FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS201E Field Placement Seminar: Learning to Serve, Record and Reflect

Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn

Contents 31
FS201E Field Placement Seminar: Learning to Serve, Record and Reflect
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Learning Beside People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Learning Beside People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Before You Begin
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
  2. Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
  4. Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Keeping Records
  1. Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
  2. Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
  3. Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
  4. Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Theological Reflection
  1. Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
  2. Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
  3. Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
  4. Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Limits and Safety
  1. Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
  2. Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
  3. Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
  4. Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Supervisor and Feedback
  1. Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
  2. Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
  3. Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
  4. Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Finishing and Discerning
  1. Lecture 6-1: Finishing Well
  2. Lecture 6-2: Evaluation and the Supervisor's Confirmation
  3. Lecture 6-3: After the Placement: Discerning What Comes Next
  4. Lecture 6-4: Carrying the Habit Forward
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Looking Back and One Page of Next Steps

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Lecture 1-1 said that a placement is for learning beside people. This lecture asks a practical question that follows: how do you choose the place? This seminar does not choose a place for you and does not name one. The programme guide and the school's staff decide which kinds of placement are acceptable, so you should read the guide and ask the staff before you commit. Within that, the choice is yours to make well.

A student may serve in a parish or a house church, in a mission or relief work, in a school or a youth or campus programme, in hospital visiting or other care work, in a community project, or in an online ministry. All of these can be good places to learn, and none of them is good for every student. This lecture gives five questions to ask about any place, a list of questions to take to a site, and a fair account of the place that a student already knows. It ends with a point on which readers do not agree: whether learning is deeper in familiar or unfamiliar ground.

The week's principle applies. Good preparation names the aims and the limits. A place is chosen well when you can say what you hope to learn there and what you cannot give.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Use five questions to compare possible places for a placement.
  • Name what a student should ask a site before agreeing to serve there.
  • Describe the advantages of serving where you already volunteer, and the trap of counting old duties as new learning.
  • Say what an online placement needs to be a real placement and what extra care it calls for.
  • State fairly two views on familiar and unfamiliar ground, and say what this seminar requires.

For which of you, desiring to build a tower, doesn’t first sit down and count the cost, to see if he has enough to complete it? Or perhaps, when he has laid a foundation, and is not able to finish, everyone who sees begins to mock him, saying, ‘This man began to build, and wasn’t able to finish.’" — Luke 14:28-30

World English Bible

Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22

WEB

After these things Paul departed from Athens, and came to Corinth. He found a certain Jew named Aquila, a man of Pontus by race, who had recently come from Italy, with his wife Priscilla, because Claudius had commanded all the Jews to depart from Rome. He came to them, and because he practiced the same trade, he lived with them and worked, for by trade they were tent makers." — Acts 18:1-3

WEB

The picture is of someone who counts the cost before building. Choosing a place is a time for counting honestly: time, strength, money and the people who depend on you.

Plans do well with counsel. A student who chooses alone, without asking anyone who knows the place, takes a risk that is easy to avoid.

Paul arrives in a city, finds a household, stays with them and works beside them. The passage does not describe a school placement, but it shows a person choosing a place where there was work to share and people to share it with.

1. Five questions to ask about any place

When you compare possible places, five questions are useful. They do not give a mark. They help you see what each place can and cannot offer.

Can I learn there? A place where you will be busy is not necessarily a place where you will learn. Ask whether anyone there does the work well and is willing to let you watch, to explain what they do, and to tell you when you are wrong. Ask whether you will be given any task that stretches you, and some time to think about it. If the answer is "we just need people to help," that is a good need, but it may not be a placement.

Is there a supervisor? Lecture 1-3 says what a supervisor does. At this stage ask a plain question: is there a person at the site, or connected with it, who is willing to be responsible for your learning, to meet you regularly and to give a confirmation at the end? The programme guide and the school's staff set who may supervise. A site with no one who can do this is a hard place to run a placement, however good its work.

Is it safe? Safety here means more than physical safety, though that matters: travel, home visits, working alone, late hours, unfamiliar neighbourhoods. It also means safety for the people you will serve, and a place that has clear rules about how students and volunteers deal with children, sick people and others who may be vulnerable. Ask what the site's rules are, in writing if they exist. Week 4 comes back to this in more detail, and Ministry Ethics and Boundaries (FS102E) teaches the conduct that goes with it. For now, a site that cannot say how it keeps people safe is a site to think about carefully.

Does it fit my time, my family and my work? A placement that is wonderful on paper and impossible in your week will fail. Count the hours, the travel and the evenings. Count the people who depend on you: children, parents, a spouse, an employer. Count your own strength. This is not selfishness. The person who promises 15 hours a week and delivers 4 helps nobody, including the site.

Does it fit my interests and my gifts? A place that matches what you enjoy and do well is a good start. But look at this honestly in both directions. A place that fits your gifts will let you do useful work at once. A place that stretches your gifts will teach you more slowly and perhaps more deeply. You will often have to weigh the two. We return to this below.

No place will score perfectly on all five. The questions are for conversation, with the supervisor, with a trusted person, and with the school's staff. They are not a test that a place must pass.

2. Questions to take to a site

Before you agree to serve, a short conversation with the site can save weeks of misunderstanding. These questions are suitable for almost any setting. They are written plainly so that you can ask them in your own words.

  • What does this place do, and whom does it serve?
  • What would I be asked to do in the first weeks, and what would I not be asked to do?
  • Who would be my supervisor? How often could we meet, and for how long?
  • Who else would I work beside, and who decides when something is unclear?
  • What are the site's written rules for volunteers and students? May I read them?
  • What should I do if I am worried about someone's safety, or about my own?
  • Has this place had students before? What did it learn from them?
  • What would help the place most from me, and what would help me most from the place?

The last question matters. It puts both aims on the table at the start, as lecture 1-1 asked. If the site says only "we need help" or the student says only "I need hours," the conversation has stopped too early.

Notice also what you hear in the way questions are answered. A leader who welcomes your questions and answers them plainly is a good sign. A leader who is irritated by them, or who cannot say what the work is, tells you something too. You do not need to conclude that the place is bad. But you may conclude that it is not the right place to learn.

3. Serving where you already volunteer

Many students begin with a place they already know: a congregation where they have served for years, a school where they have helped, a project in their own neighbourhood. This is a natural choice, and it has real advantages.

You already know the people and the people know you. You do not need months to earn trust before real work begins. You understand the language, the customs and the pace of the place. Your travel is easy. And a placement in a place where you already belong may be the most honest kind of service, because it grows out of what you are already doing.

There is also a trap, and it is a common one. A student who has served in the same way for years may simply give the old work a new name. The 200 hours are filled by duties that were already being done, in the same way, with the same people, and nothing new is learned. The placement becomes a record of what the person was doing anyway. The hours may be honest. The learning is missing.

(An invented example.) Ruth has helped in the kitchen of her congregation's weekly meal for eleven years. She decides to use this as her placement. Her pastor is glad to confirm it, because Ruth is reliable and everyone knows it. After three months she notices that she has learned nothing she did not know before. She is doing what she always did.

What was crossed here is not dishonesty. Ruth is not padding anything. What was missing was a new aim. A better path keeps the kitchen and adds something to it. Ruth could ask the pastor, or another leader, whether she could take part in the planning of the meal, or spend some of the time talking with the guests, or learn how the congregation decides whom to invite. She could also write down what she wants to learn that she did not know before. The place is the same. The placement is different, because now there is something to learn.

Two further cautions. First, check with the programme guide and the school's staff whether a site where you already serve is suitable and whether previous service counts. Do not assume. Second, a person who is already part of a place may find it hard to say honest things in a supervision meeting, because the supervisor is also a friend, a pastor or an employer. Talk about how you will make that possible.

4. One site or several

Some students serve in one place for the whole time. Some serve in two or three, for example a few months in a parish and a few months in a hospital. The programme guide and the staff set what is allowed, so ask them. Within what is allowed, the choice has costs on both sides.

A single place gives depth. You see a cycle of the year, you see how people change, and you are trusted with more as time passes. You build one relationship with one supervisor. The risk is that you see only one way of doing things and may think it is the only way.

Several places give breadth. You compare how different communities work, and you may find out what suits you. The risk is that you are always new, you never take real responsibility, and you have three supervisors who each know you a little. If you take several places, make sure that each has a supervisor and that someone helps you to put them together.

5. An online placement

Some students serve through an online ministry: a video prayer meeting, a Bible study by messages, a website that answers questions, a service held online for people who cannot attend in person. These can be real placements. Online ministry reaches people who are far away, housebound or afraid to be seen entering a church, and it is a place where the church is learning.

An online placement needs the same things as any other: a supervisor who is responsible and available, a clear task, regular meetings and a way to look back. It also needs some care of its own. It is easy to be unseen online, and a student may be given a lot of freedom and little teaching. Ask who sees what you write or say. Ask how people are protected, especially children and others who may be vulnerable, and what the site's rules are about private messages. Ask where the recordings and the messages are stored and who may read them. If time zones separate you from your supervisor, agree on a way to meet that works for both. And keep in mind that a person you cannot see is as real as a person in the room.

6. This is a point where readers will not agree

Does a student learn more in familiar ground or in unfamiliar ground?

Some readers hold that unfamiliar ground teaches best. They would say that a student who stays among people and customs already known will not see what is taken for granted, will not have to ask questions, and will meet little that is new. Their reasoning is that learning is sharpest when it is a little uncomfortable. A different kind of congregation, a different part of the city, or a different tradition forces the student to look carefully, and also to notice their own assumptions. For these readers, a student should be willing to be a stranger.

Other readers hold that depth and trust come from familiar ground. They would say that a student who is always new learns only the surface of a place, and that people do not tell a stranger their real needs. Their reasoning is that the deepest lessons of ministry, such as patience, faithfulness and the ability to stay, can be learned only where a person remains. And a student who already has relationships can give more and be corrected more honestly. For these readers, a student should go further into the place they already know.

Both positions have a serious defence and a serious risk. The first can send a student into a place where they are lost and unsupported, or where they treat others as a field trip. The second can leave a student comfortable, with nothing challenged. What this seminar requires is less than either side may ask: whichever you choose, name what will be new to you, and write down what you will learn that you would not learn by doing what you already do. If the place is familiar, find a way to see it with new eyes. If it is unfamiliar, find someone who can help you to understand it.

7. Two small cases

(An invented example.) Samuel is offered a placement with a team that visits homes in an area he has never lived in. He is excited, and he says yes at once. Only later does he learn that the visits are made in the evening, that the team often works alone in pairs, and that his own supervisor lives in another city and is reached by phone. He has not asked about travel, about safety, or about how often they would meet.

What was crossed here is that excitement took the place of questions. A better path is for Samuel to go back to the leader of the team, apologise for not asking earlier, and ask the questions in this lecture. If the visits can be made in daylight, or with an experienced person for the first weeks, or with a supervisor he can meet in person at regular times, he may be able to continue. If they cannot, he can say so honestly and look for another place. Changing his mind before he begins is much better than leaving after harm.

(An invented example.) Martha is asked by a friend to serve in a small house church that has no one to supervise her. The friend says, "You will learn by doing, and I will be your supervisor, though I am very busy." Martha does not want to hurt her friend. She says yes. Three months later she has met her friend twice, both times for a few minutes after a service.

What was crossed here is that kindness stood in for a plan. A better path would have asked, at the start, whether her friend could meet each week or each second week, and whether another leader could take part. A busy volunteer who says yes without thinking about the time is not a bad person. It is a small, ordinary mistake, and it can be put right now. Martha can ask her friend for an honest conversation: "I think we both want this to work. What can we really do?" If the answer is that regular meetings are not possible, a different arrangement or a different place may serve everyone better.

Ask early, ask kindly

It is easier to ask a hard question before you begin than to leave after a misunderstanding. A site that gives clear answers is one you can learn from.


Diagram 1. Five questions and questions for a site

Choosing Where to Learn Five questions. No place answers all of them perfectly. Learn? Will someone teach me and let me think about it? Supervisor? A person who will meet me and give a confirmation Safe? For me and for those served; clear written rules My life? Time, family, work, travel and my own strength Gifts? Fits what I do well, and stretches what I do not yet Take these to a conversation with the site and to the programme guide and the school's staff Two traps Old duties given a new name: hours without new learning A kind yes without a plan: no regular meeting, no clear task Where readers disagree Familiar ground or unfamiliar ground? Minimum: whichever you choose, name what will be new to you and what you will learn that you would not otherwise.

In short

  • Five questions help compare places: can I learn there, is there a supervisor, is it safe, does it fit my life, does it fit and stretch my gifts.
  • Ask the site plain questions before you agree, including its written rules and what would help each side most.
  • Serving where you already volunteer is a good choice if you name something new to learn; old duties given a new name are not a placement.
  • An online placement needs a supervisor and a clear task like any other, and extra care about who sees what, and about those who may be vulnerable.
  • Readers disagree on familiar versus unfamiliar ground; this seminar asks you to name what will be new, wherever you serve.
Front Back
Five questions about a place Can I learn there? Is there a supervisor? Is it safe? Does it fit my life? Does it fit and stretch my gifts?
The trap of the familiar place Counting old duties as new learning; the hours may be honest while the learning is missing.
What an online placement needs A responsible supervisor, a clear task, regular meetings, and care about who sees what and who may be vulnerable.
Who decides which places are allowed The programme guide and the school's staff; ask them before you commit.

One sentence to remember Choose a place by asking what you can learn there, not only what it needs.

This week's action Write the five questions on a page and, for one place you are thinking about, write a short honest answer to each. Mark the answers you do not yet know and decide whom to ask.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the five questions (learn, supervisor, safe, my life, gifts) do you tend to forget when you are excited about a place?
  • Look at the questions to take to a site. Which would be hardest for you to ask, and why? How could you ask it kindly?
  • If you already serve somewhere, what could you learn there that you have not yet learned? Who could teach it?
  • State in your own words the strongest form of the view that unfamiliar ground teaches best, and of the view that familiar ground teaches best. Which parts would you keep?
  • Paul found a household in Corinth and worked beside them (Acts 18:1-3). Who might be that kind of companion for you in a placement?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.