FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism

Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?

Contents 31
STEL6E AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Reading the Image
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
  2. Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
  4. Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Mind, Consciousness and Soul
  1. Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
  3. Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
  4. Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Intelligence, Person, Moral Status
  1. Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
  3. Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
  4. Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Relationship, Care, Friendship, Grief
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
  2. Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
  3. Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
  4. Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Work, Calling and Human Worth
  1. Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
  2. Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
  3. Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
  4. Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Enhancement, Immortality, Resurrection
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Old Dream, in New Words
  2. Lecture 6-2: Finitude and the Body: Is a Limit a Curse?
  3. Lecture 6-3: Resurrection and the Upload Story
  4. Lecture 6-4: Living as Creatures in Hope
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on the Human Person

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

When a machine answers a hard question well, many people feel a small shock. The answer sounds clever. Then a second question follows, often without words: is there someone there? This lecture is about that second question and why it is not the same as the first.

We will separate four words that people often mix together: intelligence (the ability to learn, solve problems and adapt), knowledge (what is held to be true and is true), wisdom (knowing what is worth doing, and doing it well), and person (someone, not something; one who can be wronged, addressed and loved). We will see why the habit of defining a person by reason is understandable and why it has a weak point. We will not say what any machine now is or is not. We write as conditionals: if a machine were such-and-such, what would follow?

This lecture opens a week with one principle: being clever, being a person and having a claim on our care are three different questions. This lecture takes the first two. Lecture 3-3 takes the third.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Define intelligence, knowledge, wisdom and person in plain words, and explain why they are different things.
  • Use the example of two equal performers to show why equal ability does not settle the question of personhood.
  • State the view that a person is defined by reason in its strongest form, and name its weak point.
  • Describe what Proverbs and 1 Corinthians 8 say about knowledge and wisdom, separating the text, a tradition's reading and our judgement.
  • Explain what Luke 18:15-17 adds to the discussion.

The fear of Yahweh is the beginning of knowledge; but the foolish despise wisdom and instruction." — Proverbs 1:7

World English Bible

Now concerning things sacrificed to idols: We know that we all have knowledge. Knowledge puffs up, but love builds up. But if anyone thinks that he knows anything, he doesn’t yet know as he ought to know. But if anyone loves God, the same is known by him." — 1 Corinthians 8:1-3

WEB

They were also bringing their babies to him, that he might touch them. But when the disciples saw it, they rebuked them. Jesus summoned them, saying, “Allow the little children to come to me, and don’t hinder them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these. Most certainly, I tell you, whoever doesn’t receive the Kingdom of God like a little child, he will in no way enter into it.”" — Luke 18:15-17

WEB

Proverbs places knowledge inside a relationship: it begins in reverence for God. Paul says that knowledge by itself can swell a person up, and that what lasts is love, and being known by God. Luke shows Jesus receiving babies who can do nothing, and naming them as the pattern of those who enter the Kingdom. None of these passages mentions machines. Together they tell us that Scripture does not measure a person by cleverness.

1. Four words that are not one word

In daily speech we say "intelligent", "knowledgeable", "wise" and "a real person" as if they were a ladder, each one a step above the last. They are not a ladder. They answer different questions.

Intelligence is an ability. It answers the question what can this do? A being is intelligent to the degree that it can take in a new problem, find a way through and adapt when the problem changes. Intelligence comes in degrees and can be measured in some ways, and it can be used for good or evil.

Knowledge answers what is held, and is it true? A person can know many facts and still misunderstand how they fit. A book also "holds" facts, and no one thinks the book is a person.

Wisdom answers what is worth doing, and how, with these people, in this time? Wisdom needs some intelligence and some knowledge, but it also needs good aims, patience, a sense of one's limits and a long habit of paying attention to others. A very clever person can be foolish. A person of modest schooling can be wise.

Person answers a different kind of question altogether: who is this? The word does not describe a level of ability. It says that here is someone, and not something. A person can be wronged and not only damaged. A person can be spoken to by name, can promise and be promised to, can be loved, and can be held to account. Lecture 3-2 tells how the word came to carry this weight.

The point of the list is that none of the first three words, however high, produces the fourth by being added up. Nor does the fourth need the first three at a high level. Keep this in mind, because the rest of the lecture is the working out of it.

2. Two equal performers

Here is a thought experiment (an invented example). Two entrants sit a long test of reasoning, set by a school. The first is Ana, a young woman who has studied for months. The second is a program, which we will imagine is able to take the same test in the same form. We do not say that any real program can do this; we ask what follows if one could. When the results come in, the two scores are exactly the same, question by question.

What follows from the equal scores?

One answer says: nothing about Ana's standing has changed, and nothing has been decided about the program's. The score measures the performance on the test. It does not tell us whether the program is someone. Ana is a person whatever her score, and she would be a person if she had scored lower or had been unable to sit the test at all. The program, for its part, might be a clever tool with nothing behind it, or something else; the score cannot say. The experiment shows only that ability and personhood can be separated in thought.

A second answer says: something has changed. If a being matches a person on every task of reasoning, then refusing to count it as a person looks arbitrary. It looks like a preference for our own kind, much as people once drew lines around others by skin or birth. This answer deserves a fair hearing. It is worried about a real injustice, the habit of excluding the unfamiliar. Its worry is not foolish.

Notice what the two answers share. Each asks whether the test score is the right kind of evidence. The first says no, the score is the wrong kind. The second says yes, if the score is all there is to see. We will meet the deeper form of this disagreement in lecture 3-3. For now, hold on to a smaller conclusion that both can accept: a score tells you about ability, and "is this someone?" is a further question that a score does not answer by itself.

There is a second use of the same example. Suppose Ana had scored lower than the program. Would she be less of a person? Almost no one thinks so. We know this from daily life. Abilities rise and fall across a life, in childhood, in illness, in old age. A child at two cannot do what the same child can do at ten, and no one says the child became more of a person. What we are doing in such judgements is already showing that we do not define a person by ability.

3. The habit of defining a person by reason

All the same, there is an old and strong habit in Western thought of linking person with reason. We should state it fairly.

In the Latin tradition, writers from late antiquity onward spoke of a person as a rational being, and the idea comes up again in lecture 3-2. In the modern period, philosophers such as John Locke (his Essay Concerning Human Understanding appeared in 1690) described a person as a thinking, intelligent being that can reflect and that knows itself as the same being across time. Other modern writers stress reason as the ground of being able to choose, to promise and to be responsible.

The strongest form of this view runs as follows. We need the word person to say who can be held to account, who can make and keep a promise, who can understand a law and obey or break it, and who can be wronged in the way that betrayal or lying wrongs someone. Those things seem to need reason. So, the view says, the idea of a person must be tied to reason, or the word will lose its job. This is a serious argument, and it is trying to protect something real: moral responsibility.

The view has a weak point, and it is a weak point that most people who hold the view would also want to avoid. If a person is whoever reasons well enough, then three things follow.

  • Persons come in degrees. If reason is what makes a person, then more reason would seem to make more of a person, and less would make less. Almost no one wants to say that.
  • Some human beings fall below the line. A newborn, a person with advanced dementia, a person with a severe disability of mind: each reasons little or not at all in the way the view requires. Those who hold the view usually refuse to draw this conclusion and look for another way to protect such people. The effort shows that the line was in the wrong place.
  • Worth becomes a prize. If personhood is earned by performance, then it can be lost by failure, and people will be tempted to prove it. This is a heavy burden to put on anyone.

The same weak point cuts the other way. If reason is enough to make a person, then any being that shows the signs of reasoning would be pulled into the circle, by the same logic. A habit of mind that makes you look for reason in order to grant standing will tend to grant standing to whatever performs reason most visibly. Those who built the view did not think of machines. But the view has no brake against them, and no brake for the protection of the very weak either. Both errors have one root: treating a person as a bundle of abilities.

We should say again what we do and do not claim. We do not claim that a machine is, or will be, a person. We do not claim that it cannot be. We claim only that a test of ability cannot be the whole of the answer, in either direction.

4. What Scripture sets beside intelligence

Scripture has much to say about knowing and about wisdom. It does not despise either. It sets them in a larger picture.

What the text says. Proverbs 1:7 says that the fear of Yahweh is the beginning of knowledge, and that the foolish despise wisdom and instruction. Here "fear" is not terror but the right reverence of a creature before its Maker. Knowledge, in this verse, does not start from the mind alone. It starts from a relation to God, and from a willingness to be taught.

Paul, in 1 Corinthians 8:1-3, answers some members of the church at Corinth who were proud of what they knew about idols. He says that knowledge puffs up and love builds up. He says that anyone who thinks they know something does not yet know as they ought. And then he turns the matter around: the one who loves God is known by God. The last thought is the one to notice. The most important fact about a human being, in this passage, is not what that person knows but by whom that person is known.

In Luke 18:15-17, people bring babies to Jesus. The disciples rebuke them, and Jesus calls the little ones to him. He says that the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these, and that whoever does not receive it like a little child will not enter it. A baby has no reasoning to show and no performance to offer. Jesus does not treat the baby's lack of ability as a lack of standing. He holds the baby up as the one who receives.

A tradition's reading. Christian traditions have read such passages in different ways, and we name only broad strokes. Many Protestant writers have stressed that standing before God is received as a gift and not earned, and they read Paul's contrast between knowing and loving in that light. Catholic teaching holds that human dignity belongs to every person because of what a person is and not because of what a person can do, and it speaks of the sick, the old and the weak in those terms. Orthodox writers stress that a person is known and called into communion with God, and that wisdom is shared in life together and not stored as private information. These emphases differ, and in this matter they point in a similar direction: worth is not a result of ability.

Our judgement today. Here we go beyond the text and the traditions, and we should say so. We judge that Scripture gives us good reason not to measure a person by cleverness, and so good reason to be cautious about any argument that makes ability the ticket of entry to being a person. We also judge, more carefully, that the same Scripture does not tell us what a machine is. It was not written to answer that question. Someone who says "the Bible proves machines cannot be persons" is saying more than the text says. So is someone who says "the Bible leaves the door open to machine persons". The honest sentence is that Scripture does not address it and we must reason with care.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some thoughtful Christians hold that, because wisdom begins in the fear of God, only a creature that can stand before God, a creature with a soul or a spirit, can be wise in the sense the Bible means, and so intelligence by itself can never become wisdom. They worry that a program "wise" changes the meaning of the word. Others hold that Scripture treats wisdom as a quality seen in conduct, including in Proverbs' picture of wisdom crying out in the street, and that we should not rule out in advance that something other than a human being could show some part of it. They worry that a rule laid down in advance is a way to avoid looking. Each side is trying to protect something real: the first, the meaning of a great word; the second, honesty in the face of what we do not yet know. What this course requires is smaller than either side requires: that we do not use the words intelligent, wise and person as if they were one word.

5. Why wisdom is the odd one out

Of the four words, wisdom is the one most worth pausing over, because it shows most plainly why ability is not enough. Wisdom in Proverbs is learned from parents, from teachers, from long watching, and from failure. It includes knowing when to be silent. It includes love of the right things. It does not hurry. The wise person of Proverbs is also someone who can be corrected and takes it well.

Notice that all of this is relational and slow. Wisdom is formed with others over time. A being could be given an enormous store of facts and a very fast way of finding patterns in them, and that would be intelligence and knowledge. Whether it would also be wise would depend on matters that these words do not decide: what it loves, how it bears correction, whether it can be answerable. This is the sense in which the question of wisdom leads back to the question of the person, and the question of the person leads back to relations. We will pick up that thread in the next lecture.

6. What this means for how we speak

A practical result follows. When we talk, in a church or a family or a classroom, about a machine that does clever things, we can keep the four words apart. We can say "that is a very capable tool" without having said "that is someone". We can say "a person who reads many books" without implying that reading makes a person. We can refuse the quick step from it answers well to it understands, and from it understands to it is someone. Each step needs its own argument, and the arguments are open.

We can also refuse the opposite quick step, from it is made by us to there could be no one there. This too needs an argument. The diagram below sets the four words side by side.


Diagram 1. Four words, four questions

Four words, four different questions They are not steps on one ladder Intelligence What can it do? Learn, solve, adapt Comes in degrees Can serve good or evil Knowledge What is held, and true? Facts and how they fit A book holds facts too Can puff up (1 Cor 8:1) Wisdom What is worth doing? Good aims, patience Learned with others Begins in reverence Person Who is this? Someone, not something Can be wronged and loved Not earned by a score Ability, held truth and good aims can all be measured or watched in what a being does. A further question, not a higher score Adding the first three together does not produce the fourth, and the fourth does not wait for them.

In short

  • Intelligence is ability, knowledge is what is held and true, wisdom is knowing what is worth doing, and a person is someone, not something.
  • Equal scores on a test show equal performance; they do not by themselves settle whether anyone is there.
  • Defining a person by reason protects responsibility but makes personhood a matter of degree and leaves out the very young and the very weak.
  • Proverbs 1:7 begins knowledge in reverence for God, and 1 Corinthians 8:1-3 puts being known by God above knowing.
  • In Luke 18:15-17 Jesus receives babies, who have nothing to show, as the pattern of those who enter the Kingdom.
  • Scripture does not say what a machine is; we reason with care and keep the four words apart.
Front Back
Intelligence, knowledge, wisdom, person Ability; what is held and true; knowing what is worth doing; someone, not something.
Why equal scores do not settle personhood A score measures performance; whether anyone is there is a further question.
Weak point of defining a person by reason It makes personhood a matter of degree and leaves out those who reason little.
1 Corinthians 8:1-3 Knowledge puffs up, love builds up, and the one who loves God is known by God.

One sentence to remember Being clever, being a person and having a claim on our care are three different questions.

This week's action Notice three times this week when you praise or dismiss someone for how clever they are, and ask whether that is the right question.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • In the example of the two equal performers, which answer seems stronger to you: that the score tells nothing about the program's standing, or that refusing it standing looks arbitrary? What does each answer worry about?
  • Think of someone you know who is wise but not well schooled, and someone clever who is not wise. What separates the two?
  • Why is it a problem for a definition of person if more reason would seem to make more of a person?
  • Paul says that the one who loves God is known by God. How does that change what we look for first in a human being?
  • What would be lost if we said "the Bible proves that no machine could be a person"? What would be lost if we said the opposite?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.