Lecture 10-2: The Whirlwind, and the Two Monsters
목차 40
- Lecture 1-1: Parallelism, and What It Actually Does
- Lecture 1-2: Image, Body, and the Work of Metaphor
- Lecture 1-3: Where These Books Sit in the Canon
- Lecture 2-1: What "Wisdom" Means, and Whether It Is One Thing
- Lecture 2-2: Israel's Wisdom among the Nations
- Lecture 2-3: The Fear of the LORD, and Wisdom's Own Limits
- Lecture 3-1: One Hundred Fifty Poems, Five Books
- Lecture 3-2: Superscriptions, "David," and the Numbering Problem
- Lecture 3-3: The Psalms in Worship: Temple, Synagogue, Church
- Lecture 4-1: Form Criticism: Gunkel, Mowinckel, and After
- Lecture 4-2: Lament: The Largest Group, and the Turn
- Lecture 4-3: Praise, Thanksgiving, Trust, and the Wisdom Psalms
- Lecture 5-1: The Royal Psalms and What Happened to Them
- Lecture 5-2: Zion, Temple, and the Songs of Ascents
- Lecture 5-3: How the New Testament Reads the Psalms
- Lecture 6-1: The Imprecatory Psalms
- Lecture 6-2: Psalm 88, and a Lament That Does Not Turn
- Lecture 6-3: Penitence, Confession, and the Seven Penitential Psalms
- Lecture 7-1: The Shape of Proverbs: Instructions, Sentences, Collections
- Lecture 7-2: Lady Wisdom, and the Woman Who Is Not
- Lecture 7-3: Reading Proverbs Without Turning Them into Promises
- Lecture 8-1: Speech, Anger, and the Company You Keep
- Lecture 8-2: Money, Work, Poverty, and Justice
- Lecture 8-3: The Woman of Strength, and Who This Book Was For
- Lecture 9-1: The Prologue, the Accuser, and the Question Behind the Wager
- Lecture 9-2: The Friends, the Cycles, and the Doctrine of Retribution
- Lecture 9-3: Job's Protest, the Vindicator, and the Oath
- Lecture 10-1: Elihu — Interruption or Contribution
- Lecture 10-2: The Whirlwind, and the Two Monsters
- Lecture 10-3: "Now My Eye Sees You": The Ending, and Whether It Undoes the Book
- Lecture 11-1: Hevel — The Word the Whole Book Turns On
- Lecture 11-2: Time, Death, and What Wisdom Cannot Reach
- Lecture 11-3: "Eat Your Bread with Joy": The Refrain, and the Ending
- Lecture 12-1: The Poem Itself — Voices, Structure, and Imagery
- Lecture 12-2: Allegory, and Why It Ruled for Two Thousand Years
- Lecture 12-3: Body, Desire, and What the Canon Does with This Book
Job has sworn his innocence in a legal register that functions as a summons: he wants God in court, answering a specific charge, on the specific question of why an innocent man suffers. What he gets, in chapters 38 through 41, is God — but not in court, and not answering that question. Yahweh speaks out of a whirlwind, and everything Yahweh says takes the grammatical form of a question: "Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?" (38:4); "Have you entered the springs of the sea?" (38:16); "Can you bind the cluster of the Pleiades?" (38:31); "Do you know the time when the mountain goats give birth?" (39:1). Two full speeches, dozens of questions, and not one of them is about suffering, sin, justice, or the wager between Yahweh and the accuser that opened the book in chapter 1 — a wager Job never learns about at all, in this book or ever. The topic is the physical and animal world: the sea shut behind doors, the dawn taking hold of the earth's edges, wild goats and wild donkeys and the ostrich's strange indifference to her own eggs, the war-horse who laughs at fear, and finally two creatures given more space than everything else combined — Behemoth in 40:15-24 and Leviathan across the whole of chapter 41.
This lecture asks what kind of answer a barrage of unanswerable questions actually is, and refuses to settle for the single most common classroom gloss, which is that God simply overwhelms Job into silence. That happens, and the text says as much (40:3-5), but "overwhelms" is not the only defensible account of what the speeches are doing, and three serious readings disagree about it in ways worth holding apart rather than blending into one comfortable synthesis. The lecture also takes Behemoth and Leviathan seriously as a real interpretive problem rather than a curiosity: whether they are extravagant descriptions of two real animals, or something closer to the personified forces of chaos known from other ancient Near Eastern literature, changes what the whole speech is claiming about the relationship between God, creation, and the disorder Job has been suffering under.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- State the formal fact that the divine speeches consist almost entirely of unanswerable questions, and explain why this form matters as much as their content.
- Describe what the two speeches actually cover — cosmic and meteorological order in 38, wild animals in 39, Behemoth and Leviathan in 40-41 — and note the near-total absence of any human figure from the description.
- Set out at least three distinct scholarly assessments of what the whirlwind speeches accomplish, naming a representative for each, without treating any one of them as the settled answer.
- Explain the main proposals for identifying Behemoth and Leviathan (ordinary animals, mythic chaos monsters, or a reading that holds both together) and state the textual evidence used for each.
- Describe Job's first, brief response (40:3-5) and explain what it does and does not concede.
Then Yahweh answered Job out of the whirlwind, “Who is this who darkens counsel by words without knowledge? Brace yourself like a man, for I will question you, then you answer me! — Job 38:1-3
World English Bible
Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth? Declare, if you have understanding. Who determined its measures, if you know? Or who stretched the line on it? Whereupon were its foundations fastened? Or who laid its cornerstone, when the morning stars sang together, and all the sons of God shouted for joy? — Job 38:4-7
WEB
Will you even annul my judgment? Will you condemn me, that you may be justified? — Job 40:8
WEB
See now, behemoth, which I made as well as you. He eats grass as an ox. — Job 40:15
WEB
Can you draw out Leviathan with a fish hook, or press down his tongue with a cord? — Job 41:1
WEB
1. A speech made entirely of questions
The most important formal fact about Job 38-41 is easy to state and easy to walk past: apart from the narrative frames ("Then Yahweh answered Job out of the whirlwind," 38:1 and 40:6) and a handful of imperatives telling Job to brace himself (38:3, 40:7), the divine speeches consist almost entirely of rhetorical questions, and every single one of them is a question only God can answer. "Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?" (38:4) is not a request for information; nobody was there, and the question's grammar assumes the answer is nobody but God. This holds for the whole first speech — cosmology (38:4-38: the earth's foundations, the sea's boundaries, the dawn, the storehouses of snow and hail, the constellations, the rain that falls where no person lives) and zoology (38:39-39:30: lion, raven, mountain goat, wild donkey, wild ox, ostrich, horse, hawk, eagle) — and it holds again for the second, shorter speech that introduces Behemoth and Leviathan. A student reading quickly can miss how total this is: there is no proposition in these four chapters that says "here is why you suffer" or "here is why the wicked prosper," stated or implied. The form itself is the first thing the lecture asks a student to notice, because a series of questions a listener cannot answer is not a lecture and not a legal ruling — it is closer to what a teacher does with a Socratic method, or what an examiner does with cross-examination, and deciding which of those two the whirlwind speeches resemble more closely turns out to matter for everything that follows.
2. What is described, and what is conspicuously absent
Read straight through, chapters 38-39 describe an order that predates any human observer and does not depend on any human use. The sea is given doors and swaddling bands like an infant (38:8-11) — an image of something dangerous being bound rather than eliminated, which will matter again for Leviathan. The rain falls "to satisfy the waste and desolate ground, to cause the tender grass to grow" (38:26-27) in places no person will ever see, which the text states plainly has no human beneficiary at all. The wild donkey is given freedom precisely because "he scorns the tumult of the city, neither does he hear the shouting of the driver" (39:7) — an animal defined by its usefulness to nobody. The ostrich, famously, "deals harshly with her young ones, as if they were not hers. Though her labor is in vain, she is without fear" (39:16), and the text adds, almost as a punchline, "because God has deprived her of wisdom" (39:17) — an animal whose apparent stupidity is stated to be God's own doing, offered without a hint of embarrassment about including a creature that looks badly designed inside a speech about how well-designed creation is. What is missing from all of this, conspicuously, is Job's own species. Humanity appears in these chapters only as the thing the speech is not about: not the measurer of the earth, not the opener of the sea, not the feeder of the raven's young, not the master of the wild donkey or the wild ox — the text specifically denies that the wild ox will serve at Job's crib (39:9-12), reversing the domesticated-ox image and putting the point sharply. A speech Job hoped would be about him turns out to be about almost everything except him.
3. Three readings of what the speeches accomplish
This is a point where readers will not agree. At least three serious and distinct accounts of what these speeches are doing have real support, and this lecture presents each in its strongest form rather than picking a winner.
The sublime, and the relativizing of Job's demand. Reading the speeches through a tradition of reflection on aesthetic experience that runs back to Rudolf Otto's account of the numinous — the encounter with something that provokes both dread and fascination, a mysterium tremendum et fascinans — this view holds that the speeches are not primarily an argument at all. They are an experience: Job is confronted with the sheer scale, strangeness, and otherness of the created order, and that confrontation does something to him that no proposition could do. On this account, Job's demand for a legal accounting was never a demand the category of "creation" could satisfy, and the speeches work by shifting Job out of the courtroom frame entirely rather than by winning the case inside it. This reading takes seriously that Job's own response (42:5-6, covered in the next lecture) describes seeing rather than being persuaded — "now my eye sees you" — which fits an experiential account better than an argumentative one.
Overwhelming power, read from underneath. Gustavo Gutiérrez, writing from the perspective of Latin American in On Job: God-Talk and the Suffering of the Innocent (1987), takes a harder-edged view of the same evidence. For Gutiérrez, the speeches are a genuine display of power that does not so much answer Job's suffering as assert God's freedom over any human claim to have God's justice figured out in advance — including the friends' confident retribution theology and, Gutiérrez argues, including any theology, ancient or modern, that treats the suffering of the poor as something owed an explanation before it can be believed. On this reading the speeches are less about admiring creation for its own sake and more about a God who refuses to be cornered by human categories of and desert, which Gutiérrez reads as good news specifically for those, like Job, who suffer without cause: God's freedom is not indifference to Job, but a refusal to let Job's suffering be explained away by the friends' tidy moral bookkeeping.
A voice among voices, deliberately left unresolved. Carol Newsom's dialogical reading, introduced in 10-1, extends into this material directly: rather than treating the whirlwind speeches as the book's final word that settles everything before it, Newsom reads them as one more voice added to a book that has been building a genuine plurality of perspectives on suffering — the frame narrator's, the friends', Job's own shifting and developing voice across the dialogues, Elihu's, and now God's — without collapsing that plurality into a single teaching, even at the end. On this view, part of what makes Job disturbing to read carefully is that the whirlwind speeches do not actually cancel the friends' theology, or Job's protest, or Elihu's claim about suffering as instruction; all of these voices remain in the text, unretracted, after God has spoken, and a reader who wants the ending to erase everything before it is asking the book to be simpler than it is.
A student does not have to choose one of these three and discard the others in order to understand the material; the goal is to be able to state accurately what each reading claims, what in the text supports it, and where the readings genuinely conflict rather than merely emphasizing different things. They do conflict: the sublime reading and the Gutiérrez reading disagree about whether the speeches are primarily aesthetic or primarily political-theological in character, and both disagree with Newsom about whether the whirlwind speeches are meant to be a resolution at all.
4. Behemoth and Leviathan
The two creatures given the most space in the divine speeches — Behemoth in 40:15-24 and Leviathan across all of chapter 41 — are also the hardest to pin down, and the difficulty is not a modern translation problem so much as a genuinely open question about what kind of creature the poem intends.
The natural-history reading takes Behemoth's grass-eating, its bones like tubes of bronze, its tail like a cedar, and its resting among the reeds and lotus plants (40:15-22) as an extravagant but recognizable description of the hippopotamus, and takes Leviathan's scales, terrible teeth, fire-breathing imagery, and description as king over all the sons of pride (41:15-34) as a hyperbolic but ultimately naturalistic description of the crocodile. On this reading the speeches close their catalogue of creation with its two most impressive and most dangerous animals, continuing directly from the lion, ostrich, and wild ox that came before, and the point is simply that these are creatures no human can master even though God made and sustains them.
The mythic reading notes that both names carry weight elsewhere in the Old Testament and in the wider ancient Near Eastern world that a hippopotamus or crocodile does not obviously carry. Leviathan appears in Psalm 74:14 as a many-headed sea creature Yahweh crushed at creation, and in Isaiah 27:1 as "the fleeing serpent... the twisted serpent," language drawn from the same conceptual world as the Ugaritic combat myths in which Baal defeats the sea-dragon Yam or Lotan (a name cognate with "Leviathan"). On this reading, the description in Job 41 of a creature "made without fear" (41:33) who is "king over all the sons of pride" (41:34) evokes not an animal in a river but the personified force of chaos itself — the same watery disorder that stands behind the sea being given doors and swaddling bands back in 38:8-11. Behemoth's description, similarly, includes details (its "tail like a cedar," 40:17, an odd description for a hippopotamus, whose tail is short) that some readers take as evidence the poem is reaching past ordinary zoology into something closer to a primordial land-monster paired with Leviathan's primordial sea-monster.
A reading that holds both together, associated with commentators including Choon-Leong Seow, argues that this need not be a choice between a real animal and a myth: the poem may be describing recognizable creatures — a hippopotamus, a crocodile — precisely in the register of myth, treating the most dangerous and untamable animals a Near Eastern audience actually knew as living emblems of the very chaos the creation speeches have already shown God binding rather than destroying. On this account, the natural-history and mythic readings are not competitors so much as two levels of the same image, and the point that survives either way is the one the text itself makes plainly: God, not Job, made these creatures, sustains them, and is not afraid of them (41:33), while Job could not draw Leviathan out with a fish hook (41:1) or make peace with him (41:4) at all.
5. Job's first answer
Between the two speeches, Job responds briefly (40:3-5): “Behold, I am of small account. What shall I answer you? I lay my hand on my mouth. I have spoken once, and I will not answer; Yes, twice, but I will proceed no further.” It is worth being precise about what this does and does not say. Job does not confess a sin here, does not retract his claim of innocence, and does not say the friends were right. What he does is stop arguing — he silences himself in the specific sense of declining to continue a case he now recognizes he cannot win on these terms, whatever the moral status of his original claim to innocence. That this brief answer comes after only the first speech, and that God then continues with a second, longer speech centered on Behemoth and Leviathan, suggests the first silence was not itself the intended destination; whatever the whirlwind speeches are doing, they are not finished doing it at 40:5, which is worth remembering when the next lecture turns to Job's second and much more debated response in 42:1-6.
6. Further Reading
- David J. A. Clines, Job 38-42, Word Biblical Commentary 18B (Thomas Nelson, 2011) — detailed philological and literary commentary on the divine speeches, Behemoth, and Leviathan.
- Gustavo Gutiérrez, On Job: God-Talk and the Suffering of the Innocent (Orbis Books, 1987) — the liberation-theology reading of the whirlwind speeches cited in this lecture.
- Carol A. Newsom, The Book of Job: A Contest of Moral Imaginations (Oxford University Press, 2003) — the dialogical reading extended into the divine speeches.
- Robert Alter, The Wisdom Books: Job, Proverbs, and Ecclesiastes (W. W. Norton, 2010) — a literary translation attentive to the imagery of the whirlwind speeches and the two monsters.
- Choon-Leong Seow, Job 1-21: Interpretation and Commentary (Eerdmans, 2013) — background on ancient Near Eastern combat mythology and the Leviathan tradition, foundational for the reading that holds natural history and myth together.
- John Day, God's Conflict with the Dragon and the Sea: Echoes of a Canaanite Myth in the Old Testament (Cambridge University Press, 1985) — the standard study of the Leviathan/Lotan mythic background across the Old Testament.
핵심 요약
- God's speeches from the whirlwind (chapters 38-41) are almost entirely questions that only God can answer. None addresses why the innocent suffer.
- They describe the cosmos and wild animals, including creatures useful to nobody. The ostrich is said to lack wisdom by God's doing. Humanity appears mostly as what the speech is not about.
- Three readings disagree. One is a sense of the sublime, as with Rudolf Otto. Gustavo Gutierrez sees God's freedom over human claims, and Carol Newsom sees one more voice among voices.
- Behemoth and Leviathan are read as hippopotamus and crocodile, as mythic chaos monsters, or as real animals described in myth's register (Choon-Leong Seow).
- Job's first reply (40:3-5) stops his arguing. It does not confess sin or withdraw his claim of innocence.
Topic: God's speeches from the whirlwind in Job 38-41, their question form, and the debated meaning of Behemoth and Leviathan.
Remember: God answers Job with unanswerable questions about creation, not with an explanation of his suffering. Humans did not make or govern creation.
Caution: The lecture warns against reading this only as God overwhelming Job. The three readings conflict and the lecture picks no single answer. Job's first reply is not a confession.
One line to carry into ministry: Do not rush to explain suffering. Sometimes the faithful answer points to God's greatness and keeps company with the sufferer.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Count the number of imperative statements versus questions in Job 38:1-38 (you do not need to be exact; a careful estimate is enough). What does the overwhelming preponderance of questions suggest about the kind of speech this is?
- The ostrich passage (39:13-18) describes an animal whose apparent poor design is attributed directly to God ("God has deprived her of wisdom," 39:17). What does the inclusion of this passage do to a reading of the speeches as primarily about creation's beauty and order?
- State, in one paragraph each, the sublime reading, the Gutiérrez reading, and the Newsom reading of what the whirlwind speeches accomplish. Then identify one specific point on which two of the three readings genuinely disagree rather than merely emphasizing different things.
- Read Psalm 74:14 and Isaiah 27:1 alongside Job 41. Does the wider Old Testament use of "Leviathan" strengthen or weaken the case for reading Job's Leviathan mythically? Defend your answer.
- Job's response in 40:3-5 comes after the first speech, and God continues with a second speech afterward. What does this sequencing suggest about whether 40:3-5 is the book's intended stopping point? Hold your answer in mind for the next lecture.