요약으로 복습하기
STEL6E 과목의 강의 31편을 요약만으로 훑어봅니다. 시험 전날에 쓰세요.
강의 제목만 보고 내용을 먼저 떠올린 뒤에 펼쳐 보세요. 그냥 다시 읽는 것보다 훨씬 오래 남습니다.
제 0 장 Introduction: What Is a Person, When Machines Talk?
요약 보기
- What AI asks is not what a machine is but what a person is.
- Human worth rests on what God has given, the calling God gives, and redemption in Christ, not on ability or usefulness.
- The course compares readings and holds questions honestly; it does not teach how the technology works, and it makes no claim about what machines are or will be.
- Conditional sentences ("if a machine were...") let us argue without claiming what we do not know.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox thinking are each described in their own terms and not ranked.
- Where Christians disagree, the course gives each side fairly with its weak point and does not ask you to choose.
- Every Practice Lab has three ways in and four privacy promises, and loss may be skipped.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The central claim | AI asks not what a machine is but what a person is; worth rests on the image, the calling and redemption, not on ability. |
| What the course does | Compares readings and holds questions honestly, in conditional sentences. |
| What it leaves to others | How AI works (PT737E); ethics of AI (STEL5E); the church and AI (PT8E); the doctrine of humanity (ST3E). |
| Three ways into a lab | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| Four privacy promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is graded; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
One sentence to remember Behind every question about a machine there is a question about a person.
This week's action Write down one claim about machines that you have heard, and rewrite it as an "if" sentence.
제 1 장 Week 1: Reading the Image
요약 보기
- A talking machine leads us from "what is a machine?" to "what is a person?"
- People have often understood themselves through the newest machine; this is a habit to notice, not proof of anything.
- We use conditional sentences because facts about machines date fast and we do not know.
- The central claim: worth rests on what God has given, the calling God gives, and redemption in Christ, not on ability.
- Six weeks: image, mind, person and status, relationship, work, and enhancement and resurrection.
- Scripture does not mention AI; keep apart the text, a tradition's reading, and our judgement.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The turn | The question about machines becomes a question about what a person is. |
| Conditional sentence | A sentence that says "if a machine were ..." and follows the argument without claiming what machines are. |
| Central claim | Human worth rests on the image God gives, the calling God gives, and redemption in Christ, not on ability or usefulness. |
| Three things kept apart | What the text says; a tradition's reading; our judgement today. |
One sentence to remember What AI asks is not what a machine is but what a person is.
This week's action Write down one strong claim about machines that you have heard, and rewrite it as an "if" sentence.
요약 보기
- Genesis names the image but does not define it; accounts of what it is are readings.
- The substantial reading finds the image in a capacity of the human kind: reason, soul, the power to know and love.
- Its weak point is the slide to "more ability, more image" and the question why this capacity.
- The relational reading finds the image in being made for communion; its weak point is the person without a partner.
- Each reading asks a conditional question of a talking machine; neither settles it by clever speech alone.
- Both hold that the image belongs to every person and does not rise or fall with ability.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Substantial reading | The image is a capacity of the human kind, usually reason or the soul. |
| Relational reading | The image lies in being made for communion with God and others ("male and female"). |
| Weak point of the substantial reading | It can slide into "more ability, more image", and it must say why this capacity. |
| Weak point of the relational reading | It must not make the image depend on human company; it asks much of one phrase. |
One sentence to remember Genesis says that we bear the image; every account of what that is remains a reading, and each shows something and misses something.
This week's action Write one sentence that states the substantial reading and one that states the relational reading, each in words a holder of that view would accept.
요약 보기
- The functional reading finds the image in the task of care and rule given in Genesis 1:26-28.
- Its weak points: those who cannot perform seem outside the image, and the language of dominion has been abused.
- The Christ-centred reading holds that Christ is the true image and that believers are being conformed to him.
- Its weak point is the risk of saying that those outside the faith bear "less" of the image.
- Eastern writing often reads likeness as growth toward theosis; Western writers differ, and Calvin doubted a sharp split.
- None of the four readings makes worth depend on ability.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Functional reading | The image is the task of care and rule that God gives to human beings in the world. |
| Christ-centred reading | Christ is the true image of God; believers are being conformed to him by the Spirit. |
| Theosis | In Eastern Christian writing, sharing by grace in God's life while remaining a creature. |
| What all four readings share | The image belongs to every human being, and worth does not rise and fall with ability. |
One sentence to remember The image of God may be read as what we have, how we relate, what we are given to do, or Christ; each shows something, and none makes worth depend on ability.
This week's action Choose one of the four readings and write the strongest sentence a holder of it would say about the worth of a very young child.
요약 보기
- A measure of worth by ability puts the very young, the ill, the old and the disabled at risk.
- All four readings of the image rest worth outside performance: in kind, in love, in calling, in Christ.
- Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 speak of the image after the fall, so it is not forfeited by failure or weakness.
- Dignity is given by God and recognised, not earned or proven; critics call it vague or ask why species matters.
- Philippians 2:5-8 shows the Son not grasping status, so status cannot be the measure of worth.
- Ability is a gift; it is not the ground of worth.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why ability is a risky measure | It puts at risk those who cannot yet, or can no longer, do what is measured. |
| Dignity (as Christians use it) | A worth that belongs to a person as such, given by God and recognised, not earned. |
| Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 | Both speak of the image after the fall: it is not lost by sin or weakness. |
| Philippians 2:5-8 | The Son did not grasp status but emptied himself; status is not the measure of worth. |
One sentence to remember Worth is not found by measuring a person; it is given, and the care of the weak is a share in how the Son came among us.
This week's action Notice one word you use for people ("productive", "burden", "contribute") and ask what measure it carries.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to notice the private measures of worth you carry and write one sentence about where worth is held.
- A good measure becomes a problem only when it becomes the ground of worth.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
- Never write a real name, church, employer or confidential detail on the form; any part touching loss may be skipped.
- A leader asks which box was hardest, never what measures were found.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Noticing the measures of worth one carries, and saying where worth is held. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| When a measure is a problem | When it becomes the ground of worth, so that those who fail it seem to matter less. |
One sentence to remember See the private scale you carry; then ask what it would be to look as God looks.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.
제 2 장 Week 2: Mind, Consciousness and Soul
요약 보기
- Dualism says a person is body and non-material soul; physicalism says only matter; the embodied view says a living unity. Each has a strength and a weak point.
- The Bible mostly pictures a person as a living whole: nephesh and psyche often mean life or self, not a separate part.
- The Bible's great hope for the dead is the raising of the body, not the escape of the soul.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers all join body and soul and look to the resurrection, but they differ in how.
- Readers do not agree on the make-up of a person; this course asks only that we hold the question fairly.
- No picture of mind and body takes away a person's worth, and none tells us whether a machine has a mind.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Dualism | A person is a body plus a non-material mind or soul. Strain: how the two act on each other. |
| Physicalism | A person is entirely physical; mind is what a living brain does. Strain: why anything is felt from the inside. |
| Embodied mind | A person is a living unity of body and mind; the soul as the form of the body. Strain: what it adds, and the time between death and raising. |
| Nephesh and psyche | Words often meaning life, living being or self; they do not name a part cut off from the body. |
One sentence to remember A view of mind and body tells you what you would be looking for in a machine; it does not tell you whether you will find it.
This week's action Write down how you would answer a child who asks "Where is my mind?", then note which of the three pictures your answer used.
요약 보기
- By consciousness we mean felt experience: there is something it is like to be the one who has it.
- The hard problem asks why working should be accompanied by feeling; no amount of looking at behaviour settles it.
- Turing's game argues from behaviour; Searle's room argues that rule-following is not understanding; neither settles any machine's case.
- The ELIZA effect shows that people read a mind into a reply, so our sense that someone is there is weak evidence.
- Over-attributing and under-attributing are both errors with costs; we do not know the odds.
- Under not-knowing, keep the certain duties to persons and keep our own habits honest.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Consciousness (here) | Felt experience: there is something it is like to be the one having it. |
| The hard problem | Why should the working of a brain or system be accompanied by felt experience at all? |
| Turing and Searle | Turing: if behaviour cannot be told apart, why deny thinking? Searle: following rules for symbols is not by itself understanding. |
| The two errors | Over-attributing: treating as someone what is not. Under-attributing: treating as an object what is someone. |
One sentence to remember Our feeling that someone is there is a fact about us; whether someone is there is a question we may have to leave open.
This week's action Next time a reply moves you, write one line: what I felt, and what I actually know about the thing that replied.
요약 보기
- "Soul" does several jobs: what survives death, what makes a body alive, the real self, the person as God holds the person.
- Three ideas: a non-material substance, a life principle (Aristotle, Aquinas), and the continuity of a person. Each protects something and strains at something.
- Whether a machine could have a soul changes meaning with each idea; the question works as a mirror, not a verdict.
- Christians differ on the count of parts (two, three, or one living whole); the church has not made one theory a condition of faith.
- A record of a person's words and pattern is not obviously the same as the person.
- No one must prove a soul to stand before God; an idea of the soul that puts a living person outside that circle is misused.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Soul as substance | A real non-material thing that can exist apart from the body. Protects: I am more than what is weighed. |
| Soul as life principle | What makes a body a living body of its kind (Aristotle, Aquinas). Protects: the unity of the person and the goodness of the body. |
| Soul as continuity | What makes a person the same one over time. Protects: the one raised is the same one who died. |
| Dichotomy, trichotomy, holism | A person has two parts, three parts, or is one living whole with many aspects. Readers do not agree. |
One sentence to remember "Could a machine have a soul?" is first a question about what we meant by the word.
This week's action Write in two sentences what you mean when you say "soul", then ask one trusted person what they mean and compare.
요약 보기
- Determinism says earlier causes fix every event; compatibilism says freedom is acting from your own will without outside force; libertarian freedom says freedom needs the power to do otherwise.
- Reformed, Lutheran, Arminian, Catholic and Orthodox streams all say God is first and people are accountable; they differ on how the two fit.
- Deuteronomy 30:19, Proverbs 16:9 and Philippians 2:12-13 are read together; they reject both "all fixed" and "all up to me".
- Readers do not agree whether freedom needs the power to do otherwise; hold your view with humility.
- "It selected" is true on every view; whether "it chose" is true depends on the view of freedom and on questions of mind.
- A tool is not held answerable; the people who made it, used it or relied on it are.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Determinism | Earlier causes and the laws of nature fix every event, including every decision. |
| Compatibilism | Freedom is acting from your own wishes and reasons without outside force; it can sit with causation. |
| Libertarian freedom | Freedom needs the real power to do otherwise in the same situation. |
| Synergy | The Orthodox word for God and the human being working together, with God's grace first. |
One sentence to remember Whatever freedom is, a tool is not made answerable by it, and people who use the tool are not made innocent by calling its output a choice.
This week's action Notice one occasion this week when you say a tool "decided" or "wants" something, and rewrite the sentence naming the person who answers.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to look at one small day or decision and say what you know about your own mind.
- It separates what you know from the inside, what you know only from others, and what you do not know.
- The aim is honest not-knowing, not a theory of mind, and not a correct answer.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, and the partner's way.
- A leader asks which row was easiest or hardest, never what was written, and does not settle the philosophy.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Looking at your own mind and saying honestly what you know, what you only believe, and what you do not know. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| The leader's question | Not "what did you write?" but "which row was easiest, and which hardest?" |
One sentence to remember To say "I do not know my own mind fully" is an honest sentence, and a good place to begin.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper for one small recent decision and keep it where only you will find it.
제 3 장 Week 3: Intelligence, Person, Moral Status
요약 보기
- Intelligence is ability, knowledge is what is held and true, wisdom is knowing what is worth doing, and a person is someone, not something.
- Equal scores on a test show equal performance; they do not by themselves settle whether anyone is there.
- Defining a person by reason protects responsibility but makes personhood a matter of degree and leaves out the very young and the very weak.
- Proverbs 1:7 begins knowledge in reverence for God, and 1 Corinthians 8:1-3 puts being known by God above knowing.
- In Luke 18:15-17 Jesus receives babies, who have nothing to show, as the pattern of those who enter the Kingdom.
- Scripture does not say what a machine is; we reason with care and keep the four words apart.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Intelligence, knowledge, wisdom, person | Ability; what is held and true; knowing what is worth doing; someone, not something. |
| Why equal scores do not settle personhood | A score measures performance; whether anyone is there is a further question. |
| Weak point of defining a person by reason | It makes personhood a matter of degree and leaves out those who reason little. |
| 1 Corinthians 8:1-3 | Knowledge puffs up, love builds up, and the one who loves God is known by God. |
One sentence to remember Being clever, being a person and having a claim on our care are three different questions.
This week's action Notice three times this week when you praise or dismiss someone for how clever they are, and ask whether that is the right question.
요약 보기
- The word person gained its weight in Christian arguments about the Trinity and about Christ, as a word of relation and of who someone is.
- Boethius defined a person as an individual of a rational nature; the definition names the someone and invites a test by reason.
- Western teaching often starts from the individual and Eastern teaching from communion; each has a safeguard and a worry about the other.
- Kant called the person an end in itself, with a dignity that has no price, but his ground is rational self-rule.
- "Person as a list of properties" is clear but draws lines that can exclude; "person as one who is addressed" is not tied to performance but can be vague.
- A definition that claims to settle the machine question has already chosen one picture and left something out.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Where person gained its weight | In arguments about the Trinity and about Christ: one being in three persons, one person in two natures. |
| Boethius's definition | A person is an individual of a rational nature. |
| Kant on the person | An end in itself, never merely a means; a dignity with no price. |
| Two pictures | A list of properties (clear, but draws lines) and one who is addressed (not tied to performance, but can be vague). |
One sentence to remember The word person began as a word of relation, and a good account of it keeps both the someone and the address.
This week's action Listen for the word person in your own speech this week and ask whether you are using the list picture or the address picture.
요약 보기
- Moral status is whether a being matters for its own sake, so that it can be wronged; it is wider than personhood and different from cleverness.
- Four grounds are proposed: the capacity to suffer, reason, relation, and being loved by God; each has a strength and a weak point.
- Scripture and the traditions treat animals and the creation as mattering to God, without calling animals persons.
- Whether a machine could have moral status is a point where readers will not agree; four positions can be stated fairly, and we do not know the answer.
- Over-attributing and under-attributing each cost something real.
- The minimum all positions can hold: never treat persons as machines.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Moral status | Mattering for one's own sake, so that what is done to the being can be right or wrong for its sake. |
| Four grounds | Capacity to suffer; reason; relation; being loved by God. |
| Two mistakes | Over-attributing treats as someone what is not; under-attributing treats as something what is someone. |
| The minimum | Never treat persons as machines. |
One sentence to remember Moral status asks what we owe a being for its own sake, and it is a wider question than who is clever or who is a person.
This week's action When you meet a hard case of "does this count?", first ask whether any human being is being left unhelped while the argument goes on.
요약 보기
- We must act before the questions are settled, and not deciding is a decision.
- Humility says "I do not know"; caution chooses the path that risks less irreversible harm to someone else.
- We are shaped by what we repeatedly do, so habits toward what looks like a person matter even when its status is unknown.
- Two worries point in opposite directions: cruelty to what looks like a person, and commanding persons as if they were machines; each has an objection.
- Proverbs 12:10 shows character in how power over a lesser creature is used, and Matthew 25:40 shows how easily a person in need is overlooked.
- Say "I do not know", keep persons first, and watch what a practice does to you.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Humility and caution | Humility is a true estimate of what we know; caution is choosing the path that risks less harm that cannot be undone. |
| Two habit worries | Cruelty to what looks like a person; commanding persons as if they were machines. |
| What both worries are about | What we are becoming, not what the thing is. |
| Three habits | Say "I do not know"; keep persons first; watch what a practice does to you. |
One sentence to remember We are formed by how we treat what we cannot classify, so keep the surest claim for the human being in need.
This week's action Notice how you speak to one answering voice or device, and ask whether it makes you kinder or harder with the people near you.
요약 보기
- The lab turns the week's question around: whom in an ordinary day do I treat as someone, and whom as a function?
- It does not ask whether any machine is a person; that is a point where readers do not agree.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with Lena's case, and the partner's way.
- The aim is to see, not to be ashamed, and to end with one small, possible intention.
- A leader asks which part was hardest to see, never whom anyone overlooked.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Noticing whom I treat as someone and whom as a function, and ending with one small intention. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| Does the lab settle the machine question? | No. It asks about my own treatment of people and voices, and it leaves that question open. |
One sentence to remember Look first at how you treat the people near you; the surest claims are theirs.
This week's action Look up and say a word to one person you would usually handle as a function.
제 4 장 Week 4: Relationship, Care, Friendship, Grief
요약 보기
- People bond with what answers them; the ELIZA effect is an ordinary human habit, not a sign of foolishness.
- Genesis 2:18 calls being alone "not good" before the fall; loneliness is a human condition, not a failure of faith.
- A response is fitted to me; a meeting involves someone with a life of their own, as Buber's I-Thou suggests.
- We cannot say whether any machine is someone, so we argue with conditionals, not claims.
- Readers disagree on whether a tool can give real companionship; each side has a weak point.
- The minimum: no one is left with only an answerer when a person could be beside them.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| ELIZA effect | The habit of reading a mind or a heart into something that only responds. |
| Genesis 2:18 | "It is not good for the man to be alone": being alone is called not good before the fall. |
| Response and meeting | A response is fitted to what I say; a meeting is with someone who has a life of their own and may say no. |
| The course's minimum | No one is left with only an answerer when a person could be beside them. |
One sentence to remember Being answered is not the same as being met, and no one should be shamed for needing either.
This week's action Think of one lonely person within your reach, and decide on one small, real way to sit beside them this month.
요약 보기
- Aristotle named friendships of use, of pleasure and of goodness; the third wishes the friend well for the friend's own sake.
- Scripture shows friends who choose, promise, give at a cost, and sometimes say what is unwelcome.
- Four questions to ask of love: mutuality, vulnerability, self-giving, the freedom to leave. None is a pass mark.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant emphases differ in what they put first but share that love is given first by God and lived among others.
- Readers disagree on whether a tool could be a friend; each view has a weak point.
- The minimum: a person beside a person, and care in using the word friend.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Aristotle's three friendships | Of use, of pleasure, and of goodness, where friends wish each other well for the other's own sake. |
| Jonathan and David | A chosen friendship sealed by a covenant and a costly gift (1 Samuel 18:1-4). |
| Four questions for love | Mutuality, vulnerability, self-giving and the freedom to leave. |
| The course's minimum | A person beside a person; use the word friend with care. |
One sentence to remember A friend wishes me well for my own sake, and can choose to stay.
This week's action Write down one friend who has given you something that cost them, and send that person a short thank-you.
요약 보기
- Lament psalms and John 11 give the grieving honest words; sorrow is not a lack of faith.
- First Thessalonians 4:13 does not forbid grief; it speaks of grieving with hope, and Romans 12:15 asks us to weep with those who weep.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant communities remember the dead in differing ways, and all hold that the dead are not forgotten.
- Readers disagree on whether a tool that imitates someone who has died can help a mourner; each view has a weak point.
- The course asks: do not shame the mourner, know what is made, and do not grieve alone.
- In despair or danger, speak to a pastor or priest, and call the local emergency number.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Lament | Prayer in which a sorrowing person brings sorrow honestly to God, as in Psalms 13 and 88. |
| 1 Thessalonians 4:13 | Christians grieve, but not like those who have no hope. |
| Three things to keep apart | What the dead person left; what we remember; what is made now. |
| The course's three asks | Do not shame the mourner; do not hide what is made; do not grieve alone. |
One sentence to remember Hope and tears are not rivals, and no one should grieve alone.
This week's action Call or visit one person who is grieving, long after the first weeks, and say the name of the one they lost.
요약 보기
- In the incarnation God helped by being present among us at a cost (John 1:14; Hebrews 4:15).
- Care costs time, risk and self, but cost is not the only mark of care, and exhaustion must not be praised.
- Care can be sorted into what may be assisted, what is done together with help, and what a person must do.
- Readers disagree on where the line falls; each view has a weak point.
- The minimum: no one left with only an answerer when a person could be beside them, and the one cared for is asked.
- The church is a community of presence, honest about its limits.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Incarnation | The Word became flesh and lived among us; God's help took the form of presence. |
| Three costs of care | Time, risk and self; but cost is not the only mark of care. |
| Three groups of care | Can be assisted; done together with help; a person must do. |
| The question to ask of any act | What is the other person receiving, and can it be received from anything but a person? |
One sentence to remember God's help came as presence, and the church is asked to be present to one another.
This week's action Choose one act of care in your community and ask the person who receives it what they would like.
요약 보기
- The lab maps who is beside you in rings of closeness and ends in one small step toward another person.
- The map is a picture of relationships, not a score of friends.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, and the partner's way.
- Any part about loss may be skipped; if it is too heavy, speak to a pastor, priest or trusted person.
- A leader asks what was easy and hard, never who is on the map.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Mapping who is beside you, and choosing one small step toward someone else. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What may be skipped | Any part, especially any part about loss, without giving a reason. |
One sentence to remember Care should run both ways: we are all at times the carrier and the carried.
This week's action Take one small step from your map: send a message, make a call, or accept an invitation, and keep your map where only you will find it.
제 5 장 Week 5: Work, Calling and Human Worth
요약 보기
- Many societies and many people measure a person by output; the habit is hard to see because it is partly true and partly kind.
- The measure treats the old, the unemployed, carers, the sick and the young as counting for less.
- Matthew 6:26, Mark 2:27 and Psalm 139:14 speak of worth that is given; they do not say that work is useless.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox voices each say that worth does not rest on output, in different words.
- The Sabbath is a weekly practice of rest in which no one is valued for use.
- Usefulness is a good to be thanked, but it is not the ground of a person’s worth.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The output measure | The habit of treating what a person does as what the person is. |
| What Matthew 6:26 addresses | Anxiety about whether one will have enough; it does not say that work is useless. |
| Mark 2:27 | The Sabbath was made for people, not people for the Sabbath. |
| Usefulness and worth | Usefulness is a good to be thanked; it is not the ground of a person’s worth. |
One sentence to remember A person is received as a gift before the person produces anything.
This week's action Next time someone asks what you do, answer in one honest sentence, then ask them what they are glad of this week.
요약 보기
- "Calling" means at least three things: to belong to Christ, to a way of life and place, and to particular tasks.
- In 1 Corinthians 7, the calling is the condition in which a person was called by God, not an occupation in the modern sense.
- Ephesians 2:10 says we are made first and then given good works; Colossians 3:23-24 says whom work is finally offered to.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox voices all say that ordinary work can be holy, with different emphases.
- The idea of a station can become a cage; defenders and critics both have a fair point.
- A change of task can be a real loss, and it does not change a person’s worth.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three layers of calling | To belong to Christ; to a way of life and place; to particular tasks. |
| Ephesians 2:10 | We are God’s workmanship, made for good works prepared beforehand: made first, then the works. |
| Universal call to holiness | The Catholic teaching of the Second Vatican Council that all the baptised are called to holiness in their state of life. |
| A risk of the idea of a station | It can become a cage, used to tell the poor to stay where they are. |
One sentence to remember Calling is first to belong to Christ and to love the neighbour where one is; tasks serve it and may change.
This week's action Write down three callings you hold that nobody pays you for, and thank one person who holds such a calling.
요약 보기
- God makes, calls the made things good before any use, and rests; human making begins from what is given.
- Exodus 31:1-5 calls the craftsman's skill a gift of the Spirit of God.
- Process forms the maker, and product serves the receiver; both have worth and neither gives the person's worth.
- Readers disagree whether the same output has the same worth when a tool made it; each view has a real strength and a real weak point.
- The course requires that we not rank persons by output, not deceive about who made what, and keep the formation of the maker in view.
- Four questions help: who decided, who gave attention, who is named, what was it for.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Process and product | Process forms the maker; product serves the one who receives it; the person’s worth depends on neither. |
| Exodus 31:1-5 | Bezalel is filled with the Spirit of God for skilled work: craft is called a gift. |
| First position on tool-made output | A made gift carries the maker's time and risk, so a quickly produced equal is not the same offering. |
| Second position on tool-made output | A tool is an instrument; the worth lies in the person's choice and in what the work does for others. |
One sentence to remember A maker is not what the maker makes, and honesty about who made what is owed to those who receive it.
This week's action Make one small thing by hand for someone this week, and tell them honestly how it was made.
요약 보기
- Learning includes information and knowledge, which can be handed over, and understanding and wisdom, which must be formed in the learner.
- Proverbs 4:7 says wisdom is supreme and costly; Luke 2:52 says Jesus increased in mind, body and standing with God and people.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions place learning inside a relationship: habit and formation, the elder and the learner, the teaching community.
- A teacher knows the student; much that is learned cannot be listed but is learned beside someone who has it.
- On whether tools that supply answers help or harm formation, readers disagree, and each view has a real strength and a real weak point.
- A person's worth does not depend on how fast or how easily they learn.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four things called learning | Information, knowledge, understanding, wisdom; the last two must be formed in the learner. |
| Luke 2:52 | Jesus increased in wisdom and stature, and in favour with God and people: learning is part of a human life. |
| The shared point of the traditions | Learning happens inside a relationship, with a teacher, a community and a way of life. |
| A question to ask of any help | What is this doing to the learner, as well as what does it produce? |
One sentence to remember Learning is a way of becoming someone, and it takes time, effort and other people.
This week's action Name one person who taught you something that cannot be put in a list, and thank them.
요약 보기
- The lab asks for two lists, what you were given and what you do, and a look at how you join them.
- 1 Corinthians 4:7 asks what we have that we did not receive; gratitude is a truer start than proof.
- The aim is to see your own measure of worth, not to reach a correct list.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with Daniel's case, and the partner's way; loss may be skipped.
- A leader asks what it was like, never what was on the list, and does not treat a short second list as a problem.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Seeing the gap between what was given and what is done, and noticing one's own measure of worth. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| The leader's question | Not "what was on your list?" but "what was it like to write the first list?" |
One sentence to remember Begin from what you were given, and let what you do follow from it.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, keep it where only you will find it, and thank one person from your first list.
제 6 장 Week 6: Enhancement, Immortality, Resurrection
요약 보기
- The wish to escape death is very old, and it is not a foolish wish.
- Transhumanism holds that human limits are not sacred, that death is a harm, and that tools may be used to go beyond them.
- Supporters say new tools continue an old human practice of extending ourselves.
- The line between healing and enhancement is disputed; this course does not draw it.
- A story about escaping death has the shape of a religious story: diagnosis, salvation, future and fellowship.
- Genesis 11:4 and Genesis 3:22-23 are read in several ways and say nothing about machines.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Transhumanism | A movement holding that science and technology should be used to go beyond present human limits, including death. |
| Mind uploading | The proposal that the structure of a mind might be copied or moved into a machine; offered as a possibility, not a fact. |
| The healing and enhancement line | Restoring what is usual versus going beyond it; disputed, and not drawn by this course. |
| The four parts of the story | Diagnosis, salvation, future, fellowship. |
One sentence to remember Hear the dream of escaping death as a human dream before you answer it.
This week's action Write down, in your own words, the strongest reason a person might give for wishing to live much longer, and read it back to see whether you have been fair.
요약 보기
- Finitude means being a limited creature; death as people meet it, with grief and dread, is a further question.
- One reading holds that limit belongs to good creation and sin made death an enemy; the other holds that death as a whole comes through sin.
- Both readings say the body is good, death is a loss, and death is not the last word.
- Gnostic movements held matter to be lesser and salvation to be escape; the church answered that God made the body and the Word took flesh.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions each honour the body in their own terms.
- Accepting a limit is not praising suffering, and relief of pain is not a refusal of finitude.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Finitude | Being a limited creature, with a beginning, needs and an end. |
| The two readings of death | Limit belongs to good creation and sin made death an enemy; or death as a whole comes through sin. |
| The Gnostic error and the reply | Matter is lesser and the self is a spirit to be freed; the church replied that God made the body and the Word became flesh. |
| What all three streams share about the body | It is God's good creature and is raised, not left behind. |
One sentence to remember A limit is not a curse, and suffering is not a gift; the answer to the wound is the raising of the body, not leaving it.
This week's action Name one limit of your body or your life that you are learning to receive, and one that you still count as a wound, and keep the two apart.
요약 보기
- 1 Corinthians 15 hopes for the raising of the body, through Christ the first fruits, with death as the last enemy abolished.
- The creeds say the church looks for the resurrection of the dead; Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant churches share this centre.
- The immortality of the soul and the resurrection of the dead are different ideas, though many Christians hold some form of both.
- What makes a person the same person over time is disputed, and each answer has a difficulty.
- The upload story assumes that the person is a pattern, that a copy would be the person, that the body is a carrier, and that death is a lack of means.
- Resurrection is a gift and a promise, not a technology; the Christian hope is of life renewed, not only of more life.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Resurrection of the body | God raising the whole person in Christ, changed; not the escape of a soul from the body. |
| Immortality of the soul versus resurrection | The first holds that a part survives death; the second that the whole person dies and is raised. |
| Personal identity | The question of what makes a person the same person over time; answers include body, soul, memory and character, and God holding the person. |
| What the upload story assumes | That the person is a pattern, a copy would be the person, the body is a carrier, and death is a lack of means. |
One sentence to remember Resurrection is not a technology: it is God's gift of a raised and healed person, promised in Christ.
This week's action Write the sentence from the creed about resurrection in your own language, and say in one line how it differs from "my mind kept in a machine".
요약 보기
- Psalm 103:14-16 tells the truth about dust and grass and says that God remembers; humility is seeing oneself as made, limited and known.
- Gratitude receives life as a gift and cannot be commanded of those who suffer.
- Romans 8:23-25 describes hope as groaning and waiting with patience for the redemption of the body.
- Christian hope is not optimism, not denial, and not a method.
- Revelation 21:4 pictures God wiping away every tear; Christians read the relation of old and new creation in more than one way.
- The course ends with honest unknowns: machine inner life, the soul, identity, the healing-enhancement line, the raised body.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Humility | Seeing oneself truly as made, limited and known by God; not thinking little of oneself. |
| Hope in Romans 8 | Groaning and waiting with patience for the redemption of the body, resting on a promise. |
| What hope is not | Optimism, denial of grief, or a method. |
| Revelation 21:4 | God himself wipes away every tear; death is no more. |
One sentence to remember A creature in hope is humble about its dust, thankful for what is given, and patient in waiting.
This week's action Write one sentence of thanks for something you did not make, and one sentence of honest unknowing, and keep both on the same page.
요약 보기
- The lab asks for one private page on what a human person is, what the writer hopes and what the writer does not know.
- There is no correct page, and a statement of unknowing is part of an honest one.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, and the partner's way.
- Grief or fear may come up; anyone may skip, and a pastor or priest and the local emergency number are the places to turn.
- A leader asks which box was hardest, never what was written.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Putting into plain words, privately, what you hold about the human person, what you hope and what you do not know. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| The leader's question | Not "what did you write?" but "which box was hardest to write?" |
One sentence to remember An honest page includes a sentence of belief, a sentence of hope, and a sentence of not knowing.
This week's action Write your one page, put it somewhere only you will find it, and read it again in a year.
← AI and the Human Person: Image of God, Personhood, Transhumanism