FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS201E Field Placement Seminar: Learning to Serve, Record and Reflect

Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback

Contents 31
FS201E Field Placement Seminar: Learning to Serve, Record and Reflect
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Learning Beside People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Learning Beside People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Before You Begin
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
  2. Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
  4. Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Keeping Records
  1. Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
  2. Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
  3. Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
  4. Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Theological Reflection
  1. Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
  2. Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
  3. Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
  4. Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Limits and Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
  2. Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
  3. Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
  4. Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Supervisor and Feedback
  1. Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
  2. Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
  3. Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
  4. Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Finishing and Discerning
  1. Lecture 6-1: Finishing Well
  2. Lecture 6-2: Evaluation and the Supervisor's Confirmation
  3. Lecture 6-3: After the Placement: Discerning What Comes Next
  4. Lecture 6-4: Carrying the Habit Forward
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Looking Back and One Page of Next Steps

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

Lecture 5-1 described the supervisor relationship. This lecture takes up the part of it that many students find hardest: being told how you are doing. Feedback is what a supervisor, or a colleague, or a person you serve, tells you about your work. It may be praise. It may be correction. It may be a question that is really a correction. Whatever its form, feedback is one of the few ways you can see yourself from the outside, and a placement is a good place to receive it, because the stakes are small enough to learn from and real enough to matter.

The central claim of this seminar is that a placement is learning beside people and a supervisor, and then looking back. Feedback is the supervisor's side of "looking back". Your own reflection (week 3) shows you what you saw. Feedback shows you what you could not see.

This lecture does not teach how to give feedback to others, and it does not say what your supervisor should say. It asks what you do when you receive it: how to listen, how to ask for more, how to weigh praise and criticism, how to turn what was said into a plan, and how to read feedback when people in different cultures give it in very different ways.

What these 24 minutes give you

  • Recognise common forms of defensiveness in yourself, and describe what listening openly looks like without pretending to agree.
  • Ask a supervisor for specific feedback on a specific piece of work.
  • Weigh praise and criticism fairly, including feedback that seems vague, unfair or mistaken.
  • Record feedback and turn it into one small plan with a date to review it.
  • Explain how direct and indirect ways of giving feedback differ, and how to ask for clarity without judging either.

Faithful are the wounds of a friend; although the kisses of an enemy are profuse." — Proverbs 27:6

World English Bible

The way of a fool is right in his own eyes, but he who is wise listens to counsel." — Proverbs 12:15

WEB

The ear that listens to reproof lives, and will be at home among the wise. He who refuses correction despises his own soul, but he who listens to reproof gets understanding." — Proverbs 15:31-32

WEB

The three sayings agree that a person who wants to grow needs to be told the truth by someone who cares, and must be willing to hear it. Proverbs also assumes the person giving the reproof is a friend. That is why this lecture speaks both of openness in the student and of how to weigh feedback that does not come from such a place.

1. What feedback is

Feedback

Feedback is information about your work, given to you so that you can learn from it. It can say what went well, what could be better, what the giver saw or did not understand, or what the giver would like you to try. It is not a verdict on your worth, and it is not a verdict on your .

In a placement, feedback comes in several shapes. A supervisor may say, at the end of a meeting, "That was good." A colleague may whisper after a service, "Next time, speak a little slower." A person you visit may say nothing and look away. A supervisor may write a few lines on a page. A supervisor may ask a question: "What did you think was happening when she stopped speaking?" That question is feedback too, because it points at something you may have missed.

Notice that feedback is rarely complete. It is the giver's view from where they stand, and it may leave out a great deal. You do not have to treat it as the last word. But you should not treat it as nothing, either.

2. Defensiveness, and what it protects

Almost everyone becomes defensive when criticised. It is a human reaction and not a sin. But it is useful to know the shapes it takes, because it is easier to notice in yourself once you have a name for it.

  • Explaining at once. Before the person has finished, you are saying why it happened: "I was told to do it that way," "There was no time."
  • Counter-attack. You answer criticism with criticism: "But last week you did the same thing."
  • Going quiet. You say "yes, yes" and stop listening. This looks like openness and is the opposite.
  • Collapsing. You say, "I am useless, I should not be here." This also ends the conversation, because now the supervisor must comfort you instead of teaching you.
  • Rejecting the person. You decide that the supervisor does not understand, and so nothing they say counts.

Each of these protects something. Explaining protects your picture of yourself as capable. Counter-attack protects you from feeling small. Collapsing protects you by making the other person stop. Underneath is usually a fear: that the criticism is true, or that it means something larger than it does.

Openness is the other way. It does not mean agreeing with everything. It means doing four small things.

  1. Listen to the end. Let the person finish. If you feel the urge to answer, wait a moment longer.
  2. Say back what you heard. "You are saying I spoke too long before asking her what she needed. Have I understood?" This shows that you listened, and it corrects misunderstandings early.
  3. Ask for an example. "Can you tell me about a moment when that happened?" An example turns a general complaint into something you can work on.
  4. Say what you will do with it. "I will think about it and try it on Thursday." You do not have to agree today. You do have to take it away and consider it.

You may disagree after you have listened. "I understand why it looked that way. From where I stood, I was trying to give her time. Can we talk about how I could do that without seeming to ignore her?" That is a conversation between two people who want the same thing. It is very different from an argument.

3. Asking for the feedback you need

Many supervisors give less feedback than students need. They are busy, or they are kind and do not want to hurt you, or they think you will ask if you want something. So it is often a student's job to ask. A request such as "How am I doing?" usually gets the answer "Fine." A better request is specific.

  • "Could you watch me lead the opening prayer on Sunday and tell me one thing that helped and one thing to change?"
  • "I visited a family on Wednesday. I would like to tell you what I said and hear what you would have said."
  • "I am trying to speak more slowly. If you notice me rushing, would you tell me?"
  • "Is there anything you have noticed that I have not asked about?"

A specific request is easier to answer, and it shows that you are working on something. It also makes the supervisor's job lighter, because the supervisor does not have to decide what is worth saying.

Asking for one thing

(An invented example.) Ana is a student in a school-based placement. After the first month her supervisor has said only "You are doing well." Ana asks: "Would you sit in on Tuesday's group and tell me one thing I could do better?" On Tuesday the supervisor notices that Ana answers every question herself and the children soon stop trying. They talk about asking one question and waiting for a count of ten. Ana tries it for two weeks and reports back. The feedback was small. It changed how she teaches.

4. Praise and criticism, both weighed

Students tend to trust criticism and distrust praise, or the other way round. Both need weighing.

Praise is not always flattery. Often it is true, and it is worth keeping, because a person who only hears faults cannot tell what to keep. But praise can also be polite. In many places it is rude to point out faults and kind to say "it was very good." So when the praise is general, ask what specifically was good, so that you can do it again. "What was it that you noticed?" turns a pleasant sentence into something you can use.

Criticism is not always right. It may come from the giver's tiredness, or a different preference, or something that happened before you arrived. It may also be right and badly said. Here are some questions to ask yourself, after the first sting has passed.

  • Is this about my work (what I did) or about me (what I am)? Feedback about the work can be used. A remark that attacks you as a person is not feedback; see below.
  • Is this a standard that the placement requires, or a preference of this person? Both are real, but they weigh differently. A safety rule is not negotiable. A preference about where to stand is a thing to learn and may change in the next place.
  • Did the giver see what happened, or only hear about it? An account that is second-hand can be wrong.
  • Does anyone else say something similar? If two or three people say the same thing in different words, it is worth taking seriously, even if each said it gently.
  • What is the small piece of truth here, even if the whole is exaggerated?

If after thinking you still believe the criticism is mistaken, say so politely, with your reason, at a good time. Do not ignore it, and do not argue about it in front of others. "I thought about what you said, and I see part of it. On the other part, here is what I saw. May we look at it together?" is a respectful way to disagree.

There is a limit. Some things said to a student are not feedback. Remarks that mock a person's body, race, background or faith, or demands that you do something unsafe, or that you cross a boundary, are not a way of teaching. Lecture 5-3 says more about difficulty with people, and lecture 5-4 about a placement that is not working. If the conduct is wrong in itself, the route to follow is in Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E), and in the meantime you tell someone you trust, such as the school's staff. You do not have to accept it as part of your training.

5. Direct and indirect cultures

Feedback does not mean the same thing everywhere. In some communities, a supervisor who respects you tells you plainly what to change, and softening it would be a kind of disrespect. In others, a supervisor who respects you would never say it plainly; the correction comes as a story, a question, or praise of something else, and silence says a great deal. In some places a student does not ask a question of an at all. In others, a student who does not ask is thought to be uninterested.

Neither way is the right one. Each has strengths and each can fail. Plain speaking can wound and can be mistaken for contempt. Careful speaking can be so careful that the message never arrives. And a supervisor and a student may come from different habits, so that a supervisor who thinks they are being clear is not understood, and a student who thinks they are being polite appears to have understood when they have not.

A few practical habits help across the difference.

  • If you come from an indirect way of speaking and your supervisor is direct, remember that the plain remark is probably not an attack. It may be a way of showing respect for your ability to hear it. If you are unsure, you may ask, "Is this something I should change, or only something to think about?"
  • If you come from a direct way of speaking and your supervisor is indirect, listen for what is not said. "That was interesting" may mean "that was a mistake." "Perhaps another time" may mean "no." If you are unsure, ask without pressure: "Is there something you would have liked me to do differently?" Give the supervisor an easy way to answer.
  • Do not decide too quickly what silence means. It may mean approval, or disapproval, or tiredness, or respect. Ask at a quiet moment.
  • Tell your supervisor how you best receive feedback, if you can do so kindly. "I find it easiest if you tell me plainly" or "I would prefer a few minutes in private afterwards" are both reasonable sentences. A good supervisor will usually be glad of the information.

This applies to you as well. When you give a word of thanks or a concern to your supervisor, think of how they are likely to hear it.

Reading a vague answer

(An invented example.) Joseph, a student in an online ministry, leads a short audio reflection. Afterwards his supervisor says, "It was interesting. Some people might find it long." Joseph is not sure whether this is praise or criticism. He says, "Thank you. Would it be better if it were shorter, or would you keep the length?" The supervisor thinks and says, "I would cut the second story." Because Joseph asked a choice question, the supervisor could answer without feeling rude. Joseph keeps a note: "second story out; try again next week."

6. Turning feedback into a plan

Feedback does nothing unless something changes. Memory is poor, and a student who hears three useful things on Tuesday may remember one on Friday. So write it down, as soon as you can, in your journal (lecture 2-2). A simple form has four lines.

  1. What was said, in the person's own words as far as you remember. Do not improve it.
  2. What I think it means. Your reading, which may be wrong.
  3. What I will try, one thing, small and clear, with a day.
  4. When I will ask again, and whom.

Notice that the first and second lines are separated. This is the same habit that lecture 2-3 taught for records: separate what was said from what you made of it. Students who write only "she thinks I am too slow" have already added an interpretation.

Bring the note to your next supervision meeting (lecture 5-1) as the "one piece of feedback I am working on". Say what you tried and what happened. This is what turns feedback into growth: the supervisor sees that you listened, you see whether the change worked, and the next piece of feedback is about something new.

Do not collect more feedback than you can use. One or two things at a time is enough. A student who tries to fix ten things at once usually fixes none.

7. Grace and accountability together

Two things need to be said together, and neither is to be said alone.

First, feedback is a form of accountability, and accountability is a good. A student who refuses all correction cannot be taught, and a placement without correction is a placement in which nothing is learned. Scripture takes this seriously: the one who listens to reproof is "at home among the wise" (Proverbs 15:31).

Second, feedback is not a verdict on you, and it is certainly not a verdict on your calling. A critical word about how you led a prayer is a word about how you led a prayer. If a supervisor tells you that you are not yet ready for a task, that is information about now and not forever. A student who hears every correction as "you are not called" will stop listening, and a student who hears every praise as "you are called" will stop learning. A placement is not a test of calling in either direction.

Both halves are needed. Without the first, grace becomes an excuse. Without the second, accountability becomes a weight. Proverbs 27:6 speaks of the wounds of a friend, and a friend's wounds are given in order to heal. Hold your supervisor's words in the same hope: that they were said to help you grow, even when they hurt.

Finally, say thank you. A supervisor who has taken the trouble to tell you something hard has given you something. A short word, "Thank you for telling me", is enough, and it makes it more likely that the next hard thing will be said.


Diagram 1. From feedback to a plan

From feedback to a plan 1. Listen Hear it to the end Say it back Ask for an example 2. Write What was said What I think it means (kept apart) 3. Weigh Work or person? Standard or preference? Who else says so? 4. Try One small change A day to try it A time to ask again Remarks that mock you, ask you to do something unsafe, or cross a boundary are not feedback. Tell someone you trust. Lectures 5-3 and 5-4 say more.

In short

  • Feedback is information about your work, given so that you can learn; it is not a verdict on your worth or your calling.
  • Defensiveness takes many forms, including explaining, counter-attack, silence and collapse; openness means listening to the end, saying it back and asking for an example.
  • Ask for specific feedback on specific work; weigh praise and criticism by asking what was seen, whether it is a standard or a preference, and who else says so.
  • Write what was said apart from what you think it means, then choose one small change and a time to ask again.
  • Cultures give feedback directly or indirectly; ask kindly for clarity and do not judge either way.
Front Back
What four things does open listening involve? Listen to the end, say it back, ask for an example, and say what you will do with it.
Why ask for specific feedback? A general question gets a general answer; a specific request on a specific piece of work gets something you can use.
What are the four lines of a feedback note? What was said, what I think it means, what I will try, and when I will ask again.
What should a student do when feedback seems vague or comes in an unfamiliar style? Ask a gentle, easy-to-answer question, such as "Would you like me to change this?", and do not decide too quickly what silence means.

One sentence to remember Feedback is a gift about your work, and it asks to be heard, weighed and used.

This week's action Ask your supervisor for one piece of specific feedback, write it in the four-line form, and choose one small thing to try before your next meeting.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which form of defensiveness (explaining, counter-attack, going quiet, collapsing, rejecting the person) is most familiar to you? What does it protect?
  • Think of a piece of feedback that helped you, from any part of life. What did the giver do that made it possible to hear?
  • In your community, how is a correction given to someone younger or less experienced? How is praise given? What might a person from another place misread?
  • What is one specific request for feedback that you could make in the next two weeks?
  • Why does it matter that feedback is not a verdict on your calling? What would be lost if it were?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.