Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
Lecture 3-1 asked who decides. This lecture asks how big a step to take.
Leaders who care about a change are tempted to take it whole and take it fast. Leaders who fear the quarrel are tempted to take it never. Both forget that there is a third choice: a smaller step, taken in the open, with a date on which everyone will look again. A change that can be tried, judged and, if need be, undone asks much less of people than one that cannot. People who would refuse a permanent change may accept a trial.
This lecture teaches a way of sorting changes by how easily they can be undone, a plain plan for a pilot, and a sober look at the cost of both hurrying and delay. It uses Acts 15 as a picture of a deliberation, not as a command for how any community today must decide.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Sort a proposed change as reversible or hard to reverse, and say what that sorting means for the size of the first step.
- Write a simple pilot plan with a length, a measure of success, a review date and a named decider.
- Name the costs of hurrying and the costs of delay, and say why neither is automatically the safer choice.
- Describe the movements of the deliberation in Acts 15 and say what they show about the way of a decision.
Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22
World English Bible
All the multitude kept silence, and they listened to Barnabas and Paul reporting what signs and wonders God had done among the nations through them." — Acts 15:12
WEB
Therefore my judgment is that we don’t trouble those from among the Gentiles who turn to God," — Acts 15:19
WEB
For everything there is a season, and a time for every purpose under heaven:" — Ecclesiastes 3:1
WEB
The Proverb says plans need counsel. Acts 15 is a story of a body that listened before it spoke. Ecclesiastes reminds us that timing is part of wisdom. None of the three is a rule for a modern committee. Together they show what careful decision looks like when it is done well.
1. Two questions before the first step
A leader who has a change in mind usually asks, "How do I get this done?" Ask two other questions first.
How hard would this be to undo? Some changes can be reversed on a Monday morning: moving a meeting to another night, trying a different order for announcements, opening a room for a new use for three months. Others cannot: selling a building, ending a ministry that many people built, changing a name, dismissing a worker. Most changes lie between the two.
What is the smallest step that would teach us something? If the full change is a large and uncertain one, ask whether a part of it can be done first. A part that is real, not a token, will tell the community more than a month of argument.
The two questions together give a rule of thumb that is worth remembering. The harder a change is to undo, the more counsel it needs and the smaller the first step should be. The easier it is to undo, the sooner it can be tried. It is a rule of thumb, not a law. There are changes that must be made at once, and there are easy changes that touch something so dear that they still need great care. But it is a good place to begin.
2. Sorting a change: three kinds
It helps to put a change in one of three groups.
Reversible and small. A different time, a different room, a different order of service within the freedom of the community, a trial of a new group. These can usually be tried on a short notice with clear speech about what is being tried.
Reversible with cost. The change can be undone, but not without loss: a new schedule that has changed people's habits, an outreach that has raised hopes, a staff role changed. Undoing it is possible, but it will hurt. These need a longer notice, a stated review date, and a promise about what will happen at the review.
Hard to reverse. A sale, a merger, a closure, a change that the church's own law does not allow to be revisited. These are the changes of lecture 3-4. They need the widest counsel the rules allow, and they should not be hidden in the language of a trial. If a change cannot be undone, do not call it a pilot.
That last sentence matters. A leader who calls an irreversible step a "trial" has told the community something false. People feel it when they find out, and it cost the leader's word.
3. A plan for a pilot
When a change can be tried, a good pilot has five parts, and each should be written before the trial begins.
- What exactly is tried. One or two sentences. Not a mood or a direction, but a thing that someone could see.
- For how long. A fixed period. Long enough to see what happens, short enough that the people who dislike it can bear it. Three to six months is common for a change in routine; a seasonal change might need a season. Choose a length that fits the thing.
- What counts as working. Say it before you start, in plain words, and say what would count as not working. If you decide afterward, the community will believe the leader chose the result first. The measure need not be a number. It might be "the people who asked for it still come," or "the people who feared it say they can live with it."
- Who decides at the end, and by what road. The pilot is not a way around lecture 3-1. The body that would have approved the permanent change decides what follows the trial. Say who it is.
- The way back. What will be put back, and how, if the answer is no. And what will be told to the people who liked it.
(An invented example.) A congregation has talked for two years about moving its main gathering from Sunday afternoon to Sunday morning, because the afternoon time keeps families with young children away. Many older members have built their week around the afternoon. The leaders propose a pilot: for the twelve Sundays after a major festival, there will be one gathering in the morning and none in the afternoon. They say that what counts as working is whether the families who asked for it come, and whether the afternoon members say they can still come or are able to join. At the end, the council that governs worship will decide, after hearing from both groups. If the answer is no, the afternoon gathering returns on the next Sunday. The leaders have said plainly that the trial is real and so is the right to say no.
Look at what that plan does. It does not hide the loss: the afternoon members will feel it. It does not say the change is certain. And it gives the people who fear it a date on which they will be heard.
4. A pilot is not a trick
A pilot can be abused. A leader may call a change a "trial" in order to get past an objection, intending all along to make it permanent. Or a trial may run so long, or change so much, that going back is no longer possible. People who have been treated this way will not trust the next trial.
Three habits keep a pilot honest.
- Fix the review date and hold to it, even if the trial seems to be going well.
- Let the objectors help set the measure. If those who fear the change help to say what would count as harm, the review means something to them.
- Be ready for the result you did not want. A leader who is truly not sure will not mind if the trial ends in "no". A leader who cannot bear "no" should not call it a trial.
5. The cost of hurrying and the cost of delay
It is easy to say that haste is dangerous. It is true, but delay is dangerous as well, and an honest leader counts both.
The cost of hurrying. People who were not heard feel run over. Mistakes that could have been seen by a wider circle are made. Those who were silent come back later, and what they say is sharper. A change made at speed is also hard to improve, because the leader has staked a reputation on it.
The cost of delay. Some problems grow while a community talks. A roof leaks; a sick programme drains the people who run it; those who feel unheard in a different matter leave while a committee studies. Delay can also be a way of avoiding grief: a community that cannot say yes or no may be avoiding the loss that either answer brings. And delay is not neutral for the people who are waiting for the change. Someone who has asked for a ministry for three years is paying a cost.
A leader should ask which cost is heavier in this case, and should say aloud which one he or she is choosing and why. "We are going slowly because this cannot be undone" is a reason. "We are going slowly because nobody wants to speak" is not.
Ecclesiastes 3:1 does not say "everything should be done slowly". It says that everything has a season. Part of the work is to discern the season: the matter that must be done before winter, the matter that may wait a year, the matter that will become ready when something else has finished.
6. Acts 15 as a picture of a deliberation
The council at Jerusalem is a rare passage that shows a community working through a disagreement about what it should require of new believers. We take it here as a story that shows the movements of a careful deliberation. We do not take it as a command that every community use the same method. Different communities today decide by different roads, as lecture 3-1 showed, and the Bible does not give a single rule for them all.
In outline, Acts 15 shows this movement.
- The disagreement is named and sent to those who can address it. Paul and Barnabas, after no small discord and discussion, are appointed to go up to Jerusalem about the question (Acts 15:2).
- The apostles and elders gather (Acts 15:6). The matter is brought before a body that has a place for it.
- There is much discussion (Acts 15:7). Disagreement is not hidden. Peter then speaks of what God has done.
- The assembly listens to witnesses. "All the multitude kept silence, and they listened to Barnabas and Paul" (Acts 15:12). The people closest to the experience are heard.
- Scripture is read in the light of the experience. James says that the words of the prophets agree with what has been reported (Acts 15:14-18).
- One person gives a judgment (Acts 15:19), and the decision is not left to drift.
- The decision is carried by the whole assembly and put in writing. The apostles and elders, with the whole assembly, choose men to send with a letter (Acts 15:22).
Notice what is absent. There is no rush, and there is no silence about the disagreement. Notice what is present: witnesses, Scripture, a spoken judgment, a letter, and messengers who will explain it in person.
We do not claim that this was the only way a church could have decided, or that any community must copy its order. What we draw from it is the way: listen to the people closest to the matter, test what you hear against what the community holds as its standard, say the judgment plainly, put it in writing, and send someone to explain it.
7. Reversible changes and the quiet people
One more thing about small steps. They are a kindness to the quiet.
The people who are most easily lost in a community are those who do not speak at meetings: the shy, the very old, the newest, those who do not like to cause trouble. When a change is large and permanent, they have no way to say "this will hurt me" except in the one meeting where they will not speak. A trial gives them months to find the words. It gives them a second chance to be heard, at a review where the leaders have promised to ask. If a change can be built to listen to the quiet, it should be.
For the stages of leading a change through a large organisation, see and Leadership (PT702E). This lecture's ground is smaller: the size of the step, and the promise of a way back.
Diagram 1. A pilot from first day to review
Diagram 2. The movements of Acts 15, as a picture of deliberation
| Movement | Where | What it shows about the way |
|---|---|---|
| Disagreement named and sent on | Acts 15:2 | A hard question is taken to those who can address it |
| A gathering | Acts 15:6 | The matter has a place and a body |
| Much discussion | Acts 15:7 | Disagreement is not hidden |
| Witnesses heard | Acts 15:12 | Those closest to the matter speak |
| Scripture read with the experience | Acts 15:14-18 | The community tests what it hears against its standard |
| A judgment spoken | Acts 15:19 | The matter does not drift |
| A letter and messengers | Acts 15:22 | The decision is written and explained in person |
In short
- The harder a change is to undo, the more counsel it needs and the smaller the first step should be.
- Changes fall into three groups: reversible and small, reversible with cost, and hard to reverse. A change that cannot be undone must not be called a trial.
- A pilot needs five parts written beforehand: what is tried, how long, what counts as working, who decides afterward, and the way back.
- Hurrying and delay both have costs. A leader counts both and says aloud which one is being chosen and why.
- Acts 15 shows a way of deliberation: name the disagreement, gather, discuss, hear witnesses, test against Scripture, speak a judgment, write it down and send messengers.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The rule of thumb | The harder to undo, the more counsel and the smaller the first step. |
| Five parts of a pilot | What is tried; how long; what counts as working; who decides at the end; the way back. |
| Not a pilot | A change that cannot be undone, or a trial whose answer cannot be "no". |
| Acts 15 shows | Disagreement named, a gathering, witnesses heard, Scripture tested, a judgment spoken, a letter sent. |
One sentence to remember A change that can be tried, judged and undone asks much less of people than one that cannot.
This week's action Take one change you have thought about and write its five-part pilot plan on half a page, including how it would end.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a change in a community you know that could have been tried as a pilot but was not. What would a pilot have changed?
- Which is harder for you as a leader, to hurry or to delay? What does that tell you about the mistake you are likely to make?
- Choose a change you know of and sort it: reversible and small, reversible with cost, or hard to reverse. What first step does your answer suggest?
- Why does it matter that a pilot's measure of success is written before the pilot begins?
- In Acts 15, which of the movements is most often missing from the decisions of communities you know?