Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
- Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
- Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
- Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
- Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
- Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
- Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
- Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
- Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
- Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
- Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
- Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
- Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
- Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
- Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
Weeks 1 and 2 helped you prepare for a placement and keep a record of it. This week asks what you do with the record. Writing down what happened is necessary, but it is not yet learning. A student who has filled thirty journal pages may have learned less than one who has thought carefully about a single afternoon. The step between the two is reflection, which here means looking back at an event on purpose, with questions, so that it teaches you something and changes what you do next.
Many students think reflection means describing how they felt. Feelings matter and they are where reflection often begins. But if the page stops there, the student has only a diary. This lecture describes a movement of five steps: experience, feeling, analysis, Scripture and tradition, and action. It is one model among several, and it is useful because it shows where a page of feeling-writing stops too early. We read the walk to Emmaus as a picture of people looking back, and we follow one small invented event through all five steps.
The central claim of this seminar applies directly. A placement is learning beside people and a supervisor, and then looking back at what happened in the light of faith. This week is about the second half of that sentence.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Describe the five steps of the reflection cycle used in this seminar and say that it is a model, not the only one.
- Tell the difference between writing about feelings and theological reflection.
- Explain what the Emmaus story shows about looking back at an event.
- Give two reasons why reflection works better with a companion.
- Follow a short event through the five steps and say what changed at the end.
Behold, two of them were going that very day to a village named Emmaus, which was sixty stadia from Jerusalem. They talked with each other about all of these things which had happened. While they talked and questioned together, Jesus himself came near, and went with them. But their eyes were kept from recognizing him." — Luke 24:13-16
World English Bible
They said one to another, “Weren’t our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us along the way, and while he opened the Scriptures to us?”" — Luke 24:32
WEB
They related the things that happened along the way, and how he was recognized by them in the breaking of the bread." — Luke 24:35
WEB
Search me, God, and know my heart. Try me, and know my thoughts." — Psalm 139:23
WEB
See if there is any wicked way in me, and lead me in the everlasting way." — Psalm 139:24
WEB
The Emmaus story shows two people going over an event together, being helped to see more than they saw alone, and then acting on it. The Psalm is the prayer of someone who asks God to examine the heart and not only the day, and who asks to be led, which means that looking back is meant to change the way one goes next.
1. Three kinds of looking back
There are at least three things a student can do with an event after it is over.
The first is remembering. You recall what happened, perhaps retell it to a friend. This is natural, and it is the raw material of the rest. Memory is also unreliable, which is why week 2 asked you to write soon.
The second is feeling-writing. You write how the event felt: tired, proud, ashamed, glad, afraid. This is honest and often helpful. Many people have never been asked how an afternoon of service felt for them. Feelings are information. They tell you what mattered to you and where you were hurt or surprised.
The third is reflection, and in this seminar theological reflection. This means that you ask questions about the event that go beyond how it felt. What actually happened? What might be going on that I did not see? What do Scripture and the long experience of the church have to say that bears on this? What will I do differently, or the same, next time? Theological reflection is not a mood. It is a kind of thinking, done with attention and with others, and it ends in a decision about action.
Theological reflection
Looking back at an event in a placement on purpose and in order: what happened, what I felt, what may be going on, what Scripture and the church's tradition say, and what I will do next. It is thinking in the presence of God and with other people, not a record of moods.
2. The five steps
The model used in this seminar has five steps. Other writers and other schools use different numbers of steps and different names. A reader who has learned another cycle may use it. What matters is that the movement does not stop at the first or second step.
Experience. Say what happened, in plain facts. Who was there, by role, not by name? What was said and done? Where and when? Leave out what you felt and what you think it meant. This is harder than it sounds, and lecture 3-2 gives it a whole lecture.
Feeling. Say what you felt during the event and what you feel now. Name two or three feelings, not a flood. Feelings are not right or wrong. They are data. A student who felt contempt for someone should write that down, because it is better to see it on the page than to act on it without seeing it.
Analysis. Ask what may be going on. Why did the event happen that way? What did each person want or fear? What did I bring to it: my habits, my assumptions, my tiredness? What might I have missed? What else could be true? This step is where reflection becomes thinking. It uses whatever the student has learned about people, communities and institutions, and it holds its conclusions loosely.
Scripture and tradition. Bring the event into conversation with the Bible and with the church's long life: its creeds, its prayers, its saints, its practice of care. This is not a search for a verse that fits. Lecture 3-3 is about doing it carefully. For now, notice that this step has a particular direction: the student asks what the text and the tradition are saying, and also lets them question the student's first reading of the event.
Action. Decide on something. It may be small: a question to ask the supervisor, a different way of beginning a visit, an apology, a prayer, a decision to wait. It may also be to do nothing different and to give thanks. Without this step the cycle has no end and the student has only been thinking.
Then the cycle begins again, because the next event is shaped by what was decided.
A model is not a machine
The five steps are a way of making sure nothing important is skipped. They are not a form to be filled in correctly. A real reflection often moves back and forth: the analysis changes how the facts are seen, and a verse changes what the feeling means. Do not treat the order as a rule.
3. The walk to Emmaus
Luke 24:13-35 is a story about looking back. Two disciples of Jesus are walking away from Jerusalem a few days after the crucifixion, and they are talking and questioning together about everything that had happened (Luke 24:14-15). A stranger joins them and asks what they are discussing. In the full text they tell him what they know: the events, their hopes, their disappointment, and the strange report of the women. That is something like our first two steps, experience and feeling, told aloud to a listener.
The stranger does not tell them to cheer up. In the text he asks them a question first and listens, and then he goes through the Scriptures with them. They say later that their hearts were burning within them as he spoke along the way and opened the Scriptures to them (Luke 24:32). Something in the way they were looking at the events changed. That corresponds loosely to analysis and to Scripture. They recognise him when he breaks the bread. And then they act: they get up at once and return to Jerusalem to tell the others (Luke 24:33-35).
We should be careful about what this proves. The Emmaus story is not a description of a method, and Luke did not write it to teach the five steps. The risen Jesus is also not an ordinary supervisor. What the story does show is a pattern that Christians have long found helpful: people go over what happened, someone listens and helps them see more, the Scriptures are opened, and the people go on differently. Two more things stand out. They were walking together, so they did not reflect alone. And their eyes were "kept from recognizing him" (Luke 24:16) while it was happening. It took the walk, the questions and the table for them to see what had been present all along. A student often cannot see the meaning of an event while it happens. That is why looking back is not a luxury.
4. Why reflection needs a companion
A person looking back alone has some advantages: quiet, and no need to explain. But three things go wrong more easily alone.
First, we tend to tell the story in our own favour, or against ourselves. One student always finds that the other person was at fault. Another always finds that she was. Both are telling a story that is too tidy. A companion who was not there asks the question that breaks it open: "What do you think she wanted at that moment?"
Second, we tend not to see our habits. A habit that feels natural to us is invisible. A supervisor or fellow student may notice that you always fill silence, or always leave quickly, or always give advice when someone only wanted to be heard.
Third, we may not have the knowledge. A reflection that reaches a confident conclusion about a family, a custom or a doctrine on the basis of one student's view may be quite wrong. Someone who knows the place or the tradition can correct it.
A companion can be your supervisor, a fellow student, a pastor or priest, a spiritual guide, or a friend who listens well. Lecture 3-4 is about reflecting with others. One principle stands now: a person who reflects only alone has chosen to have no one who can say, "I wonder if that is all there is to it."
5. A small event, taken through the five steps
(An invented example.) Amara is a student whose placement is visiting older people in their homes. She has been visiting a woman we will call Mrs K. for six weeks. On the seventh visit, Mrs K. is quiet for a while and then says, "I do not understand why God has left me here so long." Amara is startled. She says quickly, "God has a plan for everyone, and he is with you," and then asks about the garden. The visit ends pleasantly. On the way home Amara feels uneasy.
Experience. Mrs K. said that she did not understand why God had left her here so long. Amara answered with one sentence about God's plan and changed the subject to the garden. The visit lasted about an hour.
Feeling. Amara felt startled at first, then afraid of saying the wrong thing, and afterwards uneasy and a little ashamed.
Analysis. Why did she change the subject? She was afraid of the silence and had no answer. What did Mrs K. want when she spoke? Perhaps not an answer, perhaps only to be heard. She had said a hard thing, and the reply was a reassuring sentence and a different topic. Amara sees that she may have told Mrs K. that this kind of question is not welcome here. She also notices that she has been brought up to answer a sorrowful remark quickly and cheerfully. Another person might have answered in a different way. She does not know what Mrs K. felt, and she should not assume she was hurt.
Scripture and tradition. Amara knows that the Psalms contain prayers like Mrs K.'s sentence, prayers that ask why and do not end tidily; Psalm 88 is the one in which the last word is darkness. She notes that many traditions have kept such psalms in their prayer, which suggests that the church has not treated this kind of question as lack of faith. She also remembers that Scripture does not give one answer to why a person suffers, and she is careful not to say that it does. She asks herself whether "God has a plan for everyone" was a way of listening to Mrs K., or a way of ending the silence.
Action. She will bring the visit to her supervisor and ask how she might respond if Mrs K. raises the question again. Next time she will let a silence last a little longer, and say, "That sounds like a hard question. Would you like to say more?" She will not promise an answer. She will also ask her supervisor whether the parish or the programme has someone who visits Mrs K. regularly and could be told, if Mrs K. wishes.
Notice what this did and did not do. It did not decide that Amara was a failure. It did not decide what Mrs K. suffers from or why. It did not settle the theology of suffering. It moved one visit from a vague unease to a small, honest plan, and it opened a question for the supervisor.
6. What reflection does not do
Reflection has limits, and it can go wrong in four ways.
It can become self-absorbed, with the student at the centre of every event and every service turned into a study of the student's feelings. People who are served should not become material for the student's growth. Week 4 returns to this.
It can become endless. A student who reflects on everything and acts on nothing has missed the last step.
It can be harsh. Reflection is not a trial. Psalm 139 asks God to search the heart and to lead, not only to expose. If a reflection regularly ends in shame, something is wrong with the way it is being done. Equally, if it always ends in comfort, nothing is being examined. A good reflection holds accountability and grace together.
And it can be used to avoid what is plain. If an event involved danger to someone, signs of abuse, or thoughts of self-harm, it does not go into a reflection exercise first. It goes to the supervisor at once, and if there is danger now, to your local emergency number. Reflection comes after safety.
Diagram 1. The five steps of reflection
In short
- Reflection is looking back at an event on purpose and in order, so that it teaches you something and changes what you do next.
- This seminar uses five steps: experience, feeling, analysis, Scripture and tradition, action. It is a model, and other cycles may be used.
- Feeling-writing is honest and useful but stops early; theological reflection asks what else may be true and ends in a decision.
- Emmaus shows people going over an event together, being helped to see more, and then acting; it does not prescribe a method.
- Reflection works better with a companion, who can break open a story told too neatly, see habits and supply knowledge.
- Danger, signs of abuse or self-harm go to the supervisor first; reflection comes after safety.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The five steps | Experience, feeling, analysis, Scripture and tradition, action, and then the next event. |
| Feeling-writing versus reflection | Feeling-writing records how it felt; reflection also asks what else may be true, brings in Scripture and tradition, and ends in a decision. |
| What Emmaus shows | People go over an event together, are helped to see more, have the Scriptures opened, and act. It shows a pattern, not a method. |
| Why a companion | We tell stories to suit ourselves, miss our own habits and may lack knowledge a companion can supply. |
One sentence to remember Reflection is not how it felt; it is what else may be true, and what I will now do.
This week's action Choose one small event from your service this week and write it as far as step 3, analysis. Bring one question from it to a companion.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of an event from your service, or from any work you have done, that you wrote about or told to someone. Did the telling stop at what happened and how it felt? What question could it have gone on to ask?
- In the Emmaus story, what did the two disciples not see while it was happening? What helped them to see it afterwards?
- Which of the five steps would be hardest for you, and which would you be tempted to skip? Why?
- Whom do you trust to ask you the question that breaks open your first version of a story? What makes them able to do it?
- In Amara's visit, what might have been a different, honest way of listening that does not claim to answer a question about suffering?