Lecture 6-3: After the Placement: Discerning What Comes Next
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
- Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
- Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
- Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
- Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
- Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
- Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
- Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
- Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
- Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
- Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
- Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
- Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
- Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
- Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
When a placement ends, a question often arrives. What now? A student who loved the work wonders whether this is the path for life. A student who found it very hard wonders whether they were wrong to come. A student who felt nothing in particular wonders what to make of that. All three ask, in different words, whether the placement has told them something about their calling.
This lecture asks what a placement can show and what it cannot. It argues that a placement is evidence, and one piece of it, but it neither proves nor disproves a call. It describes four things that a placement can bring to light: a pull, gifts, limits and a need. It looks at how other people help in discernment and gives a way to think about four kinds of next step: to continue, to change, to rest, or to study. It states fairly a point on which readers will not agree, which is whether hardship in a placement signals that a person is not called.
The central claim of the seminar sits underneath this. If a placement is learning beside people and then looking back in the light of faith, the looking back does not stop on the last day of the hours. It carries on into what the student will do next, and it is still done with others.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Name four things a placement can bring to light and say what each can and cannot tell you.
- Explain why a single placement neither proves nor disproves a call.
- State fairly two positions on whether hardship in a placement signals an absent call.
- Describe four kinds of next step and when each might fit.
- Say why the decision is not made alone, and name the kinds of people who can help.
Now in the assembly that was at Antioch there were some prophets and teachers: Barnabas, Simeon who was called Niger, Lucius of Cyrene, Manaen the foster brother of Herod the tetrarch, and Saul. As they served the Lord and fasted, the Holy Spirit said, “Separate Barnabas and Saul for me, for the work to which I have called them.” Then, when they had fasted and prayed and laid their hands on them, they sent them away." — Acts 13:1-3
World English Bible
Don’t be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may prove what is the good, well-pleasing, and perfect will of God." — Romans 12:2
WEB
A man’s heart plans his course, but Yahweh directs his steps." — Proverbs 16:9
WEB
In Antioch a group of leaders worships and fasts, hears a word about two of their number, prays, lays hands on them and sends them. The decision belongs to a community at prayer, and the two who are sent were already serving. The passage does not say how the Spirit spoke or how long the group waited, and it is not a procedure to copy.
Paul speaks of a mind renewed over time, so that a person can recognise what is good. Discernment is part of a longer change in the way a person thinks, not a quick act at the end of a task.
A person plans and God directs. The verse holds both: planning is not wrong, and the plan is not the last word. A student can make plans for what comes next and hold them with open hands.
1. What a placement can show
Two hundred hours beside real people and a supervisor teaches things that reading cannot. Four of them bear on what comes next.
A pull. What did you look forward to? What did you find yourself thinking about on the way home? Some students discover a gladness they did not expect. Others discover that what they had thought they wanted does not draw them at all. A pull is a real piece of information. But it has many sources. It may come from novelty, from a warm group, from a supervisor you admire or from relief after a hard period. Ask whether it is still there after the novelty has gone.
Gifts. What did others see in you that you had not seen? What did you do well, and what did you do with ease that others find hard? A gift is shown in use, and a placement is a place where a gift can be used. Be careful on both sides. A gift can be hidden in a poor placement where there was no chance to use it. A person can also mistake being liked for being gifted.
Limits. What could you not do, or not do for long? Where were you out of your depth, or worn out sooner than you expected? A limit is not a failure. Knowing a limit is part of being a trustworthy servant (week 4). Some limits can be changed by training and practice. Some are part of who a person is. Many are true of one setting and not of others. A student who finds a crowded parish exhausting may thrive in quiet one-to-one care. A student who is uneasy with children may be at ease with adults.
A need. What did you see that has stayed with you: a gap, a hurt, a question that nobody was answering? Need is a real pointer. But a need is not a call. There are many needs in the world, and nobody can answer them all. A need that keeps coming back and meets a pull and a gift deserves attention. A need alone does not decide anything.
2. What a placement cannot show
A placement is one site, one supervisor, one season and one set of people. Many things shape what happens in it that have nothing to do with a person's . A supervisor may be absent because of illness. A site may be in a crisis. The student may be unwell, bereaved, short of sleep or working a second job. The tradition of the site may differ from the student's own. A placement of 200 hours is a small sample of a life.
For this reason a placement neither proves nor disproves a call. A student for whom it went well has learned something important and has not been given a guarantee. A student for whom it went badly has learned something and has not been given a verdict. This course does not treat a placement as a test of calling. It treats it as a time of learning.
3. This is a point where readers will not agree
Whether hardship in a placement is a sign that a person is not called.
Some readers hold that persistent difficulty is real information. They point out that a call is often seen in a fit between a person's gifts, their desire and a real need, and that when one has strained for a long time and found no fit, that is worth taking seriously. They remember that many people have been pressed into service that did not suit them, to the harm of themselves and of those they served. They say that to treat all difficulty as "testing" can keep a person in a place where they should not be.
Other readers hold that hardship is no verdict. They point to Scripture, where Moses objects, Jeremiah protests that he is too young and Jonah runs, and where the faithful are often shown carrying a cost. They say that a call regularly feels heavy, that tiredness and failure are part of any service, and that a person who left at the first difficulty would never stay in any work. They are afraid that to treat difficulty as a sign of an absent call teaches students to run when they should persevere.
Both positions have a serious defence. The first guards against forcing a person into the wrong place. The second guards against abandoning a good road too soon. Each has a risk. The first can excuse a person from every hard thing. The second can keep a person in a harmful one.
What this course requires is less than either position requires. Do not decide alone, and do not decide from one hard season. Whether the hardship was about you, about the site, about the season, or about the work itself is a question that is difficult to answer from the inside. Bring it to people who know you and who are free to say what they see.
4. The community's part
Acts 13 shows a call recognised in the middle of a community. The two who were sent were known to the others, were already serving, and were sent by hands and prayer. A student cannot reproduce that scene, but can take its direction: discernment is done with other people.
Whom should a student ask? The best people tend to be those who know you and have seen you at work, who are free to say what they see, and who do not gain from your choice. A supervisor can say what they observed. A pastor, priest, teacher or mentor from your own tradition can speak from the tradition's experience of such questions. A friend who will say a hard thing can help. A person from a different setting can see what people close to you cannot. The school's staff can say what the programme offers, which is a different question and not one this seminar can answer.
Some traditions have a formal process for testing a call to ordination, to religious life or to a particular office. If your tradition does, a placement may be one part of what that process looks at, and your own church will say how. This course does not describe those processes or say what they require. If you belong to such a tradition, talk to those responsible for it.
The aim in asking is to be heard, not to be told what to do. Ask people to say what they noticed, and to say what they are unsure of. Then give yourself time. Many people find that a decision made at the high point of a good placement or the low point of a bad one looks different a few months later.
5. An experience that did not fit
Some students come away from a placement certain that it was not for them. It is tempting to call that wasted time. It is not.
To learn that a kind of work does not draw you, or wears you out, or does not match your gifts, is real knowledge. It saves effort. It points to what might fit better. It can also teach compassion, because a student who found something hard understands those for whom it is always hard. A student who has been uneasy in a setting has seen that setting from the inside, and sees the people in it differently. And knowing that you are not suited to one kind of service is not the same as being unsuited to serve.
What matters is to separate three things: what did not fit me, what did not fit this site, and what was difficult but might still be right. These are hard to separate alone, and a conversation helps.
6. Four kinds of next step
After a placement there are many possible paths. Four are common.
Continue. Stay with the same site or work, perhaps as a volunteer or in a larger role. This fits when the placement drew you, when you and others saw gifts, and when the site welcomes you. Take care that you are not simply carrying on from habit or because the site is short of people. Ask whether you are still learning, and with whom.
Change. Move to a different kind of service, site or tradition of practice. This fits when you learned that the work did not suit you, or when something else in the placement drew you more. A change is not a failure of the first choice. It is what the first choice taught.
Rest. Stop for a time. This fits when you are tired, grieving, or in need of recovery, or when you cannot yet see clearly. Rest is not laziness. A decision made when worn out tends to be a poor one. The care of the minister's own life, tiredness and recovery are taught in Spiritual Formation for Ministers (FS103E).
Study. Go deeper into a subject that the placement opened. This fits when the placement raised questions that need reading, teaching or time to think. The school offers other courses, and the programme guide and staff can say what follows.
These are not exclusive. A student might rest for a month, then study, then return to the same site on a smaller scale. They are also not a ladder. Nothing here is a better or worse choice in itself. The question is which fits this person, in this season.
7. Two cases
(An invented example.) Marta finishes a placement in a youth programme and has loved it. The young people trusted her, her supervisor praised her, and she was never so happy. She wants to leave her work within the month and begin full-time ministry. She tells her family that the placement has proved her call.
What was crossed here is that one joyful placement was treated as proof, and the decision was made at its high point. A better path keeps the joy and takes it seriously. Marta brings it to her supervisor and to a pastor who has known her for years, and asks what each saw: gifts, limits, the fit with the site and the question of whether this could be done alongside work. She makes a small next step, such as continuing as a volunteer for a season. If her call is real, it will not be lost by waiting some months. If it is partly the glow of a good placement, she will find that out gently.
(An invented example.) Kofi finishes a placement that was hard. His supervisor was often away because of a family illness. Kofi felt useless, did errands, and was never sure what was wanted. He concludes that he is not called and decides to give up the programme.
What was crossed here is that a difficult site and an absent supervisor were taken to be a verdict on Kofi. A better path separates the questions. Kofi tells a pastor he trusts what happened, and says what he felt. Together they ask which part was the site, which was the season and which, if any, was about him. They find that Kofi had a pull toward teaching that he never had a chance to try. He talks to the school's staff about what the programme allows. This does not settle his path. It gives him something other than a feeling of failure to decide from.
A small test
Before you decide, write down three things: what the placement showed you, who you have asked, and what you have not yet been able to learn. If the second list is empty, ask someone.
Diagram 1. From placement to next step, with others
In short
- A placement can show a pull, gifts, limits and a need; each is real information and none is final.
- One site, one supervisor and one season neither prove nor disprove a call, and good or hard experience is not a verdict.
- Readers differ on whether hardship signals an absent call; this course requires that you do not decide alone or from one hard season.
- A placement that did not fit still teaches: what did not fit me, what did not fit this site, and what was hard but may be right.
- Four next steps are to continue, change, rest or study; they are not a ladder, and each fits some seasons.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What can a placement show? | A pull, gifts, limits and a need, each real and none final. |
| Does a placement prove or disprove a call? | Neither; it is one site, supervisor and season, and it is evidence, not a verdict. |
| What does this course require on hardship and call? | Do not decide alone, and do not decide from one hard season. |
| Four next steps | Continue, change, rest or study. |
One sentence to remember A placement gives you something to weigh, and you weigh it with others.
This week's action Write what the placement showed you in the four areas, and name one person whom you will ask to tell you what they saw.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Of the four things (a pull, gifts, limits, a need), which has your service shown you most clearly, and which is still unclear?
- Why can a placement that went well and a placement that went badly each mislead a student?
- State in your own words the strongest form of the view that hardship may signal a mismatch, and of the view that hardship is no verdict. Which parts of each would you keep?
- Whom could you ask to help you think about what comes next? Why those people, and what would you ask them?
- Of continue, change, rest and study, which is most likely to fit you in the coming season, and what would make you change your mind?