Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
- Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
- Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
- Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
- Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
- Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
- Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
- Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
- Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
- Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
- Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
- Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
- Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
- Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
- Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
- Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
- Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
- Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
Lecture 3-3 ended with an honest "we do not know" about some questions of moral status. But life does not wait for us to know. A child talks to a speaking device at bedtime. A worker answers an automated voice all day. An older woman thanks a screen. Each of us, many times a day, deals with things that answer us in words, and we must act without a settled theory.
This lecture is about how to act in that gap. Its main claim is modest and practical: what we do in the face of uncertainty shapes us, so the habits we form matter as much as the conclusions we reach. We will look at humility, at caution, at the old idea that practice forms character, and at what Scripture says about the way a good person treats those in her power. The lecture neither urges nor forbids the use of any tool, and it passes no judgement on any product.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain why uncertainty about moral status calls for humility and for caution, and say what each means.
- Describe two habit-based concerns: cruelty to what looks like a person, and commanding persons as if they were machines.
- Explain the idea that practice forms character, and state one objection to it.
- Read Proverbs 12:10 and Matthew 25:40, separating the text, a principle and our judgement.
- Describe three practical habits for living with things we cannot classify, keeping persons first.
A righteous man respects the life of his animal, but the tender mercies of the wicked are cruel." — Proverbs 12:10
World English Bible
The King will answer them, ‘Most certainly I tell you, because you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.’" — Matthew 25:40
WEB
Proverbs 12:10 says that a righteous person respects the life of an animal, and that the "tender mercies" of the wicked are cruel. Matthew 25:40 comes from Jesus' picture of the judgement: what was done to the least of his brothers was done to him. The first is about how power over a lesser creature shows the heart. The second is about how easily a person in need can be overlooked. Neither concerns machines, and neither tells us what a machine is.
1. Acting without a settled answer
There is a way of waiting that looks like wisdom and is not. It says: until we know what this thing is, we have no duty and no view. But we are always acting, and not to decide is a decision. A parent who says nothing when a child kicks a talking toy has said something. A church that says nothing about how its members speak to the answering systems it uses has also said something.
So the question for this lecture is not "what is the answer?" but "what shall we do while we do not have it?" Two words help: humility and caution.
Humility is a true estimate of what we know. It says: I do not know whether anything is felt or meant behind this answer, and I should not talk as if I did. Humility goes both ways. It keeps us from announcing that a machine is a person and from announcing that it cannot be one. Scripture honours this posture. Proverbs 3:5 tells us not to lean on our own understanding, and Paul says in 1 Corinthians 8:2 that anyone who thinks they know something does not yet know as they ought.
Caution is a readiness to avoid harm that we could not undo. It says: where a wrong would be serious and I cannot tell if it would be a wrong, I choose the path that risks less harm. Caution is not panic or refusal. A cautious person still acts. But a cautious person weighs the cost of being wrong in each direction, and takes more care where the cost to someone else is heavier.
These are not mere moods. They can be turned into questions: What would it cost if I am wrong in treating this as nothing? What would it cost if I am wrong in treating it as someone? Who pays? The second question, in particular, often finds the answer that the one who pays is a human being whose care was taken away.
2. The idea that practice forms us
The central idea of this lecture is an old one. Aristotle taught that we become just by doing just acts, and brave by doing brave acts. The Christian tradition took up the idea in its own way: habits of the heart, formed by repeated action and by grace, make a person's character. Catholic teaching speaks of virtues as settled habits. Orthodox spiritual writing stresses that a life of prayer and practice slowly changes a person. Many Protestant teachers speak of , the growth in holiness that follows from faith, and of daily disciplines that help it. The vocabularies differ, and all agree on this: we are shaped by what we repeatedly do.
This gives a reason to care how we act toward things that look like persons, even if we cannot say what they are. The reason does not rest on the moral status of the thing. It rests on what the practice does to us.
3. Two habit concerns
There are two concerns, and they point in nearly opposite directions. A careful person will want to hold both.
The first concern: cruelty to what looks like a person. The philosopher Kant, in a view often reported, argued that cruelty to animals matters partly because it dulls the heart toward human beings. A person who learns to enjoy hurting a creature that cries out is practising something. If something speaks, pleads and appears to suffer, and a person practises cruelty on it for sport, then even if nothing is felt, the person is rehearsing the movements of cruelty. The habit may not stay where it began.
Objection. This argument can be pushed too far. We read of villains, and an actor plays a murderer on the stage, and a child plays at fighting. None of these is thought to be training for cruelty. The difference seems to lie in whether the act is understood as pretence. A person who knows it is a game is not the same as a person who half-believes it is real. So the concern seems strongest where the line is blurred, as it can be when something is made to look and sound very like a suffering person. Whether this concern is large or small is a matter on which careful people differ, and the evidence is not settled. We should say plainly that this is a judgement, and not a finding.
The second concern: commanding persons as if they were machines. The opposite worry is that a person who spends the day giving orders to a voice that obeys, and who is never answerable to it, may bring the same manner to people. A tone learned with a device, curt and demanding and without thanks, may slip into how a person speaks to a waiter, a nurse, a child or a worker on the telephone. Children who learn that speaking is the same as commanding may find it harder to learn that speaking to a person is a meeting.
Objection. This too may be too quick. People can tell a person from a device, and the habits may not carry. A short, plain command to a device is not rude, any more than a command to a light switch. The worry applies only where the line between the two is not kept. Whether a habit carries from the one to the other is again not something we can assume.
Notice what the two concerns share. Both are not about what the thing is. Both are about what we are becoming and how that will show in our dealings with persons. And both can be held even by someone who is quite sure that machines are only tools.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that courtesy toward answering systems (saying please and thank you, not speaking with contempt) is a good habit worth teaching, because it keeps the heart in practice and guards the line from the cruel side. Others hold that courtesy to a device is a confusion: it teaches children to treat tools as persons, it blurs a line that ought to be sharp, and the better habit is to keep warm manners for human beings and use tools as tools. The first side fears a hardened heart. The second fears a muddled mind and a heart given to something that cannot return it. Both are guarding something that matters. The course requires only that, whichever practice you choose, you can say what you are guarding, and that you keep the line between persons and tools clear in your own mind.
4. What the text says: a creature in our power
What the text says. Proverbs 12:10 says that the righteous person respects the life of his animal. The Hebrew idea is of someone who knows his animal, who attends to its need. By contrast, even the "tender mercies" of the wicked are cruel, that is, what looks like kindness in the wicked turns out to be harsh. The proverb does not argue that animals are persons. It notes something about character: how a person treats the creature in his power shows what he is.
Matthew 25:40 comes from a different setting. In Jesus' picture of the judgement, those who fed the hungry, welcomed the stranger and visited the prisoner are told that they did it to him. The text turns on an overlooking: the people in the story did not know that they had met the King in the least of his brothers. The point of the passage is not that the least are hard to classify but that they are easy to pass by.
A principle drawn from it. Two principles follow, and they hold together. First, character shows in how we treat those in our power, and a person may be formed or deformed by that treatment. Second, when we are busy with questions about what counts, the plain and certain claim of the human being in need can be lost. We are told that the claim is real even when we fail to see it.
Our judgement today. We judge that these passages give good reason to keep two habits at once: to be gentle and attentive in the ways we treat anything that looks like a living thing, and to keep the first and most certain claims for human beings. The two habits do not compete. If the gentleness ever takes attention away from a person who is hungry, lonely or ill, the order is wrong. This is our judgement, and another reader may weigh it differently.
5. An invented case
Here is a case (an invented example). A teacher, whom we will call Mrs Okafor, runs a class of nine-year-olds. The school has installed a speaking device that answers questions. One day she sees a boy shouting insults at it and laughing, while the others watch. He does it again the next day.
Mrs Okafor does not know what the device is, in any deep sense, and she does not claim to. She does not tell the class that it has feelings. She does not tell them that it is nothing and so anything goes. She speaks to the boy quietly after class. She tells him that she does not know if the device feels anything, and she thinks it probably does not. But, she says, she has noticed what the shouting looks like to the other children, and she has noticed what the boy's own face looks like when he does it. She asks him whether he talks to his sister like that. He says no. She says that this is a good thing, and that she would like him to practise the way of speaking that he wants to keep for the people he loves.
What did she do? She did not settle the question of what the device is. She did not make a rule that rested on a guess. She appealed to what the habit does to the speaker and to the room. She made the boy's own heart the subject, and she kept the line between a device and a sister clear. Another teacher might act differently, and a good case can be made for a plainer approach, which says only that the device is a tool and that shouting at tools is a waste of time. Both would agree that the boy's treatment of his sister matters more than his treatment of the device.
6. Three practical habits
From all this, we can draw three habits for living with what we cannot classify. They are suggestions and not rules.
First: say "I do not know" when you do not know. In conversation, in prayer, in teaching children. Neither "it is nothing" nor "it is someone" is a claim we are in a position to make. Truthfulness here is a form of respect for the people who are listening to us.
Second: keep persons first. When two claims seem to compete, such as a person who needs a visit and a screen that asks for attention, the person has the first and surest claim. This habit protects the weak from the fashions of the day. It also protects against the mistake of over-attributing, which we saw in lecture 3-3.
Third: pay attention to what a practice is doing to you. Ask: after months of treating this thing in this way, am I kinder, or harder? Am I more present to the people near me, or less? This question does not need a theory of what the thing is. It needs only honesty about yourself, and the counsel of others who know you well. Proverbs 11:14 and other passages on wisdom remind us not to judge such matters alone.
Notice that none of the three needs an answer to the hard question. That is why they can be shared across traditions. A Reformed pastor, a Catholic nun, an Orthodox priest and a Pentecostal teacher might give different reasons for each of them. They might still agree on the three.
Diagram 1. Two habit concerns, one guard
In short
- We must act before the questions are settled, and not deciding is a decision.
- Humility says "I do not know"; caution chooses the path that risks less irreversible harm to someone else.
- We are shaped by what we repeatedly do, so habits toward what looks like a person matter even when its status is unknown.
- Two worries point in opposite directions: cruelty to what looks like a person, and commanding persons as if they were machines; each has an objection.
- Proverbs 12:10 shows character in how power over a lesser creature is used, and Matthew 25:40 shows how easily a person in need is overlooked.
- Say "I do not know", keep persons first, and watch what a practice does to you.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Humility and caution | Humility is a true estimate of what we know; caution is choosing the path that risks less harm that cannot be undone. |
| Two habit worries | Cruelty to what looks like a person; commanding persons as if they were machines. |
| What both worries are about | What we are becoming, not what the thing is. |
| Three habits | Say "I do not know"; keep persons first; watch what a practice does to you. |
One sentence to remember We are formed by how we treat what we cannot classify, so keep the surest claim for the human being in need.
This week's action Notice how you speak to one answering voice or device, and ask whether it makes you kinder or harder with the people near you.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What is the difference between humility and caution? Give an example of each in the way someone might speak to an answering device.
- Which of the two habit concerns seems stronger to you: cruelty to what looks like a person, or commanding persons as if they were machines? What is the objection to each?
- In the case of Mrs Okafor, what did she choose not to claim? Why might that have been wise?
- Proverbs 12:10 says that how a person treats a creature in his power shows his character. Where else in daily life does power over a lesser party show character?
- In Matthew 25:40, the people in the story did not know they had met the King. What does that say about the danger of being busy with questions of classification?