Lecture 6-1: Exclusivism, Inclusivism, Pluralism: Reasons and Weaknesses
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Study Our Neighbours' Faiths?
- Lecture 1-2: Listening First: The Best Form of a Faith
- Lecture 1-3: A Map of Christian Responses
- Lecture 1-4: Walking Beside Neighbours: Habits of a Fair Listener
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Rewriting a Description Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: The Qur'an, the Sunnah and the Prophet
- Lecture 2-2: God, the Prophets and Jesus
- Lecture 2-3: The Way of Life and Inner Diversity
- Lecture 2-4: Living Beside Muslim Neighbours
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Muslim Neighbour
- Lecture 3-1: The Buddha's Path and the Four Noble Truths
- Lecture 3-2: No-self, Dependent Arising, Karma and Nirvana
- Lecture 3-3: Theravada, Mahayana, Zen and Pure Land: One Tradition, Many Ways
- Lecture 3-4: Compassion, Meditation and Christian Neighbours
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Buddhist Neighbour
- Lecture 4-1: What "Hinduism" Names
- Lecture 4-2: Rebirth, Karma and Liberation
- Lecture 4-3: Devotion, Daily Life and Hard Questions
- Lecture 4-4: Living Beside Hindu Neighbours
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Hindu Neighbour
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Words: Secular, Atheist, Humanist
- Lecture 5-2: The Argument over Evidence: The Strongest Case
- Lecture 5-3: Science, Meaning and Morals
- Lecture 5-4: Doubt, Honesty and Friendship
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Understanding a Secular Neighbour
In lecture 1-3 we drew a map of Christian responses to other faiths. We used it as a map to carry, not a place to live. In the weeks since, you have listened to Muslim, Buddhist, Hindu and secular neighbours as they describe themselves. Now we return to the map with more knowledge, and ask the question the course was heading toward: what does Christian theology say about people of other faiths, and why?
The academic name for this work is the theology of religions. It asks what Christians should believe about the religions of others, in the light of Christ, Scripture and the church's history. This lecture sets out three well-known types of answer, called exclusivism, inclusivism and pluralism, with their subtypes. For each we give the reasons its holders offer, in the form they would recognise, and then the weakness that other Christians point to. We do not choose a winner.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Define exclusivism, inclusivism and pluralism, and name at least one subtype of each.
- State the main biblical and theological reasons offered for each type, in a form its holders would accept.
- State the main weakness that critics find in each type.
- Describe how the Catholic Church, Orthodox Christians and the Protestant streams stand in relation to the map, without forcing any of them into one box.
- Explain why a map of scholars' types is not a list of denominations.
There is salvation in none other, for neither is there any other name under heaven, that is given among men, by which we must be saved!” — Acts 4:12
World English Bible
(for when Gentiles who don’t have the law do by nature the things of the law, these, not having the law, are a law to themselves, in that they show the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience testifying with them, and their thoughts among themselves accusing or else excusing them) in the day when God will judge the secrets of men, according to my Good News, by Jesus Christ." — Romans 2:14-16
WEB
I have other sheep, which are not of this fold. I must bring them also, and they will hear my voice. They will become one flock with one shepherd." — John 10:16
WEB
Peter opened his mouth and said, “Truly I perceive that God doesn’t show favoritism; but in every nation he who fears him and works righteousness is acceptable to him." — Acts 10:34-35
WEB
The first verse is the one most often quoted for exclusivism. The second and fourth are often quoted for inclusivism, because they speak of people outside the being known and accepted by God. The third is read in several ways, and we shall see that. No single verse settles the matter; each type reads the whole of Scripture and gives these verses a place in it.
1. What the map is, and what it is not
The three words come from scholars who tried to sort the many Christian answers into families. The sorting is useful, because it shows which question is being asked. The question behind all three is this: Is Jesus Christ necessary for a person to be saved, and if so, must that person know Christ and believe in him in this life?
Notice what the map is not. It is not a list of churches. Nobody is born an "inclusivist". A Reformed pastor, a Catholic priest, an Orthodox monk and a Pentecostal teacher might each, for different reasons, be hard to fit into one box, and each would say that they follow Scripture and the church's teaching, not a scholar's label. The map is also not a ladder, with a good type at the top. We shall give each type fair space, and its weakness too.
A second warning. The map answers a salvation question. It does not tell you how to treat a neighbour. A person of any of the three types can be kind or unkind. Lecture 6-3 turns to behaviour.
2. Exclusivism: salvation only through explicit faith in Christ
What it holds. Exclusivism says that salvation comes only through Jesus Christ, and that a person is saved through hearing the gospel and responding in faith to him in this life. Other religions, in this view, are not paths to God. They may hold real insight about the world, but they do not carry people to salvation.
Its reasons. Holders point to Acts 4:12 (salvation in no other name) and John 14:6 (no one comes to the Father except through Jesus), which we take up in lecture 6-2. They point to Romans 10:14-17, where Paul asks how people can call on one they have not heard, and how they can hear without someone preaching. They draw from this the urgency of the church's mission. Many also stress that all people, in Paul's argument in Romans 1 to 3, stand under sin and need the rescue that Christ gives. Some add that the Bible's pictures of final judgement are serious, and that a church that softened them would be less than truthful.
Exclusivism comes in several forms. Here are three, in outline:
- Church-centred exclusivism. The church is the community through which salvation comes, and to be outside it is to be outside salvation. Some Christians in older centuries put it this way, and the saying "outside the church there is no salvation" has a long history. Most Christian bodies today who use the saying explain it in ways we shall note below.
- Christ-centred, gospel-requiring exclusivism. Salvation is by , received by faith, and faith comes by hearing. Many Evangelical, Reformed, Lutheran and Pentecostal Christians hold this view, and many of them state it with great sadness about those who have not heard.
- Particularist exclusivism. A scholars' term for views that stress that God's saving work is tied to particular events and a particular history (Israel, Christ, the church), and so cannot be spread across all religions.
Its weakness, as critics see it. Critics raise three. First, it seems to place the eternal destiny of most people who have ever lived in the hands of an accident of birth: someone born where the gospel never came. Holders reply with various answers, from "God is just and we leave those people to him" to a strong call to take the gospel to them, but critics say the difficulty remains. Second, critics ask what Romans 2:14-16 and Acts 10:34-35 mean if no one outside the explicit faith can be accepted by God. Third, critics say that exclusivism has too often become a reason for contempt rather than for love. Holders of the view often agree that this is a real danger in church history and call for repentance of it.
3. Inclusivism: Christ is the only Saviour, but his saving work may reach beyond the church's knowledge
What it holds. Inclusivism says two things together. Salvation comes only through Christ, and God's saving grace in Christ may reach people who have not heard of him or have not been able to believe. The name "inclusive" refers to this: Christ's work includes people who never explicitly knew him.
Its reasons. Holders point to Romans 2:14-16, where Paul says that Gentiles without the law show the work of the law written in their hearts, and to Acts 10:34-35, where Peter says that God accepts those in every nation who fear him and do what is right. They point to 1 Timothy 2:4, where God desires all people to be saved, and to the justice of God asked about in Genesis 18:25, whether the Judge of all the earth will do right. Some point to John 10:16, where Jesus speaks of "other sheep" not of this fold, and say that the verse leaves a door open, though readers differ on whom those sheep are. Many point to the old Christian teaching, going back at least to the second-century writer Justin Martyr, that the eternal Word, who became flesh in Jesus, had sown "seeds" of truth among peoples before Jesus came.
Inclusivism has several forms as well:
- The Catholic way. The Catholic Church teaches that Jesus Christ is the one Saviour and that the church is necessary for salvation. It also teaches, in the council document Lumen Gentium (1964), that those who through no fault of their own do not know the gospel or the church, but sincerely seek God and try to do his will as they know it through conscience, can be saved by God's grace. In Nostra Aetate (1965) the Church said it rejects nothing that is true and holy in other religions. The Church describes these as teachings about God's grace, not as a claim that other religions are equal paths. Some theologians within the Catholic tradition have gone further than the Church's official wording. One well-known twentieth-century example, Karl Rahner, spoke of "anonymous Christians", people who live by grace in Christ without knowing his name. Other Catholics, and many from other traditions, have objected to that phrase as unfair to those who do not wish to be called Christians.
- The wider-hope way, among some Protestants. Some Evangelical and other Protestant writers argue that God may grant salvation in Christ to people who have not heard the gospel, by faith in the God they know as far as they know him, while holding that Christ alone is the ground of salvation. Others say that those who have not heard may be given an opportunity at or after death. This last idea is disputed among Protestants, and many reject it.
- The Orthodox perspectives. Orthodox Christians vary here, and it would be a mistake to give a single Orthodox answer. Many stress that the Church is the place where Christ is known and the sacraments are given, and say that where salvation happens outside the visible Church is not for us to say; it belongs to God's mercy. Many Orthodox writers also honour the early teaching about the Word's seeds in all peoples. Some Orthodox writers have hoped that in the end all will be saved, and others reject that hope. Ask an Orthodox teacher before you speak for the Orthodox.
Its weakness, as critics see it. Critics from the exclusivist side say that inclusivism weakens the urgency of mission and the clear words of Acts 4:12 and John 14:6. If people may be saved without hearing, they ask, why risk everything to take the gospel? Inclusivists reply that mission is not driven only by fear for the lost but by love, by obedience to Christ's command, and by the joy of knowing him. Critics from the pluralist side say that inclusivism is still a kind of claim to own the truth: Christ is the answer, and all others are saved "in spite of themselves". A Muslim or Buddhist neighbour may feel this as a polite insult, and may ask not to be told they are saved by Christ against their own understanding. Inclusivists reply that Christians cannot say anything else and still be Christians, but they should say it with tact and not claim more than they know.
4. Pluralism: many religions as ways to the Divine
What it holds. Pluralism, in the scholars' sense, says that the great religions are different responses to one ultimate Reality, and that salvation or liberation is found in each. Jesus Christ is then understood as a decisive revelation of God for Christians, but not the only one. The best-known philosophical statement of this view in the twentieth century came from John Hick, who compared the change he proposed to the move from an earth-centred to a sun-centred picture of the heavens: the religions are like planets circling the one Reality, and Christianity is not the centre they circle.
Its reasons. Holders start from God's love for all people (1 Timothy 2:4 again), from the plain fact that sincere and holy people appear in every tradition, from the way a person's religion usually follows the place of birth, and from the history of Christian violence and arrogance, which they take as a warning against claiming too much. Some pluralists are motivated by experience of the holiness of Muslim, Buddhist, Hindu or other friends. Some Christian pluralists remain committed to Jesus as their own way, and say that only humility forbids them from saying that others cannot also have a way.
There are subtypes. One centres on the divine Reality which religions approach in different words. Another centres on the results: what changes lives toward compassion and justice, wherever it appears. A third speaks of mutual transformation, where each tradition is changed by honest meeting with the others and no one tries to rank them in advance.
Its weakness, as critics see it. Critics raise three. First, pluralism seems to require leaving behind what the New Testament and the creeds say about Christ: that he is Son of God, that he is the unique mediator, that he died and rose for the world. Critics say that what is left is no longer the Christian faith. Second, say critics, pluralism claims a view from above all religions, as if one could stand outside them and see that they are all the same. Muslim, Buddhist and Hindu thinkers often reject the claim, because their traditions do not say they are different words for the same thing. Pluralism, critics say, quietly makes itself a super-religion that overrides each tradition's own self-understanding. This is a weighty point, since the whole of this course asked us to take each tradition on its own terms. Third, critics say that the claim "all religions are equally valid" cannot be proved, and that some beliefs and practices in some traditions, as in some Christian history, deserve to be called harmful. Pluralists reply by distinguishing a religion's core from its failures.
5. Where the church traditions stand
It helps to place the three traditions of this course's readers on the map, in their own terms, and not in a way that boxes them.
Catholic. As above: Christ alone saves, the Church is necessary, and grace is not bound by the church's boundary. This is an inclusive teaching in the scholars' sense, though the Church would not use the word for itself. It firmly rejects the pluralist claim that all religions are equal ways, and it also rejects any contempt for others.
Orthodox. The Church is the place where Christ is known in fullness. Beyond its visible border the Orthodox usually speak with reserve: it is for God, not for us, to judge. Different writers lean in different ways.
Protestant. There is a wide range. Reformed and Lutheran Christians often stress salvation by grace through faith in Christ, with strong attention to the Word heard. Pentecostal and Evangelical Christians often stress the cross, and mission. Many in all these streams hold the exclusivist reading; a number hold the wider-hope reading; a smaller number hold pluralism. Within each stream, there are arguments. Do not assume what a person holds from the name of their church.
6. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. Exclusivists, inclusivists and pluralists all read the Bible, all love Christ, and all feel the weight of the question. The exclusivist asks: how can we be faithful to Christ's own words and to the urgency of the gospel if we say that salvation is available without him being known? The inclusivist asks: how can we be faithful to a just and loving God if we say that people who never heard are simply lost? The pluralist asks: how can we be faithful to God's love and to the evidence of holiness around us if we say that only one religion carries people to God?
Each question is honest, and each answer has the weakness set out above. The course does not choose among them. What the course requires is smaller, and it is something on which exclusivists, inclusivists and pluralists can agree: that we describe our neighbours' faiths accurately, that we do not claim to know more than we know about anyone's final end, and that we treat every person as someone for whom Christ cares, whatever we think about their way.
7. Using the map well
Three habits keep the map honest. First, ask a person what they believe before you label it. Second, remember that people move between types as they learn, and that most believers hold their view with some uncertainty. Third, notice that the three types share more than their arguments suggest. All three say that God is just and loving, and all three agree that Christ matters. Their quarrel is over how to hold two things together: the Bible's strong claims about Christ, and the Bible's strong claims about God's mercy.
Diagram 1. The map, with a reason and a weakness for each type
핵심 요약
- The theology of religions asks what Christians should believe about the religions of others, in the light of Christ.
- Exclusivism holds that salvation is through Christ, received by faith heard in this life; critics ask about those who never heard.
- Inclusivism holds that Christ alone saves but his grace may reach beyond those who know his name; critics ask about urgency and ownership of truth.
- Pluralism holds that the great religions are ways to one Reality; critics say it leaves the creeds and claims a view above all religions.
- The map is a scholars' tool, not a list of churches; Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant positions each need to be heard in their own words.
- The course requires accuracy about neighbours and honesty about what we do not know, not agreement with one type.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Exclusivism | Salvation only through Christ, by hearing and faith in this life. Weakness, say critics: those who never heard. |
| Inclusivism | Christ alone saves, and his grace may reach people who do not know his name. Weakness, say critics: urgency of mission, and a claim to own the truth. |
| Pluralism | The great religions are ways to one Reality. Weakness, say critics: it leaves the creeds and speaks from above all religions. |
| Is the map a list of churches? | No. It is a scholars' tool; each church must be heard in its own words. |
One sentence to remember Each type answers an honest question and has a real weakness, so state each fairly before you judge any.
This week's action Write one paragraph describing a type you disagree with in words a thoughtful holder would accept, then ask whether you were fair.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the three types was easiest for you to state fairly, and which was hardest? What does that tell you about where you start?
- In your own church tradition, how is the question of those who have not heard the gospel usually answered? Is it answered clearly, or left unspoken?
- Why is it a mistake to treat the map as a list of denominations?
- Take the weakness that critics find in the type you are least drawn to. Is it a fair criticism? How would a holder of that type answer it?
- What do all three types share? How might that shared ground shape how you speak with a neighbour of another faith?