FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT611E Reading the Psalms in Hebrew

Lecture 6-3: Two Kinds of Wisdom

Contents 24
BT611E Reading the Psalms in Hebrew
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Reading Hebrew Poetry
  1. Lecture 1-1: Parallelism and the Blessed Man
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Two Ways, and the Psalter's Five Books
  3. Lecture 1-3: Other Devices, and Two Doors into the Psalter
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Hymns of Praise
  1. Lecture 2-1: A Frame, and a Question at the Center of It
  2. Lecture 2-2: An Orchestra, Conducted from Heaven to Earth
  3. Lecture 2-3: One Shape, Two Realizations
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Cry of Lament
  1. Lecture 3-1: A Cry That Names God Twice
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Turn Nobody Explains
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Lament's Shape, and One Vow Left Open
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Thanksgiving and Trust
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Shepherd Who Becomes a Host
  2. Lecture 4-2: A Song for a House, a Poem About a Sickbed
  3. Lecture 4-3: A Vow Paid, and Two Ways of Standing Near Danger
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Royal and Messianic Psalms
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Nations Rage, the King Is Told a Secret
  2. Lecture 5-2: Two Words for "Lord," and a Priest Older Than the Priesthood
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Royal Psalm as a Genre
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Wisdom and Theodicy
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Prosperity of the Wicked
  2. Lecture 6-2: Until I Entered the Sanctuary
  3. Lecture 6-3: Two Kinds of Wisdom
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Penitence and Imprecation
  1. Lecture 7-1: Three Words for Sin, Three Words for Clean
  2. Lecture 7-2: By the Rivers of Babylon
  3. Lecture 7-3: Uncensored Before God
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Pilgrim Songs and the Psalter's Close
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Keeper Who Does Not Sleep
  2. Lecture 8-2: Everything That Has Breath
  3. Lecture 8-3: From Torah-Meditation to Praise

Jump to the key points ↓

16 min

Lectures 6-1 and 6-2 read Psalm 73 as a single continuous argument: a confident opening claim, a near-total collapse of that claim under observed evidence, a turning point this course has left honestly ambiguous, and a closing confession that answers a different question than the one the crisis asked. This final lecture in the chapter steps back from the psalm's own sequence to ask what genre it belongs to, and then does what Chapter 1 already told you it would: puts Psalm 73 directly beside Psalm 1.

Both psalms are usually classed, by scholars, among the Psalter's "wisdom psalms" — though, as this lecture states plainly, that label covers psalms that arrive at their shared conclusions by very different roads. Psalm 1 states its two-ways theology as an axiom, argued for by image rather than by struggle. Psalm 73 arrives at something close to the same claim only after nearly losing it entirely. This lecture's central task is naming that difference precisely, without collapsing one psalm into the other.

What these 16 minutes give you

  • Define a wisdom psalm's three characteristic features (didactic tone, righteous/wicked contrast, proverb-like generalizing statements) and identify each in Psalm 73.
  • Explain what distinguishes Psalm 1's confident, axiomatic wisdom from Psalm 73's harder, observation-based wisdom.
  • Identify the specific verbal echo between Psalm 73:27 and Psalm 1:6, and evaluate honestly whether that echo is doing real interpretive work or is an elegant-looking connection this course should be cautious about pressing too hard.
  • State, in your own words, why placing Psalm 1 first and Psalm 73 later in the Psalter's own sequence (Book I, then the opening of Book III) might itself be a meaningful editorial choice, without overclaiming certainty about anyone's intent in making it.

The wicked are not so, but are like the chaff which the wind drives away. Therefore the wicked shall not stand in the judgment, nor sinners in the congregation of the righteous. For Yahweh knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked shall perish. — Psalm 1:4-6

World English Bible

For, behold, those who are far from you shall perish. You have destroyed all those who are unfaithful to you. But it is good for me to come close to God. — Psalm 73:27-28

WEB

This lecture is a synthesis and re-quotes lines already read in full elsewhere in this course.

1. What makes a psalm a "wisdom psalm"

Chapter 6's overview named three recurring features of the genre; this section locates each one directly in Psalm 73.

Didactic tone. A wisdom psalm often addresses, at least in part, a human audience rather than speaking exclusively to God. Psalm 73 makes this explicit at 73:15, where the psalmist says that voicing his crisis publicly would have "betrayed the generation of your children" — a statement that only makes sense if the psalm imagines itself as potentially instructive, or damaging, to a listening community, not only as private address to God. Psalm 1 shows the same feature even more plainly: it never addresses God at all, in any of its six verses. It describes "the blessed man" in the third person throughout, reading closer to instruction offered to a listener than to prayer offered to God.

Righteous/wicked contrast. Both psalms are organized around this contrast as their central structural device, not merely as one theme among several. Psalm 1 states it directly, dividing its six verses cleanly between the blessed man's portrait (1:1-3) and the wicked's fate (1:4-6). Psalm 73 tracks the same contrast, but interleaved with the psalmist's own first-person crisis rather than presented as two clean, separate portraits — the wicked's catalog (73:4-12) and the psalmist's own suffering (73:13-14) sit side by side, in tension, rather than in the tidy sequence Psalm 1 uses.

Proverb-like generalizing statements. A wisdom psalm characteristically states claims in a form built to be true in general, not only true of one narrated event. Psalm 1:6's closing line — "Yahweh knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked shall perish" — is exactly this kind of statement: timeless in its grammar, offered as a standing truth. Psalm 73 has fewer statements of this kind, and the ones it has are placed carefully. Verse 1, "Surely God is good to Israel, to those who are pure in heart," functions the same way Psalm 1:6 does — a general claim, not a report of one event — which is worth noticing precisely because of where it sits: as this chapter's overview and Lecture 6-1 both observed, Psalm 73 places its one clean proverb-like claim first, then spends thirteen verses testing whether it survives contact with observed reality. Psalm 1 never subjects its own proverb-like claims to that kind of test at all.

2. Two roads to a similar place

Here is the contrast this lecture exists to state clearly. Psalm 1's wisdom is confident and axiomatic: it presents the two-ways scheme as something simply known, secured by images (a tree, chaff) rather than by any narrated struggle to arrive at the claim. Nothing in Psalm 1 suggests the poem itself ever doubted its own premise. Psalm 73's wisdom is observation-based and hard-won: the same basic scheme — the wicked's apparent security is not, ultimately, secure; nearness to God is what actually holds — is reached only after the psalmist reports nearly abandoning it entirely, and only by way of an experience at the sanctuary this course has deliberately left open to two different readings (Lecture 6-2's section 2).

Not a story of progress

It would be a mistake to describe Psalm 1 as naive and Psalm 73 as more sophisticated, as though the two psalms represent stages of a single writer's development. They are two different psalms, quite possibly from different periods and circles (Psalm 1 carries no superscription at all; Psalm 73 is attributed to Asaph, a name associated with a distinct collection of psalms concentrated at the start of Book III), and nothing in the text supports reading them as one theological argument's beginning and end. What can be said more carefully: the Psalter, as a collected book, contains both kinds of wisdom side by side — the confident statement and the tested one — without resolving the tension between them into a single official position. A reader who has only ever met Psalm 1's confidence has not yet met the Psalter's own hardest case against it; a reader who starts from Psalm 73's crisis alone might miss that the tradition also has a place for stating the claim simply, without argument, as something worth saying plainly even though it will not always feel true.

3. A tempting echo, and a caution about it

Over-reading a link

Psalm 73:27's language — "those who are far from you shall perish" — sits close enough to Psalm 1:6's "the way of the wicked shall perish" that a reader may be tempted to read Psalm 73 as consciously, deliberately echoing Psalm 1's closing line, as though the whole psalm were constructed to arrive back at Psalm 1's own vocabulary after all its wandering. This connection is genuinely there to notice — both lines use the same root idea of the wicked's "perishing" as their conclusion, and both close their respective psalms with that word doing real weight. But this is exactly the kind of connection this course's own working caution exists for: when two facts line up this neatly, the neatness itself is a reason for caution, not a reason for confidence. Nothing in either psalm's text states that Psalm 73 is quoting or answering Psalm 1 specifically; "perish" (, avad) is common vocabulary across the Psalter and the wider Hebrew Bible for describing the wicked's fate, not a rare word whose repetition here would obviously signal deliberate cross-reference. The honest position is narrower than "Psalm 73 answers Psalm 1": both psalms, independently, reach for the same ordinary vocabulary to say a similar thing about the wicked's ultimate fate, and a reader is free to notice the resonance — this course does, and finds it genuinely suggestive — without asserting that one poem was written with the other specifically in view.

4. Where this leaves Book I and the opening of Book III

Chapter 1 already noted, without developing it, that Psalm 1 opens Book I and that Psalm 73 opens Book III — a fact about the Psalter's five-book architecture, not an argument this lecture presses hard. It is worth stating plainly what can, and cannot, be concluded from that placement. What can be said: the Psalter's editors placed a psalm of confident, untested two-ways wisdom at the very start of the whole collection, and a psalm that puts that same wisdom under direct, nearly-fatal pressure at the start of its third major division — meaning a reader working straight through the Psalter meets the hard case more than once, not only at the very end after every difficulty has already been resolved elsewhere. What cannot be responsibly said, on the evidence available to this course, is that the editors intended this specific pairing as a planned theological statement about the two psalms' relationship; the five-book division's assembly history is itself debated among scholars (Lecture 1-2 already flagged this), and reading too much deliberate design into any two individual psalms' placement risks exactly the kind of overreach this course tries to avoid throughout.

Confident Wisdom, Hard-Won Wisdom Psalm 1 (opens Book I) axiomatic — stated by image, no narrated struggle, no doubt tree vs. chaff; "the way of the wicked shall perish" (1:6) Psalm 73 (opens Book III) observation-based — reached only after near-collapse (73:2, 13-14) "those far from you shall perish" (73:27) — similar word, hard road ~ Elegance is a warning sign: the "perish" echo between 1:6 and 73:27 is genuinely suggestive, but "perish" is ordinary Psalter vocabulary — neither text states that one psalm deliberately answers the other. The Psalter holds both kinds of wisdom without resolving the tension into one official position — a reader who has only met Psalm 1's confidence has not yet met the tradition's own hardest case against it.

6. Try It Yourself

Using this lecture's three wisdom-psalm features (didactic tone, righteous/wicked contrast, proverb-like generalizing statement), try to locate one clear example of each feature in Psalm 1 for yourself, before checking the answer — you have already read the full psalm in Chapter 1.

Check your answer

Didactic tone: Psalm 1 never addresses God directly in any of its six verses; it describes "the blessed man" and "the wicked" entirely in the third person, the shape of instruction offered to a listener rather than of prayer. Righteous/wicked contrast: the psalm's whole structure divides cleanly at verse 4 ("The wicked are not so") into the blessed man's portrait (1:1-3) and the wicked's fate (1:4-6) — the contrast is not one theme among several, it is the psalm's entire architecture. Proverb-like generalizing statement: verse 6, "Yahweh knows the way of the righteous, but the way of the wicked shall perish," makes no reference to any particular event or person; it is offered as a standing, timeless claim, exactly the form a wisdom psalm's central statement typically takes. If you located different verses for any of these three features, that is not necessarily wrong — Psalm 1 is short enough that more than one verse can often serve as a fair example of the same feature.

In short

  • Wisdom psalms share three features: a teaching tone aimed partly at people, a contrast of righteous and wicked, and proverb-like general statements. Psalms 1 and 73 both show them.
  • Psalm 1 states its two-ways view as an axiom, backed by images. Psalm 73 reaches a close version only after nearly abandoning it, and after the sanctuary.
  • The lecture refuses to call Psalm 1 naive and Psalm 73 mature. The Psalter holds both the confident statement and the tested one, with no single official resolution.
  • Psalm 73:27 and Psalm 1:6 both say the wicked "perish." The echo is worth noticing, but "perish" is common vocabulary, so a deliberate cross-reference cannot be claimed.
  • Psalm 1 opens Book I and Psalm 73 opens Book III. The lecture does not claim the editors planned this pairing.

Topic: This lecture places Psalm 73 beside Psalm 1 as two kinds of wisdom psalm, one confident and one hard-won.

Remember: The Psalter contains both a confident statement of the two ways and a psalm that tests it under pressure, and it keeps both.

Caution: Do not say Psalm 73 deliberately answers Psalm 1, or that their placement was a planned statement. The text and the evidence do not show that.

One line to carry into ministry: Be ready to offer both: the plain confidence of Psalm 1 and the honest struggle of Psalm 73, for different moments.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • This lecture argues that Psalm 1 and Psalm 73 should not be read as "naive" versus "sophisticated" stages of one argument, but as two different psalms holding two different kinds of wisdom side by side. Do you find that framing persuasive, or does one psalm still feel more true, or more mature, to you than the other?
  • The lecture flags the "perish" echo between 73:27 and 1:6 as tempting but uncertain — genuinely worth noticing, but not provably a deliberate cross-reference. How do you decide, as a reader, when a resonance like this is worth naming and when it risks over-reading?
  • Having now read both Psalm 1 (Chapter 1) and Psalm 73 (this chapter) closely, which psalm do you think you would reach for first if you were the one currently watching the wicked prosper — and does that answer surprise you at all?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

Definitions: Strong’s Concordance (1890/1894, public domain) · Morphology: MorphGNT/SBLGNT (CC BY-SA), Open Scriptures morphhb/WLC (CC BY 4.0)

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.