Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
- Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
- Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
- Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
- Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
- Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
- Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
- Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
- Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
- Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
- Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
- Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
- Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
- Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
- Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
- Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
- Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
- Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
In the first four weeks we listened to neighbours who belong to a named faith. This week we listen to neighbours who say they belong to none. Many of them are thoughtful, kind and serious about right and wrong. Some were raised in a church and left. Some were never in one. Some are not sure what they believe, and some are sure that there is no God.
Before we can listen well we need words. In everyday talk, "secular", "atheist", "humanist" and "non-religious" are thrown together as if they meant one thing. They do not. A neighbour who is called "secular" may be a person of no belief, a person of quiet private faith, or a Christian who supports a state that favours no religion. If we use the wrong word we have already misheard her. This lecture is a map of the words, drawn so that a neighbour would say, "Yes, that is what I mean."
This lecture does not argue for or against any of these positions. The strongest arguments of secular neighbours come in lecture 5-2.
이 19분으로 얻는 것
- Distinguish secularisation (a change in society), secularism (a principle about the state) and secular humanism (a way of life).
- Distinguish atheism from agnosticism, and both from "spiritual but not religious".
- Explain why the same word can mean different things to different people, and how to ask a neighbour what she means.
- Read Psalm 14:1 with care, and say what it does not claim about every person who does not believe.
- Describe in a few sentences how a thoughtful secular neighbour might speak of meaning, morals and community.
The fool has said in his heart, “There is no God.” They are corrupt. They have done abominable works. There is no one who does good." — Psalm 14:1
World English Bible
having good behavior among the nations, so in that of which they speak against you as evildoers, they may by your good works, which they see, glorify God in the day of visitation." — 1 Peter 2:12
WEB
Psalm 14:1 is often quoted about atheists, and it needs a careful reading, which we give below. First Peter 2:12 speaks to Christians who were spoken against by their neighbours. It does not say that they should win an argument. It says that good conduct, seen by others, speaks for itself. That is the spirit in which this week is written.
1. Why a map of words comes first
Words carry a history. When a neighbour says, "I am not religious", she may mean that she does not go to a place of worship, or that she does not pray, or that she does not believe in any god, or that she believes in something but dislikes organisations. These are different things. If we hear them all as "she is against God", we have made a caricature before she has finished her sentence. Lecture 1-2 gave the test: would a thoughtful member say, "Yes, that is us"?
So we begin by sorting the words. The sorting is not exact, because real people mix the categories. But a rough map is better than none.
2. Secularisation: a change in society
Secularisation is a word for change over time. It describes the way religion's place in a society changes: how much of public life, education, care of the sick, law and ordinary custom is shaped by religious institutions, and how much is not. Scholars who study it do not agree. Some say it is a single large process that follows modern life wherever it spreads. Others say it looks very different in different places, that it goes forward in one place and backward in another, and that in many parts of the world religion has grown stronger and not weaker in public life. You do not need to settle this. You need to know that "secularisation" names a social change, and that it is a description, not a person. No one is a secularisation.
3. Secularism: a principle about the state
Secularism, in its most common meaning, is a principle about how public institutions treat religion. The idea is that the state, the courts and public schools should not be run on behalf of one religion, and that people of every faith and of none should be treated alike under the law. This is a claim about government, not about whether God exists.
This matters because many people who hold this principle are themselves religious. Believers who live as a minority have often asked for it, because a state that favours another group's religion may not protect theirs. At the same time, versions of secularism differ. In some places it means that public institutions stay neutral and religion may be freely seen and heard in public life. In other places it has meant that religion is kept out of public view, or has been used by a government to control and limit believers. Christians have lived under both kinds, and their experiences differ.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that a state neutral among religions is a good gift: it protects conscience, it guards minorities, and it keeps the church from being used by rulers. Some, including Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant voices, hold that no public life is truly neutral, that a state which excludes religious reasoning from public debate has quietly adopted a world view of its own, and that believers are then asked to speak in a borrowed language. Both views have a weakness. The first can overlook the way a "neutral" arrangement may in practice favour a particular outlook. The second can overlook the way that an arrangement which favours one religion usually hurts the religions that are not favoured, including some Christians. This course requires only that you can say each view fairly and that you do not call a neighbour an enemy of faith because she holds a principle that many Christians themselves hold. This course does not discuss any country's laws or any party.
4. Secular humanism: a way of life
Secular humanism names a way of living and of thinking about right and wrong without appeal to a god. A person who holds it would typically say something like this: "Human beings can find out what is true by evidence and reason. We can work out how to treat one another from our shared experience, our sympathy for others and our concern for their wellbeing. Life has meaning because of the people we love, the work we do and the world we leave. We do not need a god for this, and we try to live honestly and kindly." Many humanists hold that this is not a loss but a responsibility: since there is no one else to put things right, the work is ours.
Notice what this description does. It does not say "humanists have no morals" or "humanists have no meaning". A neighbour who held it would not recognise such a sentence. Some humanists gather in communities, hold ceremonies for births, marriages and funerals, and give time to the poor and the sick. We do not need to agree with their world view to describe it correctly. In Christian understanding, such a way of life shows something of the goodness that God has put into human beings; we come back to this in lecture 5-3.
5. Atheism and agnosticism
Atheism is the view that there is no God, or no gods. Some atheists state this as a firm conclusion. Others say only that they have seen no good reason to believe, and that they live without belief. Both are sometimes called atheists. Agnosticism is a word from the nineteenth century; it names the view that we cannot know whether there is a God, or that we do not know. An agnostic is not an atheist who is shy. Many agnostics hold that honesty requires them to say "I do not know", and they mean it.
It is also worth noting that atheists are a mixed company. Some have a kind of reverence for the world, for human life, or for nature, and would not call it religion. Some are angry at harm done in the name of faith. Some are indifferent, and the question simply does not trouble them. Some are sad about it. A good question to ask is not "Why do you not believe?" which can sound like a challenge, but "How did you come to see it as you do?" which invites a story.
6. Spiritual but not religious, and the people between
A large group of neighbours would not call themselves atheists at all. Some say they are "spiritual but not religious": they sense something larger than themselves, they may pray in their own way or value silence, nature or art, but they do not belong to a community or accept a creed. Others belong without believing: they keep a family tradition, attend a festival or a funeral, and feel part of a community, but would not say they believe its teaching. Others believe in a God but have no wish to be part of an organisation. Scholars sometimes describe these people as "unaffiliated", which means only that they are not attached to a religious body. This word tells us nothing about what they believe.
Because the group is so mixed, we should be careful not to count anyone as "against us". A neighbour in this group may be closer to a church than we suppose, or farther. The only way to know is to ask, and to listen.
7. Psalm 14:1, read with care
Psalm 14:1 is often used against atheists, and it needs to be read slowly. Three things help.
First, the word translated "fool" in the Hebrew wisdom writings is mostly a moral word, not an intellectual one. A fool in the Psalms is not a person who has failed an examination; it is a person who lives as if no one will ever call him to account. The same verse goes on to describe corruption and wrong deeds. The psalm is about how a person acts when he thinks he is not seen.
Second, the verse says that the fool speaks "in his heart". It describes a hidden attitude of practical disregard, not the open statement of a person who has thought a problem through and reached a different conclusion. Many readers hold that the psalm describes what we would call a practical atheism, which can be found among people who say they believe.
Third, the verse does not describe a particular neighbour. A psalm is a prayer and a poem, not a character reference. To quote it to a thoughtful atheist who gives her life to the care of others, as if it said everything about her, would be to misuse it. It would also be a false witness, which the commandment forbids (Exodus 20:16). The lecture does not say that Christians must think nothing is at stake in what a person believes about God. It says that this verse cannot be turned into a verdict on every person who does not believe.
(a note on method: scholars of Hebrew differ on fine points of this verse, and a reader who wants more should consult a commentary.)
8. What Christians have to learn here
First Peter 2:12 was written to people who were misjudged and spoken against. The advice is to live so that the charge looks false. That cuts both ways. Secular neighbours have often been misjudged by Christians, who have said that without God a person cannot be good. Many secular neighbours have been hurt by Christians who showed contempt, who treated them as lost causes, or who used a friendship as a means to win. We are also asked to remember that Christians have at times used power to silence people who doubted or who dissented, and that this history is part of what some secular neighbours remember when they hear a Christian speak.
Honesty about this does not mean that a Christian must agree with a secular world view. In Christian understanding, the gospel is good news for every person, and Christians hope that their neighbours may come to know Christ. But the first duty of love is to hear the neighbour truly. The map in this lecture is meant to help with that: it lets us ask a better question than "Do you believe in God?"
Diagram 1. A map of words
핵심 요약
- Secularisation is a change in society; secularism is a principle about the state; secular humanism is a way of life.
- Atheism says there is no God; agnosticism says we do not know; many people hold neither word.
- Belief and belonging come apart: some believe without belonging, some belong without believing.
- The state-principle called secularism is held by believers and non-believers, and Christians differ on it.
- Psalm 14:1 speaks of a moral fool, and cannot be turned into a verdict on every unbelieving neighbour.
- Ask a neighbour what she means by her word before you answer her.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Secularisation | A change in society: the place of religion in public life shifts over time. |
| Secularism | A principle that the state and public institutions serve no single religion. |
| Secular humanism | A way of life that finds goodness and meaning without appeal to a god. |
| Psalm 14:1 | The "fool" is a moral word: one who lives as if no one will call him to account. |
One sentence to remember Before answering a neighbour, ask what she means by the word she uses.
This week's action Write down three words you use for people without religion, and beside each write what a thoughtful neighbour might mean by it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the six words on the map have you used loosely? What did you mean, and how might a neighbour have heard it?
- Why is it a mistake to think that someone who supports a state neutral among religions must be against faith?
- Read Psalm 14:1 again. Why does it matter that "fool" is mainly a moral word in the Hebrew wisdom writings?
- What is the difference between asking "Why do you not believe?" and asking "How did you come to see it as you do?"
- Think of a neighbour who is "spiritual but not religious". What might she hope for from a church, and what might she fear?