks before it looks, looks with the person, keeps little, lets it end, and looks to itself.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Galatians 6:1 | Restore with gentleness, looking to yourself. |
| Matthew 18:15 | Go to him privately first; the aim is to regain a brother. |
| The five signs | Invited, mutual, private first, aimed at restoring, free to say no. |
| Who is watched most | Those who can least refuse: children, hourly workers, those who need help, migrants, the old and sick. |
One sentence to remember Care asks, looks with the person, keeps little and lets the person say no; control imposes, looks one way, keeps the record and charges for refusal.
This week's action Choose one way your church or group keeps watch on its members and test it against the five signs, writing one line for each.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In Galatians 6:1, Paul adds "looking to yourself." What difference does it make to a correction if the one who corrects takes this seriously?
- Why does the lecture put "private first" among the signs of care? What might be lost if a church always starts with a group?
- Take one of the five signs. Describe an ordinary church situation (without naming anyone) in which that sign is hard to keep.
- In the youth group case, what could the leader do that is not watching and still takes the danger seriously?
- Think of a group of people who receive help from a church or charity. What question does the helper ask that the helper does not need to ask?