Lecture 2-2: Activities, Transitions and Clear Instructions
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Where Teaching Happens
- Lecture 1-2: Starting from the Evidence
- Lecture 1-3: Time, Room and a Plan B
- Lecture 1-4: Who Is in the Room
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Lesson Plan
- Lecture 2-1: The First and the Last Three Minutes
- Lecture 2-2: Activities, Transitions and Clear Instructions
- Lecture 2-3: Room for Everyone
- Lecture 2-4: Teaching Through a Difficult Moment
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Ten Minutes Taught
- Lecture 3-1: How Do You Know They Learned
- Lecture 3-2: Assessment That Respects the Learner
- Lecture 3-3: Short Checks, Well Made
- Lecture 3-4: After the Lesson: Notes and One Change
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Check for Your Plan
- Lecture 4-1: Watching a Lesson
- Lecture 4-2: Feedback to a Teacher
- Lecture 4-3: Hearing the Learners
- Lecture 4-4: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Observation Sheet
- Lecture 5-1: Children and Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Adults and Lay Training
- Lecture 5-3: Mixed Ages, Online and Blended
- Lecture 5-4: Lessons in Another Language or Culture
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, One Lesson, Two Rooms
The middle of a lesson is where most of the time goes, and it is where most plans meet trouble. A good activity is chosen for the goal. But even a good activity fails if people do not know what to do, or if the move from one part to the next is a muddle.
This lecture has three questions. Does this activity serve the goal? How do I move people from one part of the lesson to the next? And how do I tell them what to do so that they can do it? The third question is the one most teachers underestimate. A teacher who has prepared for hours may give an instruction in ten seconds, and then be puzzled when the room does something else.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Test an activity against the goal of the lesson and keep, change or drop it.
- Give an instruction in three parts: one step at a time, shown, and checked.
- Plan how to form groups and how to move between parts of a lesson without shaming anyone.
- Explain how activities differ for children, for adults and for mixed ages, and when a game is not acceptable.
Moses’ father-in-law said to him, “The thing that you do is not good." — Exodus 18:17
World English Bible
You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you; for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to perform it yourself alone." — Exodus 18:18
WEB
You shall teach them the statutes and the laws, and shall show them the way in which they must walk, and the work that they must do." — Exodus 18:20
WEB
So when he had washed their feet, put his outer garment back on, and sat down again, he said to them, “Do you know what I have done to you?" — John 13:12
WEB
For I have given you an example, that you also should do as I have done to you." — John 13:15
WEB
He commanded the multitudes to sit down on the grass; and he took the five loaves and the two fish, and looking up to heaven, he blessed, broke and gave the loaves to the disciples, and the disciples gave to the multitudes." — Matthew 14:19
WEB
Moses' father-in-law sees that one person cannot carry the whole work alone, and he proposes a way to share it among many. Jesus shows an action and then asks his disciples whether they understand it. And at the feeding of the crowd, the people are told to sit down before the bread is handed out. None of these is a lesson plan. Each shows a small piece of ordinary good order: share the load, show it, and prepare the place.
1. Does the activity serve the goal?
Last week you wrote a goal: what the learner should be able to say or do, and what you will see if they can. Everything in the middle of the lesson is there to bring the learners to that goal. So the first test of any activity is simple.
If a learner does this activity well, will I have seen the evidence in my goal?
If yes, keep it. If no, the activity may still be pleasant, but it is not serving this lesson.
(An invented example.) A teacher plans a 45-minute lesson with this goal: "By the end, learners can retell the story of the feeding of the five thousand in their own words and say one thing it shows about Jesus." She has an activity: learners build a model of a hillside from modelling clay. It is a lovely activity. But if a learner builds the hillside well, has the teacher seen a retelling? No. She has seen modelling. She keeps the clay for those who like it, but she adds a step: each pair retells the story to each other, pointing at their model. Now the activity serves the goal.
There is nothing wrong with enjoyment. A lesson that people enjoy is more likely to be attended. But enjoyment is not evidence of learning, and a teacher can be fooled by a noisy, happy room.
A few other tests help.
Does the activity use the time well? Activities almost always take longer than planned, especially the first time. Write a minute estimate beside each activity. Then write the minute at which you will stop it, whether or not it is finished.
Does it fit the room? An activity that needs a table does not suit a hall with fixed rows. An activity that needs reading does not suit a group with several who read slowly. Lecture 1-4 and lecture 2-3 help with this.
Can everyone take part? If the activity needs a skill, such as drawing, singing, quick reading or running, ask whether it shows the goal, or only the skill. Where it only shows the skill, offer another way to do the same thing.
2. Instructions: one at a time, shown, checked
Most failed activities do not fail because of the activity. They fail because of the instruction.
Here is the kind of instruction that gives trouble.
(An invented example.) Before. A teacher says, quickly, as people are still sitting down:
"Get into groups of four and discuss the question on the sheet and then someone write down what you decided and then when I say we will share, you have got ten minutes, and use the back of the sheet if you run out of room, and make sure everybody has a say."
How many things did she ask? Count them. Form groups of four. Discuss. Choose a writer. Write down the decision. Wait for a signal. Share. Watch the time. Use the back of the sheet. Make sure everyone speaks. That is nine instructions in one breath, and the learners were not yet listening. Some will hear the first, some the last, and a few will not hear anything because they are still looking for a pen.
A clear instruction has three parts.
One step at a time. Give the first step only. When it is done, give the next. Where the steps are many, write them on a board or a sheet so that they can be seen as well as heard. For people who follow in a second language, writing and speaking together is a great help.
Show it. Do the first step yourself, or ask one learner to do it with you, in front of the room. Showing is what Jesus does in John 13. He does an action, and then he asks, "Do you know what I have done to you?" (John 13:12), and he says he has given them an example (John 13:15). We should not push a verse too far. That scene is about service and not about classroom method. But the order is worth noticing: an example is given, and then the learners are asked whether they have understood.
Check it. Before you let go, find out whether they know what to do. Do not ask, "Does everyone understand?" Nearly everyone says yes. Ask one person, kindly, to say what they are going to do first. "Kofi, what is your group doing first?" (This is an invented name. Use a name from your own group.) If the answer is wrong, the instruction was not clear enough, and it is the teacher's to mend, not the learner's fault.
After. The same teacher, in three short moves:
"Please turn your chair to face the two people next to you, so that you are a group of three or four. [She waits.] Here is the question. [She points to it on the board.] First, each person writes one sentence on their own. Show me with your pencil: where do you write? [A learner points to the sheet.] Good. You have three minutes. I will ring this bell when the time is up. Then you will tell the others what you wrote. Let us start with the writing."
She gave one thing at a time. She showed where to write. She checked by asking a learner to point. She named the time and the sign for the end. When the first step was done, she rang the bell and gave the second.
This takes a little longer to say. It saves much more time than it costs, because the learners do what she meant the first time.
3. Forming groups
Many activities need groups or pairs. How you form them matters more than it seems.
- Pairs by seat. "Turn to the person next to you." This is quick and nobody is chosen last.
- Counting off. "Count 1, 2, 3, 4 around the room. All the ones come to this corner." This mixes people and no one chooses.
- Planned groups. You decide in advance, perhaps putting a quiet person with a patient one, or separating two who always talk together. Do it quietly and without explanation.
Avoid the schoolyard method in which two people choose teams in turn. Someone is always chosen last, and everyone watched. Avoid, too, putting a learner in a group on the spot because "you do not have anyone." In a group of children, avoid asking them to pick their own partners if some have no friend there; assign the pairs.
Remember that some learners will not want to work in a group at all, and that is allowed. A learner may do the task alone or with the teacher beside them. The goal is the learning, not the shape of the room.
4. Moving between parts
A transition is the move from one part of the lesson to the next: from listening to talking, from the whole group to pairs, from the table to the circle. Transitions are where time leaks away and where order is lost.
Plan the transitions as you plan the activities. For each, decide:
- A signal. A bell, a raised hand, a sentence such as "Let us come back together." Use the same signal every week so that the learners know it.
- One sentence to say what is next. "Now we will share what you wrote."
- What to bring. "Bring your sheet and your pencil."
- How long it will take. In a hall with fixed chairs, turning to a neighbour takes a few seconds. Moving the chairs into groups of four can take several minutes. Write it down.
A good transition is calm. If the room becomes noisy, wait. Do not shout over it. Raise your hand, stand still, and let the signal work.
5. Different learners and different rooms
Children. Keep each part short. Give one instruction at a time and show it. Use movement, because sitting still for the whole time is hard, and give them something to do with their hands. A child who is asked to do three things will usually do the last one. If you work with children, remember that two adults and an open door are the community's usual safeguard; we return to this in lecture 5-1.
Adults. Adults usually want to know why. Say what the activity is for, in a sentence. Give them a choice where you can: "Write it, or talk it over, as you prefer." Respect their time and their experience. Do not ask adults to do something that feels like play-acting for children unless you have explained why and made it easy to pass.
Mixed ages. The same activity must serve a child of eight and a grandmother of seventy. Choose tasks that have more than one way in: a picture, a word, a sentence, a story. Let each age bring what it can. Do not make children perform for adults or adults perform for children.
6. When a game or a contest is not acceptable
Games and contests are used in many communities, and in many places they are enjoyed. Teams, quizzes and races can give energy to a room. Other communities do not use them, because they think a contest does not suit the quiet of worship or the dignity of learning. Both views are held with good reason. This course requires only one thing:
A game is acceptable only if nobody is shamed by it.
Test any game with these questions. Could the slowest reader, the newest member, the one who is least sure of their words, take part with dignity? Is there a way to pass? Will a wrong answer cost anyone anything in front of others? Does a score separate people into winners and losers in a way that lasts after the game?
If the answer is no to any of these, change the game. Make the teams answer together. Score the group against a target, not against each other. Take away the public scoreboard. Or drop the game and choose another activity that serves the goal.
Remember also that the game is for the goal. A quiz game that rewards fast recall of names may not show whether a learner has understood the story. Keep asking whether this serves the lesson.
7. Dividing the work
Moses was told by his father-in-law that the work was too heavy for him alone, and that he should place able people over groups, so that every small matter could be judged by others and only the great matters came to him (Exodus 18:17-22). That is a story about justice and not about teaching. But the sense in it helps a teacher too. A teacher who tries to do every part of a lesson alone will be worn out and the learners will wait on them. Where an activity allows it, share the work: let learners lead a pair task, hold a card, read a line, pass the sheets. Let a helper hand out materials. A lesson in which many hands have something to do is a lesson in which many people learn.
Diagram 1. An instruction in three parts
Diagram 2. An activity test
| Question | If the answer is no |
|---|---|
| If a learner does this well, have I seen my evidence? | Change it, add a step, or drop it |
| Is it timed, with a stopping minute? | Write the minutes beside it |
| Does it fit the room and the people in it? | Offer a second way |
| Could anyone be shamed by it? | Change it so that no one is |
핵심 요약
- Test every activity against the goal: if a learner does it well, have I seen my evidence?
- A clear instruction has three parts: one step at a time, shown, and checked.
- Check by asking one person what their group will do first; never ask "Does everyone understand?"
- Form groups so that nobody is chosen last, and plan transitions with a signal, a sentence, a time.
- Children, adults and mixed ages need different activities, with more than one way in.
- A game is acceptable only if nobody is shamed by it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Test for an activity | If a learner does it well, have I seen my evidence for the goal? |
| Three parts of an instruction | One step at a time; show it; check it. |
| A transition needs | A signal, a sentence on what is next, what to bring, and a time. |
| Rule for games | Acceptable only if nobody is shamed. |
One sentence to remember An instruction is clear when the learners do what you meant, not when you finished speaking.
This week's action Write one instruction from your plan in three steps, say it aloud, and write the question you will ask to check that it was understood.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of an activity you enjoyed in a class. Did it also help you learn what the lesson was for? How could you tell?
- Write down the last instruction you gave, or received, in a class. How many steps did it hold?
- How would you check that a group understood an instruction without asking "Does everyone understand?"
- What are two ways to form groups that do not leave anyone chosen last?
- In your community, are games and contests used in teaching? What rule would keep them from shaming anyone?