FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS201E Field Placement Seminar: Learning to Serve, Record and Reflect

Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others

Contents 31
FS201E Field Placement Seminar: Learning to Serve, Record and Reflect
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Learning Beside People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Learning Beside People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Before You Begin
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
  2. Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
  4. Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Keeping Records
  1. Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
  2. Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
  3. Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
  4. Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Theological Reflection
  1. Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
  2. Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
  3. Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
  4. Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Limits and Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
  2. Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
  3. Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
  4. Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Supervisor and Feedback
  1. Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
  2. Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
  3. Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
  4. Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Finishing and Discerning
  1. Lecture 6-1: Finishing Well
  2. Lecture 6-2: Evaluation and the Supervisor's Confirmation
  3. Lecture 6-3: After the Placement: Discerning What Comes Next
  4. Lecture 6-4: Carrying the Habit Forward
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Looking Back and One Page of Next Steps

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Power runs in two directions in a placement, and this lecture looks at both. A student can be used badly by a site, and a student can use the people he or she is sent to serve. Neither is usually done with bad intent. Sites are busy and short of hands. Students are eager, and sometimes need to be needed. But a good placement keeps both ways in order.

The first half asks what a student can do when the placement does not match the agreement: when the work is only errands, when the supervisor is never there, when pressure for results grows, or when a request crosses a line. It asks how to raise such matters, and says that changing or ending a placement is an honest option and not a failure. The second half turns the question around. It looks at the quiet ways that a student, with good motives, can use the people served: as material for a photograph, as a collection of experiences, or as a way to feel useful.

The central claim of the seminar holds here. A placement is learning beside people and a supervisor. If the student learns nothing and only supplies labour, it is not yet a placement. If the student treats those served as the means of his own learning, it is learning at their cost. In both cases, the hours have been filled and the point has been missed.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Recognise five ways a placement may use a student badly, without making any supervisor or organisation a villain.
  • Describe a calm order for raising a problem: reread the agreement, ask, then involve school staff.
  • Say why changing or ending a placement is an honest option, and what a student should do before and while doing so.
  • Name three ways a student may use the people served, and what a respectful alternative looks like.
  • State fairly two positions on how much a lay student should take on, and on help versus dependence, and say what this course requires.

doing nothing through rivalry or through conceit, but in humility, each counting others better than himself;" — Philippians 2:3

World English Bible

each of you not just looking to his own things, but each of you also to the things of others." — Philippians 2:4

WEB

But a certain Samaritan, as he traveled, came where he was. When he saw him, he was moved with compassion," — Luke 10:33

WEB

came to him, and bound up his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. He set him on his own animal, and brought him to an inn, and took care of him." — Luke 10:34

WEB

On the next day, when he departed, he took out two denarii, and gave them to the host, and said to him, ‘Take care of him. Whatever you spend beyond that, I will repay you when I return.’" — Luke 10:35

WEB

Let no one seek his own, but each one his neighbor’s good." — 1 Corinthians 10:24

WEB

Paul asks for humility that looks to the interests of others as well as one's own. "Each of you" includes the student and the people served, and both sides of this lecture fit inside it.

In the story of the Samaritan, the helper does real work with his own hands, and then brings in an innkeeper and promises to return. He does not make the injured man his project, and he does not carry him alone for ever.

This verse gives the test for both directions: whose good is being sought?

1. When a placement uses a student badly

Most sites care about their students. Some sites, because they are short of people or money, or because nobody has thought about it, use a student in ways that do not serve the student's learning. It helps to know what these look like, so that you can recognise them without any need to blame.

Cheap labour. The student does the work that a paid or regular helper would do, with no teaching, no feedback and no room to learn. The hours pass, and nothing is taught.

Errands only. The student carries, cleans, copies and fetches, and never meets the people the site serves, never takes part in the work itself and never sits in a meeting. Errands are honest work, and every site has them. The question is whether there is anything else, and whether the agreement said there would be.

An absent supervisor. The supervisor is kind but never there: meetings are cancelled, questions go unanswered, and the student does not know whom to ask. This is often because the supervisor is a volunteer with a full life, not because he does not care.

Pressure for results. The student is expected to bring numbers: new members, decisions, donations, attendance. The pressure is rarely cruel. It comes from a site that feels it must show its funders or its community that it is doing well. But a student who is under it can be tempted to push people, to hurry them, or to report more than happened (lecture 2-4 spoke of honest accounts).

A request that crosses a boundary. A student is asked to do something outside the agreement or outside the limits of lecture 4-1: to handle money, to counsel a person alone, to be alone with someone in a way that is unsafe, to keep something secret that should be told, to do a favour that is personal, or to enter a relationship that is closer than a placement allows. Boundaries and a minister's conduct belong to Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E), and a request of this kind is told to someone at once.

Each of these has understandable causes. A site that gives a student errands may have no one with time to teach. A supervisor who is absent may be stretched thin. A site that presses for numbers may be afraid for its future. There is no villain here. Seeing this does not make the problem smaller. It makes it easier to talk about.

2. How to raise a problem

When something is wrong, the order matters. It is calm, step by step, and it begins with the plainest question.

  1. Reread your learning agreement (lecture 1-3). Is what is happening different from what was agreed? Write the difference down in a few plain lines. "We agreed that I would sit in on visits. In the last six weeks I have been to none."
  2. Ask your supervisor, at a regular meeting or by asking for one. Do not accuse. Describe what you see and ask a question: "I noticed that I have not yet joined a visit. Could we look at how that might happen?" Many problems stop here, because the supervisor did not know.
  3. Give it a little time, and see whether things change. Write down what you notice.
  4. If it does not change, or if it is a matter of safety or a boundary, tell others. This can be the site's other leaders, if the site has them and your agreement names them, and the school's staff. Ask the staff how they would like such matters raised. This course does not set a procedure, and the programme guide and the staff will tell you what they expect.
  5. If the matter involves a request that crosses a boundary, or a danger, do not wait for the slow steps. Tell your supervisor, or if the supervisor is the source of the request, the school's staff or another trusted person, and say no to the request in a calm and plain way. You do not need to explain it at length. "I am not able to do that. I would like to talk to my supervisor about it" is enough.

A word about what not to do. Do not go round a supervisor's or a site's rules to solve the problem by yourself. Do not complain behind someone's back, post about it, or recruit other students to your side. Do not quietly do less and pretend. These make things worse, and they cost you the trust that a placement needs. If you are unhappy, say so to the people who can help.

3. Changing or ending a placement

Sometimes a placement cannot be put right. The supervisor cannot be there, the work does not match what was agreed, the arrangement is unsafe or unfair, or a boundary has been crossed. In that case, changing or ending the placement is an honest option and not a failure. A student is not obliged to remain in a place that is harming them or that cannot teach them. Leaving well and learning something from it is a better result than staying and learning only resentment.

If you reach that point, do it openly. Tell the supervisor first, unless the supervisor is the cause of the difficulty, in which case tell the school's staff. Ask the programme guide and the staff how a change is made and what happens to the hours already served; this seminar does not state either. Do not simply stop turning up. Lecture 5-4 takes this further.

A different placement does not mean that you were weak, or that you were not called. A placement that does not work is a poor match. It tells you nothing about your .

4. When the student uses others

The second half of the lecture is harder, because it is about us. A student who has been used badly knows how it feels. It is easy to overlook the ways in which a student, without meaning to, uses the very people he is sent to help.

Photographs and stories as material. A student takes a photograph of children at a programme for a talk, a social media post or a fundraising letter. A student writes up a person's hardship so that it will move readers. These can be done with respect, with permission and under the site's rules. They are often done without thinking, and the person pictured or described has never been asked. Site rules come first, and for children and vulnerable people they are stricter. If permission is not clear, do not photograph, and do not tell the story.

Collecting experiences. A student arrives to "see" poverty, illness or hardship, and leaves with a story about how it changed him. The people served were present as scenery for his growth. A placement is meant to change you. But the people you meet are not there to change you. They are persons first.

The rescuer role. Some students need to be needed. They go from person to person, solving, advising, taking over, and feeling useful. Over time the people served may come to depend on the student and not on their own strength, their family or their community. And when the student leaves, there is a gap. The Samaritan in the story did what he could, found an innkeeper and went on. He did not make himself the injured man's whole help for ever.

A respectful alternative has some common marks. Ask first, before taking a picture or telling a story. Take less than you are given, in attention and in credit. Ask who will do this when you are gone, and work in ways that leave a person or a community more able, not less. Let those served speak for themselves. And look at your own motive: a helper who is honest about wanting to be needed is less likely to be ruled by it.

5. A student kept on errands

(An invented example.) Tomás is placed at a small community centre run by a few volunteers. His agreement says he will help with the weekly meal, join visits to families and sit in on planning meetings. For three months he has carried tables, washed dishes and unlocked the building. The coordinator is friendly, always busy and often says, "Next week, I promise." Tomás is frustrated but does not want to seem ungrateful.

What was missed here is that the agreement and the work have drifted apart, and nobody has said so. A better path: Tomás rereads the agreement and writes down the three things that were planned and have not happened. He asks the coordinator for fifteen minutes, and says, "I enjoy the work, and I want to do my part. We agreed that I would join visits and planning. Could we set a date for the first one?" If a date is set, the matter is closed. If it is not, or if "next week" continues, he tells the school's staff and asks what he should do. The coordinator is not an enemy. She is overloaded, and it may be that a smaller agreement would serve them both better.

6. A student asked for numbers

(An invented example.) Priya serves in an outreach project. Her supervisor says that the project's leaders will ask for a report of "decisions made" and asks her to bring at least ten each month. Priya has met many people but none of them has made any decision she could count. She is tempted to count a kind remark as a decision.

What was crossed here is a pressure to report more than happened. A better path: Priya tells her supervisor honestly what she has seen. "I have met many people. I cannot count those meetings as decisions, and I do not want to report something that is not true." She asks what the leaders really want to know, and whether a plain account of whom she met, without names, would serve. If she is told that numbers must be made up, she tells the school's staff. An honest report, even a small one, is part of what her supervisor's confirmation will rest on.

How much should a lay student take on, and does outside help serve or displace?

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some readers, often in Pentecostal and charismatic communities, in many mission settings, and in churches with a strong tradition of apprenticeship, hold that a student should be given real responsibility early. Their reasoning is this. People learn to serve by serving, and trust is a better teacher than caution. In some places the work cannot be done at all unless every willing person takes part, and a student who is held back may learn that he is of no use. These readers point out that the church has always sent out those who were still learning.

Other readers, in churches where many pastoral and sacramental acts belong to the ordained, and in professions with strong rules of protection, hold that a student should take on little. Their reasoning is this. The people served are not practice material. Some acts require training, authorisation and accountability, and a student who takes them on, even with good intent, can harm the person served and himself. Learning is better built on watching, then doing with a guide, then doing alone, in that order.

A related question is whether short-term and outside help serves a need or displaces local leadership. Some say that a visitor can meet an urgent need and bring skills and resources that a community does not have. Others say that outside help, even generous help, can take over what local people could do, and leave them more dependent than before.

Each side has a serious defence and a serious risk. The first can leave a student, and the people he serves, carrying more than either should. The second can leave a student unused, or can make a community depend on a stream of visitors.

What this course requires is less than either side requires. The scope of what a student does is set in the agreement by the supervisor and the site, and a student takes on nothing outside that scope alone. When you are asked to do more, ask. And in every case, ask who will do this when you have gone.

7. What a good use of power looks like

It would be wrong to finish with failures only. A good supervisor gives a student a little more responsibility as the weeks pass: first watching, then helping, then leading with someone beside him. A good site names what the student will learn and holds to it. A good student asks questions, keeps to the agreement, reports honestly and leaves a place better than he found it. A good student also asks the people served what they would like, and does not decide for them.

In short, a good placement is one in which both sides give something and both sides receive something, and in which the people at the centre of the work are not treated as a means to anything else.


Diagram 1. Two directions of power

Being used and using others Whose good is being sought? (1 Corinthians 10:24) A placement may use a student Cheap labour, with no teaching Errands only An absent supervisor Pressure for results A request that crosses a boundary Usually from busyness, not ill will A student may use the people served Photographs and stories as material Collecting experiences The rescuer who needs to be needed Making people depend on you Usually from good motives, not asked Reread, ask, then involve staff Calm steps; say no to a crossed boundary Changing or ending is an honest option Ask first, take less, leave people able Permission for pictures and stories Ask: who will do this when I am gone?

In short

  • A placement may use a student badly through cheap labour, errands only, an absent supervisor, pressure for results, or a request that crosses a boundary, usually without ill will.
  • Raise a problem calmly: reread the agreement, ask the supervisor, then involve the school's staff; say no plainly to a crossed boundary and tell someone.
  • Changing or ending a placement openly is an honest option and not a failure, and does not say anything about your calling.
  • A student may also use those served, by taking photographs and stories without asking, collecting experiences, or needing to rescue.
  • Ask first, take less, leave people more able, and ask who will do the work when you have gone.
  • Readers differ on how much a lay student should take on; this course requires that the supervisor and site set the scope and the student takes on nothing outside it alone.
Front Back
Five ways a student may be used badly Cheap labour, errands only, an absent supervisor, pressure for results, and a request that crosses a boundary.
Order for raising a problem Reread the agreement; ask the supervisor; give a little time; involve school staff; for a crossed boundary or danger, tell someone at once.
Three ways a student may use others Photographs and stories as material, collecting experiences, and the rescuer who needs to be needed.
What this course requires on scope The supervisor and site set it in the agreement; the student takes nothing outside it alone, and asks who will do the work when gone.

One sentence to remember Seek the good of the other person: first in what you accept, and then in what you take.

This week's action Reread your learning agreement and write down one thing in it that is not yet happening. Decide when you will ask your supervisor about it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Of the five ways a placement may use a student badly, which would be hardest for you to speak about, and why? What would make it easier?
  • Why does this lecture say there is "no villain" in these situations? Does that make the problems smaller or easier to solve?
  • Think of a service you have seen or taken part in. Who was asked before a photograph was taken or a story was told? What could have been done more respectfully?
  • Which of the two positions in the point where readers will not agree is closer to the way you were taught to serve? What would you want to keep from the other?
  • What would it mean in your site to ask, "Who will do this when I am gone?"

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.