Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
- Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
- Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
- Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
- Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
- Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
- Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
- Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
- Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
- Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
- Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
- Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
- Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
- Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
- Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
Wherever people work closely together for months, they will sometimes disagree, misunderstand each other, or hurt each other without meaning to. A placement is no exception. You may differ with your supervisor about how a task should be done. You may be irritated by a colleague, or by a person you serve who asks for more than you can give. You may find that a message was read in a way you never meant. None of this means the placement has failed, or that you are in the wrong place, or that someone is a bad person. Difficulty is part of learning beside people, because people are not easy.
This lecture asks how to meet difficulty so that it becomes learning and not damage. It follows the lecture on feedback, but it is wider, because conflict can arise with a supervisor, with colleagues, or with those you serve, and it is not always about your work. The central claim of this seminar is that a placement is learning beside people and a supervisor, and looking back in the light of faith. Conflict is one of the places where that learning is most real.
This lecture is about ordinary disagreement and difficulty. It does not deal with wrong conduct, such as abuse, exploitation or harm, which is a different matter and is treated in Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E). A short section below says how to tell the two apart.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Separate what happened, what you felt and what you think it means when you are in a disagreement.
- Describe a sequence of steps: pause, reread the agreement, speak directly, involve a third person, and know when to step back.
- Read Matthew 18:15-17 in its context and explain why it is not a rule for every disagreement.
- Say what reconciliation can and cannot require, and how forgiveness differs from restored trust.
- Tell the difference between ordinary conflict and wrong conduct, and say what to do in the second case.
If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother. But if he doesn’t listen, take one or two more with you, that at the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the assembly. If he refuses to hear the assembly also, let him be to you as a Gentile or a tax collector." — Matthew 18:15-17
World English Bible
If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18
WEB
Be angry, and don’t sin.” Don’t let the sun go down on your wrath, neither give place to the devil." — Ephesians 4:26-27
WEB
The first passage gives a path for a wrong done between believers, which begins in private and widens only if needed. The second is honest about its limits: "if it is possible" and "as much as it is up to you". The third says that anger is not itself a sin but that it must not be stored up. Together they ask for directness, patience and realism.
1. Difficulty is ordinary
Many students expect that if they are in the right place, things will go smoothly, and that conflict is a sign of a mistake. This is not what the Bible shows, nor what most communities find. Even in the early church, workers disagreed sharply (Acts 15:36-41, which lecture 5-4 returns to). A disagreement is information. It may show that two people understand the task differently, that an expectation was never said aloud, that someone is tired, or that two good aims are pulling in different directions.
A placement is also a place where several ways of doing things meet. A supervisor from one tradition and a student from another, a long-serving volunteer and a new arrival, a person served who is in pain and a student who is afraid of saying the wrong thing: each combination can produce friction without anyone being at fault. Learning to meet this well is a skill, and it is one that you will use for the rest of your service.
One more point at the start. A placement is not a test of . A student who has a conflict is not shown thereby to be unfit, and a student who has none is not shown to be called. How you meet the difficulty is more useful to learn from than whether it happens.
2. Fact, feeling and meaning
When you are upset, the first step is not to speak. It is to sort what is in your head. A simple three-part sorting helps, and you can do it on a page in a few minutes.
- What happened. Only what a camera would record, in plain words. "On Wednesday the supervisor told me at nine in the evening that I was needed at six the next morning."
- What I felt. Honestly, without arguing with the feeling. "I felt angry, and then ashamed that I was angry."
- What I think it means. Your reading, labelled as a reading. "I think he does not value my time." Then ask: what else could it mean? "He may have had a sudden need. He may not know that I travel an hour."
The third part is where most conflicts grow. A fact is small; an interpretation can be very large. Many arguments are really about the interpretations, and the facts were never in dispute. It also helps to write what the other person might say, as fairly as you can: "From his side, he might say that he tried to reach me earlier and could not." You may be wrong about this too, but the effort changes how you feel. This is the same habit as in lecture 3-2, where you separated the facts from interpretation before asking what you had missed.
Then ask a question that is harder: what is my part? Not to blame yourself, but because you can change only your own part. Perhaps you did not say that mornings are difficult. Perhaps you answered curtly. Perhaps there was nothing. Sometimes there is nothing, and it is honest to say so.
3. Steps, in order
There is no single procedure that suits every place and every person, and this seminar does not make one. But there is a sequence that wise people have followed in many communities, and it can be summed up in this order.
- Pause. Do not answer in the first hour, or the first day if you can wait. Do not send a message when you are angry. Rest, eat, pray, walk. Ephesians 4:26 says that anger itself is not the sin; the sin is what we do with it, and carrying it for weeks. Pausing is not the same as avoiding.
- Reread your learning agreement (lecture 1-3) and any written rules of the site. Many disagreements are about what was agreed, and the paper often settles it, or shows that something was never agreed and needs to be.
- Speak directly, privately and early. Go to the person concerned, at a good time, and describe what you saw and how it affected you, then ask for their view. "On Wednesday I was asked at nine in the evening to come at six. I would like to help, and I could not plan. Can we talk about how to give notice?" Speak about the matter, not about the person's character. Listen to the answer. You may find out that you misunderstood.
- Involve a third person if direct talk does not help, or if it is not safe or not possible. The third person may be another leader at the site, an older member you trust, or the school's staff. Tell the person you are doing this, if it is safe to do so. Bring your written notes, with the facts separate from feelings.
- Step back if you must. If a situation is unsafe, or the conflict is hurting you or others, you may withdraw from the matter, or pause your work there, and tell the supervisor or staff why. Lecture 5-4 speaks about changing or ending a placement.
These steps are a guide. If the person you are in conflict with is your supervisor, the direct step is more delicate, because your supervisor has authority over you and over your confirmation. Even so, honesty with a supervisor is usually the right beginning, and many supervisors respect a student who comes quietly and says, "I would like to understand something." If you do not feel able, or you fear the response, go to the third step: speak with someone else at the site you trust, or with school staff, and ask how to proceed.
4. Direct and indirect ways
As in feedback, communities differ in how disagreement is spoken. In some places a person goes straight to another person and says it plainly, and a go-between would be an insult. In others, going straight would be a shock, and the proper way is through an older relative, a senior member or a respected friend, who carries the matter gently. In some places raising a disagreement with someone older or senior is very hard for a younger person.
The steps above do not tell you to use one style. What matters in all of them is that the person concerned does not hear about it last, behind their back, and that something is actually done, instead of the resentment being carried silently. If your community's way is through a go-between, you may use that way, provided that the go-between is trusted by both and that the matter is not simply left to grow. If you are in a place where customs differ from your own, ask a trusted person how disagreement is usually raised, and do not assume that your habit is the plain one.
5. Matthew 18:15-17, read with care
A passage often used, and often stretched
Matthew 18:15-17 is the best-known passage on conflict, and it is easy to misuse. Read it in its context.
First, it speaks of a particular case: "if your brother sins against you". It is about a wrong done, among believers, where one party is in the right. Many disagreements are not that. If your supervisor prefers one method and you prefer another, no one has sinned against anyone. If you are tired and short with each other, the passage does not need to be run like a procedure.
Second, its purpose is stated: "you have gained back your brother." The aim of the steps is to restore a relationship, not to win. The widening circle, one person, then two or three, then the assembly, is a way of taking seriously that private talk may fail and that a wrong should not simply be buried.
Third, it was written for a community of equals. A student who is under a supervisor's authority is not in the same position as one brother speaking to another. A student who is being harmed is not asked by this passage to confront the person alone; the Bible elsewhere speaks of protecting the weak (Proverbs 31:8-9, which lecture 4-2 uses). Safety comes first, and a third person is wise.
Fourth, readers differ on its last words. Some read "as a Gentile or a tax collector" as a final separation. Others point out that Jesus ate with tax collectors and that the phrase may mean "a person you still hope to win". Traditions also differ on who "the assembly" is and who has authority to decide. This seminar does not settle these questions. For the purposes of a placement, what matters is the first two steps: speak with the person, and if that fails, bring someone wise. The last steps belong to the church's own life and are not a student's to carry out.
6. Two small cases
A disagreement about method
(An invented example.) Lucia serves in a parish programme for children. Her supervisor wants the children to sit still while Lucia reads a story. Lucia believes the children learn better when they act it out. For three weeks Lucia follows the instruction with a tight face, and then on the fourth Sunday does it her own way without telling anyone. The supervisor is surprised and a little hurt. Lucia feels vindicated and then uneasy.
What went wrong. There was no sin on either side. But Lucia, instead of saying what she thought, went round the instruction. The supervisor, who may have had good reasons, did not know them.
A better path. Lucia pauses, writes down the three parts (what happened, what she felt, what she thinks it means), and asks for ten minutes. She says, "I have been reading the story as you asked. I wonder if I might try once with the children acting it, and tell you how it goes. Would that be possible?" The supervisor says, "In this room we keep quiet, because there is a service next door. Try it outside, on Tuesday." The disagreement was about a practical matter Lucia could not have seen. Even if the supervisor had said no, the matter would have been spoken, and the instruction of the site would have come first.
(An invented example.) Samuel serves in a hospital visiting programme. A person he visits, in pain and frightened, speaks sharply to him one day and tells him to leave. Samuel is hurt. He decides the person does not want him and plans to avoid the room. What went wrong is that he took a frightened remark as a verdict on himself. A better path is for Samuel to pause, write the facts and his feeling, and bring it to his supervisor at the next meeting: "She told me to leave and I felt rejected. How would you read it, and what would you do?" The supervisor may say that sharpness often comes from fear, and that it is right to respect a request to leave, and to return another day, gently, and to ask whether she would like him to come. The conflict was not really with Samuel. It was between a person and her pain. Learning to tell the difference is a part of what a placement teaches.
7. Reconciliation, and its limits
Romans 12:18 is honest: "If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." It does not say that peace will always happen. Some people will not be reconciled. Your part is to do what depends on you: to speak honestly, to listen, to apologise for your own part, to refuse to repay in kind. You cannot do the other person's part.
It also helps to separate three things that are often joined.
- Forgiving is releasing the wish to repay. You can do it alone, and it does not depend on the other person's response.
- Reconciling is restoring a relationship. It needs both people, and it needs truth.
- Trusting again is a matter of what the other person has shown over time. A person may be forgiven and yet not be given a task that needs trust until they have shown they can bear it.
A student may forgive a supervisor or a colleague and still choose, wisely, to set a limit. This is not hardness of heart. It is realism. In the same way, an apology that is quick and costs nothing may not mean that the matter is mended. Real reconciliation takes time, and sometimes the best that can be done is to part in peace and speak no ill.
Grace and accountability go together here too. If you have been in the wrong, say so plainly without making a show of guilt. If the other person was in the wrong, there is room for both mercy and honesty. Neither is a substitute for the other.
8. Ordinary conflict, and wrong conduct
Most difficulty in a placement is ordinary: misunderstanding, difference, tiredness, clashing habits. But there is a different category, and a student should know it exists. It includes any behaviour that harms or exploits a person, whether by a supervisor, a colleague or anyone else at the site: abuse, harassment, being asked to cross a boundary, pressure to keep something secret that should not be kept, or a danger to a child or other vulnerable person. These are not matters for the steps above, and they are not matters to settle between two people alone.
If you see or suspect such a thing, or if it happens to you:
- Do not carry it alone. Tell your supervisor at once, unless the supervisor is the person involved; in that case, tell another leader at the site you trust, or the school's staff, or a trusted pastor, priest or other safeguarding person.
- Rules about reporting differ from place to place and from community to community. This seminar states no legal duty. Follow your local law, the written rules of the site, and the advice of the person you have told.
- If someone is in danger now, call your local emergency number.
- For what conduct is wrong and how it is dealt with, the place to go is Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E). This seminar does not repeat it.
Do not wait until you are certain. If you are unsure whether something is ordinary or wrong, tell someone and ask. That is not an accusation; it is a request for help.
9. When you are the one in the wrong
One last note. You will sometimes be the person in the wrong: late, careless, short-tempered, unfair. When that happens, the steps run in the other direction. Say what you did, without excuses. Say sorry. Ask what you can do to put it right, and do it. A student who can apologise simply is easier to teach and easier to trust. Ephesians 4:26 may be read both ways: a person who has been angry should not let the sun go down on it, and a person who has caused anger should not let it stand either.
Diagram 1. Steps in a disagreement
In short
- Difficulty is ordinary in a placement; it is information, and it does not prove that you are in the wrong place or called wrongly.
- Sort what happened, what you felt and what you think it means, and ask what your own part is.
- Pause, reread the agreement, speak directly and privately, involve a third person if needed, and step back if it is unsafe.
- Matthew 18:15-17 concerns a wrong done between believers, aims to win back a brother, and is not a rule for every disagreement.
- Forgiving, reconciling and trusting again are different; abuse, exploitation and danger are never carried alone and go by the route in FS102E.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What three things do you sort when you are upset? | What happened, what I felt, and what I think it means. |
| What are the five steps in a disagreement? | Pause, reread the agreement, speak directly, involve a third person, step back if unsafe. |
| Why is Matthew 18:15-17 not a rule for every disagreement? | It speaks of a wrong done between believers and aims at restoring a relationship; many disagreements involve no wrong, and it was written for equals. |
| What do you do if you suspect abuse, exploitation or danger? | Do not carry it alone; tell the supervisor (or another trusted person if the supervisor is involved) at once, follow local law and site rules, and call your local emergency number if there is danger now. |
One sentence to remember Meet difficulty by sorting before speaking, speaking before stewing, and never carrying real harm alone.
This week's action Choose one small friction in your placement or daily life. Write the three parts (what happened, what I felt, what I think it means) and one thing that is my part.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a disagreement you have had in any kind of work. Which was larger, the facts or the interpretation of them?
- In your community, how is a disagreement with an older or senior person usually raised? What does that way protect, and what can it hide?
- Why might Matthew 18:15-17 be misused if it is treated as a rule for every disagreement? What question would you ask before applying it?
- What is the difference between forgiving someone and trusting them again? Can you give a case where the two come apart?
- Which step in the sequence is hardest for you: pausing, speaking directly, or asking a third person for help?