Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Does AI Make Us Ask What a Person Is?
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Image: What We Have and How We Relate
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Image: Task and Christ
- Lecture 1-4: Worth Without Ability
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Measures I Carry
- Lecture 2-1: Body and Mind: An Old Argument
- Lecture 2-2: The Puzzle of Consciousness and the Machine
- Lecture 2-3: What Is a Soul?
- Lecture 2-4: Freedom and the Will
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What I Know About My Own Mind
- Lecture 3-1: Is Intelligence the Same as Personhood?
- Lecture 3-2: The Idea of Person: A Short History
- Lecture 3-3: Moral Status: Who Is Within Our Care?
- Lecture 3-4: How We Treat What We Cannot Classify
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Whom Do I Treat as a Person?
- Lecture 4-1: The Answering Machine and the Human Heart
- Lecture 4-2: Friendship and Love in Christian Thought
- Lecture 4-3: Grief and Memory: Words in a Lost Voice
- Lecture 4-4: Presence That Costs
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Beside Me?
- Lecture 5-1: Measured by Use, Received as Gift
- Lecture 5-2: Calling in Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Voices
- Lecture 5-3: Making, Creating and the Worth of the Maker
- Lecture 5-4: Learning as Becoming
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Was Given, What I Do
Christians use the word calling all the time, and they do not always mean the same thing. For one person it means a job. For another it means ordination or a monastic life. For another it means whatever God wants done with one's whole life. This lecture sorts out the word. It describes how Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox traditions, and some others, have spoken of calling, each in its own terms and without ranking them. It then asks the question the week is built on: if calling is wider than a job, what happens to a person's sense of calling when tools take over some of the tasks?
We make no forecast. We do not know what tools will do to any particular kind of work, and we speak in conditionals. The ethics of livelihood is the subject of Christian Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (STEL5E), and we do not repeat it here.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Explain the difference between a calling and an occupation.
- Describe, as each would describe itself, how Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox traditions have spoken of vocation.
- State what 1 Corinthians 7:17-24, Ephesians 2:10 and Colossians 3:23-24 say, and what they do not say.
- Name at least three callings that are not paid jobs.
- Set out the strongest forms of two views on what happens to a calling when a tool takes over a task.
Only, as the Lord has distributed to each man, as God has called each, so let him walk. So I command in all the assemblies." — 1 Corinthians 7:17
World English Bible
Let each man stay in that calling in which he was called." — 1 Corinthians 7:20
WEB
Were you called being a bondservant? Don’t let that bother you, but if you get an opportunity to become free, use it." — 1 Corinthians 7:21
WEB
For he who was called in the Lord being a bondservant is the Lord’s free man. Likewise he who was called being free is Christ’s bondservant." — 1 Corinthians 7:22
WEB
You were bought with a price. Don’t become bondservants of men." — 1 Corinthians 7:23
WEB
Brothers, let each man, in whatever condition he was called, stay in that condition with God." — 1 Corinthians 7:24
WEB
For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared before that we would walk in them." — Ephesians 2:10
WEB
And whatever you do, work heartily, as for the Lord, and not for men," — Colossians 3:23
WEB
knowing that from the Lord you will receive the reward of the inheritance; for you serve the Lord Christ." — Colossians 3:24
WEB
Paul writes to a church in a world with slavery, and he says "called" again and again. Ephesians says who we are before it says what we do. Colossians speaks to people at work, including those whose work was not chosen, and tells them whom they finally serve. The three texts are not about a career path; they are about belonging, in whatever place a person finds themselves.
1. One word, several meanings
(An invented example.) At a gathering of church members, three people say they have been "called". The first, a nurse, says she was called to nursing. The second, a young man, says he feels called to become a priest. The third, an older woman who has just buried her husband, says she has been called to stay with her grandchildren while their mother works. All three use the word truthfully. They are not speaking about the same thing.
The words in Scripture show why. In 1 Corinthians 7, the word translated "" (in Greek, klesis) is tied closely to the verb "to call". Paul is talking about the condition in which a person was called by God to follow Christ: married or single, slave or free. Many readers take "calling" here to mean the state in which a person first heard God’s call, and not an occupation in our modern sense. The word came later to cover work, and a long history lies between that verse and our use.
So there are at least three layers in the ordinary use of the word.
First, the call to belong. God calls people to himself, in Christ. This is the base of everything.
Second, the call to a way of life or a place. Marriage, single life, a household, a congregation, a country, a community of prayer.
Third, the call to particular tasks. A trade, an office, a skill, a stretch of service that may last a year or a lifetime.
Much confusion comes from collapsing all three into the third. A person who hears "calling" and thinks only "career" will feel lost in a year without a job, and will feel superior to those who have a less respected one.
2. What the three texts say
1 Corinthians 7:17-24. Paul tells each person to "walk" as God has called them. He then gives examples, including the slave: do not let it bother you, but "if you get an opportunity to become free, use it" (verse 21). Verse 22 says that the one called as a slave is the Lord’s free person, and verse 23 says "Don’t become bondservants of men." Readers have disagreed about how verse 21 should be translated and read, and this is a point where the Greek is difficult. The text clearly says that a person’s standing before Christ is not fixed by their social place, and that freedom is to be welcomed where it can be had. It does not say that every social position is a God-given pattern which must never be changed. We should be cautious about any use of this passage to tell a poor or enslaved person to stay put.
Ephesians 2:10. The verse says we are God’s "workmanship", created in Christ Jesus for good works that God prepared beforehand. The order matters: first, we are made; then, the works. The works are described as prepared, as if a path were laid out. The verse comes straight after the statement (verses 8-9) that salvation is a gift and not a result of works. So the good works here follow from being given something; they do not earn it. The text does not tell us what any particular person’s works are.
Colossians 3:23-24. Paul says to work heartily "as for the Lord, and not for men", because it is Christ they serve. The text is addressed in context to household members, including slaves. It does not say that all work is pleasant, fair or freely chosen. It says that the one to whom work is finally offered is the Lord. That is a statement about the meaning of work, which can be said even when the conditions are bad. It is not a defence of bad conditions.
3. Protestant voices
Several Protestant streams look back to the sixteenth century, to Martin Luther and John Calvin.
Luther opposed the idea that a holy life was only for monks, nuns and priests. In his view, the farmer, the housemaid, the magistrate and the parent each serve God in their place, and each serves the neighbour through the ordinary work of that place. This is often summed up in the German word Beruf, which in his usage came to mean the station or task in which one serves. It is bound up with the teaching that all believers share in a common priesthood. A Lutheran account typically stresses that God cares for people through the hands of those who work, so that the baker who bakes and the mother who feeds are instruments of God’s care for the neighbour.
Calvin, in the Reformed tradition, also taught that God assigns each person a place and a task, and that diligence in it is a service to God. Reformed writers have often spoken of the whole of life as lived before God, and of work as one way of doing it.
Both streams have been criticised, in fairness, for a danger that comes with this idea: that a station can become a cage. If everyone is told to stay in the calling in which they were put, the poor may be told to be content, and the unjust arrangements of a society may be treated as God’s will. Defenders answer that the emphasis on serving the neighbour was meant to dignify ordinary work, not to freeze anyone in place, and that both reformers criticised the abuse of power. The honest thing to say is that the idea has been used in both ways.
Anabaptist communities, in their own stress on and shared life, have tended to ask whether an occupation fits the way of Christ, and some have limited the occupations a disciple can hold. Evangelical and Pentecostal communities often speak of calling as a personal sense of what God asks, sometimes through the Spirit’s gifts, and they have places for the language of "ministry in the workplace". Each of these streams carries something of the earlier idea.
4. Catholic voices
In much Catholic usage, the word vocation was for a long time tied especially to the priesthood and to religious life. The Second Vatican Council in the 1960s (in its Dogmatic Constitution on the Church, Lumen Gentium, 1964) taught clearly that all the baptised are called to holiness, whatever their state of life. It also teaches that lay people live out this call in the world, in family and work, and so help to shape the world from within. In Gaudium et Spes (1965), the council speaks of human activity and its meaning.
Catholic teaching speaks of the dignity of work as flowing from the dignity of the person who works. In Laborem Exercens (1981) Pope John Paul II set out a view of work as something that belongs to the person and not only to the market, and spoke of the priority of the person over what the person does. A Catholic reading will often say: a person’s vocation is first to holiness, then to a particular state of life (marriage, single life, the priesthood, religious life), and then to the many tasks within it.
5. Orthodox voices
Orthodox Christians speak of life as something offered whole to God. The Church’s worship is the centre from which everything is understood: what is done in the is meant to flow into the rest of the day. Some Orthodox writers use the phrase "the liturgy after the liturgy" for this: when worship ends, the people go out to carry on in daily life what they have received. In this way of seeing, there is no sharp line between a sacred part of life and an ordinary part. Monastic life and the life of a married person, a farmer or a teacher are each ways of offering the whole of life to God.
Orthodox thought also stresses synergy, the working together of God and the human being. A person is not a passive tool, and God does not do everything alone. Work, in this view, is one place where the human being takes a share in God’s care for the world.
6. How the voices overlap, and where they part
All of these traditions say that ordinary work can be holy. All say that the call to belong to Christ comes first. All, at their best, say that work serves the neighbour.
They part in emphasis. A Lutheran or Reformed account may stress the station and the duty in it. A Catholic account may stress the universal call to holiness and the dignity of the worker. An Orthodox account may stress the offering of the whole. An Anabaptist account may stress the community’s discernment of what suits a disciple. A Pentecostal account may stress the Spirit’s gift. We have not tried to say which is closest to the New Testament. Each draws on part of what the New Testament says.
7. Calling is wider than a job
Whatever the vocabulary, we can say plainly that calling is wider than a job.
Consider whom the callings touch. A person is called to be a parent, a child of an aging parent, a friend, a neighbour, a citizen, a member of a congregation. A person is called to pray, to be present with someone who is dying, to forgive, to wait. A person who is ill is called to receive care with grace; a person who cares is called to give it. A retired person, a person between jobs, a student, a person with a disability that bars certain tasks: each has a calling, and it is not a smaller one.
This matters in two ways. First, it protects those whom lecture 5-1 described, whom a job-only idea of calling leaves out. Second, it relieves a burden. Many people, especially the young, are told to "find your calling" as if it were a single hidden object, and they fear that they may miss it. If calling is mostly the call to belong to Christ, to love the neighbour in the place where one is, and to take up what is in front of one, it is less like a treasure hunt and more like a daily faithfulness.
We should also say what this view does not claim. It does not say that a person’s occupation is unimportant, or that people should not seek work that fits their gifts. It does not say that choice is open to everyone: many people take whatever work is available. And it does not say that the circumstances of poverty or injustice are a calling. It says only that the worth and meaning of a life do not depend on getting the right job.
8. When a tool takes over a task
Now we ask the week's question, in conditional form. If a tool came to do a task that a person has long done, and had seen as part of their calling, what would happen to that sense of calling?
(An invented example.) Joel has kept the accounts for a small trading firm for thirty years. He has seen the work as a calling: he keeps the books honestly, and he has helped new staff learn to do it. His firm begins to use a tool that makes many of the entries for him. Joel is told that his position is safe, but his tasks will change. He is troubled. He asks himself: "Was I called to this, and has the call been taken away?"
Here are two views, in their strongest forms.
One view says that the task itself was part of the calling, and its loss is a real loss. A person may be formed by a practice: the care in checking, the pride in a right sum, the relationship with the people the figures affect. If the practice is handed on, something may be lost that no new task replaces. This view takes seriously the way that crafts shape a person, and does not hurry to say "you are more than your job" in order to avoid grief. People are right to mourn.
The other view says that the calling was always to something wider: to honest service of those who depend on the books, and to being the kind of colleague Joel has been. The particular tasks were the form it took, and forms change over a lifetime anyway. A calling that could only live in one set of tasks would be fragile, and the history of work is full of people whose tasks changed. On this view, the faithful response is to ask, with others, what the same calling looks like now.
This is a point where readers will not agree, and perhaps they need not. Both views are about real things. The first guards against pretending that changes cost nothing. The second guards against tying a person’s worth to a task. What this course requires is only that we hold both: that we take the sense of loss seriously, and that we do not let it become the idea that the person has lost their worth. A community can help by asking Joel the questions, and by not hurrying him to a ready answer.
There is also a plain point about honesty. We do not know whether or how tools will take over tasks, how soon, or in which places. A teaching on calling that assumed it knew would be built on sand. It is better to teach what holds under any change: that we are called first to belong, that we are made before we work, and that the neighbour is always there to be loved.
9. Three layers
What the text says. 1 Corinthians 7:17-24 speaks of walking as God has called, and welcomes freedom where it can be had. Ephesians 2:10 says we are God’s workmanship, made for good works prepared beforehand. Colossians 3:23-24 says to work heartily, as for the Lord.
A tradition's reading. Lutheran, Reformed, Catholic, Orthodox, Anabaptist and Pentecostal voices have each drawn out a calling that includes ordinary life, with different stresses.
Our judgement today. It seems right to say that calling is wider than a paid task, and that a sense of calling can survive a change of task. We should say this humbly, remembering that for many people a task is deeply tied to who they are, and that their grief is real.
Diagram 1. Layers of calling
In short
- "Calling" means at least three things: to belong to Christ, to a way of life and place, and to particular tasks.
- In 1 Corinthians 7, the calling is the condition in which a person was called by God, not an occupation in the modern sense.
- Ephesians 2:10 says we are made first and then given good works; Colossians 3:23-24 says whom work is finally offered to.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox voices all say that ordinary work can be holy, with different emphases.
- The idea of a station can become a cage; defenders and critics both have a fair point.
- A change of task can be a real loss, and it does not change a person’s worth.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three layers of calling | To belong to Christ; to a way of life and place; to particular tasks. |
| Ephesians 2:10 | We are God’s workmanship, made for good works prepared beforehand: made first, then the works. |
| Universal call to holiness | The Catholic teaching of the Second Vatican Council that all the baptised are called to holiness in their state of life. |
| A risk of the idea of a station | It can become a cage, used to tell the poor to stay where they are. |
One sentence to remember Calling is first to belong to Christ and to love the neighbour where one is; tasks serve it and may change.
This week's action Write down three callings you hold that nobody pays you for, and thank one person who holds such a calling.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the three layers of calling do you usually mean when you use the word? Which do you forget?
- 1 Corinthians 7:21 and 7:23 can be read in more than one way. Why is it dangerous to use this passage to tell someone to stay in a hard situation?
- Which of the traditions described here is closest to your own? What does another tradition add that yours does not stress?
- Name three callings in your community that nobody pays for. How does the community thank those who hold them?
- Joel’s case sets two views side by side. State each in its strongest form. What does each fear?
- What would you say to a young person who fears that they will miss their calling?