Lecture 1-2: One Passage, One Thrust
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Map of the New Testament
- Lecture 1-2: One Passage, One Thrust
- Lecture 1-3: Letting the Passage Set the Form
- Lecture 1-4: How Preaching Traditions Differ
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Naming the Kind of Writing
- Lecture 2-1: What Kind of Writing a Gospel Is
- Lecture 2-2: Telling a Gospel Scene
- Lecture 2-3: Miracles and the Hearer Who Is Not Healed
- Lecture 2-4: Preaching a Parable
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Scene or a Parable
- Lecture 3-1: Signs and Discourses in John
- Lecture 3-2: Preaching the Passion
- Lecture 3-3: The Resurrection Accounts
- Lecture 3-4: Preaching in the Church's Year and the Short Homily
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Sign or a Resurrection Scene
- Lecture 4-1: Between Description and Rule
- Lecture 4-2: The Speeches in Acts
- Lecture 4-3: The Community and the Hard Passages
- Lecture 4-4: Preaching Acts as a Series
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, One Scene from Acts
- Lecture 5-1: A Letter Is a Letter
- Lecture 5-2: Following an Argument
- Lecture 5-3: Doctrinal Passages and the Traditions
- Lecture 5-4: Household Codes, Authority and Hard Commands
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Mapping One Letter Passage
Before a preacher can decide what a sermon should do, the preacher has to decide what the sermon is on. That sounds obvious, but it is where many sermons go wrong. A preacher takes too little (a single verse, pulled out of its setting) or too much (a whole chapter, so that nothing is said well). The passage is the unit, and choosing the unit is the first act of service to the text.
This lecture does two things. First, it looks at how to choose a unit in each kind of New Testament writing: a scene, a paragraph, an argument. Second, it looks at the thrust of a passage, which means the one main thing the passage does or says to its hearers. Then it sets three common sermon forms side by side (expository, topical and narrative), with the honest strengths and costs of each, using one passage and an invented outline for each form.
이 18분으로 얻는 것
- Choose a sensible unit of text for a sermon, depending on the kind of writing.
- State the thrust of a short passage in one sentence.
- Describe the expository, topical and narrative forms, with one strength and one cost of each.
- Recognise when a sermon has more than one thrust and is pulling in two directions.
Again, the Kingdom of Heaven is like a treasure hidden in the field, which a man found, and hid. In his joy, he goes and sells all that he has, and buys that field." — Matthew 13:44
World English Bible
Again, the Kingdom of Heaven is like a man who is a merchant seeking fine pearls," — Matthew 13:45
WEB
who having found one pearl of great price, he went and sold all that he had, and bought it." — Matthew 13:46
WEB
Two short stories, told one after the other. A parable is a short story, usually from ordinary life, that Jesus tells to make people think. These two are small enough to read aloud in half a minute, which makes them useful for seeing how a unit is chosen.
1. Choosing the unit
A passage is a piece of text that holds together. In the New Testament it usually takes one of three shapes.
A scene. In a Gospel or in Acts, the natural unit is often a scene: a place, some people, something that happens and a result. A scene begins when the setting changes and ends when it changes again. If a sermon takes half a scene, it may leave out exactly the moment that gave the scene its meaning.
A paragraph or a short unit. A parable, a short saying of Jesus, a short section of teaching: these are often a few verses long. A parable should be heard whole. To preach the first half of a story is to preach a different story.
An argument. In a letter, the unit is often longer: a stretch of reasoning from a claim, through its reasons, to its result. Verse divisions do not always follow the argument. A preacher who treats each verse as a separate text may lose the thread that holds them together. Week 5 takes this up.
The rule of thumb is simple. Take the smallest piece of text that still says one whole thing. Too small, and you are quoting; too large, and you are skimming.
There is a practical side too. A preacher who speaks for fifteen minutes cannot say all that is in a chapter. Choosing a unit also means deciding what you will leave unsaid, and being at peace with that. The text is larger than any one sermon on it.
2. Finding the thrust
Once the unit is chosen, the next task is to say what the passage is doing. A common word for this is the thrust: the single push of the passage on its hearer. In the course Preaching Practicum (PT726E) a preacher learns to put the sermon into one sentence. Here the same discipline applies, with one change: the sentence should come from the passage, not from the preacher's wish.
Take the two short stories in Matthew 13:44-46. One person finds a treasure by chance, and the other is a merchant looking for pearls on purpose. Both find something of great value. Both sell everything. The first does it "in his joy". This is a clue to the thrust: the stress is not on the loss but on the worth of what is found.
A cautious statement of the thrust might be: The kingdom of heaven is worth more than everything, and the one who sees it gives up the rest gladly. That sentence stays inside the two stories. It does not say who the man is, or what the field is, or what the pearl means in detail. It says what the two stories together do to a hearer.
This is a point where care is needed, and the next sentences are not a ruling. Through the centuries some preachers have read the man in these stories as a picture of Christ, who gave up everything for the world, and others have read him as the disciple who finds the kingdom. Both readings have been held in the church, and each has been argued with care. A reader may also notice that the man in the first story hid the treasure, and some hearers ask about that. A preacher does not need to settle all these questions to preach the thrust. But a preacher should know they exist, and should say which reading the sermon follows and keep to it. Week 2 returns to how much meaning to find in the details of a parable.
A test for the sentence: if the passage were removed, could the sentence still stand? If so, it did not come from the passage. A sentence like "Faith is important" could be put over any text. "The kingdom is worth more than everything, and the finder gives up the rest gladly" belongs to these stories.
Two thrusts in one sermon are a warning sign. If the outline pulls toward "the kingdom is precious" in one place and "you must give up your possessions" in another, either the sermon has two sermons in it, or one thrust has been pushed farther than the text takes it.
3. Three common forms
The unit and the thrust are decisions about the passage. The form is a decision about how the sermon will move. Three forms are very common, and many preachers move between them. Each has real strengths and real costs, and none is the villain.
The expository form. Expository means that the sermon opens up the text and follows its order. The preacher walks through the passage, explains what it says, and draws out what it means for the hearers. Its strength: it keeps the sermon close to the words, and it teaches the hearers to read the text for themselves. Its cost: if the preacher simply follows the verses one by one, a sermon can become a commentary, and hearers lose the thrust in the details. A good expository sermon still has a single point.
The topical form. Topical means that the sermon starts from a subject (a question, a need, a theme) and gathers what Scripture says about it, perhaps from several passages. Its strength: it can answer a question the congregation is actually asking, and it can show how texts speak to each other. Its cost: a single passage can shrink into an illustration of what the preacher already meant to say, and a verse may be taken out of its setting. A topical sermon is safest when each passage it uses is heard in its own context first.
The narrative form. Narrative means that the sermon itself moves like a story: it has a beginning, a turn, an ending, and the hearers are carried through it. It suits stories in the text especially well. Its strength: hearers remember a story and feel it, and the sermon does what the passage does. Its cost: a story can carry feeling without meaning, and the preacher can invent details the passage does not give. The narrative form must be disciplined by the text.
None of these forms is right for every passage. A preacher in a lectionary tradition may find that the form is partly set by the occasion. A preacher in a free tradition may choose the form freely. Lecture 1-3 asks how the passage helps set the form, and lecture 1-4 asks how traditions differ.
4. One passage, three outlines
Here are three outlines of a sermon on Matthew 13:44-46, all built on the same thrust. (An invented example.) They are outlines, not scripts, and they are only one way of each form.
Expository outline (an invented example)
- The first story (verse 44): a man finds a treasure and, in his joy, gives up everything he has to own it.
- The second story (verses 45-46): a merchant finds the one pearl he was looking for, and he too gives up everything.
- What they share: two different people, one by chance and one by search, and both see the same worth.
- For us: we are asked to see the worth of the kingdom, and then to hear the gladness in the giving-up.
Topical outline (an invented example)
Subject: "What is worth everything?"
- Our hearers are asked every week to give up something for something else. What do they choose and why?
- Jesus' two stories answer from one angle: the kingdom is the thing worth everything (Matthew 13:44-46).
- We hear what the stories say about gladness, and not only loss.
- We ask where we hold on too tightly, and what it would mean to hold more loosely.
Narrative outline (an invented example)
The sermon is told as a story of two people who each find something. It begins with a field, a digging, a surprise. It slows at the moment of finding. It lets the hearers hear the man go, almost running, to sell everything. It does the same with the merchant. At the end it turns to the hearers with one line: which of us has seen it, and what are we holding that we would put down?
Look at what is the same and what is different. All three carry the same thrust. The expository outline stays close to the order of the verses. The topical outline starts from a question the hearers carry. The narrative outline tells and lets the story do the work. All three can be faithful, and each has its risk. The expository outline can drift into commentary. The topical outline may lean on the stories as an illustration. The narrative outline may add detail that the stories do not give.
5. What goes wrong when the thrust is lost
A sermon on these stories can easily go wrong in a way that sounds pious. Suppose the sermon says that the passage teaches that Christians must give away everything they own. This pulls the stories toward a rule that the text does not state, and some hearers will hear a demand about money. A preacher who then presses people to give money to a cause has used the passage in a way it does not support. Week 6 returns to the use of the pulpit to press hearers for money.
The better course is to let the stories carry what they carry: the worth of the kingdom, and the joy of the one who sees it.
Diagram 1. From passage to sermon: four decisions
Diagram 2. Three forms compared
| Form | Starts from | Strength | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expository | The order of the passage | Stays close to the words; teaches hearers to read | Can become a commentary and lose the thrust |
| Topical | A subject or question | Meets a real question; shows texts in conversation | A passage can shrink to an illustration |
| Narrative | The movement of a story | Hearers remember and feel it | Feeling may outrun meaning; details may be invented |
핵심 요약
- Choose the smallest piece of text that still says one whole thing: a scene, a short unit or an argument.
- The thrust is the one push of the passage on its hearers, stated in a sentence that could not fit any other text.
- Two competing thrusts in one sermon are a sign that one has been pushed beyond the text.
- Three common forms are expository, topical and narrative. Each has a strength and a cost, and none is a villain.
- One passage can be preached faithfully in all three forms if each keeps the one thrust.
- For general craft and the one-sentence discipline, see PT726E.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The unit | The smallest piece of text that still says one whole thing. |
| The thrust | One sentence saying what the passage does. It should not fit any other text. |
| Expository, topical, narrative | Follows the passage; starts from a subject; moves like a story. Each has a strength and a cost. |
| A warning sign | Two thrusts in one sermon, or a rule the text does not carry. |
One sentence to remember Choose the passage's own unit, find its one thrust, and then choose a form that serves it.
This week's action Pick a short passage and write its unit and thrust in one sentence each. Test the sentence: could it be put over another text?
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What is the smallest piece of text that says one whole thing in the last passage you heard preached? Was the sermon on that piece, or on something larger or smaller?
- Try to state the thrust of Matthew 13:44-46 in a sentence of your own. Does it pass the test of not fitting any other text?
- Some readers see the man in the first story as a picture of Christ. Others see him as the disciple. What would each reading do to a sermon? What would you need to be honest about in either?
- Which of the three forms feels most natural to you or to your community? What is the cost of that form, and how might you guard against it?
- A hearer might hear Matthew 13:44-46 as a demand to give away money. How could a preacher keep the stories from being used that way?