Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
- Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
- Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
- Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
- Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
- Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
- Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
- Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
- Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
- Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
- Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
- Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
- Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
- Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
- Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
- Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
- Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
- Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
We say of a person "she chose it" and of a machine "it selected an answer". The two sentences sound alike, and the difference between them hides a very old question: what does it mean to choose? If everything that happens has causes, then so does what I decide. If my decisions have causes that go back to my birth, my upbringing, my body and the world, in what sense are they mine? And yet we hold people answerable for what they do, and the Bible calls people to choose.
This lecture sets out three broad answers to the question of free will, shows how Christian streams have taken them up, and asks what the question looks like when we ask whether a machine "chooses". It links to the question of who answers for what a tool does, which is the subject of Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (STEL5E). Here we stay with the nature of freedom itself.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain determinism, compatibilism and libertarian freedom in plain words.
- Describe, in broad strokes, how Reformed, Lutheran, Arminian, Catholic and Orthodox streams have spoken of the will and of grace.
- State fairly the disagreement between those who hold that freedom needs the power to do otherwise and those who hold that it does not.
- Explain what is at stake when people ask whether a machine "chooses", without claiming what any machine does.
- Show why Deuteronomy 30:19, Proverbs 16:9 and Philippians 2:12-13 are read together and not against each other.
I call heaven and earth to witness against you this day, that I have set before you life and death, the blessing and the curse. Therefore choose life, that you may live, you and your descendants;" — Deuteronomy 30:19
World English Bible
A man’s heart plans his course, but Yahweh directs his steps." — Proverbs 16:9
WEB
So then, my beloved, even as you have always obeyed, not only in my presence, but now much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling. For it is God who works in you both to will and to work, for his good pleasure." — Philippians 2:12-13
WEB
Moses sets life and death before the people and tells them to choose. The proverb says the heart plans and God directs. Paul tells believers to work out their salvation and says that God works in them to will and to work. Read together they hold two things side by side, and Christian thinkers have spent centuries asking how.
1. The question, put plainly
Everyday life assumes that we choose. We make plans, weigh reasons, regret, blame and praise. Yet we also know that choices have causes. A person raised in hunger may find it harder to trust. A person in pain may snap. A person who has learned a habit may find it hard to break. The more we learn about how bodies, brains and surroundings shape people, the more we may wonder whether anything is left over for "I chose".
Three broad answers have been given. They are not Christian or non-Christian answers; Christians and non-Christians are found on all three. We state each in the form its holders would accept.
2. Answer one: determinism
Determinism holds that every event, including every human decision, is the necessary result of earlier causes together with the laws of nature. Given everything that was true before, only one thing could happen next. A determinist may add that this does not feel like a prison, because the causes of my choice include my own thoughts, wishes and character. But in the end, on this view, nothing I decide could have been otherwise.
A strict determinist usually concludes that "free will", in the sense of an uncaused act, does not exist. Some go on to say that praise and blame must then be rethought; others say that we shall go on holding each other to account, because it works.
A strength: it takes seriously how much of us is caused, and it fits a picture of the world as an orderly whole.
A weak point: it seems to undercut the sense in which we deliberate. If the outcome is fixed, why weigh anything? And many find that holding people answerable at all is hard to make sense of if no one could have done other than they did.
3. Answer two: compatibilism
Compatibilism is the view that freedom and determinism are not enemies. It says that being free does not mean being uncaused; it means acting according to one's own wishes and reasons, without being forced from outside. A man who walks out of a room because he wishes to is free; a man who is carried out by guards is not. Both the walk and the carrying have causes. The difference is whether the action comes from the person's own will. On this view you can be fully caused and fully free, because the causes run through your character and desires.
A strength: it keeps our ordinary practice of praise, blame and answerability without denying that choices have causes. It is also a way of reading some important Christian teaching about God's sovereignty and human responsibility together.
A weak point: a critic asks whether it has changed the meaning of "free". If my wishes were themselves caused by things I did not choose, in what sense is acting on them my doing? The compatibilist replies that this demand for a first cause is a demand no one could meet, and that it is the wrong test of freedom.
4. Answer three: libertarian freedom
Libertarian freedom (the word has nothing to do with the political movement) is the view that a free act is one where the person really could have done otherwise, in exactly the same situation. The act is not fully fixed by earlier causes; the person is its source, and a different choice was open. Those who hold this view often say that without this power, responsibility is a pretence: you cannot be blamed for what you could not avoid.
A strength: it matches how deliberation feels and what we seem to presuppose when we say "you should have chosen differently". It holds that love freely given is only love if it could have been withheld.
A weak point: critics ask how an act can be neither fixed by causes nor merely random. If nothing in me settled the choice, how is it mine? Defenders of the view reply that the person, as a source of action, is itself the explanation, though they differ in how to describe it.
5. How Christian streams have taken them up
Here we speak in broad strokes and only about what is well known, as each stream would describe itself. Any stream has more variety than a few lines can show.
Reformed teaching has generally stressed God's sovereignty over all things, and the bondage of the human will to sin until grace frees it. The Westminster Confession of 1646, a leading Reformed statement, says that God's decree does not do violence to the will of creatures, but establishes their freedom. Many Reformed thinkers are therefore called compatibilists: they hold that people choose according to their own desires, and that this is what responsibility needs. The American theologian Jonathan Edwards, in the eighteenth century, argued in this direction.
Lutheran teaching has stressed that the human will in matters of salvation is not free to turn itself to God without the Spirit's work, while holding that in ordinary matters people truly choose. Martin Luther's The Bondage of the Will (1525) was written against Erasmus, who had defended the freedom of the will in 1524. Later Lutheran writers have held various positions, and the tradition holds together the claim that God alone saves with the claim that people are accountable.
Arminian teaching, from Jacobus Arminius in the Dutch lands around 1600 and widely taken up in Methodist and many Evangelical and Pentecostal churches, holds that God's grace goes before every good act but can be resisted, so that human beings truly can accept or refuse. This is closer to a libertarian view of freedom. It is held to protect the reality of love and the justice of judgement.
Catholic teaching holds that human beings are truly free and are responsible for their acts, and that grace comes first and heals and lifts the will. In the sixteenth century Catholic teachers disputed how divine grace and human freedom fit together. Dominican theologians stressed God's priority in every act; Jesuit theologians stressed human freedom more. The church did not settle the dispute in favour of either, and the church allows both to be taught.
Orthodox teaching speaks of synergy, a Greek word meaning "working together": God and the human being cooperating in salvation, with God's grace always first. The human will is wounded but not destroyed, and freedom is understood less as a neutral power to pick either option than as the growing capacity to turn toward the good and toward communion with God.
Notice that these streams differ, and they also overlap. All say that God is first. All say that people are accountable. They differ on how to hold these together, and on whether the power to do otherwise is necessary for freedom.
6. Reading three verses together
Deuteronomy 30:19 sets before the people life and death and says choose. The text speaks as if the choice is truly theirs, and the call would be pointless otherwise. Proverbs 16:9 says that the heart plans a course, and God directs the steps. Paul says in Philippians 2:12-13 both to work out salvation and that God is the one at work in the believer. These verses do not say how the two fit; they place them side by side without apology.
A reader may take them in different ways. A compatibilist may say that the verses show choice and sovereignty are two descriptions of one event. A libertarian may say that the verses show God leaving room for a real human answer. Others may say that the verses stand as a mystery we are not meant to explain. What the three verses support, on every reading, is that a Christian should neither say "it is all fixed, so nothing I do matters" nor "it is all up to me, so I need no help." Both sentences are rejected by the text in different ways.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that freedom requires the power to do otherwise, because without it neither obedience nor love nor guilt would mean anything, and because Scripture's calls to choose assume a real alternative. They would add that making God the cause of every choice makes it hard to say why sin is not God's doing. Others hold that freedom is acting from one's own heart without compulsion, because Scripture also teaches that God directs the steps and works in the will, and because a freedom that depended on being uncaused would put our salvation in our own hands. They would add that the demand for a power to do otherwise sets up a freedom that no one could have, and that it leaves the sovereignty of God hard to confess. Each side can say what the other struggles to answer: the first, how God's rule over all can be real; the second, how guilt is real if one could not do otherwise. What this course requires is less than either requires: that you can state the other's reasons fairly, and that you hold your view with the humility that Philippians 2:12-13 itself suggests, "with fear and trembling".
7. When we ask whether a machine "chooses"
Now we can look at the question from the other side. We say that a machine "chooses" an answer, "decides" to flag a message, "prefers" one option over another. These words are borrowed from the vocabulary of persons. What happens when we ask whether they are true?
We make no claim about how any machine works. We state the shape of the question under each view.
- If freedom means being uncaused, then a machine whose selection is fully explained by its design and the data it received is plainly not free, and neither, on this view, is anyone whose acts are fully explained. The question is then whether human beings are exceptions to causation, and why.
- If freedom means acting according to one's own wishes and reasons without outside force (compatibilism), the question is whether the machine has wishes and reasons of its own, in the sense that makes them its wishes. That depends on matters of mind and consciousness from lecture 2-2, and on whether anything in the machine is its own as opposed to the maker's.
- If freedom means the power to do otherwise in the same circumstances, the question becomes whether anything in a machine plays the role of an agent as a source, or whether it only runs.
In every case the question about a machine is not settled by the word "choose". A machine may be said to select without it being said to choose in the sense in which a person chooses. The sentence "it selected" is true in every picture; the sentence "it chose" depends on the picture.
The larger point is a human one. What makes a choice a person's choice, and not merely an event, is bound up with things that persons have: a life, a character, a set of loves, a place among others who can ask "why did you do that?", and the ability to be held to account. Whichever view of freedom you hold, these ties belong to the answer.
8. Freedom, responsibility and the tool
This brings us back to responsibility. Whatever view of freedom is true, we do not hold a tool answerable. We do not require an apology from it, and we do not restore what it broke by making it pay. The people who made it, chose to use it, relied on it or could have said no are the ones who answer. That does not change if the tool is complex, or if its output is hard to predict. A person who sets something in motion and cannot predict what it does has not thereby become free of what it does. Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (STEL5E) works this out in detail. Here we need only see the link: the question of freedom is not an escape from the question of who answers. Nobody who is serious about freedom can say "the system chose, so I did not".
9. Three layers
- What the text says. Deuteronomy 30:19 sets life and death before the people and says to choose. Proverbs 16:9 says the heart plans and Yahweh directs the steps. Philippians 2:12-13 tells believers to work out their salvation and says God works in them to will and to work.
- A tradition's reading. Reformed, Lutheran, Arminian, Catholic and Orthodox streams read these verses in the ways sketched above, and the church has never required a single account of how divine action and human choice fit together.
- Our judgement. We judge that a Christian can neither deny that choices matter nor deny that God is first, and that the question whether a machine "chooses" must not be allowed to blur the question of who answers for what the machine does. Beyond this we hold our view of freedom humbly.
Diagram 1. Three answers about freedom
In short
- Determinism says earlier causes fix every event; compatibilism says freedom is acting from your own will without outside force; libertarian freedom says freedom needs the power to do otherwise.
- Reformed, Lutheran, Arminian, Catholic and Orthodox streams all say God is first and people are accountable; they differ on how the two fit.
- Deuteronomy 30:19, Proverbs 16:9 and Philippians 2:12-13 are read together; they reject both "all fixed" and "all up to me".
- Readers do not agree whether freedom needs the power to do otherwise; hold your view with humility.
- "It selected" is true on every view; whether "it chose" is true depends on the view of freedom and on questions of mind.
- A tool is not held answerable; the people who made it, used it or relied on it are.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Determinism | Earlier causes and the laws of nature fix every event, including every decision. |
| Compatibilism | Freedom is acting from your own wishes and reasons without outside force; it can sit with causation. |
| Libertarian freedom | Freedom needs the real power to do otherwise in the same situation. |
| Synergy | The Orthodox word for God and the human being working together, with God's grace first. |
One sentence to remember Whatever freedom is, a tool is not made answerable by it, and people who use the tool are not made innocent by calling its output a choice.
This week's action Notice one occasion this week when you say a tool "decided" or "wants" something, and rewrite the sentence naming the person who answers.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Describe a decision you made that you would call free. What would have to be true for it to be less free? More free?
- A compatibilist says a man walking out because he wishes to is free, and a man carried out is not. Do you find the line clear? Where would you test it?
- Why do the Arminian and Reformed streams each think the other puts something precious at risk? State each concern in words the other would recognise.
- Deuteronomy 30:19 says "choose" and Philippians 2:13 says God works in the will. What does a believer lose by holding only one of them?
- Which of the three pictures makes "it chose" most natural when said of a machine? Which makes it least natural? What does this show about the word?
- Why can nobody who takes freedom seriously say "the system chose, so I did not"?