Lecture 6-2: Finitude and the Body: Is a Limit a Curse?
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
- Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
- Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
- Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
- Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
- Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
- Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
- Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
- Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
- Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
- Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
- Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
- Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
- Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
- Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
- Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
- Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
- Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
Lecture 6-1 heard the dream of escaping death. This lecture asks what the Christian tradition says about the thing the dream wishes to escape: our limits, and above all the body that carries them. We grow tired, we need food and sleep, we get old, we die. Is this a defect in us, a curse, a mark of being a creature, or some of each?
Two questions run together here and it helps to keep them apart. The first is about finitude, which means having limits: a creature that has a beginning, a size, a need, an end. The second is about death as we meet it, with its grief and its fear. Christians have answered the first and the second in more than one way, and the differences matter. We look at two readings, we look at an old error that despised the body, and we look at how Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers each hold the body as good. Along the way we try to avoid two mistakes: calling every limit a punishment, and calling suffering a blessing to be sought.
The lecture follows the principle of the week: the oldest dream of escaping death has new words; the Christian answer is not escape from the body but the hope of its raising. To see why the answer is not an escape, we must first see how the body is understood. We make no claim about what machines can do; where we speak of them it is in conditionals. Medicine and the care of the dying are not covered in this course.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Distinguish finitude (being a limited creature) from death as people meet it.
- State two Christian readings of death, one that sees limit as part of good creation and one that sees death as a result of sin, and give the strength and weak point of each.
- Explain what the ancient error of contempt for the body held, and how the church answered it.
- Describe how Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions each hold the body as good, in terms each would accept.
- Explain why accepting a limit is not the same as praising suffering.
So teach us to number our days, that we may gain a heart of wisdom." — Psalm 90:12
World English Bible
By the sweat of your face will you eat bread until you return to the ground, for out of it you were taken. For you are dust, and to dust you shall return.”" — Genesis 3:19
WEB
God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good. There was evening and there was morning, a sixth day." — Genesis 1:31
WEB
Therefore as sin entered into the world through one man, and death through sin; and so death passed to all men, because all sinned." — Romans 5:12
WEB
Psalm 90:12 asks for wisdom in the counting of days. Genesis 3:19 names the return to dust in the words spoken after the first disobedience. Genesis 1:31 says that everything God had made, which includes the body, was very good. Romans 5:12 is one of the texts on which the second reading below rests. The four passages do not say the same thing in the same tone, and the lecture tries to let each speak.
1. Two questions: limit and death
Begin with a plain fact. A human being is small, and needs air, water, food, sleep and other people. A human being learns slowly, forgets, tires, and cannot be in two places. None of this is a wrong done to us by anyone. It is what it is to be this kind of creature. We can call it finitude.
Now ask a separate question. Is the end of life, with its grief, its fear and its sense of tearing, simply the last of these limits? Or is it something that does not belong?
The Bible gives us texts for both views, which is part of why Christians have read the matter in two ways. Psalm 90:12 does not complain about the number of our days; it asks to be taught to count them well. Genesis 3:19 speaks of a return to the dust as part of the word spoken after the disobedience. Genesis 1:31 says that creation, with its creatures, was very good. And Romans 5:12 says that death entered through sin. Read quickly, these can seem to pull apart. Read carefully, they give the two readings that follow.
2. The first reading: limit belongs to good creation
This is a point where readers will not agree. One reading holds that being a limited, mortal creature is part of the good creation, and that what entered with sin was not the bare fact of finitude but the way death is met: as an enemy, with dread, as separation from God and from one another. On this reading, the first human beings were made as creatures who were to grow, and to be given life as a gift, and not as beings who already held deathlessness in their own right. The closing of the way to the tree of life (lecture 6-1) might then be read as a kind of mercy and a sign of dependence, not as the removal of something they already owned.
Its strength. It takes Genesis 1:31 seriously, and it explains why Psalm 90 can speak of the number of our days without despair. It also guards against a view in which the creature should be, by right, unlimited. It fits the sense that to be a creature is to depend on a Creator.
Its weak point. It has to explain how the Bible can call death an "enemy" (1 Corinthians 15:26, which we meet in the next lecture) if death were part of good creation. It has to say that what is the enemy is not death in its first sense, but death as it has become: with fear, with separation, with the pull of sin. Critics say that this is a subtle distinction and that most people who mourn do not meet it.
3. The second reading: death comes through sin
The other reading holds that death as a whole, and not only its fear, is a result of the human turning from God. Romans 5:12 is the central text: sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin. On this view the first human beings were made for life, and death is a wrong done to creation, an intruder, an enemy to be defeated. This is why, for those who hold this reading, the work of Christ is to undo death and not only its terror.
Its strength. It takes seriously the Bible's language of death as enemy and its promise that death will be abolished. It respects the instinct, shared by nearly everyone, that death is not simply right. It speaks truly to the mourner, who does not need to be told that the loss is "natural".
Its weak point. It has to say how it fits with the evidence of the world, in which creatures have always died, and with passages that speak of a return to the dust as part of what was given. Different thinkers answer in different ways: some read Genesis less as a history of the first death and more as a statement of what death means for the human person; some stress that death for the human being, as a person called to God, is not the same as the dying of other living things. We note these answers without choosing among them.
What the course requires. It requires less than either reading. A student should be able to say: Christians read death in two main ways, as an end that was part of finite creation but became an enemy through sin, and as itself a result of sin. Both hold that death is not the last word, and that Christ has met it. A reader who prefers one reading does not need the other to be foolish.
4. What the two readings share
Notice how much the two readings share. Both hold that the body is a creature of God and good. Both hold that death as people now meet it is a loss, and not to be called pleasant. Both look for its defeat. And both would say, in different ways, that the wish never to die is not wicked in itself; it points to something true about what a human person was made for. The disagreement is about whether the dust is part of the original gift. It is not a disagreement about whether the body matters.
This gives us a first answer to the title of the lecture. Is a limit a curse? A limit by itself is not. To be a creature is to be limited, and Genesis 1:31 calls creatures good. But the way our limits have become a weight, in pain, in loss and in the fear of death, is something the tradition, in both readings, treats as a wound and not as the plan.
5. An old error: contempt for the body
Early in the church's history there arose a family of movements, called by later writers Gnostic, from a Greek word for knowledge. They differed from one another and our knowledge of them is partly from their opponents, so we speak only in broad terms. Many of them held that the material world is a lesser or even an evil creation, and that the true self is a spark of spirit trapped in a body. Salvation, for them, was an escape: the spirit freed from matter by hidden knowledge.
The church's answer was firm. Writers such as Irenaeus, who wrote against these teachings in the second century, held that the one God made the material world and called it good, that the Word became flesh, and that salvation is therefore of the whole person, body included. The early creeds say the same. The speaks of the resurrection of the body, and the speaks of the life of the world to come. A teaching that despised the body had to deny either that God made it or that the Word truly took flesh, and the church refused to do either.
We tell this for a reason. A modern story of escape from the body, in which the true self is a pattern that could be moved out of its flesh, is not the same as the old movements, and we should not say it is. But it echoes a question that Christians answered long ago: is the body a prison from which a person is rescued, or a part of the person who is saved? The church's answer has been the second. This is the ground for lecture 6-3.
6. Three traditions on the goodness of the body
Each of the large streams of Christian thought honours the body, in its own terms. We describe each as it would describe itself, and we do not rank them.
Catholic teaching holds that the human person is a unity of body and soul. A person is not a soul that has a body, or a body with a soul attached. The Second Vatican Council's constitution Gaudium et Spes (1965) speaks of the human being as made of body and soul, yet one. This teaching grounds the care for the body, the blessing of the sick, the reverence for the dead, and the hope for the raising of the body. In the Catholic view, the and the sacraments, which use bread, water and oil, show that matter can carry grace.
Orthodox teaching holds the body in honour through the incarnation. God the Son took flesh, and so matter has been taken into the life of God. Orthodox writers defended the use of icons, in the eighth century, on just this ground: since God took a body, the body and matter may carry the holy. Orthodox worship uses the whole body, with bowing, incense, kissing of icons and the Eucharist. Death, in the Orthodox view, is an enemy that Christ has trampled down by his own death, as the Paschal hymn sings. The aim of the Christian life is , a Greek word for being made to share in the life of God; it is a transformation of the whole person, body included.
Protestant teaching is varied, but it too holds the body as God's good creation. The Reformed tradition's Heidelberg (1563) begins by saying that the believer's only comfort, in life and in death, is that he or she belongs, body and soul, to Christ. Lutheran and Reformed writers have stressed that ordinary bodily life, in eating, in work, in marriage and in care for neighbours, is a place where God is served. Evangelical and Pentecostal churches, each in its own way, pray for and expect the Spirit's work in the body, and hold to the bodily resurrection of the dead at the last day. Anabaptist traditions have stressed the body as the place where is lived, in peace, in sharing and in service.
These descriptions are broad, and a member of each tradition will want to add what we have left out. The point is that all of them, from different starting points, reject the view that the true self is a spirit waiting to leave the body.
7. Do not romanticise suffering
A lecture about limits could slip into a mistake that does harm. It could make suffering sound good. We must say plainly: it is not.
Accepting that one is a limited creature is not the same as praising pain. A person who is ill, old, disabled or grieving is not obliged to find the suffering beautiful. Christians have always visited the sick, comforted the dying and prayed for relief, and none of that is a refusal of finitude. The Bible's laments, which we met in an earlier week, speak of pain without pretending. To say to a suffering person "this is good for you" is a statement that needs great care, and often it is a wrong one.
What the tradition can say, with care, is narrower. A limited creature may learn something, over time, from limits: dependence on others, patience, gratitude for what is given. These are lessons that some people say they have learned. They are not a reason to seek suffering, nor to deny help to those who suffer. And whether a particular means of easing pain or lengthening life is wise is a question of medicine and its ethics, which this course does not cover.
8. Back to the title
Is a limit a curse? We can now answer in three parts.
First, to be limited is to be a creature, and creatures were called good. A limit is not, as such, a curse.
Second, the weight of our limits, in pain, in loss and in the fear of death, is read by the tradition as a wound. Christians read its origin in two ways, but they agree in hoping for its healing.
Third, the answer to the wound is not to leave the body. Both readings, and all three streams we described, look for the raising of the body and not for its abandonment. What this means is the subject of lecture 6-3.
9. A short case (an invented example)
A woman in her late seventies, Mrs. Okafor in this example, tells her grandson that she is glad to be old. She says that her knees ache, and she cannot read the small print, and that she does not mind. Her grandson, who has been reading about extending life, is troubled. He says: "You only say that because you cannot change it."
She answers, without anger, that this may be partly true. But she says that she has learned to receive her days and has been taught to ask for help. "I am not saying pain is good," she says. "I am saying that I am not the maker of myself."
Two lessons can be drawn without taking sides. Her answer does not deny that her grandson's wish for her long life comes from love. And his challenge is fair: it is easy to praise limits when one cannot change them. A hearer who wishes to answer well will hold both.
Diagram 1. Two readings of death, side by side
In short
- Finitude means being a limited creature; death as people meet it, with grief and dread, is a further question.
- One reading holds that limit belongs to good creation and sin made death an enemy; the other holds that death as a whole comes through sin.
- Both readings say the body is good, death is a loss, and death is not the last word.
- Gnostic movements held matter to be lesser and salvation to be escape; the church answered that God made the body and the Word took flesh.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions each honour the body in their own terms.
- Accepting a limit is not praising suffering, and relief of pain is not a refusal of finitude.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Finitude | Being a limited creature, with a beginning, needs and an end. |
| The two readings of death | Limit belongs to good creation and sin made death an enemy; or death as a whole comes through sin. |
| The Gnostic error and the reply | Matter is lesser and the self is a spirit to be freed; the church replied that God made the body and the Word became flesh. |
| What all three streams share about the body | It is God's good creature and is raised, not left behind. |
One sentence to remember A limit is not a curse, and suffering is not a gift; the answer to the wound is the raising of the body, not leaving it.
This week's action Name one limit of your body or your life that you are learning to receive, and one that you still count as a wound, and keep the two apart.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which is easier for you to say: "my limits are part of what I am" or "my limits are a wound"? What makes the other one hard?
- State the first reading of death in a way a holder of the second reading would accept, and then the second in a way a holder of the first would accept.
- Why did the church insist that the body is part of the person who is saved, and not a prison? What would be lost if it had agreed with the Gnostic teachers?
- Which of the three descriptions (Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant) of the goodness of the body is closest to what you were taught? What did it leave unsaid?
- In the case of Mrs. Okafor and her grandson, what is each person right about?