Lecture 5-2: Following an Argument
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Map of the New Testament
- Lecture 1-2: One Passage, One Thrust
- Lecture 1-3: Letting the Passage Set the Form
- Lecture 1-4: How Preaching Traditions Differ
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Naming the Kind of Writing
- Lecture 2-1: What Kind of Writing a Gospel Is
- Lecture 2-2: Telling a Gospel Scene
- Lecture 2-3: Miracles and the Hearer Who Is Not Healed
- Lecture 2-4: Preaching a Parable
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Scene or a Parable
- Lecture 3-1: Signs and Discourses in John
- Lecture 3-2: Preaching the Passion
- Lecture 3-3: The Resurrection Accounts
- Lecture 3-4: Preaching in the Church's Year and the Short Homily
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Sign or a Resurrection Scene
- Lecture 4-1: Between Description and Rule
- Lecture 4-2: The Speeches in Acts
- Lecture 4-3: The Community and the Hard Passages
- Lecture 4-4: Preaching Acts as a Series
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, One Scene from Acts
- Lecture 5-1: A Letter Is a Letter
- Lecture 5-2: Following an Argument
- Lecture 5-3: Doctrinal Passages and the Traditions
- Lecture 5-4: Household Codes, Authority and Hard Commands
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Mapping One Letter Passage
A letter does not only give instructions. It reasons. Paul writes "therefore", "but", "for", "so that" and "so then", and each of those small words tells the hearer how one sentence leans on another. A sermon that ignores them will often keep the words of the letter and lose its meaning.
This lecture teaches a habit for the preacher: preach the flow, not a pile of verses. To preach the flow is to find where the passage begins its thought, where it turns, and where it arrives, and to let the sermon travel the same road. The habit is a response to the kind of writing a letter is. It is not a course in how to study an argument; that belongs to Advanced Expository Preaching (PT701E).
The lecture also looks at a special case. Letters sometimes contain a hymn or a confession fragment: a short, rhythmic or formal piece that looks as if it was sung or recited in worship before it was written into the letter. These pieces need their own handling.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Find the connecting words in a passage and say what each one asks the preacher to do.
- Explain why splitting an argument into verses can change its meaning, and show it in an example.
- Preach a hymn or confession in a letter by asking why the writer placed it where he did.
- Outline a sermon that follows the movement of a passage in three or four steps, without turning it into a list of unrelated points.
If there is therefore any exhortation in Christ, if any consolation of love, if any fellowship of the Spirit, if any tender mercies and compassion," — Philippians 2:1
World English Bible
make my joy full, by being like-minded, having the same love, being of one accord, of one mind;" — Philippians 2:2
WEB
doing nothing through rivalry or through conceit, but in humility, each counting others better than himself;" — Philippians 2:3
WEB
each of you not just looking to his own things, but each of you also to the things of others." — Philippians 2:4
WEB
Have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus," — Philippians 2:5
WEB
who, existing in the form of God, didn’t consider equality with God a thing to be grasped," — Philippians 2:6
WEB
but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of men." — Philippians 2:7
WEB
And being found in human form, he humbled himself, becoming obedient to death, yes, the death of the cross." — Philippians 2:8
WEB
Therefore God also highly exalted him, and gave to him the name which is above every name;" — Philippians 2:9
WEB
that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of those in heaven, those on earth, and those under the earth," — Philippians 2:10
WEB
and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father." — Philippians 2:11
WEB
Being therefore justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ;" — Romans 5:1
WEB
Therefore I urge you, brothers, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable to God, which is your spiritual service." — Romans 12:1
WEB
Philippians 2:1-11 is the main passage. The two sentences from Romans are there for the small word they share: both begin with "therefore", and in both the word points backward.
1. Small words carry the argument
Read Romans 5:1 again: "Being therefore justified by faith, we have peace with God." The word "therefore" tells the hearer that this sentence is a conclusion. Something came before it, and this is what follows from it. A preacher who begins a sermon at Romans 5:1 and says "Let us talk about peace with God" has started at the conclusion and left out the reasons. The hearers get a pleasant verse and miss the argument that makes the verse true.
Romans 12:1 does the same on a larger scale. "Therefore I urge you, brothers, by the mercies of God." Many readers see the letter turning here, from long teaching about what God has done toward what a life shaped by it looks like. The "therefore" does not mean "so now, a few rules"; it means "because of everything I have said". The mercies are the reason for the appeal. A sermon on presenting our bodies that does not mention the mercies has torn the sentence off its foundation.
Here are the small words that most often carry an argument, and what each asks of the preacher.
- Therefore, so, so then, for this reason: a conclusion. Ask: what came before? Do not preach this sentence without it.
- But, yet, however: a turn. Ask: what is being set against what? A sermon that skips the first side makes the second pointless.
- For, because: a reason. Ask: what is the reason supporting? Do not preach the reason as if it were the main point, or the main point as if it had no reason.
- So that, in order that: a purpose. Ask: what is this for? The purpose is often the point the writer cares about most.
- If... then: a condition. Ask carefully what is being said. Many "if" clauses in letters state something taken to be true ("since you have been raised"), not a doubtful condition.
The last point is one to hold lightly. When a preacher is not sure what a small word is doing in a given verse, the honest step is to check a good commentary, or to read two translations, or to say less. This course does not ask the preacher to work it out from Greek. It asks the preacher to notice that the word is there.
2. The danger of the pile of verses
Many sermons on a letter are piles. The preacher takes a passage of ten verses, divides it into ten parts, finds a lesson in each, and walks through them. Each lesson may be true. But the passage has been turned from a road into a heap. The hearer cannot say where the letter was going.
A heap does worse than bore. It can change the meaning. Take a passage whose argument is "because of A, do B", and divide it so that "do B" is a sermon in itself. B now has no reason. It becomes an order, and the hearers hear a command with no ground, which is the opposite of what the passage was doing.
The better method is to let the movement of the passage set the movement of the sermon. If the passage moves from a problem to a pattern to a result, the sermon will move from the problem to the pattern to the result. Verse numbers can be named for orientation, but they do not set the shape.
3. A worked road: Philippians 2:1-11
Here is how the habit works on the main passage.
Paul is writing to a church he cares about. In this part of the letter he appeals to them. They need to be of one mind, and the opposite of oneness is described: rivalry, conceit, each person guarding their own things (2:3-4). The letter itself speaks of Paul's imprisonment in its opening chapter. He is not scolding from comfort.
Notice the small word at the start. "If there is therefore any exhortation in Christ..." The "therefore" reaches back to what he has just written, an appeal to live in a way worthy of the gospel. So the passage does not begin in verse 1; it begins in the middle of an appeal.
Then verse 5 gives the hinge: "Have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus." The word "this" points forward to what follows. And what follows is the movement of verses 6-11.
Down: Christ "existing in the form of God" did not treat equality with God as something to be grasped. He "emptied himself", took "the form of a servant", was "found in human form", "humbled himself", and became "obedient to death, yes, the death of the cross." Every step goes lower.
Up: Then another small word turns the passage: "Therefore God also highly exalted him" (2:9). God gives him the name above every name. Every knee will bow and every tongue confess "that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father."
The shape is a curve: down to the cross, then up to the name above every name. The hymn is not decoration. It is placed here because the church is being asked to take the same downward road that Christ took: to count others better than themselves, look to the things of others, and trust God for the exaltation.
Now compare two sermon plans. (Both are invented outlines.)
A pile: 1. Rivalry is bad (v. 3). 2. Humility is good (v. 3). 3. Jesus was God (v. 6). 4. Jesus became a servant (v. 7). 5. Jesus died (v. 8). 6. God exalted Jesus (v. 9). 7. Every knee will bow (v. 10). 8. Confess Jesus as Lord (v. 11).
A road: 1. A church pulling apart: Paul's appeal for one mind (vv. 1-4). 2. The mind of Christ: down, step by step, to the cross (vv. 5-8). 3. God's answer: the name above every name (vv. 9-11). 4. What the road asks of us: to walk down it together, trusting the answer.
The second plan does not preach less of the passage. It preaches it in the order in which it works, and every part has a reason to be there.
4. Hymns and confession fragments
Some short pieces in the letters look as if the writer was quoting something the churches already knew. Philippians 2:6-11 is the best-known example. Many scholars hold that these verses are an early hymn, or hymn-like, and that Paul used it. Others hold that Paul composed it for this letter. The preacher need not settle that. Either way the same two facts hold: the piece has a rhythm and a compact form, and it was placed here for a reason.
Elsewhere, Paul sometimes says that he is passing on what he himself received. In 1 Corinthians 15 he gives a short summary of the gospel in just that way, as something handed down. That tells the preacher that the church was confessing the faith before it was writing letters about it, and that some of the shortest sentences in the letters carry the heaviest weight.
How should such a piece be preached?
- Ask why it is here. In Philippians, a hymn about Christ appears in the middle of an appeal about unity. It is placed there as a pattern to be followed, not only as a statement to be believed. A sermon that treats it only as a lecture on who Christ is, and drops the appeal around it, preaches half of what the passage does.
- Keep the poetry as poetry. A hymn praises. It does not define every term. The words "emptied himself" have been read in several ways by Christians over the centuries, and the churches have discussed what they mean for the nature of Christ. The sermon does not need to settle all of that. It needs to say what the passage says: he did not grasp, he gave, he went down, and God raised him.
- Let it be sung, if your community sings. The first hearers probably knew the pattern of such pieces by ear. A reading aloud, a pause, a sung line can do what an explanation cannot.
- Say little where the passage says little. The risk with a famous piece is to load it with everything the preacher has ever read about it.
5. What this asks of the hearer
A last note on writing for the hearer. When a sermon follows an argument, the hearer needs to hear the turns. A speaker who reads out "therefore" without any marker can lose people. The preacher may say, "Here Paul turns", or "Notice the word therefore; it tells us that what comes next depends on what we have just heard." One plain sentence at each turn gives the hearer a handrail, especially a hearer listening through an interpreter or on a radio, who cannot see the page.
(One line of general craft: writing the sermon for the ear is the subject of Preaching Practicum, PT726E.)
6. Not every letter argues in the same way
Some letters argue closely, as Romans does. Others, such as 1 Thessalonians or Philemon, move by warmth and appeal more than by logic. James strings together short pieces of teaching. Hebrews has long stretches of exposition tied to quotations. The preacher listens for the kind of movement the particular passage has, and does not squeeze a loose collection into a tight argument, or a tight argument into a loose collection.
Diagram 1. Philippians 2:1-11 as a road
Diagram 2. Small words and what they ask
| Word | What it signals | The preacher asks |
|---|---|---|
| Therefore, so then | A conclusion | What came before? |
| But, yet | A turn | What is set against what? |
| For, because | A reason | What does this support? |
| So that | A purpose | What is this for? |
| If... then | A condition, or something taken as true | Which is it here? |
핵심 요약
- Small words such as "therefore", "but", "for" and "so that" tell the hearer how a sentence leans on the one before it.
- Preach the flow of the passage, not a pile of verses. The movement of the passage sets the movement of the sermon.
- Dividing an argument into verse-sized lessons can strip a command of its reason and change its meaning.
- Philippians 2:1-11 moves from an appeal, down to the cross, and up to the name above every name, and the hymn serves the appeal.
- A hymn or confession in a letter is preached by asking why it is placed where it is, and by leaving poetry as poetry.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| "Therefore" | A conclusion. Ask what came before, and do not preach the sentence without it. |
| A pile of verses | A passage cut into separate lessons; it can lose the reason that makes a command a command. |
| The road of Philippians 2:1-11 | Appeal to one mind; Christ's way down; God's answer; what the road asks of a church. |
| A hymn in a letter | Ask why it is here; keep it as praise; let it do what the letter uses it to do. |
One sentence to remember Preach the road the passage walks, not the stones it is made of.
This week's action Take a passage from a letter, mark every "therefore", "but", "for" and "so that", and write the flow in three or four steps.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Choose a passage from a letter. Mark every small connecting word. What does each one tell you about how the sentences lean on each other?
- Have you heard a sermon that took a famous verse from a letter and left out the "therefore"? What did the hearers miss?
- In Philippians 2, the hymn is placed inside an appeal about unity. What might a sermon lose if it preached the hymn alone?
- Where might a preacher say too much about a famous hymn-like passage? What would be a restrained way to preach it?
- How would you help a hearer who cannot see the page follow a turn in the argument?