Review by summary
All 31 lectures of STEL7E, as nothing but their summaries. For the night before an exam.
Try to recall each summary from the title before revealing it. It stays with you far longer than re-reading does.
Chapter 0 Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Technology?
Show summary
- Every new tool has raised the same questions: what does it make possible, and what does it take from us?
- Technology is part of the task of cultivating and keeping the world, and it also shapes our time, relationships, worship and attention.
- It is neither only a neutral tool nor only a fate; Christians discern together by love, rest and the gathered body.
- The course reads history with the eyes of faith and does not retell church history, teach habits or explain how AI works.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox thinking are each described in their own terms and not ranked.
- Where Christians disagree, the course gives each side fairly with its weak point and does not ask you to choose.
- Every Practice Lab has three ways in and four privacy promises.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The central claim | Technology helps us cultivate the world and also shapes us; we ask what it makes possible and what it takes, and judge by love, rest and communion. |
| The three eyes | Entrusting, shaping, discernment. |
| Tool or fate? | Neither only; Week 6 gives the strongest case for each side. |
| What it leaves to others | How AI works (PT737E); AI ethics (STEL5E); the human person (STEL6E); habits and misinformation (LM304E, LM307E). |
| Three ways into a lab | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
One sentence to remember Before every new tool, ask what it makes possible, what it takes, and whom it serves.
Chapter 1 Week 1: Seeing Technology
Show summary
- In this course technology means the making and using of tools, techniques, machines and systems, from the stone axe to the postal service.
- A tool extends the hand; a technique is a learnable way of doing; a machine works by itself; a system joins many parts and people.
- Scripture takes human making for granted and asks what it is for and how it goes.
- Every technology serves a purpose and also reshapes habits and worlds, so we ask what it makes possible and what it takes from us.
- "Only a tool" and "a driving force" each hold a truth; the course tests both.
- AI comes last in the course because its questions are the old ones asked again.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Technology, in this course | The making and using of tools, techniques, machines and systems by which people do what bare hands and memory could not. |
| Tool, technique, machine, system | A thing used for a job; a learnable way of doing; a tool that works by itself once set going; a whole of many parts and people. |
| The two questions | What does it make possible? What does it take from us, or turn us into? |
| Why Psalm 8 matters here | It holds human smallness and human calling together, and makers need both. |
One sentence to remember Every tool serves a purpose and also reshapes the people who use it, so we ask both what it makes possible and what it takes.
This week's action Pick one tool you use every day and write two lines: what it is for, and one habit it has changed.
Show summary
- Genesis 1:28 gives a blessing and a command to fill, subdue and have dominion; Genesis 2:15 gives the work of cultivating and keeping.
- Work and keeping the earth belong to the garden before the fall, so making tools is part of the original calling.
- "Subdue" has been read as a licence to exploit and as a care-taking rule; historians debate how much the first reading caused.
- Some Protestant writers call Genesis 1:28 the cultural mandate; Catholic teaching since Laudato Si' stresses care and doubts a technocratic mindset.
- Psalm 24:1 reminds us that the earth is Yahweh's, so every human claim is limited.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Genesis 1:28 and 2:15 together | Fill and rule the earth, and do it as work and keeping in a garden that belongs to another. |
| Two histories of "subdue" | A licence to master and take; or a care-taking rule under God. Both are real, and the weight of each is debated. |
| Cultural mandate | A Protestant name for the calling to cultivate and develop the world through work, family and art. |
| A garden question for any tool | Does it help us to cultivate, and does it help us to keep? |
One sentence to remember We are called to work the earth and to guard it, on ground that belongs to God.
This week's action Choose one tool you use and write one sentence on how it helps you cultivate and one on how it helps you keep.
Show summary
- Genesis 4:20-22 names the first herdsman, musician and metalworker in Cain's line, and neither praises nor condemns them.
- Readers take Genesis 4 as ambiguity, as common grace, or with suspicion; each has a weak point.
- Exodus 31 and 35 say God filled Bezalel and others with the Spirit for wisdom, understanding, knowledge and workmanship.
- The tabernacle was made by many skilled hands, to a pattern given by God, so that he might dwell among his people.
- Together the texts show skilled making as old and varied, not the problem; direction and heart matter.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Genesis 4:20-22 | The first herdsman, musician and metalworker, named in Cain's line without praise or blame. |
| Three readings of Genesis 4 | Ambiguity (skill grows beside sin), common grace (God's gift to all), suspicion (culture grows away from God). |
| Bezalel | A craftsman said to be filled with the Spirit of God for the work of the tabernacle. |
| What the pair teaches | Skilled making is old and varied and not the problem; the question is direction and heart. |
One sentence to remember The Bible names makers with neither fear nor flattery, and asks whose pattern their skill serves.
This week's action Name one skill you or someone you know has, and write what pattern or purpose it might serve.
Show summary
- Genesis 11:3-4 notes brick and tar without blame, and names the aim: a city, a tower, a name, no scattering.
- Readers take Babel as pride, as refusing to fill the earth, or as one imperial system; each has a weak point.
- Psalm 115:8 says that makers become like what they trust; whether it applies to modern tools is a point of reading.
- Isaiah 2:4 turns the same metal from war to farming; Joel 3:10 turns it back.
- The "direction and heart" view puts the question in purpose and trust, but may make a tool sound lighter than it is.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Babel, Genesis 11 | Bricks and tar used for a city, a tower and a name; readings: pride, refusing to fill the earth, one system. |
| Psalm 115:8 | Those who make idols and trust them become like them; a warning about trust, read narrowly or widely. |
| Isaiah 2:4 and Joel 3:10 | The same metal is beaten into ploughs or into swords; the purpose decides. |
| Weak point of "direction and heart" | It can make the tool sound lighter than it is; shape, system and trust also tilt and form us. |
One sentence to remember Scripture asks of every making what it serves and whom it trusts, and also what it makes of the maker.
This week's action Write down one tool you rely on, and say in one line whom or what you trust when you use it.
Show summary
- The lab asks you to notice the tools you hold, what each serves, and what each asks of you.
- A tool may be an object, a technique or a system; the question is what it makes possible and what it takes.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
- Never write a real name, church, employer or confidential detail; the lab neither urges nor forbids any device or app.
- A leader asks which question was hardest, never which tool was found.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Noticing the tools you hold, what each serves and what it asks, and choosing how to hold one. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What a leader asks | Which question was hardest to answer, never which tool was found. |
One sentence to remember See the tools in your hands; then ask what each serves and what it asks of you.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.
Chapter 2 Week 2: From Handwriting to the Printing Press
Show summary
- God's word reached people first by voice; writing kept the voice and carried it to those far away.
- Jeremiah 36 shows speaking, dictating, a scroll read aloud, the scroll burned and written again.
- A scroll must be unrolled to find a place; a codex opens anywhere.
- Early Christians used the codex early and often; why they did so is debated.
- Writing gave a text that can be compared, and put memory and the reader's attention at risk.
- Traditions describe differently how written Scripture relates to the community that reads it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Scroll | A long strip of writing on one side, rolled up; read by unrolling, with no pages. |
| Codex | Leaves fastened along one edge and written on both sides; the ancestor of the modern book. |
| What is debated about the codex | Why the early Christians used it so readily: convenience, searching, holding several writings, or older habits. |
| Gain and cost of writing | A fixed text that reaches far and can be compared; a risk to memory, and power in the hands of those who read. |
One sentence to remember The voice, the scroll and the codex each carried the Word; each gave something to the hearer and asked something of the hearer.
This week's action Write one sentence on how you most often meet the Word today (hearing, reading, seeing or singing), and one thing that way gives and one that it takes.
Show summary
- Hand copying produces small differences between copies; careful copyists tried to limit them but could not remove them.
- Monasteries were major places of copying in the West and the East; cathedral schools, professional scribes and Jewish scribes also copied.
- A book was rare and costly, and was treated with honour; traditions differ on how that honour is shown.
- Most believers met the Word by hearing, singing, seeing and living the church year.
- Copying was understood in some monastic writing as service and prayer; we cannot say this of every copyist.
- The hand-copied book gave care and continuity and kept access narrow.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why copies differ | A copyist's eye skips, repeats or confuses; margin notes enter the text; no hand copy is perfect. |
| Where books were copied | Monasteries (West and East), cathedral and church schools, professional scribes, Jewish scribes. |
| How believers met the Word | Read aloud and explained, sung and said by heart, seen in pictures and icons, lived in the church year. |
| Gain and cost of hand copying | Care, reverence and continuity; narrow access and dependence on those who held and read the books. |
One sentence to remember When books were few, the Word still reached the many by ear, song, image and the church year, and what it gave in care it cost in access.
This week's action Name two ways the Word reached you before you owned a Bible of your own, and who carried it to you.
Show summary
- Movable type made many identical copies quickly; it also spread whatever anyone chose to print.
- Erasmus's Greek New Testament (1516), Luther's German Bible and Tyndale's English New Testament show print serving reform inside and outside a church.
- Catholic, Reformed, Anglican and radical writers all printed; authorities on every side licensed and banned books.
- "The press caused the Reformation" is a one-cause story; print carried arguments that had other causes.
- Print brought many readings, solitary reading, repeated misprints and a risk to oral and visual ways.
- Traditions differ on who interprets Scripture; each has a weak point it can name.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What was new about the press | Identical copies, speed and falling cost, wide reach, and the ability to print any message. |
| Why "the press caused the Reformation" fails | Many causes worked together; print served Catholic, Reformed and radical writers, and authorities used it too. |
| Two new problems of print | Many readings at once; reading alone (also errors repeated in every copy, and oral and visual ways pushed aside). |
| Who may interpret Scripture | A disputed question: the church's teaching office, the church's confessions, or the believer and the Spirit. Each tradition has a weak point. |
One sentence to remember The press carried the Word to more people, and carried every other message too, and left the churches to answer the question of who reads and who explains.
This week's action Write two sentences stating how a tradition other than your own would describe who may interpret Scripture, in words that tradition would accept.
Show summary
- The Word has been in translation from the first: Greek for Aramaic speech, the Septuagint, then Latin, Syriac, Coptic and many more.
- Translation is a technology: script, grammar, dictionary, type and press give a language a book.
- Local-language Scripture made hearing, local leadership, a standard language and local song and preaching possible.
- Word choices and dialect choices carried old meanings and could raise one form of a language over others.
- Mission translation was tangled with empire and the slave trade, and also gave local churches their own voice.
- Readers disagree on how to weigh these; hold both and refuse the hero story and the charge sheet.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Translation as a technology | Giving a language a script, grammar, dictionary, type and press so that the Word can be written and printed in it. |
| What local-language Scripture made possible | Hearing in one's own language, local leaders, a standard written language, and local prayer, song and preaching. |
| What word choices risk | Carrying old meanings (such as a name for God), raising one dialect, and giving credit to the foreign hand. |
| The disagreement about empire | Whether the gifts of translation outweigh its entanglement with power, or the entanglement forbids praise; each side has a weak point. |
One sentence to remember Translation put the Word into the speech of the people, and it often travelled with power; the honest account keeps both.
This week's action Write down the language in which you first heard the Word, and one thing a translator had to decide so that you could hear it.
Show summary
- The lab asks you to trace how the Word has reached you and what each way gives and takes.
- No way of meeting the Word is only gain or only loss; the form asks you to describe, not to rank.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
- Never write a real name, church, employer or confidential detail on the form; any box touching a hard memory may be skipped.
- A leader asks which box was hardest, never which way was found, and reads the case aloud.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Tracing the ways the Word has reached you, and saying what each gives and takes. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab does not do | Rank the ways of meeting the Word, or require a correct answer. |
One sentence to remember Notice who carried the Word to you, and what each way gave and took.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.
Chapter 3 Week 3: Clocks, Factories and the Church
Show summary
- The mechanical clock divided the day into equal hours; it brought real goods and also changed how work and time were governed.
- Whether monastic hours helped to produce the clock is debated; the idea is possible, partly supported, and not proved.
- Factory work made the hour the unit in which labour was bought, and "time is money" became a common saying.
- The saying has a use as a warning against carelessness, but it prices every hour and can make rest look like waste.
- Sabbath and Lord's Day are time not owned by use; they set aside time that cannot be priced.
- The church year and the Lord's Day tell time by Christ's story and not by the market.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Clock time | The day divided into equal hours by a machine; useful for markets, travel and shared work, and a new way of governing labour. |
| Monastery and clock | A suggested link, debated by scholars: possible, partly supported, not proved. |
| Time is money | A saying with a use as warning, and a danger when every hour must earn. |
| Time not owned by use | The Sabbath and Lord's Day set aside time that is not for gain; it is given for rest, worship and joy. |
One sentence to remember The clock is a good servant of shared life and a poor master of it; the Sabbath and the Lord's Day remind us that some time is given and not spent.
This week's action Notice one hour this week that you treat as "wasted" because it earned nothing, and ask whether it was given to someone or something that matters.
Show summary
- Factories and cities moved work away from home and put it under wages, hours and machine pace; some gained and some lost.
- The machine age was joined to slavery, because some mills depended on cotton grown by enslaved people.
- Churches answered by staying with the suffering, by pressing for changes in the law, and by teaching about work.
- Rerum Novarum (1891) taught the dignity of work, a just wage, the right to form associations and rest.
- In some places churches were late, depended on owners, or told workers to accept their station.
- Genesis 2:15, Colossians 3:23 and James 5:4 together say: work is good, do it as for the Lord, and God hears the cheated.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three answers | Stay with the suffering (care and charity); change the law (reform); teach about work (dignity, wage, rest). |
| Rerum Novarum | A Catholic letter of 1891: work has dignity, wages must be just, workers may form associations, rest belongs to them. |
| Where the church was late | Dependence on owners, rented pews, teaching that the poor should accept their station, silence about cruelty. |
| James 5:4 | Wages kept back by fraud cry out, and God hears the cry of the workers. |
One sentence to remember The church had the resources to meet the factory age, and it used them partly: care came early, justice often late.
This week's action Think of one kind of work you rely on every day and ask who does it, under what conditions, and whether anyone has asked them.
Show summary
- Steamship, railway and telegraph shortened travel and news, and mission societies used them to send people, letters, money and Bibles.
- The new means were not only European; they were largely controlled by a few powers and companies.
- Local believers and leaders carried a large share of the work of teaching, translating and leading churches.
- Mission was tangled with empire: it travelled on the same routes and sometimes shared its assumptions.
- Many missionaries also opposed the wrongs of empire, and many people chose the faith freely.
- No culture is ranked above another; we ask who built the road, who walked it and who was asked.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the new means made possible | Regular travel, reports and letters, shipped Bibles and books, schools and hospitals, and mission societies on a larger scale. |
| Who carried much of the work | Local evangelists, catechists, translators, teachers, pastors and elders. |
| The entanglement | Mission travelled on the routes of trade and empire, sometimes relied on its protection and shared its assumptions. |
| Weak points of the two views | The first may excuse too much; the second may treat local believers as victims and not as agents. |
One sentence to remember New roads open the way for good news and for conquest alike; ask who built the road, who walked it and who was already there.
This week's action Name one way the gospel reached your own place, and ask who carried it and what road they used.
Show summary
- The machine age made rest harder, because machines can run without stopping and work moved away from home.
- Deuteronomy 5 ties the Sabbath to release from slavery, so rest is a protest against using people up.
- Exodus 20 ties the Sabbath to creation, and Mark 2:27 says it was made for people; rest is a gift.
- Heschel's The Sabbath is a Jewish work that speaks of holiness in time; it is not a description of the Lord's Day.
- Sabbatarian and non-Sabbatarian Christians differ on whether the Sabbath command continues; each has a strength and a weak point.
- Rest is best protected together, and it is not a ban on tools.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Two reasons for the Sabbath | Creation (Exodus 20) and release from slavery (Deuteronomy 5). |
| Sabbatarian view | The command continues, kept on the seventh day by some and on the first day by others; clear shape, risk of rules. |
| Non-Sabbatarian view | The Sabbath was fulfilled in Christ; Christians are free, yet gather on the Lord's Day; freedom, risk of lost rest. |
| Rest and tools | Rest is protest and gift, not a ban on tools; it asks whether people are received and not only used. |
One sentence to remember Rest is a gift that says we are not our output, and a protest against using anyone up.
This week's action Name one way your community could make rest easier for someone who cannot choose their hours.
Show summary
- The lab asks you to look at the shape of your week and write one sentence about how time is received or owned in it.
- A schedule is not a fault; it matters only when it becomes the only way you hold time.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
- Never write a real name, church, employer or confidential detail on the form; any part may be skipped.
- A leader asks which box was hardest, never how a person's week is arranged.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Looking at the shape of one's week and saying how time is received or owned in it. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| When a schedule is a problem | When it becomes the only way one holds time, so that unused time feels like waste. |
One sentence to remember Look at the shape of your week; then ask whether any part of it is given and not owned by use.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.
Chapter 4 Week 4: Telegraph, Radio, Television
Show summary
- Before the wire, a message travelled inside a person; the telegraph and radio began to separate the message from the messenger.
- The first public telegraph message of 1844 used Numbers 23:23, a cry of wonder at what God has done.
- Radio brought one voice to many homes at once, but a scattered audience is not a gathered congregation.
- Telegraph and radio drew both praise and warning, and both were partly right.
- Psalm 19:1-4 and Romans 10:18 give a direction for the word, not a blessing on any device.
- Four questions for any medium: who can now hear, who decides, what happens to the face, what stays the same.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the wire changed | It separated a message from the person who carried it, and sped news far beyond a rider's pace. |
| Numbers 23:23 in 1844 | The first public telegraph message used it; it shows awe at a new gift, but not what the gift would carry. |
| Radio's new public | One voice heard at once in many homes by listeners who do not see one another. |
| Praise and warning | Both were partly right; the balance differed by place, person and year. |
One sentence to remember When a message no longer travels inside a person, we gain reach and must ask who speaks, who controls the line, and what the face used to do.
This week's action Put the four questions to one means of communication you use each week, and write one answer to each.
Show summary
- Two questions are easy to confuse: what a medium carries, and the shape it gives to the carrying.
- McLuhan argued that a medium changes what we notice and the pace of life; his strength of claim is debated.
- Postman worried that public talk, religion included, drifts toward entertainment on television.
- The counter-view stresses those whom new media reached and that old media also shaped their message.
- First Corinthians 2:1-5 and 2 Corinthians 4:2 give a test for manner, not a rule about technology.
- Ask of every form: what it rewards, what it cannot carry, and who gains and who pays.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Content and form | Content is what is said; form is the kind of medium through which it is said. |
| McLuhan (1964) | A medium shapes what we notice and the pace of life, whatever it carries; how strong the claim is, is debated. |
| Postman (1985) | Public talk, including religion, tends to drift toward entertainment on television; the counter-view stresses who new media reached. |
| Paul in Corinth | He chose plain proclamation and open means; the passages test manner and do not give a rule about technology. |
One sentence to remember Ask of every medium both what it carries and how it shapes the carrying, and state each side of the debate fairly.
This week's action Take one sermon, hymn or prayer you know and write what changes when it is heard on the radio instead of in the room.
Show summary
- Broadcast worship serves the housebound, the distant, the endangered and the hesitant; any account of it must make room for them.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox communities each speak of broadcast as help to those absent, with different emphases on bodily presence.
- Hebrews 10:24-25, Matthew 18:20 and Acts 2:42-47 speak of gathered people, not of broadcast, and are read in different ways.
- One view says broadcast extends worship; the other says it cannot replace the gathered body; each has a real concern and a weak point.
- The course requires holding together the need of the person who cannot come and the meaning of the gathered body.
- A church can keep a minimum: be truthful about what the broadcast is, visit those who cannot come, invite those who can.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Who broadcast serves | The housebound, the distant, the endangered and the hesitant. |
| Hebrews 10:24-25 | Believers are to stir one another to love and not give up meeting; it speaks to those who could meet and did not. |
| Two positions | Broadcast is an extension of worship; or it cannot replace the gathered body. Each has a real concern and a weak point. |
| What the course requires | Hold together the need of the one who cannot come and the meaning of the gathered body. |
One sentence to remember A broadcast can carry the Word and prayer to the absent, and a church must still go to them and still gather.
This week's action Name one person who cannot come to your gathering, and decide how you could bring the gathering to them in person.
Show summary
- A room gives a spoken word a loop between speaker and hearers, a shared silence, and a preacher who can be questioned.
- A recorded or broadcast voice gains reach, patience, lasting and fit for weak listeners, and may lose those features of the room.
- Romans 10:17 supports the importance of hearing; it does not say whether recorded hearing equals live hearing.
- First Thessalonians 2:8 joins the preached word to a shared life.
- John 1:14 does not prove that recording is poor, but asks us to leave room for the bodily and personal side of the gospel.
- Traditions differ in how they weigh hearing and seeing; every tradition both speaks and enacts the Word.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What a room gives a word | A loop between speaker and hearers, a shared silence, and a preacher who can be asked and held to account. |
| What a recording gains | Reach, patience, lasting, and fit for weak or distant listeners. |
| Romans 10:17 | Faith comes by hearing; the verse does not say whether live and recorded hearing are equal. |
| John 1:14 | The Word came in a body; this does not prove recording is poor but asks us to keep the bodily side of the gospel alive. |
One sentence to remember Value the recorded voice for what it does well, and keep the voice joined to a life and a gathering.
This week's action Think of one person who hears a sermon only by recording, and plan one way to bring them a word in person.
Show summary
- The lab asks you to notice the ways the Word reaches you, what each gives and takes, and to write one sentence about joining the Word to a gathering and a person.
- A way of hearing becomes a problem only when it becomes the only way and a bodily meeting drops out of the week.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer’s way with the printed case, the partner’s way.
- Never write a real name, church, employer or confidential detail; if you record yourself, only you listen.
- A leader asks which box was hardest, never how a person hears the Word.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Noticing the ways the Word reaches you, what each gives and takes, and how to keep it joined to a gathering and a person. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer’s way; the partner’s way. |
| When a way of hearing is a problem | When it becomes the only way and a bodily meeting, shared table or person drops out of the week. |
One sentence to remember See where the Word reaches you, what each way gives and takes, and what is missing.
This week’s action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.
Chapter 5 Week 5: The Internet and Digital Communities
Show summary
- The network promised to reach anyone at any hour; it gave real goods to the distant, the isolated and minorities.
- General worries are comparison, scattered attention, anger magnified and ease of leaving; these are worries, not proofs.
- Koinonia means sharing in common; 1 Corinthians 12 adds mutual need, honour to the weaker, and shared suffering.
- A working tool: connection passes information, association gathers the like-minded, communion binds us to those we did not choose.
- Readers differ on whether online ties are real fellowship; each side has a strength and a weak point.
- Ask of any network use: does it keep us together, meet needs, keep the weaker member, and let us feel with the suffering?
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Koinonia | A Greek word for sharing in common: partnership, fellowship, participation (Acts 2:42). |
| Connection, association, communion | Information passing; people joined by shared taste or need; people bound to those they did not choose. |
| The body in 1 Corinthians 12 | Many members, each needed; the weaker are necessary; one member suffers and all suffer with it. |
| Online fellowship | Contested: one side stresses access and care; the other stresses presence and the weight of the body. |
One sentence to remember The network is strong at connection and association; the church asks whether it can also carry communion, with the weaker member kept in.
This week's action Write down one good the network has brought to someone in your community, and one thing it cannot carry for them.
Show summary
- Preaching and private prayer travel with little dispute; singing and fellowship travel in part; communion and baptism are where traditions part.
- Those who press the Incarnation argue that sacraments are acts of matter and presence, done by persons who are together.
- Those who see room for online communion argue that the Lord’s presence and the Spirit’s gathering are not bound to a room.
- The needs of the sick, the migrant and the persecuted are real; the churches have long answered by going to them.
- Each side has a weak point: what "gathered" means without a room, and what to offer the person who truly cannot come.
- The minimum: hold the isolated person’s need and the gathered body’s meaning together.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The argument from the Incarnation | God took a body (John 1:14), so the sacraments are acts of matter and presence done together. |
| The argument for online communion | The Supper is the Lord’s, not a room’s; the Spirit gathers across distance; the isolated should not be left without. |
| Weak points | The first must define "gathered"; the second must say what it gives the one who truly cannot come. |
| The minimum | Hold the isolated person’s need and the gathered body’s meaning together. |
One sentence to remember Before asking what a screen can carry, ask who cannot come and who will go to them, and what the table is for.
This week's action Write one sentence stating the other side of the online-communion question so that someone who holds it would accept it.
Show summary
- Many Christian traditions treat attention as a spiritual matter: watchfulness and stillness are ways of loving God and neighbour.
- Distraction is old; Luke 10:40 names it in a person busy with good work.
- Borgmann’s device paradigm: a device delivers a result and hides the effort and setting; focal practices gather people and ask something of them.
- Martha and Mary have been read as active and contemplative lives, as a word to workers, and as a word about the guest; the text does not call serving bad.
- Rest is freedom from usefulness, not a ban on tools; Christians differ on how strictly the day is kept.
- Readers differ on how sharp the critique of technology should be; each side has a weak point.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Watchfulness and stillness | Keeping alert in heart and quiet of heart so that one can pray; ways of loving by attention. |
| Device paradigm (Borgmann) | A device delivers a result and hides the effort; focal practices gather people and ask effort of them. |
| Martha and Mary (Luke 10:38-42) | Active and contemplative lives; a word to workers; a word about the guest. The text does not call serving bad. |
| Rest | Freedom from usefulness, a gift not to be earned; not a ban on tools. |
One sentence to remember Attention is close to what prayer is, and rest is the gift of a time that is not measured by use.
This week's action Choose one ordinary tool you use and write what it delivers and what you once had to do to receive it.
Show summary
- A gathered body does in full what needs people near: bread and water, bearing burdens, the poor beside the rich, correction, being known over years.
- Networks add real things: reach to the sick and far away, links among small churches, shared teaching, joint work.
- Church planting by network and wandering between churches are described, not judged; the questions are who is near and who answers.
- A parish assumes belonging by place; a congregation assumes belonging by commitment; the network presses on each differently.
- Readers differ on how much weight the local body should have against the network; each side has a weak point.
- Galatians 6:2 supposes someone near enough to carry a burden.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What a gathered body does in full | Bread and water, bearing burdens, the poor beside the rich, correction, being known over years. |
| What a network adds | Reach to the isolated, links among small churches, shared teaching, joint work. |
| Parish and congregation | Belonging by place under a bishop; belonging by chosen commitment. Each meets the network differently. |
| The test question | Who is near enough to bear this burden, and who will come to the door? |
One sentence to remember Networks supply what the body lacks only when the supplies reach a body that is there to receive them.
This week's action Write down who in your life is near enough to bear a burden with you, and who you are near enough to help.
Show summary
- The lab asks you to see where you gather in person and where you meet by screen, and to write one sentence about the rhythm you want.
- The lab judges no device and no pattern; it asks what each gives, what it asks, and who is near enough to bear a burden.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
- Never write a real name, church, employer or confidential detail; any part touching loneliness may be skipped.
- A leader asks which box was hardest to fill, never how much screen anyone uses.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Seeing where one gathers and where one meets by screen, and writing a sentence about the rhythm one wants. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the leader asks | "Which box was hardest to fill?" Never "how much screen do you use?" |
One sentence to remember Look at your own pattern of gathering and screen, and ask who is near enough to bear a burden with you.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.
Chapter 6 Week 6: Reading Technology Theologically, and AI as the Last Chapter
Show summary
- The question is who is in charge: the tool as a neutral instrument, or technology as a force that shapes us.
- The neutral view keeps responsibility with people; its weak point is that tools are shaped by design, cost and habit.
- The determinist view sees how tools remake time and work; its weak point is that people refuse and shape, and it can excuse everyone.
- One theological view holds good creation, bent use, formation of habits, and hope with a task.
- A design can tilt choices without forcing them; four questions make the tilt visible.
- Readers disagree on neutrality; the course asks you to state both sides fairly.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Case for neutrality | A tool has no will; the purpose is human, so responsibility stays with people. |
| Weak point of neutrality | Tools are not empty: design, cost and habit shape the user whatever the intention. |
| Case for determinism | Tools once adopted reorder time, work and habit, and competition forces adoption. |
| A design that tilts | It makes some choices easy and others costly without forbidding any. |
One sentence to remember A tool is made for ends and bent by use, and it forms the one who uses it; so we are neither only users nor only carried along.
This week's action Pick one tool you use daily and write what it makes easy, what it makes hard, and who chose that.
Show summary
- Ellul used "technique" for the whole effort to find the most efficient method in every field; his weak point is treating it as one thing with one direction.
- Heidegger, a philosopher, described technology as a way of seeing things as stock to be used; his account is not the Christian story.
- The Catholic letter Laudato Si' names good fruit and questions a technocratic mindset, asking what technology is for.
- Orthodox thought gives matter a high place and asks whether a tool serves thanksgiving; Reformed and Evangelical streams stress calling, common grace and mission.
- Readers disagree on how sharp the critique should be; the course asks you to state both sides fairly.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ellul: technique | The whole effort to find the most efficient method in every field of life, so that efficiency becomes the only judge. |
| Heidegger: way of seeing | Technology as a way of seeing things as stock to be ordered and used; he is a philosopher, not a theologian. |
| Catholic letter | Names good fruit and questions a technocratic mindset, asking what the technology is for. |
| Orthodox emphasis | Matter can bear grace; the question is whether use serves thanksgiving and offering. |
One sentence to remember Each voice presses a real point and each has a weak point; listen to all, and let none become the last word.
This week's action Choose one voice from the lecture and write the question it would ask of a tool in your own setting.
Show summary
- This lecture asks the course's old questions of AI in conditional form; it gives no forecast and no claim about present capability.
- The five questions are: what is made possible, what might be taken, who gains and who carries the load, how we might be shaped, what happens to the gathered body and rest.
- AI is like earlier tools in being human-made and tilting choices; any difference should be stated as a possibility.
- Neither "only another tool" nor "unlike anything before" is warranted by the history.
- Ethics, the human person and how such tools work belong to the school's other courses.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why conditionals? | Facts about AI date quickly; "if... might..." tests questions without claiming what is true now. |
| The five questions | Possible; taken; who gains and who pays; how we are shaped; the gathered body and rest. |
| Two quick moves to avoid | "It is only another tool" and "it is unlike anything before". |
| Where to go next | STEL5E for ethics, STEL6E for the human person, PT737E for how such tools work. |
One sentence to remember Ask of the newest tool what we asked of the oldest, and guard the heart first.
This week's action Write the five questions on a card, and put them beside any new tool before you decide about it.
Show summary
- Discernment is a practice learned by use, and in Philippians 1:9 love comes before it.
- Seven questions: love of neighbour, the weak, time and rest, the gathered body, truthfulness, dependence, what the tool asks of us.
- Discernment is best practised together, with those the tool touches, a provisional decision, a review date and a written note.
- The questions can be misused to win an argument or taken as a licence to stop watching.
- Readers disagree on how fast to take up a new tool; the course asks you to state both views fairly.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The seven questions | Love of neighbour; the weak; time and rest; the gathered body; truthfulness; dependence; what it asks of us. |
| Why together? | Nobody sees everything; a group steadies mood; it practises the skill; its decision is more likely to be kept. |
| A pattern | Name it, invite those it touches, ask, decide provisionally, set a review date, write it down. |
| Two misuses | Using the questions to win an argument; treating the decision as the end of watching. |
One sentence to remember Discernment is love learning to see, practised together and reviewed on a date.
This week's action Choose one small tool in your community and ask the seven questions with at least one other person.
Show summary
- The lab asks you to gather your thinking into one page: what you believe, what you do not know, what questions remain, and one rhythm.
- A page with no unknowns is often a page that has stopped thinking; "I do not know" is a true answer.
- A rhythm is small, repeated, specific and has a date to look again.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed page, the partner's way.
- A leader asks which part was hardest to write, never what people believe.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Gathering one's thinking into a page: belief, unknowns, questions and one rhythm. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| A good rhythm | Small, specific, repeated, and with a date to look again. |
One sentence to remember A page written honestly, with its unknowns and one small rhythm, is worth more than a verdict.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, keep it where only you will find it, and put a date in your diary to read it again.