Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Law and the Prophets: Gleaning, Sabbath, Jubilee and the Cry for Justice
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus and the First Churches: Presence, Sharing and the Neighbour
- Lecture 1-3: How the Church Has Remembered: Almsgiving, Deacons, Hospitals and Hospitality
- Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My First Reaction
- Lecture 2-1: Dignity and the Shape of a Gift
- Lecture 2-2: Relief, Recovery, Development and Change
- Lecture 2-3: Choosing Fairly, Keeping Confidence, Keeping Records
- Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reviewing How We Receive a Request
- Lecture 3-1: Listening First: Needs and Gifts in the Same Street
- Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
- Lecture 3-3: Working Together: Other Churches, Agencies and Neighbours of Other Faiths
- Lecture 3-4: Knowing Our Limits: Noticing, Referring and Staying Beside
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Neighbourhood Map
- Lecture 4-1: Food, Housing, Work and Learning
- Lecture 4-2: Older People, Disabled People, Single Parents and Carers
- Lecture 4-3: On the Street, in Prison and Coming Home
- Lecture 4-4: Neighbours of Other Faiths and None: Serving a Plural Neighbourhood
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Designing One Small Service
- Lecture 5-1: Volunteers: Choosing, Training and Boundaries
- Lecture 5-2: Mercy and Witness: Without Conditions, Without Hiding
- Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
- Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Our Words and Our Deeds
No congregation thinks alike. In the same pew sit people who vote for different parties, who read the news differently, who disagree about what causes poverty and what to do about it, and who feel more or less hopeful about the world. Some have been helped by public services and some have been hurt by them. Some have a good deal of money and some are counting coins for the bus. Some have come from other countries; some have never left the town. And all of them are the church.
When a church begins to take mercy and justice seriously, these differences surface. One member thinks the church should do more; another thinks it already does too much. One thinks the church should say something about a law; another thinks it should stay out. One feels that the church is full of good people, and another feels that nobody has asked what they think. A church that does not prepare for this will either go quiet, so that nobody says what they think, or break, so that people leave.
This lecture has two parts, and a single argument behind them. A church that serves its neighbours must first be a place where its own people can differ without being broken, and where justice is done at home before it is asked of others. The first part is about the table inside the church: how to keep it open, how to run a conversation that does not split the church, and how to hear the minority who feel unheard. The second is about justice at home: how the church treats its staff, cleaners, volunteers and guests, what it pays and owes, and how it confesses where it has fallen short.
Both parts follow from the course's central claim. Justice is the shared responsibility of a whole community. A congregation is one such community, and it is the first place where it can be seen to be shared, or not.
This lecture does not teach employment law or church governance; the courses on church staff and personnel and on church safety and compliance do that. It gives principles, and tells you to find out and follow the rules of your own place.
이 35분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why differences among members are normal, and how to keep the table open when members vote, think and feel differently.
- Describe how to run a conversation that does not break the church: listening first, keeping to what Scripture says, and naming what is not agreed.
- Describe how a church can hear a minority who feel unheard.
- Explain what justice at home asks of a church in its treatment of its staff, cleaners, volunteers and guests, in principle, and where to find out the local rules.
- Describe how a church can confess its own failures, using Nehemiah 5, Acts 6 and James 2 as a mirror.
Then there arose a great cry of the people and of their wives against their brothers the Jews." — Nehemiah 5:1
World English Bible
Yet now our flesh is as the flesh of our brothers, our children as their children. Behold, we bring into bondage our sons and our daughters to be servants, and some of our daughters have been brought into bondage. Neither is it in our power to help it; for other men have our fields and our vineyards.”" — Nehemiah 5:5
WEB
Also I said, “The thing that you do is not good. Ought you not to walk in the fear of our God, because of the reproach of the nations our enemies?" — Nehemiah 5:9
WEB
Now in those days, when the number of the disciples was multiplying, a complaint arose from the Hellenists against the Hebrews, because their widows were neglected in the daily service." — Acts 6:1
WEB
My brothers, don’t hold the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ of glory with partiality." — James 2:1
WEB
But if you show partiality, you commit sin, being convicted by the law as transgressors." — James 2:9
WEB
You shall not oppress a hired servant who is poor and needy, whether he is one of your brothers, or one of the foreigners who are in your land within your gates." — Deuteronomy 24:14
WEB
So then, let us follow after things which make for peace, and things by which we may build one another up." — Romans 14:19
WEB
being eager to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace." — Ephesians 4:3
WEB
Three of these passages show a community looking at itself. In Nehemiah, the cry comes from inside the community, against its own leaders and lenders. In Acts, a complaint is raised within the church, by a group that felt overlooked, and the church listens. James asks believers to hold their faith without partiality, and then describes a congregation that favours the well-dressed. The others describe how a people may live together: the hired worker is not to be oppressed, and the unity of the Spirit is kept through peace. They are not texts about enemies outside. They are mirrors held up to the church.
1. Many voices are normal
A church in which everybody agrees about every public question is either very small or very quiet. Real congregations hold people who differ. The questions that most easily divide them are those that touch mercy and justice: how much a church should give and to whom, whether the church should speak about a law or a leader, what causes people to be poor, whether help makes people dependent, what a stranger owes a community and what a community owes a stranger.
On these questions, thoughtful Christians reach different conclusions. They do so because they weigh Scripture, history, their own experience and the news differently, and because they have different things to lose. A member who has had a small business may think about markets in one way, a nurse in another, a person who has lived without work in a third. This is not a sign of faithlessness. It is the ordinary state of a body with many members (1 Corinthians 12 uses the picture of the body for this reason).
The danger comes not from the difference but from how the difference is handled. Three patterns do harm.
- Silence. Nobody says what they think, because everyone knows there will be trouble. A congregation can look peaceful for years while some members quietly decide that the church is not for people like them.
- Winning. One view takes the room, perhaps because it is held by the leader or the loudest, and the others are treated as mistakes to be corrected. The people who differ either leave or are tolerated with a cooler welcome.
- Sorting. Members drift into groups that think alike, and the church becomes a set of parties that share a building.
The aim is a fourth pattern: a table that stays open while people differ. This is slow work and it requires some skill.
2. Keeping the table open
Keeping the table open means, in practice, a small number of habits that a church can learn.
Say what unites us, and say it often. The church is held together by the gospel, the creeds or confessions it holds, and its shared worship, not by agreement on every public question. Ephesians 4:3 speaks of keeping a unity that already exists, "the unity of the Spirit", and asks us to be eager about it. Romans 14:19 says to follow what makes for peace and mutual building. A leader can say regularly: We are one body. We do not all think the same about these things, and we will talk about them with respect.
Separate the question of belonging from the question of opinion. A person does not need to hold any political view to belong, and no view puts a person outside. Where a church holds a confession of faith, belonging is defined by that, and not by a policy. A person who votes the other way, or who thinks the church's mercy ministry is misguided, remains at the table.
Make sure that those who help are not the only voices. Those who serve are close to the need and may speak with passion. Those who do not may have reasons, fears or other burdens. Both belong in the conversation.
Remember who is not in the room. The neighbours served by the church, the members who work on Sundays, the older members who cannot get out at night, the newcomers who do not yet know how to speak: all of them may be missing. A church may ask, before it holds a meeting, whom must we hear who would not usually come? and then go to them.
3. A conversation that does not break the church
A difficult conversation needs a shape. Here is one that has worked in many congregations. Adapt it to the setting.
- Agree the purpose. Is the meeting for deciding, or for listening, or for learning? A meeting that begins as a listening session and ends with a vote on the spot has surprised people. Say what it is for at the start.
- Start with Scripture, read together, and with what it says. Not with what each person thinks it implies. Read the passage aloud, ask what it says, and write down what everyone agrees it says. Often this is more than they thought.
- Listen before you answer. Each person speaks without interruption for a short time, and the next speaker begins by saying back what they heard: "I heard you say..." This is slow, and it makes a large difference. James 1:19 is useful here. Swift to hear, slow to speak.
- Ask each person what they fear and what they hope for. Underneath most disagreements there is a fear: that the church will forget its mission, that it will become a political group, that someone will be hurt, that nothing will change. Fears can often be answered where positions cannot.
- Name what is agreed, what is not agreed and what is not yet known. Write the three lists on a board. People are often surprised how long the first one is, and relieved to see that the second is short and honest.
- Decide only what needs to be decided, and decide it in the way the church's own rules require. A congregation need not settle every question. Some can be left open with a promise to talk again.
- Close with a shared act: prayer, bread, a meal, a task together. The way people part is as important as how they argued.
(An invented example.) The people of Alder Street Church in the town of Orrel Vale held a members' meeting about a proposal to join a town campaign asking the council to build more places where people could sleep safely at night in winter. Some members were strongly in favour. Others were uneasy, for different reasons: one feared that the campaign was run by a political party; a retired builder thought the council's plan was impractical; a young mother said she was afraid for the safety of the children in the church hall if the church became involved in such a project.
The chair, a named Corin, began by saying what the meeting was for: "We are here to listen, and to decide only whether to explore this further." Then he asked someone to read Isaiah 58:6-10 aloud, and asked, "What does this passage say about what God wants?" The group wrote down the answers, which were mainly about sharing bread, sheltering the homeless and loosing unjust bonds. Nobody disagreed with those.
Corin then asked each person to say what they hoped and what they feared. One by one they did. The young mother's fear was heard. The builder's practical worries were written down. The man who feared the political party was asked what exactly he feared, and said it was that the church's name would be used on a banner. Several others shared the same fear. When Corin asked what was agreed, the list included "the church should care about people who sleep outside in winter"; on the list of what was not agreed was "whether to join this campaign"; on the list of what was not yet known was "who runs the campaign and what it would ask of us".
The meeting decided two things: that a small group, including the builder, the young mother and one of the keen members, would find out who ran the campaign and what the church would be asked to do; and that the church would go on, whatever it decided, with its own winter blanket drive. They closed with a cup of tea. A month later the small group reported that the campaign had a plain list of three requests and no party label. The church decided to take part in one request and not in the others. Two members still disagreed, and said so, and stayed.
Nobody in this story is a villain or a saint. The meeting did not produce unanimity. It produced a decision the church could live with, and a table that remained open.
4. The minority who feel unheard
Every congregation has some who feel unheard. They may be a few members who hold a view that the majority does not share. They may be those who have less money or less education than most. They may be a group by language, age or origin. They may be the people who cleaned the hall for years and were never asked what they thought.
James 2:1-4 describes a gathering in which a person in fine clothes is given a good seat and a poor person is told to stand. James says the church has become a judge with evil thoughts. The church may not do this on purpose. It may happen through habit: the meeting is held at an hour that excludes shift workers, the language of the meeting is hard for newcomers, the people who speak are always the same, and nobody notices.
A church can take simple steps.
- Ask them directly, one at a time, in private if they prefer. "What is it like for you to be part of this church? What do you wish we understood?"
- Look at who speaks in meetings and who does not. If it is always the same, ask why.
- Change the time, the place or the language where it keeps people out. Provide childcare, a translator or a way to speak without a crowd.
- Include people on committees and in decisions, and not only in the lists of those who are served.
- Say thank you when someone says a hard thing. A person who says, "I do not think we are fair to the cleaners," has done the church a service, even if they said it clumsily.
- Do not treat a dissenting view as disloyalty. The minority may be seeing something that the majority has stopped noticing.
A church in which the minority are treated as threats will lose them. A church that listens may find that they have been carrying a part of its conscience.
5. Justice at home
Before a church asks others to be fair, it can ask whether it is fair itself. Matthew 7:3-5 (lecture 5-3) asks us to look at our own eye. Justice at home means looking at the people who are closest to the church and asking what it owes them.
The principle is the one the law in Deuteronomy gives: "You shall not oppress a hired servant who is poor and needy, whether he is one of your brothers, or one of the foreigners who are in your land within your gates" (Deuteronomy 24:14). Both the member and the stranger within the gates are covered. Colossians 4:1 says the same to those in charge: give what is just and fair.
Principle only. This course does not teach employment law, and the rules differ greatly between places. In some places a church that employs a cleaner, a caretaker or a musician is bound by detailed rules about pay, contracts, hours, insurance and records. In others the rules are few and the church must decide for itself what is fair. In every case the church should find out in advance what applies to it, write it down and follow it, and ask a qualified person where it is unsure. The course on church staff and personnel goes further.
With that said, here are the questions a church may ask about those closest to it.
- Staff and those paid. Are they paid what they were promised, on time, and what is fair for the work in this place? Do they have a way to raise a concern with someone other than the person who might be the cause? Do they have rest? Does anyone pay a worker "in kind" or with praise in place of what the person needs to live on?
- Cleaners and caretakers. The people who clean the building and lock it at night are often the least noticed. Do the church's members know their names? Are they asked to do more than the agreed work because they are "part of the church"? Are they employed by the church or by a company, and does anyone know whether the company is fair?
- Volunteers. Volunteers are not employees, but they are not to be worked without limit or thanked in empty words. Lecture 5-1 sets out what a church owes them.
- Guests and hall users. Are other groups, including groups that are poor or foreign, charged and treated fairly in the use of the building? Is the hall free to the same extent for all?
- What the church pays and owes. Does the church pay its bills on time, including to small traders? Does it keep its promises about rent, repairs and gifts? Does it treat money given for a purpose as given for that purpose? Does it keep honest accounts (see the course on church safety and compliance)?
- Those who are not members. Is a neighbour who uses the church's service treated as fairly as a member? Do the church's own prayers and notices honour them?
This is not a list for scolding. A church may find that it has fallen short in some of these, and may find that it is doing well in others. What matters is the habit of asking, and the habit of asking those affected, not only those in charge. This lecture is not legal or tax advice.
(An invented example, from the other side.) The cleaner at Alder Street Church, a man named Idris, had worked there for six years. When the church's treasurer reviewed the accounts as part of a "justice at home" check, she saw that his pay had not been changed since he began, though his tasks had grown: he now also set up chairs for the Thursday supper. She asked Idris, privately, whether he would be willing to talk about it. He said, with some embarrassment, that he had not wanted to ask because the church had been kind to him when he was out of work. The treasurer took the question to the leaders. They found out what was customary for such work in their town, adjusted his pay, wrote down his tasks and thanked him publicly with his agreement, and invited him to say, whenever he wished, if the arrangement was no longer fair.
From Idris's side: it was hard to ask a church that had helped him. From the treasurer's side: it was not a scandal; it was an oversight that she was glad to find. From the congregation's side: some members were uneasy about the cost, and the leaders explained plainly why they had acted. One member, a retired schoolteacher, said she had been going past Idris for years and had never asked his surname.
6. The church confesses
A church that has found a failing has a choice: to hide it, to defend it or to confess it. Scripture gives examples of the third.
Nehemiah 5 is a remarkable passage. The cry comes not from outside enemies, but from the people against their brothers: the poor have mortgaged their fields and sold their children into bondage to pay debts to their own kin. Nehemiah is angry (5:6). He calls a great assembly, names the wrong, puts himself among those who also lend (5:10), and asks for restoration. The nobles agree to give back what they took, and the leaders swear an oath. Notice that it is the leader who names it. He does not wait for an outside voice to do it, and he does not exempt himself. Note also that we are told what was done, not how long it took or whether it lasted; the text does not say that all was well afterwards, and we should not claim it does.
Acts 6:1 shows a church where a complaint is made by one group of widows who were being overlooked in the daily service. The apostles did not dismiss the complaint, defend their record or tell the Hellenists to be patient. They called the whole community, named the problem and chose seven people of good report to see to it (Acts 6:3, lecture 5-1). The church was honest about a failing early in its life.
James 2:1-9 is a mirror. A person in fine clothes is shown to a good seat, and a poor person is told to stand. James does not say, "this happens in other churches." He says, "haven't you shown partiality among yourselves?" The verse names the sin without softening it. We should read it as asking: where do we do this? Whom do we seat well and whom do we leave standing?
A church that confesses does five things.
- Names the wrong plainly, without excuse, and without an unnecessary list of who was to blame.
- Hears those who were wronged and asks what would be fair, not what would be convenient.
- Makes it right, as far as can be done, by repaying, changing a practice or restoring a place.
- Says what will change, and tells people how to check. A promise that nobody can see being kept is not much of a promise.
- Does not make a show of it. A confession is for the people who were wronged and for the health of the church, not for the church's reputation for humility.
A church that confesses may find that its neighbours trust it more, not less. A church that never admits a failing may be telling the neighbours that it has never made one.
7. The same matter from other sides
From the side of the church leader, the task is to hold the church together without silencing anyone. A leader may feel pulled between members who want the church to do more and those who want it to do less, and may be tempted to avoid the matter. A leader who names the tension, gives it a shape and models listening shows the church how to do it.
From the side of the member who disagrees, the difficulty may be that they love the church, and worry that their view marks them as an outsider. A church that says, kindly and often, "You belong here, and we want to hear what you think," makes it possible to stay.
From the side of the neighbour who is served, a church that is divided in public, or that treats its own cleaner unfairly, tells them something about how far its words can be trusted. A church that is honest at home is more credible abroad.
From the side of the worker or cleaner, the church may be both an employer and a family, and that is a hard mix. A worker may be reluctant to ask for what is due because the church has shown them love. The church should make it easy for them to ask, in the knowledge that asking is not ingratitude.
Diagram 1. An open table and a fair house
핵심 요약
- Members differ on mercy and justice; the harm comes from silence, winning or sorting, and the aim is a table that stays open while people differ.
- Unity rests on the gospel and shared worship, not agreement on every public question, and belonging never depends on an opinion.
- A good conversation states its purpose, reads Scripture first, listens, names fears, and lists what is agreed, not agreed and not yet known.
- Listen to the minority one by one, and change time, language or place where it keeps people out.
- Justice at home asks what the church owes staff, cleaners, volunteers, hall users and neighbours; find out local rules and follow them.
- A church confesses by naming the wrong, hearing those wronged, making it right, saying what will change and not making a show.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three patterns that harm | Silence (nobody says), winning (one view takes the room) and sorting (members form groups that think alike). |
| A conversation that holds | State the purpose, read Scripture, listen and say back, ask fears and hopes, list what is agreed and not, decide only what is needed, close together. |
| Justice at home | Ask what the church owes its staff, cleaners, volunteers, hall users and neighbours; find out local rules; ask those affected. |
| How a church confesses | Name it plainly, hear those wronged, make it right, say what will change and how to check, and do not make a show. |
One sentence to remember A church that can keep its table open when members differ, and be fair to those nearest, has earned the right to be heard on justice abroad.
This week's action Choose one person in or near your church who is seldom asked what they think, and ask them one open question about how it is for them.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In your church, which of the three harmful patterns, silence, winning or sorting, is most common when members differ? What might help?
- Read the seven steps for a difficult conversation. Which step would be hardest in a church you know, and why?
- Who is usually missing from your church's meetings? How might you hear from them?
- In the story of Alder Street Church, what did the chair do that kept the table open? What would you have done differently?
- In the story of Idris, why might a worker be slow to ask a church for what is fair? How could a church make it easier?
- Choose one of Nehemiah 5, Acts 6:1-6 or James 2:1-9. What does it show a church doing, and what is the lesson for a church today?
- From a member's side: what would let you disagree with your church about a public matter and still feel that you belong?