Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
- Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
- Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
- Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
- Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
- Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
- Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
- Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
- Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
- Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
- Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
- Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
- Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
- Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
- Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
- Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
- Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
- Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
The first three lectures of this week asked what a meeting between persons is, what friendship needs, and what grief asks. This lecture draws them together around one word: presence. Christians say that God did not help us from a distance but came among us. The church, in turn, is asked to be a people who are present to one another.
We ask what it means that care costs, and we are careful not to say too much. Not every cost is a proof of love, and a tired carer is not a failure. We then ask a practical question that many churches now face: which parts of care may be helped by tools, and which must be done by a person? The strict ethics of this belongs to Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (STEL5E, Week 6), and the wider theology of AI in church life belongs to Christianity and Artificial Intelligence (PT8E). Here we give a way of sorting, not a rule.
As before, we make no claims about what any machine can do. We argue from what care is.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Explain how the incarnation (John 1:14, Hebrews 4:15) grounds the Christian idea of presence.
- Describe three kinds of cost in care (time, risk, self) and one danger of treating cost as the proof of love.
- Sort acts of care into those that can be assisted, those done together with help, and those a person must do, and give reasons.
- State fairly two views on where the line falls, and the minimum the course asks.
- Describe the church as a community of presence, including its limits.
The Word became flesh, and lived among us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the one and only Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." — John 1:14
World English Bible
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
For we don’t have a high priest who can’t be touched with the feeling of our infirmities, but one who has been in all points tempted like we are, yet without sin." — Hebrews 4:15
WEB
I was naked, and you clothed me. I was sick, and you visited me. I was in prison, and you came to me.”" — Matthew 25:36
WEB
John 1:14 says that the Word, who is God, became flesh and lived among us. Hebrews 4:15 says that the one who intercedes for us knows our weakness from within. Galatians 6:2 turns this toward the church: bear one another's burdens. Matthew 25:36 is part of Jesus' picture of the last judgement, where visiting the sick and the imprisoned is counted as service to him. None of these texts mentions tools. All of them concern what it is to be with someone.
1. God with us
John 1:14 says that "the Word became flesh, and lived among us." The old Christian word for this is , from the Latin for "in flesh". The verse does not say that God sent advice, or a message, though God did speak. It says God came, took a body, and lived among people.
Christian traditions read this in several ways, and they share a central point: God's way of helping humanity was to be present, and to be present at a cost. Catholic and Orthodox writers have often stressed that the incarnation joins God to human nature itself, so that the body and the common life are not left behind but taken up. Protestant writers have often stressed the cross, where the presence of Jesus with sinners goes all the way to death. Hebrews 4:15 puts the same thing in plain terms: Jesus is not far from our weakness, but "touched with the feeling of our infirmities."
What the text says: the Word became flesh and lived among us; Christ knows our weakness from within. A principle drawn from it: presence, being with another in their actual condition, is the form that God's own help took. Our judgement today: a church that wishes to follow this way will count presence as a main part of its care, not an extra. This is our reasoning from the principle. The texts themselves say nothing about modern tools.
2. What presence costs
Presence costs, and it helps to say how. At least three costs are common.
Time. To be with someone is to give hours that could have gone elsewhere. A visit to a person who cannot speak much, an evening beside someone grieving, a day in a hospital corridor: each is a slice of a life given away.
Risk. To be present is to be exposed. The person we sit beside may be angry, or ashamed, or in pain that we cannot mend. We may say the wrong thing. We may catch what they have, or be drawn into conflict. We may find that we are needed more than we can give.
Self. The deepest cost is that we are asked to give not only things but ourselves: our attention, our patience, our own sorrow. Galatians 6:2 says to "bear" burdens, a word that suggests weight carried on the body. The burden is not removed by the carer. It is shared.
There is a gift in all this. A person who is visited knows that someone chose to come, and chose it at a cost. That can say, without a word, "you matter".
But we must be careful not to say too much, for three reasons.
First, cost is not the only mark of care. A short kind word from a busy person helps. A neighbour who sends a message each morning is giving something real, even if it takes little time. We must not suggest that only exhausting care counts.
Second, cost must not become a way of glorifying exhaustion. Carers are often tired. The man who looks after a parent at home, the woman who sits with a sick child, the volunteer who has not rested for weeks, are not failing because they need help. Jesus himself withdrew to rest. A church that praises the cost of care and offers no relief to carers has misread this lecture.
Third, the person who receives care also pays a price. To be cared for is to depend, and many people find dependence hard. Some prefer to ask no one, so that they feel no burden to anyone. For such a person a tool that asks nothing back may seem easier. We should hear that honestly, not scold it. And we should say, as gently as we can, that part of human dignity is the freedom to receive: to let another carry something for us. Persons who need care, such as the very old, the very young or those with severe disability, are not tests for an argument. Their worth does not depend on how little they ask of others.
3. Sorting care: three groups
Many churches now ask which parts of care can be helped by tools. We offer a way of sorting, with the warning that where lines fall is a matter of judgement. A person, a church or a tradition may draw them differently.
Care that can be assisted. These are tasks around the care, where the person's presence is not the point. Examples: keeping a calendar of visits, reminding a volunteer of an appointment, finding the time of a bus, reading a small-print letter aloud to someone with weak eyes, translating a notice. A tool might help with these, as paper lists and telephones long have. The act of care is still done by a person; the tool helps with the arrangement.
Care done together with help. Here a person does the caring and a tool helps with a part of it. A volunteer might use help to write a clear note to a family, but read it, change it and send it as their own. A pastor might ask for help to find a Scripture passage, but choose what to read at a bedside. The question to ask is always: whose voice is this, and does the person who receives it know? Honesty matters, as in earlier courses.
Care that a person must do. These are acts where the other person's need is, in large part, to be met by another person. We can name some:
- Sitting with someone who is grieving and saying nothing.
- Asking forgiveness, or giving it.
- Receiving a confession, or hearing a person's account of their life.
- Prayer said with and for a person, and the blessings and rites of the church. Catholic and Orthodox traditions hold that some of these, the sacraments, are given through ordained ministers of the church. Protestant traditions differ on who may do what, and many stress the ministry of all believers. In every case it is a person, in the name of the church, who acts.
- Touch: the hand held, the embrace, the washing of feet.
- Being known over years by someone who has watched a life unfold.
The three groups are not sharp. A kind visit may include a reminder; a message may be both arrangement and care. The groups help us ask a question: in this act, what exactly is the other person receiving, and can it be received from anything but a person?
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is where the line falls between care that may be handed to a tool and care that must stay with a person.
One view draws the line close to the person. Its holders say that anything that stands in for a visit, a word of comfort or a presence, even a good one, teaches people to expect less than they need, and that churches under strain will be tempted to let tools replace people because they are cheaper. A tool's care, they say, is never costly in the way that Christ's presence was. The weak point of this view is that some people do not have a visit available at all, whether through distance, illness or lack of volunteers, and a firm rule that only persons may care could leave them with nothing. It also tends to assume that all human care is good and all tool help is poor, which is not always true.
The other view draws the line further out. Its holders say that what matters is the good of the person cared for, that a tool may relieve tired carers and reach lonely people no one else is reaching, and that to refuse help in the name of purity may be unkind. A tool that frees a carer to sit longer with a patient, they say, adds to presence. The weak point of this view is that "relief" can slide into replacement. A church that is short of volunteers may simply come to accept tools in place of persons without having decided to. It also tends to assume the tool's help is faithful, without knowing whether it is.
The course requires only the minimum already stated: no one left with only an answerer when a person could be beside them, and a church that decides these matters together, openly, and with the weak and tired in view.
4. The church as a community of presence
Paul's picture of the church in Galatians 6:2 is of people bearing one another's burdens. The Greek word for the gathered church, ekklesia, means an assembly, and the church has always met in person, at table, in water and in bread and wine, in the laying on of hands. Here the traditions differ in many details, but all agree that Christian life is life together.
A church also has to be honest about its limits. No congregation can be present everywhere. People live far apart; some are housebound; some carers cannot leave home. Presence is not only the body in the room. A phone call, a letter and a message of prayer are ways of being with someone, and Christians have always used letters. The test is not whether the means is old or new, but whether a person is giving themselves to another person. Where it is possible, a visit is better. Where it is not, the person who makes the call or writes the letter is present in a way that no automatic reply can be.
5. A case (an invented example)
A small congregation in a town has a member, Mr Adeyemi, who can no longer leave his house after an illness. For years three members have taken turns to visit him on Thursday afternoons. Now two of them have moved away, and the third, a busy parent, feels she can only manage once a month.
The church council discusses what to do. One member suggests using a program to remind volunteers of the rota and to send Mr Adeyemi a short greeting each day. Another worries that a greeting from a program might be taken as a visit. A third says, "We have not asked Mr Adeyemi what he would like."
They ask him. He says he would like a call on the days no one can come, from a person who knows him, even if short. He says he does not want a greeting from something that has no face. He also says he is glad to have a rota for the visitors, since he used to feel guilty for being forgotten.
The council agrees to use a simple reminder list for the rota, to ask two more members to take the calls, and to review it in three months. No one claims this is the only right answer. The case shows a church sorting care into what may be assisted and what must be done by a person, and asking the one cared for.
Diagram 1. Sorting care
In short
- In the incarnation God helped by being present among us at a cost (John 1:14; Hebrews 4:15).
- Care costs time, risk and self, but cost is not the only mark of care, and exhaustion must not be praised.
- Care can be sorted into what may be assisted, what is done together with help, and what a person must do.
- Readers disagree on where the line falls; each view has a weak point.
- The minimum: no one left with only an answerer when a person could be beside them, and the one cared for is asked.
- The church is a community of presence, honest about its limits.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Incarnation | The Word became flesh and lived among us; God's help took the form of presence. |
| Three costs of care | Time, risk and self; but cost is not the only mark of care. |
| Three groups of care | Can be assisted; done together with help; a person must do. |
| The question to ask of any act | What is the other person receiving, and can it be received from anything but a person? |
One sentence to remember God's help came as presence, and the church is asked to be present to one another.
This week's action Choose one act of care in your community and ask the person who receives it what they would like.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- John 1:14 says the Word "lived among us". What does it mean to you that God's help took the form of presence and not only of advice?
- Think of a time when someone's care cost them something. How did it feel to receive it? Was there also a time when a small, cheap act helped you?
- Why is it dangerous for a church to praise the cost of care and offer no rest to those who give it?
- Take three acts of care in your own community. Where would you place each in the three groups? Do others in your group place any differently, and why?
- In the case of Mr Adeyemi, what did the council learn by asking him? What might they have missed if they had not?