무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

PT707E Teaching Practicum: Designing, Teaching and Assessing a Lesson

Lecture 4-2: Feedback to a Teacher

목차 31
PT707E Teaching Practicum: Designing, Teaching and Assessing a Lesson
제 0 장 · Introduction: A Lesson Is Learned, Not Only Taught
  1. Introduction: A Lesson Is Learned, Not Only Taught
제 1 장 · Week 1: Designing One Lesson
  1. Lecture 1-1: Where Teaching Happens
  2. Lecture 1-2: Starting from the Evidence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Time, Room and a Plan B
  4. Lecture 1-4: Who Is in the Room
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Lesson Plan
제 2 장 · Week 2: Teaching the Lesson
  1. Lecture 2-1: The First and the Last Three Minutes
  2. Lecture 2-2: Activities, Transitions and Clear Instructions
  3. Lecture 2-3: Room for Everyone
  4. Lecture 2-4: Teaching Through a Difficult Moment
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Ten Minutes Taught
제 3 장 · Week 3: Checking What Was Learned
  1. Lecture 3-1: How Do You Know They Learned
  2. Lecture 3-2: Assessment That Respects the Learner
  3. Lecture 3-3: Short Checks, Well Made
  4. Lecture 3-4: After the Lesson: Notes and One Change
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Check for Your Plan
제 4 장 · Week 4: Watching and Feedback
  1. Lecture 4-1: Watching a Lesson
  2. Lecture 4-2: Feedback to a Teacher
  3. Lecture 4-3: Hearing the Learners
  4. Lecture 4-4: Receiving Feedback
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Observation Sheet
제 5 장 · Week 5: Different Learners, Different Places
  1. Lecture 5-1: Children and Young People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Adults and Lay Training
  3. Lecture 5-3: Mixed Ages, Online and Blended
  4. Lecture 5-4: Lessons in Another Language or Culture
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, One Lesson, Two Rooms
제 6 장 · Week 6: Revising and Teaching for the Long Run
  1. Lecture 6-1: Revising the Lesson
  2. Lecture 6-2: Authority, Dignity and Questions
  3. Lecture 6-3: Teaching Together and Sharing Honestly
  4. Lecture 6-4: Teaching Over the Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Three-Month Teaching Plan

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

24분

An observer has a record. Now she must do the harder thing: speak to the teacher. This is the moment when good observation can be wasted, or can do harm.

Most of us have received feedback that taught us nothing, or that stung for a week. Most of us have also given some and wondered afterwards whether we helped. This lecture offers one simple form for feedback on a lesson, three words to hold it together: what I saw, what helped, what I wonder. It then looks at what the form is protecting: the teacher's dignity, her freedom to choose, and the lesson as the thing under discussion.

It also deals with three matters that ordinary advice about feedback leaves out in a church or community setting: the difference between a comment on method and a disagreement about belief; what to do when a comment is really an attack; and what rules a group of teachers might agree so that their feedback does not wound.

이 24분으로 얻는 것

  • Give feedback on a lesson in the form "what I saw / what helped / what I wonder," using records and not verdicts.
  • Rewrite a comment about the person into a comment about the lesson.
  • Explain why one thing at a time is better than a full list, and why a teacher need not take all the advice she hears.
  • Tell a comment on method from a disagreement about belief, and say where each belongs.
  • Draw up a short set of rules for a teachers' group that protect the teacher and the lesson.

but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15

World English Bible

Faithful are the wounds of a friend; although the kisses of an enemy are profuse." — Proverbs 27:6

WEB

Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1

WEB

Ephesians joins truth and love and sets them toward growth. Proverbs says that honest hurt from a friend can be trusted more than flattery from an enemy. Galatians speaks of a different matter, a person caught in a fault, but it shows the spirit in which one person may speak to another: gently, and looking to oneself.

1. Why feedback is hard to give

Giving feedback to a teacher is hard for a reason that is easy to miss. A lesson is not an object like a table. It is something a person made and did, in front of others, often unpaid, and often because she cared. When you comment on the lesson, you touch something the teacher put herself into. Even a kind comment can feel heavy when it arrives.

That is not a reason to say nothing. A teacher who never hears what her lesson looked like from outside may repeat the same difficulty for years. It is a reason to give feedback with care. Care here does not mean softness. It means attention to three things: what exactly you say, what you leave unsaid, and what the teacher can do with it.

Two views about this are both held by thoughtful people, and each deserves its strongest statement.

One view says that feedback should be direct and plain. People who are busy and serious about their work want to know what went wrong, quickly. Wrapping a comment in so many gentle words that its point is lost is not kindness; it is a failure to respect the teacher's ability to hear. In many places and many professions, plain speech is a sign of respect.

The other view says that feedback should come gently and by stages. People who give their time to teach in a church or a community are often volunteers, and they may measure criticism against their sense of . A blunt comment can end a person's willingness to teach, for the sake of a small improvement. In many places and communities, a direct comment from a person of lower standing to one of higher standing is simply not done, and gentleness is a form of respect.

This lecture does not pick one of these. It asks for something both can accept: that feedback be true, about the lesson, and given so that the teacher can use it. How direct or how soft it should be depends on the community, the people and the occasion. A teacher and an observer may agree beforehand how they would like to speak to each other, and that agreement is itself a good use of five minutes.

2. The form: what I saw, what helped, what I wonder

One simple form carries most feedback well. It has three parts.

What I saw. A record: what happened, with the time or the count, without a verdict. "At 10:07 you said, 'Do the thing on the sheet.' For about thirty seconds nobody moved."

What helped. Something specific that worked, and why, so the teacher can keep it. "When you read the question aloud and then waited, six people began to write. That waiting seemed to help."

What I wonder. A real question, not advice dressed as a question. "I wonder how the learners knew which part of the sheet you meant." An honest question is one to which the observer does not already have the answer. "Don't you think you should have said which page?" is advice in disguise, and the teacher will hear it as such.

The three parts do different work. "What I saw" gives the teacher the same picture the observer has. "What helped" tells her what to protect, and it is not flattery: a teacher who has only heard about her faults often changes the things that worked. "What I wonder" leaves the next step with the teacher. The form never tells her what to do.

A full piece of feedback in this form is short. It might run to two minutes.

(An invented example.) An observer's feedback to a teacher after a forty-minute lesson for a mixed-age class.

"Thank you for letting me sit in. Here is what I saw. At the start you said what the lesson was about, in one sentence: that today we would learn why Ruth went with Naomi. Then the reading went about six minutes. At 10:07 you asked them to get into groups and said, 'Do the thing on the sheet.' For about thirty seconds nobody moved, and one learner asked, 'Which thing?' It was five minutes before all three groups had started.

What helped: when a girl asked her own question at 10:22, you stopped the groups and asked everyone. Five people spoke, and I saw the room lean in. It was the best moment I noticed.

What I wonder: I wonder how the sheet and the instruction could be tied together, so that nobody has to ask which thing. And I wonder what you meant the learners to be able to say at the end, because I did not hear it asked."

Notice what this feedback does not contain. It has no adjective about the teacher. It does not tell her what she should have done. It does not mention that other teachers do better. It has one main difficulty (the instruction) and one smaller one (the closing), and it keeps them as questions.

3. About the lesson, not the person

The most important rule is the simplest: the subject is the lesson. Compare these pairs.

About the person About the lesson
You are not clear. The instruction at 10:07 did not say which task.
You always run out of time. Today the closing did not happen, because the group work ran to 10:30.
You talk too much. You spoke without a break from 10:02 to 10:14.
You don't care about the quiet ones. Three learners did not speak, and the question went to the same two people each time.
You're not a natural. The opening took seven minutes before the aim was said.

The left column is easy to write and hard to answer. A person who is told "you are not clear" has no place to put the comment except on herself. The right column names an event. An event can be looked at and changed. A person is much harder to change than an event, and she is much more likely to leave.

A further point. Comments about the person tend to repeat the words "always" and "never." Almost nobody always does anything. These words are a sign that the observer has stopped describing one lesson and started describing a character.

4. One thing at a time

A teacher can usually do something about one thing, or two, before the next lesson. She cannot do something about nine. An observer who has a long list should choose.

How to choose? Ask which one thing, if it changed, would do the most for the learners. Often it is the thing that came earliest in the lesson and spoiled what followed. In the example above, the unclear instruction spoiled five minutes and probably cost the closing. The unclear instruction is the one to speak about first. The other items stay on the observer's sheet. If the teacher asks, "Was there anything else?" the observer may answer. Otherwise, they wait for another day.

The "one thing at a time" rule also helps the observer. It reminds her that she is not there to prove that she saw everything. The aim is a better lesson next week, not a complete report.

5. A teacher need not take all the advice

A teacher who asks for observation does not promise to follow every suggestion. She owes the observer a careful hearing and her thanks. She does not owe obedience.

There are good reasons for this. The observer saw one lesson, on one day. She does not know the history of the class or what the teacher has already tried. She may be right about what she saw and wrong about what it means. The teacher may have reasons, good ones, for doing what the observer found puzzling. And the teacher is the one who will stand in front of the group next week; the change has to be one she can make.

The observer, for her part, should give feedback as an offer, not an instruction. "One thing you might try" is better than "You need to." And she should not check up afterwards to see whether the advice was taken.

6. Asking the teacher first

A useful order for a conversation is this. First, the observer asks, "How did it feel to you?" or "What did you notice?" and listens. Many teachers already know what the main difficulty was. When the teacher names it first, the observer need only say, "Yes, I saw that too," and the conversation moves directly to what might be done. When the teacher does not see it, the observer's record may be the first time she has seen it, and it is better received because she has had a chance to speak.

Second, the observer says what she saw, what helped, what she wonders. Third, the two of them look at one thing and decide whether anything will change.

This order is a suggestion, not a law. In some communities the teacher will not feel free to speak first, or the observer will be expected to start. Adjust it. The principle is that the teacher is a partner in the conversation, not its subject.

7. A comment on method is not a quarrel about belief

A church or community teacher may be observed by someone who believes something different from what the lesson taught. The observer may be a colleague of another tradition, or may hold a different view on a matter the lesson touched. It is easy for a disagreement of that kind to slip into feedback dressed as a comment on method.

"I wonder whether the lesson was too one-sided" may be a fair comment on method, or it may be a statement of disagreement about the doctrine. The difference matters, because the right place for each is different.

A comment on method concerns what the lesson did: the clarity of the aim, the time, the instructions, who took part. It can be made by anyone who watched. A disagreement about belief concerns what the lesson said. It belongs in a conversation of its own, with the person in the community who is responsible for what is taught. It should not be hidden inside the teacher's feedback, where she cannot answer it as a doctrinal matter and may think her teaching skill is under question.

An observer who notices that she disagrees with the content should say so to herself, and then ask: Is there something about the method that I would say whether or not I agreed? If so, say that. If not, keep the disagreement out of the feedback, and raise it, if it needs raising, in the proper place.

8. When a comment is an attack

A comment that is not about the lesson, or is not made in good faith, is not feedback. It can be spotted by some signs: it is about the teacher's age, voice, accent, appearance, background or standing; it is a comparison with another teacher; it is public and was not invited; it is repeated again and again; it comes with a threat or an attempt to push the teacher out. A teacher who receives this does not have to accept it as "feedback" and need not try to improve on it. Lecture 4-4 says what she can do. The observer or the group, for their part, should know that anyone in the group who does this is acting wrongly, and that the responsible person must be told.

9. Rules for a teachers' group

Feedback is easier where a group has agreed on its rules before anyone is in the chair. Here is a short set a group might adopt, and amend, for itself.

  1. Only by invitation. A teacher is observed or discussed only if she has agreed.
  2. The lesson is the subject. We speak about what happened, not about the person, her faith or her worth.
  3. Record first. We say what we saw before we say what we think.
  4. One thing, and a question. Each speaker offers one main point, as a question or an offer.
  5. The teacher speaks first and last. She says how it felt before we speak and decides at the end what, if anything, she will try.
  6. No comparing. We do not say that one teacher does it better than another.
  7. What is said here stays here. Nothing is repeated outside the group without the teacher's agreement.
  8. We may pass. Anyone may decline to give or to receive feedback on any day.
  9. If something serious comes up, that is, harm to a learner or someone in danger, we stop and take it to the person named in the community's rules.
  10. Our own belief is not on trial. A disagreement about what is taught goes to the person responsible for it, and not into this feedback.

A group that keeps rules of this kind is not being timid. It is making a place where a teacher can take a risk, because she knows what will and will not happen to her.

10. A short note on preaching

Feedback on a sermon follows many of the same principles, but a sermon has features of its own: the text, the congregation, the form and the moment in the service. Those are covered in Preaching Practicum (PT726E). This lecture concerns the lesson.


Diagram 1. Saw, helped, wonder

Feedback in Three Parts About the lesson, one thing at a time, an offer and not an order WHAT I SAW A record, with the time or the count "At 10:07 nobody moved for thirty seconds." The same picture the observer has WHAT HELPED Something specific that worked, and why "When you waited after the question, six began to write." So she knows what to keep WHAT I WONDER A real question, not advice in disguise "I wonder how the sheet and the instruction could meet." The next step stays with the teacher The order of the conversation 1. Ask the teacher how it felt. Listen. 2. Say what I saw, what helped, what I wonder. 3. Look at one thing together. 4. The teacher decides what, if anything, to try. Adjust to your community's way of speaking. Not feedback Comments on the person: age, voice, accent, worth, faith "Always" and "never" Comparison with another teacher A disagreement of belief dressed as method

Diagram 2. The same comment, three ways

The comment A verdict on the person Saw / helped / wonder
The closing did not happen "You never finish properly." "The group work ran to 10:30 and the lesson ended at 10:40 without a closing. I wonder what you would have wanted them to say at the end."
The room went quiet "You lost them." "At 7:22 there were nine seconds of silence after your question. I wonder whether it was thinking time or whether the question was unclear."
A good moment "That was great." "When you stopped the groups for her question, five people spoke. I saw the room lean in."

핵심 요약

  • Feedback on a lesson can follow three parts: what I saw (a record), what helped (what to keep), what I wonder (an honest question).
  • The subject is the lesson, not the person. "Always" and "never" are signs that a comment has become about character.
  • One main point at a time, offered, not imposed. A teacher owes a careful hearing, not obedience.
  • A comment on method differs from a disagreement about belief; the second belongs with whoever is responsible for what is taught.
  • Comments about age, voice, accent, worth or faith are not feedback, however they are phrased.
  • A teachers' group may agree rules: by invitation, the lesson as subject, record first, no comparing, confidence kept.
Front Back
The three parts What I saw (a record); what helped (what to keep); what I wonder (an honest question).
About the lesson Name an event the teacher can look at and change, not a trait of the person.
Method or belief A comment on method concerns what the lesson did; a disagreement about belief concerns what it said, and goes to the person responsible for teaching.
A teacher's freedom She owes a careful hearing and thanks, not obedience to every suggestion.

One sentence to remember Good feedback gives the teacher a true picture of one lesson and leaves the choice with her.

This week's action Take one piece of feedback you have given or received and rewrite it as saw, helped, wonder, with nothing about the person.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Think of feedback you once received that helped, and feedback that hurt without helping. What was different about how it was given?
  • Rewrite one comment about a person ("You are too fast") as a comment about a lesson. What did you have to know to do it?
  • In your community, would a direct comment be heard as respect or as rudeness? How might a teacher and an observer agree how to speak to each other?
  • Where is the line between a comment on method and a disagreement about belief? Give one example of each.
  • Choose three of the ten rules for a teachers' group. What would each protect?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.