FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL5E Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence: Responsibility, Bias, Surveillance, Work

Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers

Contents 31
STEL5E Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence: Responsibility, Bias, Surveillance, Work
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Ethics Is About People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Ethics Is About People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Eyes of Ethics
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
  3. Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
  4. Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Responsibility
  1. Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
  2. Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
  3. Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Bias and Fairness
  1. Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
  2. Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
  3. Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
  4. Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Surveillance and Privacy
  1. Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
  2. Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
  3. Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
  4. Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Work and Livelihood
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
  2. Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
  3. Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
  4. Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Truth, Care and the Church Together
  1. Lecture 6-1: Truth and Counterfeit
  2. Lecture 6-2: Can Care Be Handed Over?
  3. Lecture 6-3: Judging Together as a Church
  4. Lecture 6-4: Dignity at the Centre: Gathering the Course
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Ethics Page

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Some of the oldest prayers in Scripture are prayers about being seen. One believer is comforted by it: "You know me." Another is afraid of it and hides. A third, a woman with no power at all, gives God a new name because he saw her when no one else did. The Bible does not give one answer to the question "How does it feel to be seen?" It gives several, and all of them are true.

This matters for the fourth week of the course because the new tools of our time are, among other things, tools for seeing. They can notice where a person goes, what a person writes, how fast a worker moves, who is absent from a meeting. This course does not explain how they do it (that belongs to AI for Ministry Leaders, PT737E). It asks what watching does to persons, and it asks it from the centre of the course: every person bears God's image and has dignity.

The principle of the week is this: to see a person is a power; Scripture teaches us to ask who is watching, for whom, and with what right. This first lecture lays the ground. It reads three scriptural scenes of being seen, shows what is different about God's seeing and a human watcher's, tells the old story of a building designed for watching, and ends with three questions that the rest of the week will use.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Describe two ways Scripture speaks of being seen by God: as comfort and as exposure.
  • Explain three differences between God's seeing and a human watcher's.
  • Say what the panopticon was designed to do, and what it shows about power.
  • State the three questions of the watcher: who is watching, for whom, and with what right.

Yahweh, you have searched me, and you know me. You know my sitting down and my rising up. You perceive my thoughts from afar. You search out my path and my lying down, and are acquainted with all my ways. For there is not a word on my tongue, but, behold, Yahweh, you know it altogether. You hem me in behind and before. You laid your hand on me. This knowledge is beyond me. It’s lofty. I can’t attain it." — Psalm 139:1-6

World English Bible

Where could I go from your Spirit? Or where could I flee from your presence? If I ascend up into heaven, you are there. If I make my bed in Sheol, behold, you are there! If I take the wings of the dawn, and settle in the uttermost parts of the sea; Even there your hand will lead me, and your right hand will hold me. If I say, “Surely the darkness will overwhelm me; the light around me will be night”; even the darkness doesn’t hide from you, but the night shines as the day. The darkness is like light to you." — Psalm 139:7-12

WEB

Search me, God, and know my heart. Try me, and know my thoughts. See if there is any wicked way in me, and lead me in the everlasting way." — Psalm 139:23-24

WEB

They heard the voice of Yahweh God walking in the garden in the cool of the day, and the man and his wife hid themselves from the presence of Yahweh God among the trees of the garden. Yahweh God called to the man, and said to him, “Where are you?” The man said, “I heard your voice in the garden, and I was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid myself.”" — Genesis 3:8-10

WEB

She called the name of Yahweh who spoke to her, “You are a God who sees,” for she said, “Have I even stayed alive after seeing him?”" — Genesis 16:13

WEB

Three scenes, three feelings. The psalmist is held, the man in the garden is afraid, and Hagar is, for the first time in the story, noticed. Do not hurry to a single conclusion. Let each scene say what it says.

1. Three ways of being seen

Think of three ordinary experiences. A mother comes into a room where her child is sleeping and stands for a minute. A teacher stands behind a student who is doing badly in an examination. A stranger across the street is writing down which door you enter every day. In all three, someone is watching. The first is care. The second is judgement. The third is a threat.

What makes the difference? Not the act of looking. It is the relation between the watcher and the watched: whether the watcher loves, whether the watched knows, and whether the watched can answer. Keep these three in mind. The Bible's scenes of being seen are scenes in which they change.

2. Psalm 139: a comfort that is also a weight

What the text says. The psalm is a prayer. A person speaks to God and says that God has searched him and knows him. God knows when he sits and when he stands, knows his thoughts "from afar", knows his words before he says them. Then comes the surprise: the psalmist asks where he could go to be away from God, and the answer is nowhere. Heaven, the place of the dead, the far end of the sea, the darkness: none of them hides him. And in the end the psalm does not say this with terror. It says "This knowledge is beyond me", and then, in the last verses, it asks God to search him and lead him.

The psalm holds comfort and weight together. It is a comfort because a person who is known completely and is not abandoned is held. It is a weight because there is nothing in a life that is outside the sight of God, and some readers, in some seasons, find that hard to bear. The psalm itself does not hide from the weight. It says the knowledge is "beyond me."

A principle drawn from it. Being fully seen is bearable only when the seer is trustworthy. A friend who knows everything about you and loves you is a home. The same knowledge in the hands of someone who does not love you is dangerous. So the question to ask of any seeing is not first "How much does the watcher see?" but "Who is the watcher?"

Our judgement today. The psalm is a prayer of a believer to God. It is not a rule that humans may watch one another, and it is not an argument that nothing is private. Some people use the psalm like this: "If God sees everything, you should have nothing to hide from your employer or your government." That is a leap the text does not make. The psalmist speaks of the only one who knows the heart as well as the act, and who is the Creator. No human watcher is in that place. We will come back to that.

3. Genesis 3: hiding from the one who sees

What the text says. After the man and the woman eat the fruit, they hear the sound of Yahweh God walking in the garden, and they hide. God calls to the man, "Where are you?" The man answers that he heard the voice, was afraid, was naked, and hid.

Notice three things in the text. First, the hiding comes after the act. Before it, they were naked and not ashamed; after it, they hide. Second, God's first words are a question. Many readers, in many traditions, have noticed that the question does not read like the words of one who cannot find someone. It reads like a call. Third, the man gives two reasons: fear, and nakedness. He does not say, "I have done wrong." He says he was afraid because he was exposed.

A principle drawn from it. The wish to hide is old, and it is not always the wish of the guilty. It can be the wish of anyone who feels exposed. A person who is seen without being met feels uncovered. A person whom God calls by name, in a question that gives a chance to answer, is treated as someone who can answer.

Our judgement today. The story does not say that wanting privacy is wrong, and it does not say that wanting privacy proves guilt. We should be slow to say about anyone, "If you were not hiding something, you would not mind being watched." In Genesis 3 the one who hides is afraid, ashamed and in the wrong, and the one who comes in search is God. In our world the one who looks may be a manager or an office or a system, and none of them is God. The text gives us no licence to treat them as if they were.

4. Hagar: seen by God when no one else saw

What the text says. In Genesis 16 Hagar is a servant, treated harshly, and she runs away into the wilderness. The angel of Yahweh finds her by a spring. She is alone, pregnant, with no rights and no protector. In the verse we have read, she gives a name to the God who spoke to her: "You are a God who sees." Then she asks, in her astonishment, whether she has stayed alive after seeing him.

A principle drawn from it. Here being seen is not exposure or control. It is rescue from being invisible. Hagar's masters used her; no one in the story had asked what she needed. The God who sees looks at the one that nobody looks at. This gives the course its second, more important thread. Watching is a power, and power has a direction. A good deal of the watching in the world is aimed at people who are already weak: workers, children, the poor, strangers. And there is another sort of failing to see: the weak are often the ones that systems and powerful people do not see as persons at all. Sight can serve a person, and the lack of it can also do harm. So the question is never only "Is this person being watched?" but also "Is this person being seen?"

Our judgement today. We should be careful here. Hagar's story does not tell us whether a church may keep a list of members who need help. It tells us what kind of seeing God honours: seeing that notices the person nobody notices, and that goes to them. This is a standard against which to test human seeing. It is not a rule that settles any case.

5. What God's seeing is, and what a human watcher's is not

Compare the scenes with the human watcher. There are at least three differences.

God knows the heart as well as the act. A human watcher, whether a person or a system, sees what can be seen: where a person goes, what a person types, how long a person stops. The watcher then guesses at the reason. The guess may be wrong. A woman who leaves her station for six minutes may be sick, or grieving, or helping a colleague. A watcher who only sees the six minutes may judge her. The psalmist is known "altogether", words before they are spoken. No human watcher sees like that, and none should act as if it did.

God's seeing is joined to love and to justice. The psalm ends with a request to be led in the "everlasting way". Seeing is the beginning of guidance, not only of record. Human watching is often joined to a different aim: to count, to save money, to prevent loss, to prove blame later. These aims are not always wrong. But they are not love, and we should not say they are.

God can be answered. The man in the garden is asked a question. The watched were given a chance to speak. A great deal of human watching has no place where the watched can say, "That is not what happened." A record made about you that you cannot see and cannot correct is a different thing from being known by God.

So when we say that human watchers must not take the place of God, we do not mean that every watcher is sinful. We mean that a human watcher has less knowledge, more mixed motives and fewer ways to be answered than the God of the psalm, and so should hold power with more caution, not less.

6. The panopticon: a picture of seeing without being seen

This section is history only. In the late eighteenth century an English thinker named Jeremy Bentham described a plan for a building, which he called a panopticon, a word made from Greek words that mean roughly "all-seeing". The plan was for a round building, such as a prison, with a tower in the middle. The rooms were arranged around the ring so that a watcher in the tower could see into every room, while the people in the rooms could not tell whether they were being watched at that moment. The idea was that if you never know when you are watched, you will behave as if you are always watched.

We do not need to decide here whether the plan was ever carried out in full, or what Bentham hoped for. We take it only as a picture of something in the world. Its heart is not the tower. It is the one-way look: the watcher sees and is not seen, the watched cannot see who watches, or when, or what is written down. Compare this with Genesis 3. There, the one who sees comes into the open, speaks, and asks. In the picture of the panopticon, the one who sees stays hidden, and the watched adjust themselves without a word being said.

The lesson is not that every camera is a panopticon. It is that a setting where watching is hidden and one-sided changes the watched. They become quiet, careful, and sometimes afraid. Scripture teaches that people are made for a face-to-face life, where we are known, answered, and addressed by name. A setting that takes this away has a cost to persons, whatever its gain.

7. Three questions for every watcher

Here is the tool we will use for the whole week. It is deliberately short.

The three questions of the watcher

1. Who is watching? Name a person or an office. If no one can be named, that is already a finding.

2. For whom? Whose purpose does the watching serve: the watched person, the watcher, someone else? Is the purpose said aloud?

3. With what right? What gives this watcher the standing to see this? Was it given by the person, by a role that person accepted, by a duty of care, or by a written rule that the person could read? Or was it simply possible?

Notice the word "possible". The most important error in this field is the quiet slide from "we can see this" to "we may see this." Being able to see is not the same as having the right to see.

Here is a short case, to try the questions on. (An invented example) In a warehouse, a screen in the manager's office shows how many items each worker handles in each hour. The workers have been told that "performance is measured", but not what is measured, and they cannot see their own figures. A worker named only as "a new employee" had a bad week after a family loss. The manager does not know why. Late in the month, the screen turns her row red.

Who is watching? The manager, and behind the manager, the owners who asked for the measure. For whom? Mostly for the owners' interest in output; the workers are told it is for "fairness", but they cannot check it. With what right? The employer has some right to know that work is done. But does it have the right to see this much, to keep it, and to use it without a chance for the worker to explain? The case does not settle that. It shows the questions that must be asked, and it shows who is least able to ask them.

8. What this course will, and will not, do

This week will not tell you to refuse or to accept any tool. It will not say how to build a system that watches or how to avoid one. It will give you a way of judging, as the other weeks do. In the next lecture we turn to what is hidden and what is entrusted. In the one after that, we meet the reasons people give for watching, including good ones. Then we ask what care looks like when it does not become control.


Diagram 1. Three scenes of being seen

Three Scenes of Being Seen The look is the same. What differs is who looks, and whether you can answer. Psalm 139 Known completely, and not abandoned. Comfort and weight The seer is trusted. The psalm says it is "beyond me". Genesis 3 The man hides. God asks, "Where are you?" Exposure and a question The seer comes into the open and gives a chance to answer. Genesis 16 Hagar is alone. "You are a God who sees." Rescue from invisibility The weak are not seen by people, and are seen by God. A human watcher is not in God's place It sees the act, not the heart. Its motives are mixed. The watched often cannot answer. So it should hold power with more caution, not less. Three questions for every watcher 1. Who is watching? 2. For whom? 3. With what right?

Diagram 2. The one-way look

Genesis 3 The panopticon (history only)
Who sees One who comes into the open and speaks One in a tower who cannot be seen
What the watched are asked "Where are you?" Nothing. They adjust themselves
Can the watched answer? Yes. The man answers No place is given to answer
What it does to the watched Fear, and a chance to speak Quiet, caution, and sometimes fear

In short

  • Scripture speaks of being seen in several ways: Psalm 139 as comfort and weight, Genesis 3 as exposure and a question, Genesis 16 as rescue from being unseen.
  • The difference between care and threat is not the act of looking but who looks, whether the watched know, and whether they can answer.
  • A human watcher sees the act and not the heart, has mixed motives, and often gives the watched no place to answer.
  • The psalm is not an argument that nothing is private; it speaks of God alone.
  • The panopticon is a picture of the one-way look: the watcher sees and is not seen, and the watched change themselves.
  • The three questions of the watcher: who is watching, for whom, and with what right? "We can see it" is not "we may see it."
Front Back
Psalm 139 God knows the whole person and does not leave; comfort that is also a weight.
Genesis 3:9 God's first words to the hiding man are a question: "Where are you?"
Genesis 16:13 Hagar names God as the one who sees; the unseen is seen.
The three questions Who is watching? For whom? With what right?

One sentence to remember To see a person is a power, so before we judge any watching we ask who is watching, for whom, and with what right.

This week's action Choose one place where you are watched or you watch (a workplace, a home, a church) and write the answers to the three questions in three short lines.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a time when being seen was a comfort to you, and a time when it was a weight. What was the difference between the two?
  • Why does the lecture say that Psalm 139 cannot be used to argue that "an honest person has nothing to hide" from a human watcher?
  • In Genesis 3 God's first words are a question. What difference does that make to how we read the scene?
  • Hagar is seen by God when no one else sees her. How can the same course be concerned both with people who are watched too much and with people who are not seen at all?
  • Apply the three questions (who, for whom, with what right) to the warehouse case. What would you need to know before you could judge?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.