FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT602E The Synoptic Gospels

Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal

Contents 37
BT602E The Synoptic Gospels
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Three Gospels, One Subject
  1. Introduction: Three Gospels, One Subject
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: What the Synoptic Gospels Are
  1. Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
  2. Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
  3. Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Synoptic Problem
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The World in Which Jesus Taught
  1. Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
  2. Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
  3. Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Gospel of Mark
  1. Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
  2. Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
  3. Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Gospel of Matthew
  1. Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
  2. Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Gospel of Luke
  1. Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
  2. Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: The Kingdom of God
  1. Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
  2. Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Parables
  1. Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
  2. Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
  3. Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Miracles, Exorcisms, and Healing
  1. Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
  2. Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
  3. Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Jesus, the Law, the Temple, and Israel
  1. Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
  2. Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
  3. Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Passion, Death, and Resurrection
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
  2. Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
  3. Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: The Historical Jesus and the Gospels Today
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Quests for the Historical Jesus, from Reimarus to the Present
  2. Lecture 12-2: Criteria, Method, and What History Can and Cannot Establish
  3. Lecture 12-3: Preaching and Teaching the Synoptic Gospels

Jump to the key points ↓

48 min

The parables in this lecture are mostly Luke's, and they behave differently from the kingdom parables of lecture 8-2. Those were about a process. These are about people: a father with two sons, a traveller who stops, a rich man who does not, a manager who cheats his way to a soft landing, servants given money, women waiting with lamps, tenants who kill an heir. They are longer, they have dialogue, and several of them end without telling us what happened.

Two commitments shape the lecture, and both should be stated at the start so that the reader can watch for them.

The first is that the endings matter. The parable of the father and two sons does not end with the party; it ends with the father outside in the dark, pleading with the elder son, and the elder son's answer is not recorded. The parable of the dishonest manager ends with a commendation nobody has satisfactorily explained. A reading which quietly finishes these stories on the interpreter's behalf has replaced the parable with a summary of it — and, as lecture 8-1 argued, a parable that has been fully resolved has stopped doing what parables do.

The second is that several of these parables have a long history of being read in ways that make Judaism the antagonist. The elder brother has been decoded as the Pharisees, and beyond them as the Jewish people, jealous of the Gentiles' welcome. The priest and the Levite have been explained as men whose purity law forbade them to touch a body — a claim the text does not make and which misdescribes the law it invokes. The tenants in the vineyard have been read as Israel, dispossessed in favour of the church. These readings are not marginal; they are in commentaries, in preaching, and in the hymns and art of many centuries. This lecture treats them as an interpretive problem to be examined rather than an embarrassment to be passed over, and gives particular attention to the criticism of them by the Jewish New Testament scholar Amy-Jill Levine, including the places where her own proposals have been questioned in turn.

What these 48 minutes give you

  • Explain how the setting at Luke 15:1-3 shapes all three parables that follow, and state what the third parable asks of the elder son without supplying an answer the text withholds.
  • Identify at least three points at which a common Christian reading of these parables depends on an unsupported claim about first-century Judaism, and explain in each case what the text actually says.
  • Set out four or more distinct interpretations of the dishonest manager in Luke 16:1-8 and explain why the parable remains genuinely unresolved.
  • Compare the talents in Matthew 25 with the minas in Luke 19, describe the structural differences, and present both the stewardship reading and William Herzog's subversive reading in their strongest forms.
  • State what the parable of the wicked tenants claims and what it does not, and describe how the "given to others" of Mark 12:9 has been read both supersessionistically and otherwise.

Now all the tax collectors and sinners were coming close to him to hear him. The Pharisees and the scribes murmured, saying, “This man welcomes sinners, and eats with them.” He told them this parable. — Luke 15:1-3

World English Bible

But he was angry, and would not go in. Therefore his father came out, and begged him. But he answered his father, ‘Behold, these many years I have served you, and I never disobeyed a commandment of yours, but you never gave me a goat, that I might celebrate with my friends. But when this, your son, came, who has devoured your living with prostitutes, you killed the fattened calf for him.’ “He said to him, ‘Son, you are always with me, and all that is mine is yours. But it was appropriate to celebrate and be glad, for this, your brother, was dead, and is alive again. He was lost, and is found.’” — Luke 15:28-32

WEB

But a certain Samaritan, as he traveled, came where he was. When he saw him, he was moved with compassion, came to him, and bound up his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. He set him on his own animal, and brought him to an inn, and took care of him. — Luke 10:33-34

WEB

Now there was a certain rich man, and he was clothed in purple and fine linen, living in luxury every day. A certain beggar, named Lazarus, was laid at his gate, full of sores, and desiring to be fed with the crumbs that fell from the rich man’s table. Yes, even the dogs came and licked his sores. — Luke 16:19-21

WEB

He also said to his disciples, “There was a certain rich man who had a manager. An accusation was made to him that this man was wasting his possessions. He called him, and said to him, ‘What is this that I hear about you? Give an accounting of your management, for you can no longer be manager.’ “The manager said within himself, ‘What will I do, seeing that my lord is taking away the management position from me? I don’t have strength to dig. I am ashamed to beg. I know what I will do, so that when I am removed from management, they may receive me into their houses.’ — Luke 16:1-4

WEB

His lord commended the dishonest manager because he had done wisely, for the children of this world are, in their own generation, wiser than the children of the light. — Luke 16:8

WEB

He began to speak to them in parables. “A man planted a vineyard, put a hedge around it, dug a pit for the wine press, built a tower, rented it out to a farmer, and went into another country. — Mark 12:1

WEB

Therefore still having one, his beloved son, he sent him last to them, saying, ‘They will respect my son.’ But those farmers said among themselves, ‘This is the heir. Come, let’s kill him, and the inheritance will be ours.’ They took him, killed him, and cast him out of the vineyard. What therefore will the lord of the vineyard do? He will come and destroy the farmers, and will give the vineyard to others. — Mark 12:6-9

WEB

But the tax collector, standing far away, wouldn’t even lift up his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, a sinner!’ I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but he who humbles himself will be exalted.” — Luke 18:13-14

WEB

Luke 15:1-3 is placed first because it is the frame for everything in the first half of the lecture: three parables told in answer to a complaint about table fellowship. Luke 15:28-32 is quoted rather than summarised because the ending is the argument of this lecture's central section, and paraphrase always finishes it. The two verses from the Samaritan give the action without the framing question, so that the reader can notice what the story says about the Samaritan and what it does not say about anyone else. Luke 16:1-4 and 16:8 give the beginning and the punchline of the dishonest manager with the middle omitted; the omission is deliberate and is explained in the lecture. Mark 12:1 and 12:6-9 supply the vineyard parable at its two decisive points. Luke 18:13-14 is here because the Pharisee and the tax collector is the parable most easily used to reproduce the fault it describes.

1. The frame at Luke 15

Luke does something with these parables that Matthew and Mark rarely do: he tells us what the argument was about. Tax collectors and sinners are drawing near; Pharisees and scribes complain that this man welcomes sinners and eats with them; and then, in the singular — "he told them this parable" — three stories follow. A lost sheep, a lost coin, and a man with two sons.

The complaint is about table fellowship, and it is a serious complaint, not a petty one. Eating with someone in this culture was an act with social meaning, as lecture 3-3 of this course sets out: it acknowledged the other as an acceptable associate. To eat regularly with people known for defrauding their neighbours was to make a public statement about them. A reader who treats the objection as mere snobbery has not understood the objection and therefore cannot understand the answer.

The first two parables share a shape: something is lost, someone searches, it is found, and there is a celebration with friends and neighbours. Both end with a statement about joy in heaven over one sinner who repents. Notice that the sheep and the coin do not repent; the word is in the application, not in the stories. This is one of the places where the relation between a parable and its attached application is worth watching, in the manner described in lecture 8-1.

The third parable has the same shape and then keeps going.

2. The father and two sons, and the son who is left outside

The parable falls into two halves of nearly equal weight. The younger son asks for his share of the property, leaves, spends it, reaches destitution among pigs, rehearses a speech, returns, and is met before he can deliver it. The father runs, embraces him, and orders a celebration. That is where most readers stop, and it is where roughly half the parable stops.

The second half begins with the son in the field. He hears music, asks a servant what is happening, learns the reason, and refuses to go in. The father comes out and pleads with him. The elder son's reply is a grievance stated with precision: years of service, no disobedience, not even a goat for his friends, and now a fattened calf for a brother who wasted the family's living on prostitutes. The father's answer is not a rebuke. It is two sentences: you are always with me and everything I have is yours; but it was right to celebrate, because your brother was dead and is alive.

Then the parable ends. We are not told whether the elder son went in.

That ending is the parable's design, and the reader who is looking for a moral has to notice that it has been withheld. Recall the frame: the parable is addressed to people who have complained about whom Jesus eats with. The elder son's position in the story is the complainants' position in the frame, and the father's last words are a plea, not a verdict. The parable ends with the door open and the question unanswered, which is a way of putting the question to the hearers rather than answering it for them. This is the Nathan mechanism of lecture 8-1 in a subtler form: no "you are the man," but a story that stops at the exact point where the hearer must decide.

Two further observations about the elder son.

First, his grievance is legitimate, and the father says so. "All that is mine is yours" is not sarcasm; under the arrangement described in verse 12, the property has already been divided, and what remains is in fact the elder son's. He has not been cheated. But he has been asked to celebrate a decision he was not consulted about, concerning a brother he refers to, pointedly, as "this, your son." The father's reply corrects only that: "this, your brother."

Second, the reading that dissolves the elder son into a symbol of joyless legalism is not supported by the text and has done real damage. Nothing in the parable says his years of service were resentful before this evening, and nothing says his obedience was a means of earning anything. He is, on the story's own showing, the son who stayed.

This is a point where readers will not agree.

The traditional decoding. From at least the patristic period, the two sons have been read as two groups: the younger as Gentiles or as sinners received into the church, the elder as the Jewish people or as the Pharisees who resented that reception. On this reading the parable is about the transfer of God's favour, and the elder son's exclusion at the end is his own doing. This reading has been standard in Western preaching and is still widely repeated.

Amy-Jill Levine's criticism. Levine, in Short Stories by Jesus, argues that this decoding is both exegetically unsupported and historically harmful. Exegetically: the parable is one of three about losing and finding, and its Jewish hearers would have recognised a much older pattern — pairs of brothers in Genesis, where the younger is repeatedly preferred and the elder is repeatedly the one who must be reconciled with. The parable, on her account, is about a family that must find a way to hold both sons, not about one son replacing the other. Historically: reading the elder as "the Jews" turns a parable told by a Jewish teacher to a Jewish audience into an anti-Jewish parable, and this reading has been used to characterise Judaism as a religion of grudging bookkeeping in contrast to Christian grace — a characterisation Levine argues is false to the Judaism of the period, which had its own well-developed language of repentance and divine mercy.

Kenneth Bailey's cultural reading, and the objection to it. Bailey, in Poet and Peasant and The Cross and the Prodigal, argued from long residence in Middle Eastern village communities that the younger son's request amounts to wishing his father dead, that a father of standing would never run because running requires lifting the robe and exposing the legs, and that the father's run is therefore an act of public self-humiliation to protect the returning son from the village's hostility. This reading has been enormously influential in preaching. The objection is methodological: Bailey's evidence is drawn from twentieth-century village life and from interviews, and the inference that first-century Galilean practice matched it is an assumption rather than a finding. Some of his specific claims — the shaming ceremony he describes for a son who lost family property among Gentiles — have no first-century attestation at all. The honest verdict is that Bailey's readings are often illuminating as a way of noticing what is dramatic in the text and are not reliable as historical evidence for what the original audience assumed.

Where Levine has been questioned in turn. Levine's own reconstructions are proposals, and some have been contested. Her reading of the parable as centrally about a family's property and grief rather than about repentance has been criticised for underplaying Luke's own framing, which does speak of repentance in the applications at 15:7 and 15:10. Reviewers sympathetic to her main argument, including scholars working on Luke, have suggested that she sometimes treats a possible first-century Jewish hearing as the only one available. Her central point about the anti-Jewish reception history is, however, not seriously disputed; the argument is about what to put in its place.

3. The Samaritan, and a claim the text does not make

The parable at Luke 10:30-35 is set inside an exchange: a lawyer asks what he must do to inherit eternal life, answers his own question correctly with the double command to love God and neighbour, and then asks — "desiring to justify himself" — who his neighbour is. The parable answers a different question from the one asked, and Jesus makes the substitution explicit at the end by asking which of the three became a neighbour to the man in the ditch. The question has been turned from "whom must I include?" to "what kind of person am I?"

The purity reason is missing

Now the claim that must be examined. It is very commonly said, in commentaries and in preaching, that the priest and the Levite passed by because touching what might be a corpse would have made them ritually unclean and unable to perform their duties. The text does not say this. It gives no reason at all for either man's conduct. And the law invoked does not support the inference as it is usually stated: Jewish law recognised the obligation of the met mitzvah, the neglected corpse, which a passer-by was required to attend to even at the cost of contracted impurity, and even — in later rabbinic discussion — in the case of a priest. Impurity of this kind was moreover temporary and remediable. Both men, on the story's own detail, are travelling down from Jerusalem, that is, away from the temple, so a concern about being unfit for service is not obviously in view.

Why does the purity explanation persist? Partly because it supplies a motive where the text withholds one, and readers dislike an unexplained action. Partly, and less innocently, because it converts the parable into a contrast between a religion of rules and a religion of compassion, which is a familiar and satisfying shape for a Christian sermon and a defamatory account of Judaism. Levine has pressed this point hard and is right to.

If the purity explanation is set aside, what is the shock? Two proposals are worth weighing. The conventional one is the identity of the helper: Samaritans and Judeans were mutually hostile, and the third traveller is the enemy. Luke has already shown Samaritan hostility at 9:52-53. The second, argued by Levine and others, concerns the expected sequence: priest, Levite, and then — in a familiar triad — an ordinary Israelite. A hearer anticipating "Israelite" gets "Samaritan," and the substitution is felt as an intrusion. On this reading the parable's sting is that the man in the ditch, if he could choose, would rather not be saved by this person. A third element deserves mention: 2 Chronicles 28:8-15 narrates northerners returning Judean captives, clothing them, anointing them, giving them food and drink, setting the feeble on donkeys, and bringing them to Jericho. The verbal and situational overlap with Luke 10 is striking, and several scholars have proposed it as a background. It is a proposal, not a demonstration, but it is more textually anchored than the purity explanation.

4. The rich man and Lazarus

Luke 16:19-31 is the only parable in which a character is given a name, and the name is the beggar's. The rich man has purple, fine linen, and daily luxury; Lazarus has sores, hunger, and dogs. They die, and the positions reverse.

Three cautions. First, the parable has a close relative in ancient folk literature — Jeremias pointed to an Egyptian tale of a reversal after death that circulated in Jewish tradition, and there are rabbinic stories of a similar shape. The existence of a traditional form does not settle what Luke's version claims, but it does mean that the afterlife geography — the gulf, Abraham's bosom, the torment, the request for water — is the story's furniture rather than its argument. Building a doctrine of the out of these verses asks the parable to do work it shows no interest in doing.

Second, the parable does not say why the rich man is where he is. It never states that he was cruel, only that Lazarus lay at his gate and desired the crumbs. The absence of an accusation is itself the accusation: the man is condemned for a situation he did not notice.

Third, the sting is at the end. The rich man asks for a messenger to warn his brothers; Abraham replies that they have Moses and the prophets; the rich man insists that a visitor from the dead would persuade them; and Abraham answers that if they do not listen to Moses and the prophets, neither will they be persuaded if one rises from the dead. Read in a Christian setting after Easter that sentence carries an obvious additional resonance, and interpreters differ over whether Luke intends it. What should be noticed regardless is what the sentence claims: the scriptures already in hand are sufficient, and the demand for a more spectacular sign is not a sign of a serious inquiry.

5. The dishonest manager, which no one has solved

This is placed deliberately at the centre of the lecture. A manager is accused of wasting his master's goods and told to give an accounting. Knowing he will lose the post and unfit for manual work or begging, he calls in his master's debtors and reduces their bills substantially. Then comes the line: his lord commended the dishonest manager because he had done wisely.

The middle two verses are not quoted above because the text of them in this edition runs two words together where a footnote marker has been dropped, and the lecture does not want the reader working from a defective line; the substance is that two debtors' bills are reduced, one by half and one by a fifth.

Interpretations, none of which commands agreement:

One: he remits his own commission. On this reading, argued in various forms by J. D. M. Derrett and taken up by Joseph Fitzmyer, the amounts struck off the bills are the manager's own markup, not the master's principal. The manager is therefore giving away his own money to buy goodwill, the master loses nothing, and the commendation is straightforward. Difficulty: the text calls him dishonest in the very sentence that commends him, and the arrangement has to be supplied entirely from outside the story.

Two: he removes concealed interest. Derrett also proposed that the inflated bills concealed interest, which the prohibits between Israelites, and that the manager is bringing the accounts into conformity with the law. The master cannot object without admitting to usury. Difficulty: the same as above, plus the need to assume the audience would supply the legal background unprompted.

Three: the commendation is not moral approval. On this reading — closest to Jülicher's method — the single point of comparison is decisiveness in a crisis, and the manager's dishonesty is scenery. The children of this age act with resolve when their position collapses; the children of light do not. Difficulty: it requires the reader to bracket the moral character of the central action of the story, which is a large thing to bracket, and it makes the parable's vehicle almost gratuitously offensive.

Four: the "lord" who commends is Jesus, not the master. The Greek word rendered "his lord" is the same word Luke uses for Jesus elsewhere, and some interpreters have proposed that verse 8a is Jesus' comment rather than a narrated action inside the story. Difficulty: "his lord" with the possessive most naturally refers to the master in the story, and the reading solves the problem by relocating the sentence.

Five: verse 8b and the verses following are already interpretation. Whatever the parable originally meant, Luke has attached applications — about making friends by means of unrighteous wealth, about faithfulness in little and much, about serving two masters — and these applications pull in more than one direction. Several interpreters conclude that Luke himself had received a difficult parable and offered more than one way to use it. Difficulty: this explains the shape of the passage without explaining the parable.

The right conclusion is that this parable is unresolved. That should be said in a classroom rather than concealed. A discipline that only presents its solved problems misrepresents itself, and a student who has been taught that every parable has a recoverable point will be badly equipped the first time one does not.

6. The talents and the minas

Matthew 25:14-30 and Luke 19:11-27 are related but not identical. Matthew has a man going abroad who entrusts five, two, and one talent to three servants according to their ability; Luke has a nobleman going to receive a kingdom who gives one mina each to ten servants, of whom three are reported, and who is opposed by citizens sending a delegation to say they do not want him to reign. Matthew's amounts are enormous — a talent was worth many years of a labourer's wages — and unequal; Luke's are modest and equal. Luke's version ends with the execution of the objecting citizens, which Matthew has nothing corresponding to. Whether these are two versions of one parable or two different parables is disputed; the differences are large enough that either conclusion is defensible.

The standard reading. The master is God or Christ, the departure and return frame the period between the resurrection and the end, the entrusted money is whatever has been given, and the third servant is condemned for doing nothing with it. This reading has the support of the framing in both gospels — Matthew places it among parables about the delay of the master's return, Luke introduces it explicitly because the hearers "supposed that the Kingdom of God would be revealed immediately."

The subversive reading. William Herzog, in Parables as Subversive Speech, argued that the parable should be read from the third servant's position. In an economy where aristocratic wealth was accumulated through rents, debt, and the labour of others, a master who admits to reaping where he did not sow is describing exploitation, and the third servant, by burying the money, refuses to participate. On this reading the parable exposes a system rather than commending investment, and the third servant is the truth-teller who is punished for it. Richard Rohrbaugh has argued along similar lines, noting that ancient peasant economies regarded wealth as a limited good, so that gaining more was assumed to mean taking from someone.

Assessment. Herzog's reading is a genuine contribution because it takes the master's self-description seriously instead of treating it as incidental, and because it notices that the standard reading requires us to admire a figure the text describes as hard. Its difficulties are also real. Both gospels frame the parable eschatologically, and in Luke the framing is explicit; the concluding sayings in both — to everyone who has, more will be given — sit awkwardly with a reading in which the master is the villain, unless those sayings too are secondary. And the reading is more comfortable in a modern setting concerned with economic critique than the evidence alone requires, which is the kind of fit that lecture 8-1's working test asks us to be suspicious of. Present it at full strength, then state that objection.

7. The wicked tenants, and the reading that has done most damage

Mark 12:1-12, with parallels in Matthew 21 and Luke 20, opens with a vineyard described in words drawn almost verbatim from Isaiah 5:1-2 — planted, hedged, a pit for the winepress, a tower. Any hearer familiar with the prophets knows what a vineyard planted and cared for by an owner signifies, because Isaiah 5:7 says so explicitly: the vineyard of the Lord of Armies is the house of Israel. The parable begins by invoking a known image and then does something different with it. In Isaiah the vineyard itself fails and produces wild grapes; in the parable the vineyard is fine, and the problem is the tenants.

That distinction carries the weight of everything that follows. Servants are sent and beaten or killed; finally the owner sends his son, whom the tenants kill in order to take the inheritance; and the parable ends with a question and its answer: the owner will destroy those tenants and give the vineyard to others. Mark then notes that the hearers perceived the parable was spoken against them — "them" being, in Mark's narrative, the chief priests, scribes, and elders who have just challenged Jesus' authority.

The supersessionist reading. "He will give the vineyard to others" was read for many centuries as meaning that God has taken his from the Jewish people and given it to the church. This reading is ancient, is found in patristic writers, and appears in Western commentary and preaching well into the modern period. It has been used, historically, in support of the view that Judaism was superseded and had no continuing standing.

What the text supports. Three points can be made without polemic. First, the vineyard is not destroyed in the parable; only the tenants are. If the vineyard is Israel, the parable does not say Israel is rejected — it says its custodians are replaced. Second, the "them" in Mark 12:12 is the leadership that has just been confronted, not a people. Third, the parable belongs to a well-established Jewish prophetic pattern in which a prophet denounces the leaders of Israel in the name of Israel's God; Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel all do this at length, and to read such denunciation as anti-Jewish is to misread the entire prophetic corpus. Klyne Snodgrass, whose first book was a study of this parable, and Amy-Jill Levine both argue essentially in this direction, from different starting points. Note that this is not a claim that no Christian tradition has ever held a supersessionist theology; it is a claim about what this parable says.

A complication worth knowing. A version of this parable appears in the Gospel of Thomas, saying 65, without the Isaiah 5 opening and without the quotation of Psalm 118 that follows in Mark. Crossan and others have argued that this is an earlier, non-allegorical form, and that Mark has added the scriptural framing. Others — Snodgrass among them, and Simon Gathercole on broader grounds about Thomas's relation to the Synoptics — argue that Thomas is dependent on the Synoptic tradition and has abbreviated it. The dispute is part of a larger argument about the date and independence of Thomas that this course does not settle. What matters here is that the allegorical dimension of this particular parable is unusually well anchored: the opening quotation of Isaiah 5 is not a later reader's decoding but is in the text of all three Synoptics.

8. The ten virgins, and the Pharisee and the tax collector

Two shorter treatments to close.

Matthew 25:1-13 stands in Matthew's final discourse among parables about a delayed return. Ten young women wait for a bridegroom; five have brought oil and five have not; the bridegroom is delayed, all sleep, and at midnight the cry goes up. The unprepared five go to buy oil and find the door shut. The parable is harsh, and interpreters have often tried to soften it — by reading the wise as uncharitable for refusing to share, or by finding an allegorical meaning for the oil (good works, the Spirit, faith). The refusal to share is better read as part of the story's logic: the thing lacking cannot be transferred at the last moment. The unmistakable point is the delay and the length of it, which tells us something about the situation Matthew's community was in, and the equally unmistakable point is the closed door. A reading that removes the closed door has removed the parable.

Luke 18:9-14 is addressed, Luke says, to people convinced of their own righteousness who despised others. A Pharisee prays a prayer of thanksgiving that is, in its form, entirely ordinary — thanksgiving for not being among the wicked has parallels in Jewish prayer, and fasting and tithing are genuine devotion, not hypocrisy; the flaw is the clause comparing himself to the man behind him. A tax collector, whose occupation involved collaborating in extraction from his neighbours, asks for mercy. Jesus says the second went home justified.

Pharisee does not mean hypocrite

The trap in this parable is well known and still routinely sprung. A reader who concludes "thank God I am not like that Pharisee" has prayed the Pharisee's prayer. Levine makes this observation and it is the correct one, but the point can be sharpened: the danger is not only in the individual reader's self-congratulation but in the standing use of "Pharisee" in Christian English as a synonym for hypocrite. That usage is not what the word means, it does not describe the historical movement discussed in lecture 3-2 of this course, and every time it is used the parable is being made to do the opposite of what it does.

Luke 15: three parables, one complaint, no ending The third parable repeats the shape of the first two and then does not close The frame (15:1-2) Tax collectors and sinners draw near. Pharisees and scribes object: he welcomes sinners and eats with them. Lost sheep (15:4-7) one of a hundred lost search, find, carry home friends called to rejoice closed by an application Lost coin (15:8-10) one of ten lost lamp, sweep, seek, find friends called to rejoice closed by an application Two sons (15:11-32) one of two lost he returns; father runs the household celebrates and then it continues The second half (15:25-32) The elder son will not go in. The father comes out and pleads. The son states a grievance the father does not deny: all that is mine is yours. The parable stops. We are not told what he did. The people in the frame are still standing there. Why the repetition matters The first two parables train the hearer to expect the celebration as the ending. The third gives it, then keeps going past it, so that the hearer who had settled into agreement is asked a question he was not expecting.

The diagram is a structural argument, not a summary. Its point is that the third parable's second half is invisible unless the first two are read alongside it: the repeated shape sets an expectation of closure, and the withheld ending is felt as a withholding only against that expectation. The panel on the right marks where interpreters most often supply what the text does not.

6. Further Reading

  • Amy-Jill Levine, Short Stories by Jesus: The Enigmatic Parables of a Controversial Rabbi (HarperOne, 2014). Read the chapters on the lost sheep and two sons, the Good Samaritan, and the Pharisee and the tax collector directly, and note where the argument is exegetical and where it is about reception.
  • Klyne R. Snodgrass, Stories with Intent, 2nd ed. (Eerdmans, 2018), for the fullest survey of the options on the dishonest manager and on the wicked tenants; his earlier monograph The Parable of the Wicked Tenants (Mohr Siebeck, 1983) is the specialist study.
  • William R. Herzog II, Parables as Subversive Speech: Jesus as Pedagogue of the Oppressed (Westminster John Knox, 1994). The full statement of the reading of the talents discussed above.
  • Kenneth E. Bailey, Poet and Peasant and Through Peasant Eyes, combined ed. (Eerdmans, 1983). Widely used, frequently illuminating, and to be read alongside the methodological criticism noted in this lecture.
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke, 2 vols., Anchor Bible (Doubleday, 1981-1985). Careful, cautious treatment of the Lukan parables, including a full discussion of Luke 16:1-8.
  • Arland J. Hultgren, The Parables of Jesus: A Commentary (Eerdmans, 2000), for even-handed summaries of the debates in this lecture.
  • John T. Pawlikowski and Hayim Goren Perelmuter, eds., Reinterpreting Revelation and Tradition: Jews and Christians in Conversation (Sheed & Ward, 2000), for the broader question of how Christian reading of these texts has been revised in Jewish-Christian dialogue.

In short

  • The parable of the father and two sons (Luke 15:11-32) deliberately withholds its ending: the elder son's answer to the father's plea is never recorded, which puts the question to the Pharisees and scribes complaining in the frame (15:1-3) rather than answering it for them.
  • The traditional reading of the priest and Levite passing by the wounded man as motivated by purity law (Luke 10:30-35) is not in the text and misdescribes Jewish law, which recognized the obligation of met mitzvah to attend to a neglected corpse even at the cost of impurity — a point Amy-Jill Levine presses hard.
  • The dishonest manager (Luke 16:1-8) is presented as genuinely unresolved: five interpretations are given (he remits his own commission, he removes concealed interest, the commendation praises decisiveness not honesty, "his lord" means Jesus not the master, or the applications following are already interpretation), and none commands agreement.
  • The wicked tenants parable (Mark 12:1-12) opens with vineyard imagery quoted almost verbatim from Isaiah 5:1-2, where Isaiah 5:7 identifies the vineyard as the house of Israel — but only the tenants, not the vineyard itself, are destroyed and replaced, which undercuts the historic supersessionist reading that God rejected Israel wholesale.
  • William Herzog's subversive reading of the talents/minas (Matthew 25:14-30; Luke 19:11-27) takes seriously the master's own admission to "reaping where he did not sow," arguing the third servant who buries the money is a truth-teller resisting exploitation rather than a failure to be condemned.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: These Lukan parables are built around endings that refuse to resolve, and reading past that refusal is how centuries of interpretation went wrong. The father and two sons never tells us whether the elder brother went in to the feast, leaving the Pharisees who complained about Jesus eating with sinners (Luke 15:1-3) exactly where the story leaves them — with an open door and an unanswered question. The Good Samaritan's priest and Levite are given no stated motive at all, yet commentaries have long supplied one (ritual purity) that the text does not support and that misdescribes the very law it invokes. The dishonest manager's commendation (Luke 16:8) has never been satisfactorily explained by any of five competing readings. And the wicked tenants, opening with Isaiah 5's vineyard-as-Israel imagery, destroys only the tenants, not the vineyard — a detail that undercuts, without fully deciding, the reading that has done the most damage: that the whole vineyard was given away.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Luke 15 ends without telling us what the elder son did. Give one good reason a storyteller might end there, and then consider what is lost when a preacher supplies an ending. Is supplying one ever legitimate?
  • The purity explanation for the priest and the Levite is not in the text. Reconstruct how such an explanation becomes standard, and identify one other place in this lecture where a familiar reading rests on an assumption about Judaism rather than on the passage.
  • Five interpretations of the dishonest manager were listed. Rank them by how much they require the reader to supply from outside the story. Does your ranking match your sense of which is most likely true?
  • Present Herzog's reading of the talents in its strongest form, including the detail about the master reaping where he did not sow. Then state the two strongest objections. Has the objection defeated the reading, or limited it?
  • Mark's parable of the tenants destroys the tenants and not the vineyard. How much weight can that distinction carry against the supersessionist reading, and what else would be needed to make the case?
  • A reader finishes Luke 18:9-14 relieved not to be like the Pharisee. Describe precisely what has gone wrong, and propose a way of teaching the parable that makes the error harder to fall into.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.