Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
- Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
- Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
- Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
- Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
- Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
- Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
- Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
- Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
- Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
- Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
- Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
- Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
- Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
- Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
- Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
- Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
Lecture 3-1 showed where unfairness can enter a system. The obvious next question is harder: fair compared to what? To say that a result is unfair we need some idea of what a fair result would look like. People who share the same faith, and who all want to be just, give different answers.
This lecture puts four common measures of fairness on the table. They are old measures. Nobody invented them for machines. A village elder dividing a harvest, a teacher marking papers and a church council choosing who receives help have all used them. Then the lecture turns to Scripture, which has a great deal to say about justice, and asks what it requires and what it leaves open.
Along the way the lecture meets one of the points where readers will not agree. We state the disagreement as fairly as we can, and then say what this course asks of every reader, which is less than any one measure requires.
What these 23 minutes give you
- State four measures of fairness and the strongest case for each.
- Show with a simple invented case that the four measures can give different answers.
- Explain the pairing of justice and righteousness in biblical language, and what Deuteronomy 16, James 2 and Amos 5 each require.
- State the disagreement over the measure of fairness without declaring one side the winner.
- Say what this course requires of everyone, whichever measure they prefer.
You shall not pervert justice. You shall not show partiality. You shall not take a bribe, for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise, and perverts the words of the righteous." — Deuteronomy 16:19
World English Bible
You shall follow that which is altogether just, that you may live, and inherit the land which Yahweh your God gives you." — Deuteronomy 16:20
WEB
My brothers, don’t hold the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ of glory with partiality." — James 2:1
WEB
For if a man with a gold ring, in fine clothing, comes into your synagogue, and a poor man in filthy clothing also comes in;" — James 2:2
WEB
and you pay special attention to him who wears the fine clothing, and say, “Sit here in a good place”; and you tell the poor man, “Stand there,” or “Sit by my footstool”;" — James 2:3
WEB
haven’t you shown partiality among yourselves, and become judges with evil thoughts?" — James 2:4
WEB
But let justice roll on like rivers, and righteousness like a mighty stream." — Amos 5:24
WEB
You shall not deny justice to your poor people in their lawsuits." — Exodus 23:6
WEB
Notice that none of these verses gives a formula. They name wrongs (a bribe, a look that sorts people by their clothes) and they name a longing (justice like a river). We will keep that difference in view.
1. Four measures, in plain words
Imagine a congregation's education fund has ten places for a year of study and sixty people have asked. It must choose. (An invented example.) The sixty differ. Some have studied before and have good records. Some have never had the chance to study at all. Some live far away and would need travel money. Some are young, some are old. Four honest people on the committee each think of fairness in a different way.
The first measure: the same rule for all. Write one rule down, apply it to everyone in the same way, and let no one ask for an exception. Perhaps the rule is "the ten with the best written answers." This measure protects against favouritism. The committee cannot choose its friends if the rule is plain and public. Its strongest case is that it treats every person as someone whose case counts equally, and that it makes the judges accountable, because anyone can check whether the rule was followed. Its cost is that a rule can be blind to differences that matter. If some applicants never had a school to write their answers in, the same rule treats unequal starting points as if they were equal.
The second measure: equal opportunity. Make sure everyone has a real chance to compete, and then let the best result win. Here the committee asks: has everybody had the same chance to prepare, to hear of the fund, to apply? If the notice was only in one language or only given after the service, it takes steps to widen it. Its strongest case is that it takes the starting line seriously without giving up the idea of . Its cost is that it is hard to know when the chance has been truly equalised. One person's chance includes a quiet room and an educated parent, and no committee can supply all of that.
The third measure: fair results. Look at who actually receives the places, and ask whether the result is fair across groups. If all ten places go to one district, or to one language group, or only to men, then something has gone wrong, whatever the rule said. Its strongest case is that it judges by what really happens to people, and not by what was intended. A result that falls always on the same people is a warning, even if no one meant it. Its cost is that it can lead the committee to adjust the choice to reach a pattern, and some will say this treats individuals as members of a group, or sets one person aside because of what others like them have done.
The fourth measure: priority for the weak. Give first attention to those who have least, or who are most at risk of being overlooked. In the congregation, this might mean that the person for whom this is the only chance of study counts more than the person who could study anyway. Its strongest case is that Scripture's concern for the widow, the orphan and the stranger is not a footnote. In Catholic social teaching, the phrase "option for the poor" is used for this stress. Many Protestants and Orthodox Christians also put the weak at the centre of justice, in their own words. Its cost is that the committee must decide who is "weak," and that a person who is not weak in the committee's eyes may feel unjustly passed over.
The four are not enemies. Most thoughtful people use some of each. But when resources are short and the choice must be made, they pull in different directions.
2. The same ten places, four answers
Suppose the committee splits into four groups, one for each measure. The first group, using "the same rule for all," picks the ten best written answers. The second, "equal opportunity," first asks who never heard of the fund and extends the deadline, then picks the best. The third, "fair results," examines the ten chosen and finds none from the far district, and revises. The fourth, "priority for the weak," picks first from those who have no other way to study.
Each group can defend its list honestly. The lists are not the same. No arithmetic makes this go away, and no tool can remove the need to choose. A tool can only carry out a measure someone has chosen, and that is why the question "which measure does this system use?" matters so much. A system that quietly uses the first measure is not neutral. It has chosen.
This is the main teaching of the lecture so far: the measure of fairness is a moral choice, and it must not be hidden inside a tool. If a system ranks people, someone should be able to say, in plain words, what "fair" meant when it was designed, and the people affected should be able to ask.
3. What the text says: justice and righteousness
Scripture does not give a definition of fairness that settles our committee. But it speaks about justice constantly, and a careful reader can learn several things.
First, the Hebrew Bible often joins two words: justice (in Hebrew, mishpat, the right ordering of a case or a society) and righteousness (tsedaqah, being in right relation, doing what the relationship requires). Amos 5:24 sets them together: "let justice roll on like rivers, and righteousness like a mighty stream." The picture is of something that flows and keeps flowing, not a single verdict. Justice here is more than correct procedure. It is a whole way of living in which people are put right with one another.
Second, Deuteronomy 16:19 names three hindrances to justice: perverting it, showing partiality and taking a bribe. The reason given for the third is striking: a bribe "blinds the eyes of the wise." The wise can be made unable to see. This is useful for us because it names a way that judgement is damaged that does not need a villain. Anything that makes a judge unable to see a person clearly, whether money, rank or habit, is a bribe in this sense.
Third, Deuteronomy 16:20 asks for "that which is altogether just." The passage does not say how to calculate it. It says to follow it, as one follows a path.
Fourth, James 2:1-4 describes a gathering where a man in fine clothing is given a good seat and a poor man is told to stand. James calls this partiality and says the ones who do it have "become judges with evil thoughts." The test case is a small one, a seat, and the matter is what a glance does. That reminds us that unfairness is often not a grand decision but a thousand small ones. It also reminds us that a church is not exempt: James speaks to believers.
Fifth, Exodus 23:6 says: "You shall not deny justice to your poor people in their lawsuits." The weak have a special need of justice because they cannot buy it. Elsewhere the same law, as we saw in lecture 3-1, forbids showing favouritism to the poor in a judgment (Leviticus 19:15). Read together, these are not in contradiction. The first protects the poor from being failed by the court. The second protects the court from being swayed by the status of the party, rich or poor. The poor are not to be given a false verdict, and they are not to be given a false denial.
4. From text to principle to judgement
What the text says. God's people must not pervert justice, show partiality or take bribes. They must treat the poor and the rich alike in court, and must not fail the poor because they cannot pay. The prophets long for justice to flow like a river.
A principle drawn from it. Fairness has at least two faces. One face asks that the rule be applied to each person without favour. The other asks that the weak not be left to fall because they have no power to protect themselves. Scripture holds both, and does not offer a single formula that joins them.
Our judgement today. A system that sorts people should be able to say which of these faces it shows and why. We think that a system which ignores the second face, and quietly lets the weak fall because the first face was satisfied, is open to the charge James brings against the usher with the good seat. We hold this as a judgement, not as a verse. The verses do not mention any system, and they do not tell us which measure above to choose.
5. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree about what measure of fairness a system, a committee or a church should use.
Some Christians hold that the first measure, the same rule for all, is the heart of justice. They point to the warnings against partiality and bribes, and to the fear that once a judge begins to weigh people by what group they belong to, favouritism will walk in by the back door. A fair rule, publicly known and applied without exception, is for them the best protection that a weak person has against a powerful one. They add that rules which are adjusted for each case give hidden power to whoever adjusts them.
Others hold that the fourth measure, priority for the weak, comes first. They point to the law's care for the widow and the orphan, to the prophets' anger at those who sell the needy, and to James's picture of the poor man told to stand. They say that equal treatment of unequal people only repeats the old inequality in clean language, and that a church above all must see who is at the bottom of the list and begin there. Many Catholic voices speak this way, and so do many Protestant and Orthodox voices, each in their own vocabulary.
Still others place the weight on equal opportunity, and say that the work of justice is to remove the obstacles before the race begins, and then to let the result stand. And others look first at results across groups, because they believe a pattern that falls always on the same people is the clearest sign that something unjust is at work, whatever anyone intended.
Each of these positions has serious people behind it, and each has an answer to the others' objections. The first group says that outcome-watching can punish individuals for the history of their group. The second group answers that blind rules do exactly that to the groups who were left behind. We do not decide it here.
What this course requires is only this, and it is much less than any one of these positions requires. Do not blur responsibility: someone must be able to say which measure was used, who chose it, and who answers for it. Keep the weak in sight: whatever measure is chosen, ask what happens to the people with the least power to object, and listen to them. A reader who prefers any of the four measures can meet these two requirements. A reader who holds that fairness is not a single measure at all can meet them too.
6. Reading Scripture without making it a rulebook
A temptation lurks here, and it is worth naming. When we see how much Scripture says about justice, we may feel we can lift a rule from it and apply it to a ranking system: "Deuteronomy says no partiality, so the tool must give every group equal numbers." That is a step the text does not take. Deuteronomy speaks to judges in a court, in a particular society, with bribes in mind. To move from there to a modern selection process is to reason by analogy, and analogies must be marked as such. The way to keep honest is to say in each case, as this lecture has tried to, "the text says," "a principle," "our judgement."
This also guards against the opposite error: saying that because Scripture has no verse about such systems, it has nothing to say. It has a great deal to say about how people with power over others should judge, and whom they should be careful not to fail. Those words are for us.
7. A short practical habit
When you meet a system, a committee or a rule that sorts people, ask in this order:
- What does "fair" mean here? Can anyone say it in a sentence?
- Who chose that meaning, and who can ask them about it?
- Whom does this measure protect, and whom does it leave exposed?
- Who has no voice in this room?
The fourth question prepares the ground for lectures 3-3 and 3-4.
Diagram 1. Four measures, four questions
In short
- Four common measures of fairness are the same rule for all, equal opportunity, fair results, and priority for the weak.
- The four measures can give different answers to the same choice, and no arithmetic removes the need to decide.
- The measure of fairness is a moral choice and must not be hidden inside a tool.
- Scripture joins justice and righteousness, forbids partiality and bribes, and guards both the poor in court and the court from partiality.
- Readers differ on which measure to use. This course requires only that responsibility not be blurred and that the weak be kept in sight.
- Text, principle and judgement must be kept apart: the verses do not mention systems or choose a measure.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four measures of fairness | Same rule for all; equal opportunity; fair results; priority for the weak. |
| Justice and righteousness | Often paired in the prophets: right ordering of a case or society, and right relation among people (Amos 5:24). |
| What James 2:1-4 shows | Partiality can lie in a small act, such as who gets the good seat, and a church is not exempt. |
| What the course requires | Do not blur responsibility, and keep the weak in sight, whichever measure is preferred. |
One sentence to remember No tool chooses what "fair" means; a person must choose, say so plainly, and answer to those who are affected.
This week's action Find one decision in your community that sorts people, and write one sentence saying which measure of fairness it uses, even if no one ever said so.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Take the ten places and sixty applicants. Which measure comes most naturally to you? Which would you find hardest to defend to someone who disagrees?
- Deuteronomy 16:19 says a bribe "blinds the eyes of the wise." Besides money, what else might blind a wise person's eyes in a selection process?
- How would you explain the difference between Leviticus 19:15 (no partiality to the poor in a judgment) and Exodus 23:6 (do not deny justice to the poor)? Why do both stand in the same law?
- Why is it a problem if a system uses a measure of fairness but no one can say in plain words which one?
- The course asks only that responsibility not be blurred and that the weak be kept in sight. Is that too little, or enough for a start? Say why.