FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL5E Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence: Responsibility, Bias, Surveillance, Work

Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching

Contents 31
STEL5E Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence: Responsibility, Bias, Surveillance, Work
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Ethics Is About People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Ethics Is About People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Eyes of Ethics
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
  3. Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
  4. Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Responsibility
  1. Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
  2. Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
  3. Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Bias and Fairness
  1. Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
  2. Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
  3. Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
  4. Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Surveillance and Privacy
  1. Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
  2. Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
  3. Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
  4. Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Work and Livelihood
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
  2. Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
  3. Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
  4. Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Truth, Care and the Church Together
  1. Lecture 6-1: Truth and Counterfeit
  2. Lecture 6-2: Can Care Be Handed Over?
  3. Lecture 6-3: Judging Together as a Church
  4. Lecture 6-4: Dignity at the Centre: Gathering the Course
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Ethics Page

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Most watching is not done by villains. A mother checks that her small child is safe near the water. A manager wants to know that a dangerous machine is being used correctly. A town wishes to protect a street where people have been robbed. A church wants to keep its children safe from harm. These are good aims, and a course that treated every watcher as a suspect would be unfair to them and would be of no use to those who must decide.

But the same reasons can carry us a long way. A watching that begins for safety may continue for convenience, then for control, and in the end it may be used on people it was never meant for. This lecture is about that tension. It looks at three settings (the home, the workplace and public safety), gives four marks by which to judge whether watching is right, and then turns to a point where Christian readers will not agree: how to weigh safety against liberty.

It also takes up two chapters of Scripture that are often brought into this debate, Romans 13 and Revelation 13, and states honestly the different ways they are read.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Describe a good reason and a danger for watching in each of three settings: home, work and public safety.
  • Apply four marks of right watching to a case: stated purpose, proportion, openness, and a limit with a way to object.
  • State fairly the case for safety and the case for liberty.
  • Explain three ways of reading Romans 13, and why Acts 5:29 and Revelation 13 are brought beside it.

Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God. Therefore he who resists the authority, withstands the ordinance of God; and those who withstand will receive to themselves judgment. For rulers are not a terror to the good work, but to the evil. Do you desire to have no fear of the authority? Do that which is good, and you will have praise from the same, for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn’t bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." — Romans 13:1-4

World English Bible

Therefore you need to be in subjection, not only because of the wrath, but also for conscience’ sake. For this reason you also pay taxes, for they are servants of God’s service, attending continually on this very thing. Give therefore to everyone what you owe: taxes to whom taxes are due; customs to whom customs; respect to whom respect; honor to whom honor." — Romans 13:5-7

WEB

But Peter and the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men." — Acts 5:29

WEB

He causes all, the small and the great, the rich and the poor, and the free and the slave, to be given marks on their right hands, or on their foreheads; and that no one would be able to buy or to sell, unless he has that mark, the name of the beast or the number of his name." — Revelation 13:16-17

WEB

These texts are about rulers, obedience, and a power that controls who may buy and sell. They were written for believers who met such powers. They are not about cameras or software. We will say clearly, each time, what is the text, what is a principle drawn from it, and what is our own judgement.

1. Three settings, three good reasons

The home. Parents watch small children, and they should. A child of three needs someone to see where she is. As the child grows, the watching must change, or it becomes something else. A parent of a young teenager may reasonably ask what a child is doing online, and may reasonably set limits. A parent who reads every private message of an older teenager, for years, and tells no one, is no longer watching to protect; the teenager is losing the chance to become someone who can be trusted. The good reason is protection. The danger is that protection is never allowed to end. A useful sign is a plan for the watching to grow lighter as the child grows.

The workplace. An employer may need to know that work is safe and done. Where machines are dangerous, or money is handled, or a customer's private details are kept, some watching protects both workers and the public. The danger is the slide from knowing the work is done to knowing every minute of a person. Measures that count the pace of work, the time away from a desk, or the tone of a person's voice, tend to measure what is easy to measure, not what is good. They can also press hardest on workers with the least power to refuse: those who are paid by the hour, who cannot easily find another job, or who are paid least.

Public safety. A community may want cameras on a street, or a system that tries to match faces against a list, or a way of predicting where harm is likely. Safety is a real good, and the people who are harmed when nobody is looking are very often the weak. The danger is that a tool built to find a few people watches everyone, that the list it matches against is made by someone no one can question, and that the people watched most are not those who most need watching, but those who are already least trusted.

2. Four marks of right watching

In the last lecture we asked three questions: who is watching, for whom, and with what right. The third question deserves more room. A watcher who is asked "with what right?" can be tested by four marks. They are not a legal rule, and they do not give one answer for every setting. They show what to look for.

Four marks of right watching

1. A stated purpose. The watcher can say, in a sentence, what the watching is for. A purpose such as "to be safe" is too wide to test. A purpose such as "to see who enters the building at night" can be tested.

2. Proportion. What is seen is no more than the purpose needs. If a camera can cover the door, it need not cover the whole room. If a number is enough, the person's whole record is not needed.

3. Openness. The watched can know that they are watched, by whom, and what is kept. Hidden watching has a high burden and needs a very strong reason.

4. A limit and a way to object. The watching has an end or a review. What has been collected is not kept for ever. A person who is wrongly described can say so and be heard by someone who can change it.

Notice that each mark guards a different person. Purpose guards the watched from being used for aims they never heard of. Proportion guards the ordinary person from being swept up. Openness guards the person's dignity. The limit and the way to object guard the one who has been wrongly seen.

3. Where readers will not agree: safety and liberty

This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians, and thoughtful people in every tradition, differ on how to weigh safety against liberty, and they differ for reasons that are not foolish.

Some hold that safety must come first, or at least that the burden falls on those who would refuse protection. Their strongest argument runs like this. Love for the neighbour is not only a feeling but a duty to keep the neighbour from harm. Children, the elderly and the poor are the people who are hurt most when no one is looking. A refusal to watch can be a refusal to protect, and those who say "liberty" often do not need protecting as much as those they leave behind. Faced with a real danger, they say, it is unloving to leave a door unguarded for the sake of a principle.

Others hold that liberty must come first, or at least that the burden falls on those who would watch. Their strongest argument runs like this. Every power that watches has a tendency to grow. What is built for one aim is used for others, and what is collected once is kept. The people watched most are not those who do the most harm, but those who have the least power to object. Being watched changes people; they become more careful, more quiet, less willing to speak or to help a neighbour in trouble. A community that trusts its members, they say, is also safer in the long run, and dignity includes the right to be trusted until there is a reason not to be.

Both arguments protect the weak, in different ways. The first says: do not leave the weak unguarded. The second says: do not make the weak the first ones watched. This course does not decide between them. It requires two things only. First, do not blur responsibility: whoever decides to watch can be named, and answers for it. Second, keep the weak in sight: ask both who could be harmed if no one looks, and who could be harmed by the looking. A judgement that has asked only one of these questions has not finished.

4. Three ways of reading Romans 13

Romans 13:1-7 is one of the most used passages in debates about authority, and it is used in debates about watching too. It is wise to know that readers have taken it in more than one way.

One reading takes the passage as a call to respect authorities in their proper role. Rulers, it says, are "a servant of God to you for good", they keep order, and they are not a terror to good conduct. On this reading, a Christian does not start from suspicion of public watching that is meant to keep people safe. The passage supports a presumption of cooperation with lawful measures for the public good.

A second reading takes the passage together with Acts 5:29. In Acts the apostles are told by the authorities to stop teaching, and they answer, "We must obey God rather than men." On this reading, Romans 13 describes a normal case and Acts 5 describes the limit. An authority that commands what God forbids, or forbids what God commands, does not receive obedience from conscience at that point. Whether a given measure falls on one side of the line or the other is a matter for judgement and not for a slogan.

A third reading pays attention to the measure that the passage itself gives. The authority is "a servant of God to you for good". Readers who hold this view say that the passage praises authority by what it does: it is for the good, and rewards good conduct, and it does not terrorise the good. They conclude that an authority which is not acting for the good of those it watches has not earned the passage's praise, though they differ about what a Christian should then do.

These three readings are held by serious readers, and they are not exclusive. A person can hold something of each. What no reading permits is to use Romans 13 as if it settled whether a particular tool may be used. The passage was written to believers in a city under imperial rule, long before the tools we are discussing. It tells us something about the standing of government, and not about any camera.

5. Revelation 13: handle with care

Revelation 13 describes a beast that gives a mark to all, small and great, rich and poor, free and slave, so that no one may buy or sell without it. This passage has often been used to condemn some new form of identification or tracking. Readers in the Christian tradition have read it in several ways. Some read it as a picture of a particular historical power in the first century that demanded loyalty and controlled trade. Some read it as a picture of an end-time power still to come. Some read it as a picture of any power in any age that claims the place of God and uses control of daily life, including buying and selling, to force a loyalty that belongs to God alone.

Two cautions follow. First, we do not say that any present-day tool, company or government is what Revelation 13 describes. To do so would be to pass judgement on a present group with a certainty the text does not give us, and the church has repeatedly been wrong when it tried. Second, what we can take as a principle from the passage, on any of the readings, is a warning: when a power controls whether a person can buy, sell, work or belong, that power holds something close to a hold on a person's whole life, and a believer should ask whom that power asks them to serve. This is a principle, not a rule about any tool, and our own judgement must say whether any given arrangement comes near it.

6. Those who have been watched

There is one more voice to hear. In many times and places, churches have met knowing that someone might be writing down names. A register of who came, a list of who gave, a note of who prayed aloud: these are ordinary things, and in some places they have been a danger to those whose names were on them. Communities that have lived this way have learned things that others forget. A name that is written can be found. A list that was made for care can be taken and used for harm. Some of these communities keep very little in writing, and some meet without announcing where or when.

Their view is not a political argument. It is a memory. It reminds a church that has never been watched in this way not to assume that its own lists are safe in other hands, or in another country, or in another decade. It also reminds us that the people who most need a church's care, the migrant, the new convert, the person at odds with family or state, are the people for whom a record can be dangerous. A church that wants to use a tool that collects or shares such records should ask this question first: if this list were read by someone who meant us harm, who would be hurt?

7. Two short cases

(An invented example) A father learns that his thirteen-year-old daughter has been talking online to an adult stranger. He is frightened. He asks to see the messages and she refuses. He wonders whether he should use a programme on her phone that would show him everything she does without her knowing. Apply the four marks. His purpose is a good one. But is the whole of her private life needed to serve it? Could he tell her openly that he will look, and why? Could he say when it will end? A father who watches openly and for a limited time, and who explains, is doing something different from a father who watches in secret and does not stop. What the case does not say is that either father is a bad man.

(An invented example) A church had a break-in at its hall. The council considers a camera at the entrance. Three members object. One is a recent arrival from a country where his congregation was infiltrated, and he is troubled by any record of who comes. The council might choose a camera that faces only the door, that keeps its recordings for a short time only, that is announced on a notice in the hall, and that is viewed only by two named people when a theft is reported. It might also choose not to have a camera and to find another way. Both are within what the course allows. What the course asks is that the council ask the three questions, that the member's memory is heard, and that someone is named who answers if the record is misused.


Diagram 1. Four marks of right watching

With What Right? Four Marks A test for any watching: home, work or public place 1. A stated purpose Can it be said in one sentence? "To be safe" is too wide. Guards the watched from unknown aims. 2. Proportion No more is seen than the purpose needs. The door, not the whole room. Guards the ordinary person. 3. Openness The watched can know who, and what is kept. Hidden watching needs a strong reason. Guards dignity. 4. A limit and a way to object An end or a review. A person wrongly described can say so and be heard. Guards the one wrongly seen. Safety and liberty: readers will not agree Safety says: do not leave the weak unguarded. Liberty says: do not make the weak the first watched. The course requires: name who answers, and keep the weak in sight both ways. If this list were read by someone who meant us harm, who would be hurt? Ask it before any list, camera or record is made.

Diagram 2. Three readings of Romans 13

Reading Emphasis Pointer to
Respect for rightful authority A presumption of cooperation with lawful measures for the public good Romans 13:1-4
The normal case and its limit Obedience, except where it means disobeying God Acts 5:29
Authority judged by its purpose The ruler is "for good"; praise follows what the authority does Romans 13:3-4

In short

  • Watching has good reasons in home, work and public safety, and each has a danger that grows with time.
  • Four marks test watching: a stated purpose, proportion, openness, and a limit with a way to object.
  • Christians differ on safety against liberty. The course requires only that responsibility not be blurred and the weak be kept in sight.
  • Romans 13 has been read as respect for authority, as a normal case limited by Acts 5:29, and as authority judged by its purpose.
  • Revelation 13 has several readings; this course names no present tool or group as its beast.
  • A community that has been watched asks: if this list were read by someone who meant us harm, who would be hurt?
Front Back
The four marks A stated purpose; proportion; openness; a limit and a way to object.
What the course requires on safety and liberty Name who answers for the watching, and keep the weak in sight both ways.
Romans 13 and Acts 5:29 The normal case of respect for authority, and its limit when obedience would mean disobeying God.
Revelation 13 Read in several ways; no present tool or group is named as its beast.

One sentence to remember Watching for safety can be right, and the way to keep it right is a stated purpose, proportion, openness, and a way for the watched to object.

This week's action Choose one kind of watching you meet (a camera, a measure at work, a rule at home) and test it against the four marks, writing one line for each.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • In which of the three settings (home, workplace, public safety) is it hardest for you to say where good watching ends? Why?
  • Take one of the four marks (stated purpose, proportion, openness, a limit and a way to object). Think of a real kind of watching you know of in general terms and say which mark is easiest to forget.
  • State the argument for safety in its strongest form, and then the argument for liberty in its strongest form. Which seemed harder to put fairly?
  • Why is it wrong to say that Romans 13 settles whether a tool may be used? Why is it wrong to say that Revelation 13 identifies one?
  • What does a community that has been watched teach a community that has not? What question follows?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.