Lecture 6-4: Teaching Over the Years
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Where Teaching Happens
- Lecture 1-2: Starting from the Evidence
- Lecture 1-3: Time, Room and a Plan B
- Lecture 1-4: Who Is in the Room
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Lesson Plan
- Lecture 2-1: The First and the Last Three Minutes
- Lecture 2-2: Activities, Transitions and Clear Instructions
- Lecture 2-3: Room for Everyone
- Lecture 2-4: Teaching Through a Difficult Moment
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Ten Minutes Taught
- Lecture 3-1: How Do You Know They Learned
- Lecture 3-2: Assessment That Respects the Learner
- Lecture 3-3: Short Checks, Well Made
- Lecture 3-4: After the Lesson: Notes and One Change
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Check for Your Plan
- Lecture 4-1: Watching a Lesson
- Lecture 4-2: Feedback to a Teacher
- Lecture 4-3: Hearing the Learners
- Lecture 4-4: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Observation Sheet
- Lecture 5-1: Children and Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Adults and Lay Training
- Lecture 5-3: Mixed Ages, Online and Blended
- Lecture 5-4: Lessons in Another Language or Culture
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, One Lesson, Two Rooms
So far the course has looked at one lesson, and then at the cycle around it. A teaching life is longer than one lesson. Some people teach for a term. Some teach for forty years. The question for this lecture is how a person keeps teaching well over many years without wearing out, and without turning into someone who repeats the same lesson long after it has stopped serving.
The answer has four parts. A teacher belongs to a group that goes on from year to year. A teacher looks back once a year at what the lesson records show. A teacher rests, and plans the rest. And a teacher learns from others, including those of other traditions. At the end we turn to the people who do not teach, but who keep teaching going.
This is the second half of the principle for the week. A teacher grows by repeating the cycle. Over the years the cycle is the same, but it is walked on three clocks: the lesson, the month and the year.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Say what a teachers' group does over the years, and how to begin one with very few people.
- Use a yearly look back to read lesson records as a whole, and name what to ask.
- Explain why rest and a term off belong to a long teaching life, and plan one.
- Name ways to learn from other traditions without ranking them, and name roles for those who do not teach.
Remember your leaders, men who spoke to you the word of God, and considering the results of their conduct, imitate their faith." — Hebrews 13:7
World English Bible
He said to them, “You come apart into a deserted place, and rest awhile.” For there were many coming and going, and they had no leisure so much as to eat." — Mark 6:31
WEB
The things which you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit the same to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also." — 2 Timothy 2:2
WEB
Hebrews asks readers to remember those who spoke the word to them and to imitate their faith. In Mark, Jesus invites his followers to rest, at a time when they have been overrun by people coming and going. Second Timothy gives a chain: Paul's words go to Timothy, then to faithful people, then to others. Each passage is about people and not about lesson plans, and we use them as pictures of a teaching life lived in a line of people.
1. A teacher in a line
Look at the chain in 2 Timothy 2:2. There are four steps in the sentence: what Timothy heard from Paul, among many witnesses; what he passes to faithful people; what they can do, which is to teach others; and the "others" themselves. A teacher is in the middle of a line. Someone taught you, and you teach someone, who will teach another.
Hebrews 13:7 asks readers to remember their leaders, "considering the results of their conduct," and to imitate their faith. Notice what is to be imitated: the faith, and not a technique. A teacher who remembers the teachers who helped her will not copy all of their ways, but she may be grateful, and she may learn from the way they lived and taught. Some communities have a custom of remembering teachers by name on certain days. Others do not. Either way, a practical step is simple: write a note of thanks to one person who taught you. It is a small thing, and it keeps the line alive.
This picture matters for the long run for one reason. A teacher who sees herself as the end of the line will want to hold on to everything. A teacher who sees herself in the middle will want to hand something on. That means writing records so another can read them, welcoming a new teacher beside her, and, in time, stepping aside.
2. The teachers' group over the years
Lecture 6-3 set out the rules of a teachers' group. Over the years, such a group changes.
In its first year, the group learns its rules and begins to bring lesson records. Feedback feels strange, and people are careful. In its second and third years, the group becomes a place where a teacher can say, "This did not work," and nobody is shocked. After that, the group may do more: welcome new teachers, keep a shelf of plans with source notes (lecture 6-3), ask an older teacher to talk about what she has learned, and hold the yearly look back together.
If you do not have a group, you may begin with very little.
- Two people are enough. Meet for thirty minutes once a month. Each brings one lesson record.
- Write letters or messages if you cannot meet, keeping learners' names out of them.
- Ask someone who taught longer than you to listen once a term. Do not ask for approval. Ask for what they see.
- Join online a group of people who teach in your kind of place, with the same rules of privacy.
A group of two that meets for a year will teach you more than a large plan that never starts.
3. The yearly look back
Once a year, set aside an evening, or a half-day if you can, to read your lesson records as a whole. A single note shows one lesson. A year of notes shows a pattern, which no single note can show. The look back is not curriculum planning. Planning a curriculum over a term or a year is the work of Church Curriculum Design (PT708E). The look back is simpler: you read your own records and ask what they say.
Here are seven questions.
| Question | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| What can my learners do now that they could not do a year ago? | It turns the year into evidence, and not a feeling |
| Which lessons needed the same change twice? | A change that fails twice may be the wrong change, or the trouble may lie elsewhere |
| Which lessons went well without changing? | Keep them; they may help a newer teacher |
| Which lessons should I retire? | See lecture 6-1 |
| What one skill do I want to learn this year? | One, and not ten |
| What did I not do this year? | For example, no observer came; no group met |
| Who helped me, and have I thanked them? | It keeps the line alive |
(An invented example.) A teacher who has led a youth group for two years reads her twelve records. She sees that the same line appears in five of them: "closing rushed." She had changed the closing each time. She stops and asks why. Reading the notes together, she sees that the closings were rushed because the middle activity always ran long. The trouble was not the closing. The plans had one part too many. She decides that every lesson this year will have three parts, not four, and she will write that on the top of each plan. A single note would not have shown her this.
Do not use the look back as an examination of yourself. It is a reading of records. If you are tempted to ask, "Am I a good teacher?", change the question to, "What did the year show about my lessons?" You can share it with your group or keep it to yourself.
4. Rest, and a term off
In Mark 6:31 Jesus says to his followers, "You come apart into a deserted place, and rest awhile," because many were coming and going and they had no leisure even to eat. Notice the situation. They had just returned from work, and the crowds had not stopped. Jesus did not say that work did not matter. He said that those who work need to stop.
A teaching life without rest goes sour. Tired teachers rush, repeat and stop listening, and their records show it. Rest is not desertion, and it is not a sign of weak commitment. It is part of how a long life of teaching is kept going.
Plan it. Here is how a term off may be arranged.
- Choose it in advance. A term off decided only when you are worn out comes too late.
- Tell the person responsible early, and agree who will teach in your place.
- Hand over your lesson records and plans, with notes. Do not hand over anything a learner told you in confidence. Follow your community's written rules about what is passed on about learners.
- Keep light contact, if you wish: a note to the group, a visit. Do not return to full work at once.
- Come back by choice. Return when you are ready, and not because you were not replaced.
Some communities ask teachers to rotate. Others honour teachers who serve for life. Neither way is ranked here. In both, rest is possible: in a rotating community, it is built in; in a lifelong one, it must be planned. If your tiredness is heavy and does not lift with rest, speak to a trusted pastor, and to a doctor. Teacher burnout, and what causes it, is treated in The Art of Teaching (LM402E, lecture 7-1).
5. Learning from other traditions
Christians teach in many ways. In some places the teacher explains and learners listen. In some, learners learn set questions and answers. In some, a group studies by asking questions together. In some, children and adults learn the same thing at the same time. Each has a use and a risk, as lecture 1-1 said.
A teacher can learn from a tradition that is not her own. Here are some ways.
- Visit as a guest, with the permission of the person who leads the class and, for any class of children, of the person responsible and under the local rules. Sit at the back and watch what is done.
- Read a plan or a guide written by someone from another community.
- Ask a teacher from another community how she begins, how she closes, how she checks.
- Take one small thing. A way of opening, a kind of question, a way of ending. Not a whole system.
Three cautions keep this useful.
First, do not go to judge. If you go to see what is wrong, you will see only that. Go to see how learners are served.
Second, separate method from content. A way of opening a class can be borrowed freely. If a lesson's content differs from what your community teaches, that is a matter for the person responsible, not for you to adopt alone.
Third, do not shop. A tradition is not a shelf of techniques. If you borrow something, borrow it with respect for the whole from which it came.
6. Roles for those who do not teach
Many people do not teach, and never will. Teaching still needs them. A class has more going on than a teacher's voice.
| Role | What it does for learning |
|---|---|
| Welcome | A person at the door who greets by name, so that learners arrive ready to learn |
| Room and set-up | Chairs, light, heat, a board that works, a screen that is ready |
| Materials | Printing, copies and the like, within the terms of the owner and local law |
| Assistant | A second adult in the room, who helps groups and keeps the room safe |
| Timekeeper | Watches the clock so the closing is protected |
| Observer | Watches with a sheet, as in lecture 4-1, and gives "what I saw, what helped, what I wonder" |
| Record-keeper | Helps with the lesson record and, where the community wishes, a shelf of plans |
| Prayer | Prays for the class and its teachers, in the way the community prays |
| Host online | Opens the session, manages the screen, and helps with access |
| Follow-up | Sends a short note to learners who missed a session |
None of these is a smaller role. A lesson begins at the door, and a teacher who has a good welcome, a ready room and someone keeping time has more strength to teach. If you do not teach and you wish to help, ask the person responsible what is needed, and offer one thing for a term.
Diagram 1. Three clocks of a teaching life
Diagram 2. The yearly look back
| Question | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| What can my learners do now that they could not do a year ago? | Evidence, not feeling |
| Which lessons needed the same change twice? | The change may be wrong, or the trouble elsewhere |
| Which went well without change? | Keep them; share them |
| Which should I retire? | A lesson is a tool, not a monument |
| What one skill do I want to learn? | One, not ten |
| What did I not do? | An observer; a group meeting |
| Who helped me? | Thank them |
핵심 요약
- A teacher stands in a line: someone taught her, and she teaches someone. Records, welcome and stepping aside keep the line going.
- A teachers' group grows over years. If you have none, begin with two people meeting for thirty minutes each month.
- A yearly look back reads lesson records as a whole. It asks what learners can now do, which lessons needed the same change twice, and what to retire.
- Rest and a term off belong to a long teaching life. Plan them early, tell the person responsible, and hand over your notes.
- Learn from other traditions as a guest, take one small thing, separate method from content, and do not go to judge.
- People who do not teach keep teaching going: welcome, room, materials, assistant, timekeeper, observer, records, prayer, online host.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The three clocks | Each lesson (note and one change); each month (the group); each year (the look back and rest). |
| The yearly look back asks | What learners can now do; which lessons needed the same change twice; what to keep, retire and learn; what was not done. |
| Planning a term off | Choose it early, tell the person responsible, hand over records and notes, keep light contact, return by choice. |
| Learning from another tradition | Go as a guest; take one small thing; keep method separate from content; do not go to judge. |
One sentence to remember A long teaching life is kept going by a group, a yearly look back, planned rest and the people who help without teaching.
This week's action Name one person with whom you could start a two-person teachers' group, and write the date of your first thirty-minute meeting.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In 2 Timothy 2:2 there are four steps in the chain. Where are you in it? Who taught you, and whom might you teach?
- What is the smallest teachers' group you could start, and what would it need on its first day?
- If you read twelve of your own lesson records, what pattern do you expect to find, and what would you do about it?
- Why do teachers find it hard to rest? What would you need in order to take a term off?
- What one small thing could you learn from a tradition other than your own, and what would you check before using it?