Lecture 2-3: Money, Work and Roles
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Marriage in Scripture
- Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Marriage
- Lecture 1-3: Many Kinds of Households
- Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Marriage
- Lecture 2-1: The Shape of Preparation Conversations
- Lecture 2-2: Expectations, Family Background and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Money, Work and Roles
- Lecture 2-4: Intimacy and Sexuality, Spoken with Restraint
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Page of Preparation Questions
- Lecture 3-1: Where Couples Collide
- Lecture 3-2: The Basics of a Conflict Conversation
- Lecture 3-3: In-Laws, Wider Families and Cultures
- Lecture 3-4: Roles and Authority
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The First Conversation in a Conflict
- Lecture 4-1: What Forgiveness Is and Is Not
- Lecture 4-2: When Trust Is Broken: After Unfaithfulness
- Lecture 4-3: Separation and Repeating Conflict
- Lecture 4-4: Knowing When and How to Refer
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases, Three Responses
- Lecture 5-1: Recognising Abuse: Safety Comes First
- Lecture 5-2: Responding When Someone Tells You
- Lecture 5-3: Divorce and Remarriage: The Positions
- Lecture 5-4: Beside Those Who Part
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Referral Map and a First Reply
- Lecture 6-1: Children, Blended Families and Single Parents
- Lecture 6-2: Distance, Migration, Childlessness, Singleness and Widowhood
- Lecture 6-3: The Carer's Own Household and Boundaries
- Lecture 6-4: A Church That Supports Households Over Years
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Household Care Policy
Money is one of the places where couples most often collide, and it is also one of the places where couples are least likely to speak before the wedding. People feel shy about money. They may be ashamed of a debt, proud of a salary, afraid of being thought greedy, or unwilling to seem not to trust the other. So the subject waits until the first bill arrives. By then it has become a quarrel about trust instead of a conversation about arrangements.
This lecture helps a carer open three connected subjects before the wedding: money and debt, work and care in the home, and how decisions will be made. It asks the carer to help the couple speak plainly, and then to step back. It offers no formula and no model household. It does mark one line clearly: openness about money is a gift between two equals, and a person who is kept from knowing about or using shared money is a sign that the carer must not ignore.
Questions about household roles and authority are contested among Christians, and lecture 3-4 sets out the main positions fairly. This lecture asks only the preparation questions: what does each of you expect, and have you said so?
This course is not marriage therapy and not legal advice, and it is not financial advice. A carer does not tell a couple how to invest, how much to save, which debt to pay first or what a contract means. Those are matters for a qualified adviser or a lawyer; the rules about property, inheritance, debt and tax differ by country and sometimes by region: check locally.
이 26분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why openness about money, debt and earning is a fitting part of preparation, and how to introduce it kindly.
- Ask a couple about the division of work and care in their household without prescribing a pattern.
- Describe the difference between agreed arrangements and control, and name the signs of financial control.
- Explain what a carer does and does not say about household decisions, and why the carer sends legal and financial questions to qualified people.
- Describe how money and work questions look in households of different shapes and sizes.
For which of you, desiring to build a tower, doesn’t first sit down and count the cost, to see if he has enough to complete it?" — Luke 14:28
World English Bible
Owe no one anything, except to love one another; for he who loves his neighbor has fulfilled the law." — Romans 13:8
WEB
Know well the state of your flocks, and pay attention to your herds:" — Proverbs 27:23
WEB
each of you not just looking to his own things, but each of you also to the things of others." — Philippians 2:4
WEB
In Luke the Lord speaks of a builder who sits down and counts the cost before beginning a tower. It is a picture of looking ahead honestly, and a couple who talk about money before they marry are doing something like it. Romans 13:8 speaks of owing nothing except love. It does not forbid every loan, and no one should use it as a verdict on a person who is in debt. It names a direction: love is the debt we are never done paying. The proverb tells the owner of flocks to know their state and pay attention, an old way of saying that a household which knows its own condition is better placed than one which does not. And Philippians 2:4 asks each person to look beyond their own interests to the interests of others, which is a fair summary of what two people do when they decide about money together. None of these verses is a budget. None promises wealth to the careful or condemns the poor.
1. Why money is hard to talk about
Before a carer opens the subject, it helps to know why it is hard.
- Shame. A person may owe money, may earn little, may have been unemployed, or may have helped a relative whose need was never repaid. They may fear that the other will think less of them.
- Pride. A person may earn more, or own more, and not wish the other to feel small. Or may fear being valued for it.
- Family duty. In many places a person is expected to help parents, brothers and sisters, or a wider family, and this may be a duty that the future spouse has never been told about. In other places the expectation runs the other way, and it is the older generation that is expected to help the young couple.
- Habit. Some households never discussed money in front of children. Others spoke of nothing else. A person brings the silence or the worry into the marriage.
- Difference of means. Many couples come from different backgrounds, and the difference may be large. One may have grown up never short, the other never certain.
- Culture and faith. Traditions differ on lending with interest, on giving to the church, on gifts at the wedding, on who holds the household's money, and on what is owed to parents. This course takes no side among them. It asks that the two people understand each other's expectations.
A carer who understands these reasons does not scold. "It is hard to speak of this, and almost everyone finds it so. That is why I would like us to try before the wedding, while no bill has arrived." A little warmth takes the sting out.
2. What openness means
To say that a couple should be open about money does not mean that they must reveal every figure at once, or that every item must be shared. It means this:
- Nothing that matters to the marriage is hidden. A debt that the household will have to pay, a regular obligation to support others, a loan guaranteed for a friend, a dependent child or relative, a gambling loss, a lawsuit, a plan to send money abroad: these affect the other person's life, and the other person has a right to know before they marry.
- Each can ask, and each can answer. "How much do you owe?" and "Why?" are fair questions between two people about to share a life. So is "What would you like us to do about it?"
- Disclosure is kindly received. If a person tells the truth about a debt and is mocked, they will not tell the truth again. The carer sets the tone: "Thank you for telling us. How can the two of you plan for this together?"
- Privacy is not the same as secrecy. A person may keep a small private account, or a private gift, and neither is a betrayal if both know the habit exists and have agreed to it. What matters is whether the other person would be harmed or deceived by the silence.
A carer may use a few plain questions.
- What do you each earn or expect to earn, roughly, and how steady is it?
- Is there any debt, a loan, a guarantee, or an obligation to others, that the other should know about?
- Whom do you support now, or expect to, and for how long?
- What does each of you think money is for? What would you spend on happily, and what would worry you?
- Who will pay for what, and who will know what is paid?
- What will you give to the church or to charity, and how will you decide?
- How will you make large decisions together: a house, a loan, a move?
The carer does not need to hear the answers in detail. The couple must hear them. A good result is often that the couple says, "We have to go home and talk about this."
(an invented example) In a village where most people farm, a young man, Kofi, tells his fiancée, Abla, in front of the who is preparing them, that he has promised to pay his younger brother's school fees for three more years. She had not known. She is quiet. The elder does not take sides. He asks Abla, "What do you need to know about this?" and Kofi, "What would you like Abla to understand?" They speak. Abla says that she does not mind the fees but is hurt that she heard last. Kofi apologises. The elder says to both, "You have found, before the wedding, one of the ways you will need to speak to each other for the rest of your life."
3. Work and care in the home
Households need paid work, and they also need work that is not paid: cooking, cleaning, fetching water, mending, minding children, caring for the sick and old, keeping the accounts, tending the garden, keeping the family's network of obligations. In many homes unpaid work is invisible. The person who does it is thanked rarely, and the person who does not do it may not know it exists.
A carer who wants to help can ask about both kinds of work.
- Who earns, and how? Will both of you do paid work? What if one loses work, or falls ill, or wishes to change?
- Who does what in the home? What did you see done at home, and what do you hope to do the same or differently?
- Who looks after children, if you have them? Who looks after an older parent?
- How will you decide, if you do not agree, who gives up work, hours or a chance to study, in order to care for others?
- How will you notice if one of you is carrying too much?
The lecture takes no position on which pattern is right. In some places and traditions the husband is expected to earn and the wife to keep the home. In others both are expected to earn. In others the wife earns and the husband cares for children and house. Households built in migration may find that work arrangements change completely from one country to the next. A carer who treats one of these as the only proper one will mislead couples whose life is otherwise. The carer's task is to help the two people say what they expect and to notice where they differ. Roles that are not spoken are likely to be assumed, and assumed roles are often assumed unfairly.
Two notes keep this fair.
No arrangement is more holy than another. A woman who works for pay is not neglecting her family, a man who cares for children is not shirking his duty, and a woman who keeps the home is not less, because of the pattern. What the carer watches for is whether both persons agree, understand their load, and have dignity in their part.
Equality in dignity is not sameness in tasks. Two people may have quite different tasks and each still be treated as a person of equal worth. The question is whether each can say "This is too much" and be heard.
(an invented example) In a large urban congregation, a couple, Mei and Lucas, are preparing to marry. Mei is a nurse who works nights and earns more than Lucas, who is a part-time teacher. Lucas's father has told him privately that a man should be the main earner, and Mei's mother has told her not to let him feel less. The preparation couple, Henrik and Sofia, ask each person, "What do you want your home to be like, and what are you afraid people will think?" Mei says she is afraid Lucas will resent her wage. Lucas says he is afraid of being thought weak. They decide to talk about it together, and, in Lucas's words, "to stop letting our fathers and mothers keep score."
4. How decisions will be made
Every household makes decisions: large ones, such as where to live, whether to borrow, whether to have another child, and small ones that come every day. There is more than one way to decide.
- Sometimes one person decides after listening.
- Sometimes each decides in their own area.
- Sometimes the two decide together on large matters and divide the small ones.
- Sometimes elders or parents are asked.
- Sometimes a church leader is asked.
Traditions differ about who holds the final word in a marriage, and lecture 3-4 will set out the main positions in their strongest form. In preparation, the carer asks only a modest set of questions.
- How do you imagine we will decide the big things? What if we disagree?
- Who should be asked, besides the two of you, when you are stuck? Parents? An elder? A friend? A professional?
- What will each of you do if you feel your view is not being heard?
- What is not open for decision by one person alone? (For example: a large debt, moving abroad, ending a job.)
The carer is not trying to give the couple the right answer. The carer is helping them to notice whether they have the same picture. Above all the carer hopes the couple will agree that neither person's will is to be imposed on the other by force, fear or control, whatever pattern they choose. That line holds for every tradition. Where it is crossed, the matter is no longer about roles. It is about safety.
5. Agreed arrangements and financial control
The most important distinction in this lecture is between an arrangement and control.
An arrangement is a way of handling money and work that both persons understand, agreed freely, and can raise again. In some marriages one person handles most of the accounts because they like it, or are better at it; the other knows what is there and can ask. In some marriages the money is joint, in others each keeps some apart. All of these can be good.
Financial control is different. It is a way in which one person limits the other's knowledge of or access to money so that the second cannot act freely. Signs a carer may notice, in preparation or in later care, include:
- one person will not say what they earn or what is in any account;
- one person controls all the money and gives the other a small amount only after being asked and explaining;
- one person insists on the other's accounts or documents being in their name or in their keeping;
- one person must justify every purchase;
- one person is not allowed to work, or to keep what they earn, or is made to hand over all their wages;
- a person fears the other's reaction when money is mentioned.
None of these proves that someone is doing harm. People's habits differ, and some of these are customs in some places. But when one person seems afraid to ask, or when the arrangement allows no question, or when a person says in private that they cannot leave or act without permission, a carer should slow down. This may be part of a pattern of control, and where there is control or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes before the wedding and before the reputation of any family or church. The carer believes the person, does not report to the other partner, does not arrange a joint meeting about it, and helps the person to reach those who know about such situations. Research in advance which specialist services exist in your region, and keep a list at hand; the safe church course and Week 5 of this course say more.
6. What the carer does not say
- "A man should hold the purse" or "A woman should hold the purse." The lecture takes no side, and neither does the carer.
- "God will provide, so you need not plan." Faith and planning are not opposites. Luke 14:28 uses the picture of counting the cost.
- "Debt is a sin." Traditions differ on lending and borrowing, and a person in debt is not thereby a sinner. The carer helps the couple to plan.
- "You must tithe this much." Giving is a matter for each church's teaching and for the couple's conscience. The carer may explain what their church teaches. They do not pressure.
- Any advice about investments, contracts, wills, property or tax. These go to a qualified adviser or lawyer: check locally.
7. In other shapes of household
Not every couple preparing for marriage fits the picture of two young people starting out.
- Older couples, perhaps widowed or divorced, may have property, pensions, children and obligations from earlier years. Money and inheritance are often the most delicate subject. The carer encourages them to talk openly and to see a lawyer about property and wills.
- Couples with children already will plan around what children cost and who is responsible.
- Couples in cross-border or migrant households may send money to families in other countries, and expectations about it may be strong.
- Couples who live in an extended household with parents or siblings will share some money and decisions beyond the two of them.
- Couples with little money at all may feel that talk of budgets does not apply to them. The conversation is the same: what do you owe, what do you owe each other, how will you decide?
(an invented example) In a small parish in a poor district, a couple in their sixties, Valdemar and Ines, are to marry. Each has adult children and a small house. The parish priest asks them what they want to happen to their homes if one of them dies, and they realise they have not spoken of it. He does not tell them what to do. He says, "This is a question for a lawyer, and I would like you to see one before the wedding, not after." They find a legal adviser through the parish; the priest does not pay or advise.
Diagram 1. Three conversations before the wedding
Diagram 2. Agreement or control?
핵심 요약
- Money is hard to speak of because of shame, pride, family duty, habit and culture; a warm word makes it easier.
- Openness means nothing that matters to the marriage is hidden, each can ask and answer, and disclosure is received kindly.
- Paid and unpaid work both count; the carer asks who does what and takes no side among patterns of work.
- Whatever pattern is chosen, no will is to be imposed on another by force, fear or control.
- An agreed arrangement can be raised again; control cannot, and the person harmed comes first.
- Legal and financial advice goes to qualified people; the carer does not give it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Openness about money | Nothing that matters to the marriage is hidden; each can ask and answer; disclosure is kindly received. |
| Work and care | Both paid and unpaid work; the carer asks who does what and does not prescribe a pattern. |
| Arrangement or control | An arrangement is agreed and can be raised again; control narrows one person's freedom and cannot be questioned. |
| Limit of the carer | No financial, legal or tax advice; send property, wills, debt and status to qualified people. |
One sentence to remember Whatever pattern a couple chooses, it must be one that both understand, both chose, and both can raise again.
This week's action Make a short list of the kinds of qualified adviser in your area (for example, someone who advises on debt, a lawyer for property) to whom a couple might be sent, and find out how to reach them before you need to.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Why do couples often delay talking about money until the first bill arrives? What could your church do to make the conversation easier to start?
- In your community, what pattern of work and care in the home is expected? Which other patterns exist in your congregation? How does the church treat them?
- What is the difference between an arrangement and control? How could a carer tell the difference without accusing anyone?
- Which of the things the carer does not say do you most often hear in your community? What does each do to a couple?
- When a couple needs advice on property, wills, debt or tax, whom could your church send them to? Who would know?