Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
- Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
- Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
- Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
- Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
- Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
- Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
- Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
- Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
- Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
- Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
- Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
- Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
- Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
- Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
- Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
- Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
- Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
- Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
- Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
- Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
- Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
- Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
- Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
- Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
- Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
- Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
- Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
Rome tolerated almost everything. It absorbed the gods of every people it conquered, gave them temples, and let them keep their priests. Egyptian Isis, Persian Mithras, Syrian Atargatis and the Great Mother of Asia Minor all acquired Roman followings. Nobody was required to stop believing anything.
So the question is not why an intolerant empire attacked a religion. It is why a strikingly tolerant one made an exception.
The answer is that Roman religion was not primarily about belief at all. It was about doing the right things, publicly, so that the gods stayed favourable to the community. What a person privately thought was between them and the gods. What they did in public was everyone's business, because everyone shared the consequences. A group that would not do the public things was not exercising a private freedom; from a Roman point of view, it was endangering the city.
This lecture sets out four reasons Christians became a problem — political, social, legal and religious. The legal one is where the standard textbook account goes wrong, and this lecture corrects it.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Explain how the confession that Jesus is *Kyrios* collided with the imperial cult, and why the collision was about loyalty rather than about doctrine.
- State the three rumours attached to Christians — atheism, cannibalism, incest — and identify the actual Christian practice behind each.
- Explain accurately how Christians ended up without legal protection, and why the familiar idea of Judaism as a "licensed religion" that Christianity lost is not supported by Roman law.
- Explain the idea of the *pax deorum* and how it turned Christians into the explanation for plague, famine and defeat.
But Peter and the apostles answered, 'We must obey God rather than men.'" — Acts 5:29
World English Bible
The sentence that generates this entire chapter. Notice that it is an answer given to a court, and that it concedes the court's power while refusing its authority. Peter does not say the council has no right to be there. He says there is a case where its instruction cannot be followed.
1. The empire that tolerated nearly everything
Start by getting Roman religion right, because most misunderstandings of this period begin here.
Roman public religion had no creed, no scripture, no conversion, and no requirement to believe. It had rites. Sacrifices were performed on the right days, in the right words, by the right people, and if a word was misspoken the whole rite was repeated. What mattered was correct performance, because the relationship between the city and its gods was understood as a contract: honour us properly and we will protect you.
You could hold whatever philosophical view of the gods you liked. Educated Romans held every position from pious literalism to something close to atheism, and it caused no trouble at all, as long as they turned up.
Into that world came a group that would not turn up.
2. Kyrios: a confession that answered a question nobody had asked
The earliest Christian confession we can reconstruct is very short: Kyrios Iēsous — Jesus is Lord.
Kyrios was an ordinary word. It meant an owner, a master, the man of the house. But it had two loaded uses. In the Greek Old Testament that Greek-speaking Christians read, Kyrios stood in for the divine name. And in the eastern provinces it was used of the emperor — the same word, in the same cities, at the same time.
So a confession that was meant as worship arrived in Roman ears as a comparison. Saying "Jesus is Lord" in a Greek-speaking city was, whether the speaker meant it or not, a sentence with a second half.
Do not overstate it
Here it is important to be precise, because this is often overstated. Most emperors did not claim to be gods in their lifetimes, and Roman authorities were not much interested in Christian theology. Domitian, who reportedly liked being addressed as "master and god", was unusual and was remembered as unpleasant for it. The imperial cult did not require you to think the emperor divine. It required you to honour him: to sacrifice, to offer incense, to swear by his genius.
That is why the collision was about loyalty rather than about doctrine. Nobody asked Christians to believe Caesar was a god. They were asked to do a small public act signifying that they were part of the same community as everybody else — and they would not.
3. Three rumours, and the practices behind them
Public opinion ran ahead of the authorities. Three accusations circulated, and each one grew out of something Christians actually did.
Atheism. Christians were called atheoi — godless. The charge sounds absurd applied to people who died rather than deny God, and it made perfect sense to a Roman. Christians had no temple, no image, no sacrifice and no priest that anyone could see. Whatever they had, it did not look like religion. And because they refused the public rites, they were, in the only sense that mattered civically, without gods.
Cannibalism. The community met privately to eat a meal at which they spoke of consuming the body and blood of someone. Rumour did the rest, and the accusation took the form of the "Thyestean banquet" — a reference to a Greek myth in which a man is served his own children. Athenagoras, Justin and the Octavius of Minucius Felix all answer the charge directly, which tells us it was widely believed.
Incest. Members called each other brother and sister, greeted one another with a kiss, and met at night behind closed doors. The rumour was of "Oedipal intercourse" — deliberate incest in the dark.
Notice the mechanism, because it recurs in every century. The rumours were not invented from nothing. They were what a hostile outsider could construct from the true facts of a closed community's life. Private meetings, family language, and a meal about a body: each of those is real, and each becomes something monstrous when the only people describing it are outside it and afraid.
This is the lecture's point of contact with your own situation. If your congregation is a minority where you live, you are probably already carrying a version of this — a story about what you do at your meetings that is not quite a lie and is not remotely true. The early church's answer was neither to become secretive nor to abandon the practices. It was to explain them in public, in writing, to hostile readers, which is lecture 2-3.
4. The legal position — and the correction
Here is where most accounts follow a scholarly convention that turns out not to be supported.
The usual story. Judaism was a religio licita, a "permitted religion", legally recognised and protected. Christianity sheltered under that legal umbrella while it was taken for a Jewish sect. When it became visibly separate, it lost the protection and became a religio illicita, an illegal religion — and from then on being a Christian was itself a crime.
The problem. Roman law had no such categories. There was no register of permitted religions, no licence, no procedure for granting or withdrawing one. The phrase religio licita occurs in Tertullian, a Christian writer arguing a case around 197, and does not appear in Roman legal sources as a technical term at all. It has been read back into Roman law by modern scholars, and specialists — de Ste. Croix among the most forceful — have been pointing out for sixty years that it does not belong there.
What was actually true, and it gets you to the same place by a better road:
- Jews held specific, real privileges, granted piecemeal by particular rulers to a particular people: exemption from the imperial cult and from military service, the right to collect and send the temple tax, permission to assemble. These were concessions to an ancient national custom, not a licence category. Rome respected antiquity, and Judaism was visibly ancient.
- Christians were at first taken for Jews and were covered incidentally. As they became recognisably distinct — a process lecture 1-2 showed was slow and uneven — that cover thinned. After the Jewish revolts and the imposition of the fiscus Judaicus, the tax on Jews, the boundary hardened from both sides.
- What Christians never acquired was any protection of their own. They were a new association with no ancestral custom to plead, meeting privately, in a legal system deeply suspicious of unauthorised clubs.
- There was no anti-Christian statute for most of this period. Governors acted under coercitio, their general power to keep order and punish. That is why the treatment varied so wildly from province to province and governor to governor: there was no law to apply consistently.
So the change of status is real. It just was not a change of legal category. Christians did not lose a licence they had held. They emerged from behind someone else's protection into a space where nothing covered them. That is a more precise account, and it explains the erratic, local, governor-by-governor character of persecution far better than a legal ban would.
5. The peace of the gods, and who gets blamed
The last reason is the one that turned dislike into violence.
Romans held that the safety of the community depended on the pax deorum, the peace of the gods — maintained by correct public worship. This was not a fringe superstition; it was the working assumption of the state, which is why priesthoods were public offices and why omens were reported to the Senate.
The logic that follows is short and terrible. If the gods are honoured, the city is safe. If the city is not safe, the gods have been offended. Who has offended them? The people who refuse to honour them.
Tertullian describes it with the exasperation of someone who has heard it too many times: if the Tiber floods, if the Nile does not, if there is drought, earthquake, famine or plague, the cry goes up at once — Christians to the lion.
This is what made persecution popular. Most of the killing in this period began with crowds, not with emperors. A famine, a plague, an earthquake, and a mob has an explanation and a target. The governor who executed the martyrs of Lyons in 177 was responding to public fury, not implementing a policy from Rome.
And it explains the shape of the accusation. Christians were not charged with holding a false opinion. They were charged, in effect, with endangering everyone — which is why the required remedy was always an act. You cannot repair the peace of the gods by changing your mind. You repair it by sacrificing.
6. What the empire was actually asking
Put the four together and the demand becomes clear. Rome wanted no confession of faith, no renunciation of Christ in the heart, and no theology. It wanted a pinch of incense.
That is precisely what made it impossible. A demand for belief can be met with reservations. A demand for an act cannot. Either the incense goes on the fire or it does not, and everyone watching can see which.
A community is defined by what it will not do — and the church of this period discovered its own outline not by writing a creed, which was still decades away, but by finding out where its members stopped.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Reason | The Roman logic | What it demanded | The common error to avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Political | Refusing the emperor's honours marks you as outside the community | Sacrifice and an oath by the emperor's genius | Thinking Rome required belief that the emperor was divine |
| Social | A closed group doing unexplained things at night | Nothing formally — but it supplied the mobs | Treating the rumours as pure invention; each had a real practice behind it |
| Legal | A new association with no ancestral custom | Nothing consistent; governors used general powers | The religio licita story — Roman law had no such category |
| Religious | Neglected gods bring disaster on everyone | An act that repairs the peace of the gods | Thinking persecution was mainly imperial policy rather than local fury |
5. Going to the Sources
- Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96–97 — the letter and Trajan's reply, together. Read the test itself, and notice that Trajan forbids seeking Christians out and forbids anonymous accusations.
- Tertullian, Apology 40 — the pax deorum argument answered by someone who had heard "Christians to the lion" shouted in the street.
- Minucius Felix, Octavius — a dialogue in which a pagan speaker states the rumours in full and a Christian answers them. The best single text for how the charges sounded.
- The Letter of the Churches of Lyons and Vienne (177), preserved in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 5.1 — a mob, a governor, and a very hard read.
In short
- Rome tolerated almost every religion. Its public religion was about correct rites, not belief, so a group refusing to take part seemed to endanger the city.
- Kyrios Iēsous, "Jesus is Lord", sounded to Romans like a comparison with the emperor. The collision was about loyalty shown by a small public act such as sacrifice, not about the emperor's divinity.
- Three rumours grew from true facts seen by hostile outsiders: atheism (no temple or image), cannibalism (a meal about a body) and incest (brother and sister, a kiss, night meetings).
- The idea that Christians lost a "permitted religion" status is not supported by Roman law. They emerged from behind Jewish privileges into a space where nothing covered them, and governors acted under coercitio.
- Romans believed the pax deorum, the peace of the gods, depended on public worship, so plague or famine made Christians the explanation. Most persecution began with crowds.
Topic: This lecture explains why tolerant Rome made an exception of Christians, through political, social, legal and religious reasons.
Remember: Rome cared about public acts, not private belief. Christians would not perform the public act that showed belonging, and in a crisis that made them the people to blame.
Caution: The lecture does not say emperors demanded belief in their divinity. It also corrects the idea that Christians lost a legal licence, since Roman law had no such category.
One line to carry into ministry: If your congregation is a minority, answer false stories about what you do by explaining your practices openly, neither hiding them nor dropping them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Rome asked for an act, not a belief. What act is currently required of you in order to be counted a normal member of your society — and would refusing it cost you anything?
- Each rumour about Christians grew out of a real practice seen from outside. What does your congregation do that would look strange described by someone who had never been inside?
- The lecture corrects the story of a "licensed religion" that Christianity lost. Does the more accurate account — that Christians had no protection of their own — change how you read the period?
- The *pax deorum* made Christians the explanation for disaster. Where do you see communities today looking for a group whose difference explains a misfortune?