Lecture 6-2: Evaluation and the Supervisor's Confirmation
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
- Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
- Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
- Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
- Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
- Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
- Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
- Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
- Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
- Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
- Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
- Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
- Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
- Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
- Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
A placement ends with two kinds of looking back. The student looks at their own learning. The supervisor looks at the student and, at the end, confirms the placement. School staff then check that confirmation. These are the only facts about the school's rules that this seminar states: the placement is 200 hours, it ends with a supervisor's confirmation, and staff check it. Everything else, such as what the confirmation looks like, what it must contain, when it must be given and how it reaches the school, is set by the programme guide and the school's staff. Read the guide and ask the staff. This lecture invents none of it.
What this lecture offers is a way to think about the looking back. We ask what a self-evaluation is for, how to write it as statements of learning and not as marks, what a supervisor's evaluation can and cannot be, what honesty requires of both people when a confirmation is given, and how to receive an evaluation that is a disappointment. A short section says how the placement connects to a capstone paper.
The central claim of the seminar bears directly on this. If the number of hours is the frame and not the learning, then a confirmation that says only "200 hours done" says the least important thing about the placement. The student and the supervisor can make it say something true about the learning, and the school's rules decide only how it is submitted.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Write a self-evaluation as statements of what you can now do and what you still find hard, with a piece of evidence for each.
- Say what a supervisor's evaluation is and is not, and prepare for the conversation about it.
- State which facts about the confirmation this seminar can assert and which it leaves to the programme guide and staff.
- Explain why both inflating and understating a record are failures of honesty, and say what a student can do to make an honest confirmation possible.
- Describe a fitting way to receive an evaluation that is lower than hoped.
For I say, through the grace that was given me, to every man who is among you, not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think; but to think reasonably, as God has apportioned to each person a measure of faith." — Romans 12:3
World English Bible
The ear that listens to reproof lives, and will be at home among the wise." — Proverbs 15:31
WEB
Even so you also, when you have done all the things that are commanded you, say, ‘We are unworthy servants. We have done our duty.’”" — Luke 17:10
WEB
Paul asks for an honest estimate of oneself, neither too high nor too low. An evaluation is exactly that: thinking soberly about what is true, in a measure given by grace.
A person who listens to correction is called wise. The verse does not say the correction will be pleasant or that every correction will be right. It says that listening is where growth is.
This verse is not a rule for a student's self-evaluation. In its setting, Jesus speaks to the disciples about service done without a claim on a reward. For this lecture it is a reminder that a placement is not a bargain in which hours are exchanged for approval.
1. What a self-evaluation is for
A student's self-evaluation is a short account, written near the end, of what the placement taught. It is not a mark, and it is not a defence. Nobody is being persuaded to give a good grade. It exists so that the student can see what was learned while it is still fresh, and so that the closing conversation with the supervisor has something real to start from.
The weakest self-evaluation is a list of what was done: "I led a group, I visited, I helped to organise two events." That is a record of hours and activities, and it belongs in the journal. The learning is something else. It is what the student can do or see now that they could not before.
Write in statements of learning. Each one has three parts: what I can now do or understand, what shows it, and what is still hard. For example:
- "I can now prepare for a visit by thinking about what the person might need, not only what I want to say. In the third month I began to write one question before each visit. I still find it hard to stay quiet when a person is silent."
- "I understand better that a plan needs a second person who can read it. The first schedule I made had gaps that only the supervisor saw. I still tend to finish things alone."
Each has a piece of evidence that someone could check, such as the way you changed, a thing you did differently or a conversation you remember. A self-evaluation with no evidence is a mood. A self-evaluation with no difficulty in it has not looked hard enough.
Your journal and your reflection pages (weeks 2 and 3) are where the evidence is. Read back through them with this question: what changed? Notice the entries where you were confused, the events you reflected on, and the feedback you recorded. Then write the statements. Keep them to a page or two.
2. Aims met, partly met, unmet
If you wrote a learning agreement at the beginning (lecture 1-3), take it out. It names the aims you set with your supervisor. For each aim, say honestly whether it was met, partly met or not met, and why. An unmet aim is not a disgrace. A site may not have offered the chance. The supervisor may have been unable to meet as planned. The student may have chosen an aim that was too large. Say what happened, and say what you would plan differently. The reason is not to find fault. It is to make the next agreement wiser.
3. What a supervisor's evaluation is
The supervisor knows things the student cannot see: how the student appeared to the people served, how reliable they were, how they used feedback, what a sharp or a gentle week looked like from outside. A supervisor's evaluation is that person's honest account of what they saw. It is a judgement, and like any judgement it can be wrong, and like any it deserves to be heard.
The form of the supervisor's evaluation, and what must be written and by when, are set by the programme guide and the school's staff. If you do not know, ask the staff. The supervisor may also have their own way of giving feedback, and may do it in conversation. Ask for it early, and ask for it to be specific (lecture 5-2). "You did well" is kind and tells you very little. "You were punctual, and you took correction well in the second month, and I would like to see you plan further ahead" tells you something you can use.
A supervisor can be a volunteer, short of time, and anxious about hurting a student. A student can help. Bring your own self-evaluation to the conversation. It gives the supervisor something to answer rather than a blank page. Ask two direct questions: What did you see grow in me? and What should I work on that I have not seen?
4. The supervisor's confirmation
At the end, the supervisor confirms the placement. This seminar can say only three things about that: the placement is 200 hours, it ends with the supervisor's confirmation, and school staff check the confirmation. It cannot say what the confirmation must look like, which activities count towards the hours, whether there are dates by which it must arrive, or how it is delivered. It does not say that anything is sent by email or by any automatic means. For all of that, read the programme guide and ask the school's staff.
What the seminar can say is about honesty. A confirmation is a statement that something is true. It is true only if the account behind it is true. That depends on two people.
The student's part is to keep an honest account and to put it before the supervisor without polish. Lecture 2-4, Honest Hours and Honest Accounts, taught this. If a record of hours is padded, or an account of a placement has been smoothed, the supervisor is asked to confirm something that did not happen. The supervisor may never know. The student does.
The supervisor's part is to confirm only what they believe to be true, and to say so if they cannot. A supervisor who signs because the student is kind, or because refusing would be awkward, has turned a trust into a formality. This lecture does not invent any school rule about that. It only says that it is dishonest, whoever does it.
If a student is unsure whether an activity counts, or has fewer hours than expected, or the supervisor is unsure what to confirm, the right step is to ask the school's staff before the confirmation is given. Do not decide among yourselves what the school will accept.
(An invented example.) Ada has served at a care site for most of her placement. In the last month her hours fell short because of illness in her family. She thinks she is about twenty hours behind her plan. Her supervisor, who likes her, says, "I will just confirm the full amount. You did far more than that in learning."
What was crossed here is that kindness replaced the truth. The supervisor's praise may be fair about the learning, but the hours are a separate matter. A better path starts with an honest account. Ada tells the supervisor the real number. They write down together what happened, including the illness. Then they ask the school's staff what to do, and they follow what the staff say. The supervisor may well tell the staff how much Ada learned. That is a true statement and it is a good one. It is not a substitute for the hours.
The same care applies on the other side. A student who understates, who says "I learned nothing" when the journal shows otherwise, is also giving a false account. Romans 12:3 asks for sober judgement, and sober judgement can be generous as well as strict.
5. Receiving a disappointing evaluation
It is possible to receive an evaluation lower than you hoped. A supervisor may name a weakness the student had not seen, or may say that something was not done well. This is hard to hear, particularly after months of work.
Here are four steps that tend to help.
Listen all the way through before replying. The first reaction is often to defend. A defence is sometimes right, and it is better made after a day than in the moment.
Ask for specifics. "Can you tell me about a time you saw this?" turns a general sting into something that can be examined. Sometimes the specific example shows that the supervisor was mistaken, and sometimes it shows that they were right.
Write it down and let it rest. Read it again after a day or two. Ask whether any of it is true. Most evaluations contain some truth and some distortion, and it takes time to sort them. Lecture 5-2 gave this practice in detail.
Bring a concern to the right place. If you believe the evaluation is unfair, say so to the supervisor first, calmly. If that does not help, ask the school's staff what can be done. Do not argue it in public, and do not pass it quietly to others as a complaint.
Two things the evaluation is not. It is not a verdict on whether you are called. A student may be a poor fit for one site and a fine fit for another, and a hard evaluation may tell you about the match as much as about you. Lecture 6-3 returns to this. It is also not the end of the road. Ask what a next step could be, and ask the programme guide and the staff what the options are.
6. Both people need to be able to be honest
An evaluation works when both people feel safe to say what is true. A supervisor who fears the student will leave angry may soften everything. A student who fears a poor evaluation will hide the difficulties. Each can help the other. The student can say, early, "I would rather hear the hard things." The supervisor can say, early, "I will tell you what I see, and I will not drop you." A conversation begun like that is likely to be useful.
7. How the placement connects to the capstone paper
Some students will write a capstone paper, an extended piece of academic writing. Whether and how the placement is connected to it is set by the programme guide, so follow what the guide says. If the guide invites you to draw on the placement, then your journal and reflections are a source of material, and your self-evaluation is a draft of some of its themes. But whatever you write must still protect the people involved: no real names, no places and no identifying detail, as week 2 taught. If you are unsure whether something may be used, ask your supervisor and the staff. For the writing itself, Theological Research and Writing (FS101E) goes into sources, argument and style.
8. What a good use of the final weeks looks like
A good use is calm and truthful. The student has an honest account and a written self-evaluation. The supervisor has been asked for specific feedback and has given it. Questions about what counts have been taken to the staff in good time. Nobody has agreed to a convenient version of events. The confirmation, when given, says something that is true. That is all it needs to be.
Diagram 1. Two looks back, and what lies outside them
In short
- The school's rules, as stated here, are only these: 200 hours, a supervisor's confirmation, and staff who check it; everything else is for the programme guide and staff.
- A self-evaluation is a set of statements of learning with evidence and with difficulty named, not a list of activities and not a mark.
- A confirmation is true only if the account behind it is true; both inflating and understating are failures of honesty.
- If unsure whether something counts, ask the school's staff before the confirmation is given.
- A hard evaluation is to be heard, checked and learned from; it is not a verdict on a call.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A statement of learning | What I can now do or understand, what shows it, and what is still hard. |
| Who decides the form and deadline of the confirmation? | The programme guide and the school's staff; this seminar invents none. |
| When is a confirmation honest? | When the account behind it is true, and the supervisor confirms only what they believe to be true. |
| First steps with a disappointing evaluation | Listen fully, ask for specifics, write it down and let it rest, then take a real concern to the supervisor and, if needed, the staff. |
One sentence to remember A confirmation says something worth saying only when what it confirms is true.
This week's action Read your learning agreement and journal and write three statements of learning, each with evidence and one difficulty. Bring them to your supervisor.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of something you can do now that you could not do at the start of your placement, or a placement you expect. What would you point to as evidence?
- Why is "I did these activities" weaker than "I can now do this, and this shows it"?
- A supervisor says, "I will confirm it all; you learned plenty." What is right and what is missing in that kindness?
- How does your community or culture usually give hard feedback, directly or indirectly? How might that shape how you hear an evaluation?
- If you received an evaluation lower than you hoped, which of the four steps would be hardest for you, and who could help?