FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT706E How Children and Young People Grow in Faith

Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult

Contents 31
PT706E How Children and Young People Grow in Faith
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
  1. Introduction: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Seeing Growth
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
  3. Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
  4. Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Early Years (about 0 to 6)
  1. Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
  2. Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
  3. Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
  4. Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The School Years (about 7 to 12)
  1. Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
  2. Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
  3. Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
  4. Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Teen Years (about 13 to 18)
  1. Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
  2. Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
  3. Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Life and Heart of Young People
  1. Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
  2. Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
  3. Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
  4. Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Moving On and Growing Together
  1. Lecture 6-1: Bridges Between Stages
  2. Lecture 6-2: Working With Families
  3. Lecture 6-3: Young People Serving and Leading
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Community That Grows With Its Children
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: One Step for One Age

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

(An invented example.) At the end of a harvest festival, a leader asks six-year-old Mia to stand in front of the whole gathering and say, in a clear voice, why she loves Jesus. Mia has practised the sentence at home. She says it perfectly. The adults smile, and someone says, "She is so mature for her age." Mia sits down and, for the rest of the afternoon, does not want to play.

Nobody in this scene meant harm. The leader wanted to honour a child. The parents were proud. The gathering was warm. And yet it is worth asking what Mia learned. She may have learned that she was loved. She may also have learned that adults are most pleased with her when she sounds like one of them.

This lecture begins the course with a plain claim that the rest of the course will keep returning to: a child is not a small adult, and a child’s faith is not an unfinished faith but a whole faith for that age. We will look at what Jesus does with a child, at two common ways of getting a child wrong, and at the pressure to hurry that many communities feel, often with good intentions. We will not say that adults should expect nothing of children. We will ask what a child can do with joy, and what only an adult can carry.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Describe what Jesus does and says in Matthew 18:2-5 and Matthew 19:13-14, and what these passages do not claim.
  • Explain two ways of getting a child wrong, "the small adult" and "the future adult", and say what each ignores.
  • Explain what it means to say that a child’s faith is whole for that age.
  • Name three common pressures to hurry a child and say what a child may learn from each.
  • Apply three questions to a request that a community makes of a child.

Jesus called a little child to himself, and set him in their midst, and said, “Most certainly I tell you, unless you turn, and become as little children, you will in no way enter into the Kingdom of Heaven. Whoever therefore humbles himself as this little child, the same is the greatest in the Kingdom of Heaven. Whoever receives one such little child in my name receives me," — Matthew 18:2-5

World English Bible

Then little children were brought to him, that he should lay his hands on them and pray; and the disciples rebuked them. But Jesus said, “Allow the little children, and don’t forbid them to come to me; for the Kingdom of Heaven belongs to ones like these.”" — Matthew 19:13-14

WEB

And Jesus increased in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and men." — Luke 2:52

WEB

The first passage shows Jesus placing a child where everyone can see. The second shows adults trying to protect Jesus from children, and Jesus refusing the protection. The third is a single sentence about Jesus himself: he grew.

1. A child in the middle

Just before the words of Matthew 18:2-5, the disciples had asked who is greatest in the Kingdom of Heaven. It is a question about rank. Jesus does not answer with a name or a title. He calls a child, "and set him in their midst". The child does nothing. The child does not recite, explain or perform. The child is simply there, in the middle, and the adults are asked to look.

Then Jesus says three things. Unless the disciples "turn" and become like children, they will not enter the Kingdom. Whoever humbles himself like this child is the greatest. And whoever receives one such child in his name receives Jesus.

Notice what Jesus does not say. He does not say that children are perfect. He does not say that adults should become childish, as if growing up were a loss. He does not say that children are valuable because of what they will one day become. The weight falls on receiving a child as a child. In the ancient world, as in many places today, a child had little power and little say. A child was the person least able to pay anyone back. To receive such a person is to be moved away from rank and towards welcome.

Matthew 19:13-14 shows the same thing from the other side. Children are brought to Jesus so that he may lay his hands on them and pray, and the disciples rebuke the people who bring them. The disciples may have thought they were protecting a busy teacher. Jesus says: "Allow the little children, and don’t forbid them to come to me." The word that matters is come. The children are not to be sent away until they are ready. They come as they are.

The Gospels have another version of this scene, in Mark 10:13-16, which we will read in lecture 1-4. For now, it is enough to see the shape. The Gospels do not treat a child as a rehearsal for a person. They treat a child as someone to whom the Kingdom already belongs.

2. The first mistake: the small adult

The first way of getting a child wrong is to treat a child as a small adult. A small adult is expected to sit as still as a grown person, to speak as a grown person speaks, to control feelings as a grown person tries to, and to understand the words of worship and teaching in the way a grown person does. When the child cannot, the child is seen as lacking: lacking attention, lacking respect, lacking faith.

This is not a foolish view, and its strongest form deserves a fair hearing. Those who hold it can say, truthfully, that children often understand and do more than adults expect. They can say that low expectations are a form of disrespect, that habits begun early often last, and that Scripture itself tells parents to teach children from the earliest days. All of this is worth keeping. A community that expects nothing of its children has also made a mistake.

What goes wrong is not the expecting but the measuring. The small-adult view uses an adult’s body, an adult’s attention span and an adult’s way of speaking as the ruler, and then finds the child short. A four-year-old cannot sit for forty minutes without moving. This is not a failure of faith; it is a fact about four-year-olds, in the way that being unable to reach a high shelf is a fact about height. A child who fails an adult test learns, very quickly and without anyone saying so, that something is wrong with them.

3. The second mistake: the future adult

The second way of getting a child wrong looks like the opposite, but it shares a root. It treats a child as a future adult: someone who is not yet a real member of the community, whose present is a waiting room. In this view, the work with children is preparation. We teach them now so that they will be good members later. We plan for the young people who will "one day lead". The child’s own present faith is called "sweet", "a phase", or "just a child’s way of seeing".

Here too there is something true. Children are growing, and a community does well to think about what they will need years from now. It is honest to say that a child has much still to learn, and wise not to put adult burdens on a child. The "not yet" view protects children from being used.

What goes wrong is that the present disappears. If the child is only becoming something, then today is only a step. Yet a child’s trust in a caring adult, a child’s wonder at a story, a child’s grief at a death and a child’s sense of what is fair are all real now, not simply early versions of later things. A child who is treated as a future person may learn that the community is interested in what they will become, and not in who they are.

The two mistakes are mirror images. The small adult asks the child to be what an adult is now. The future adult asks the child to be of use later. In both, the child who is actually present is overlooked.

4. A whole faith for that age

The claim of this course is that a child is whole now. Whole does not mean finished or complete. A five-year-old is not an unfinished ten-year-old. A five-year-old is a complete five-year-old, with the trust, the questions, the imagination and the love that belong to being five. Nothing needs to be added before the child counts.

What does this mean for faith? It means that a young child’s faith is not a weak copy of adult belief. It may be shown through the way a child leans on an adult’s shoulder during a prayer, through an eager question about where an animal goes when it dies, through a drawing, a song, or the quiet comfort of a familiar ritual. A ten-year-old’s faith may show itself in a fierce sense of fairness, a love of stories, a loyalty to friends and a wish to belong. A fifteen-year-old’s faith may show itself in honest, even sharp, questions. Each is a way of being faithful at that age. Each also grows, and the community’s task is to walk beside the growing, not to push it.

This is a claim about how we see. It does not settle every theological question. Traditions speak differently about how a child stands before God. Some begin from the child’s baptism and belonging; some begin from the child’s need and a later personal response; some stress both. Some speak of children as born with a share in a damaged human nature, and some speak more of the child’s innocence. Lecture 3-3 returns to the questions of baptism, confession and profession. What this lecture asks is smaller, and every tradition can accept it: that the child is a person known and loved by God now, and that the community can receive that child now.

Nor does it mean that childhood is perfect. Children can be unkind, afraid, stubborn and hurt. A child is not an angel. A child is also not a tiny sinner to be fixed. A child is a child.

5. Luke 2:52: even Jesus grew

Luke gives us one sentence about the growing Jesus: he "increased in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and men." You can read four kinds of growth in this: in wisdom (mind), in stature (body), in favour with God (his relationship with God), and in favour with people (his relationships with others). The sentence does not claim that Jesus was always already everything. It says that he increased.

Christians across many traditions confess that Jesus was truly human, and that a human life begins with growing up. Traditions explain in different ways how Jesus’ growth relates to who he is, and this course does not need to settle that. We can read the plain sentence: the one who stands in the middle of the disciples did not skip childhood. If growth was part of his life, then growth is not a delay or a fault in anyone else’s.

Notice too that Luke names more than one area. Growth in this sentence is not only about knowing more. This will be the framework for lecture 1-2.

6. The pressure to hurry

Why, then, do communities hurry children? Rarely from bad will. More often from love, from fear for the child’s future, from pride, or from a belief that earlier is safer. Here are three common forms.

Performance. A child is asked to do something in front of adults, such as reciting, singing a solo, leading a prayer, or giving a speech. A child may enjoy this, and there is nothing wrong with a child sharing a gift. The difficulty begins when the performance is for the adults’ delight, when the child cannot easily say no, or when the reward is a flood of praise that teaches the child that love is earned by doing well. Watch what the child’s face and body say, not only what the audience feels.

Recitation. Many traditions value memory. Children have learned psalms, creeds, answers and long passages of Scripture for centuries, and many adults treasure what they learned that way. The difficulty is not memorising. The difficulty comes when recitation becomes the measure of a child’s faith, so that the child who recites the most is taken to be the most faithful. A child can say the words of a creed with love and without understanding, and another child can understand a great deal and be unable to remember a line. Lecture 3-1 will return to the difference between remembering and understanding.

Early public professions. In some communities a child is invited to stand up, to come forward, to give a testimony, to declare a decision or to speak publicly of faith. In others, a child is expected to take part in a rite at a certain age, in a certain way, with certain words. In both cases the question is whether the child is making a move they are ready for, or whether the child is meeting an adult expectation. A public moment can be a real step, and can also be a heavy one. A child who feels that everyone is watching and waiting for a particular answer may give that answer. Lecture 3-3 looks at this carefully.

There is also a quieter kind of hurry: the compliment "mature for her age". It is often kindly meant. Yet it is worth asking what is being praised. Very often the child praised is quiet, obedient and easy for adults. A child praised for being like an adult may learn that being a child is the lesser thing. (This is an observation about a common habit, not a finding about how often it harms.)

7. What the pressure looks like in two kinds of community

The same pressure takes different forms in different places. In a parish with a long, formal , it may arrive as an expectation that a child will kneel, stand and respond at the right moments for an hour, and be silent between. In a free-church assembly with an open microphone, it may arrive as an invitation, or an expectation, to speak before everyone. The practices are different, and each has gifts for children: the liturgy gives a child a rhythm, a body and a place; open sharing gives a child a voice. The question is the same in both: is this at the child’s pace, and does the child know they may stop?

8. Three questions for any request of a child

When you or your community ask a child to do something, three questions help. They are not rules; they are ways of looking.

  1. Is this something that children of this age can do with joy? A request that a child can meet with ease, or with a stretch they enjoy, respects the child. A request that needs a child to behave like a grown person does not.
  2. Does the child know they may say no, or stop? A child who can say "I don’t want to" and still be loved is being treated as a person. A child who cannot is being used, however kindly.
  3. Whom is this for? If the honest answer is "so that the adults will be pleased", it is probably too much. If the answer is "so that the child may take part in something that belongs to them", it is probably right.

Return for a moment to Mia. Suppose the leader had asked Mia beforehand, privately, whether she would like to say something, had told her she could say no, and had accepted a "no" with the same warmth. Suppose that Mia, being six, had said she would rather draw a picture of the harvest and put it on the wall. The gathering would have had a picture, and Mia would have learned that she is welcome as she is. That is the whole of this lecture’s practice in one small decision.

A last word on the course itself. The adults reading this lecture are not asked to know everything about children. They are asked to look again at a child, and to ask what is whole in the child now. The next lecture gives some maps for the looking.


Diagram 1. Two wrong pictures and one right one

Three Ways of Seeing a Child Two pictures that look past the child, and one that looks at the child The small adult Measured against the adult outline, and found short. Asks: be what I am, now. The future adult Today is a waiting room for a later person who counts. Asks: be of use later. A whole child, now Whole for this age, and still growing in every way. Asks: who are you today? Three questions before asking a child for anything Can a child of this age do it with joy? May the child say no? Whom is it for?

In short

  • A child is not a small adult. The small-adult view measures children against adult stillness, speech and understanding, and finds them short.
  • The "future adult" view treats childhood as a waiting room, so the child who is present today goes unseen.
  • In Matthew 18:2-5 and 19:13-14, Jesus receives children as they are and refuses to send them away until they are ready.
  • A child’s faith is whole for that age: not finished, but lacking nothing that must be added before it counts.
  • Luke 2:52 names growth in mind, body, relationship with God and relationships with people; even Jesus grew.
  • Test any request of a child with three questions: can they do it with joy, may they say no, and whom is it for?
Front Back
Two mistakes about children The small adult (measured by adult standards) and the future adult (valued only for later).
What "whole" means Whole for this age, not finished: nothing has to be added before the child’s faith counts.
Luke 2:52: four kinds of growth Wisdom, stature, favour with God, and favour with people.
Three questions before asking a child Can they do it with joy? May they say no? Whom is it for?

One sentence to remember Receive the child who is here today, and do not measure that child against an adult or hurry them toward one.

This week’s action Notice one thing you ask of a child in your care, and ask yourself the three questions about it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a time when you were praised as a child for being "good", "grown up" or "mature". How did it feel then? How does it look to you now?
  • In your community, where might a child be treated as a small adult? Where might a child be treated as someone who will matter later? Which is the more common?
  • Matthew 19:13-14 says the disciples rebuked those who brought the children. What are the modern forms of that rebuke, such as a look, a sigh, a rule or a room placed far away?
  • What is a request your community makes of children that you think children can do with joy? What is one that makes you hesitate?
  • In the Luke 2:52 sentence, which of the four kinds of growth does your community pay most attention to in children? Which does it pay least attention to?
  • How does your tradition speak of children before God? Does the claim "a child is whole now" fit comfortably, or does it need to be said with care?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.