Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
(An invented example.) A children's leader is preparing a gift for Mother's Day, one small card for every child to take home. Then she thinks of a boy who lives with his grandmother, a girl whose mother died last year, and a girl whose two mothers have not been to the church before. She thinks of a boy in a foster home whose "mother" changes every few months. She puts down her scissors. She is not sure whether to cancel the card, to change it, or to say nothing and hope for the best.
Her hesitation is the right place to begin. Every child in your community comes from a family. No two families are the same, and no child comes from an ideal one. This is not a complaint about families; it is a plain description of how people live. Some are looked after by two parents. Some by one. Some by grandparents, aunts or older brothers. Some by foster carers or adoptive parents. Some are far from a parent who works in another country. Some have little money. Some are carrying grief. Some have a child who cares for a sick parent. Most are a mixture, and they change over time.
The week's principle is: notice what is happening in a young person's world and heart; stay, listen, and pass on to the right person; you are not their doctor. In this lecture the world is the home. The practical task is to make the community a place where a child from any home is not made to feel odd, and where no adult asks the child to explain or defend their family. The central claim of the course is at work again: a child is whole now, in the home they have, and their faith is whole for their age within it.
This lecture does not teach parenting, and it does not decide what a family ought to look like. Traditions teach different ideals about marriage, divorce and the household, and thoughtful believers disagree about some of them. Those questions belong to a community's teaching. What this lecture asks is narrower: whatever a community teaches, the child did not choose their home, and must never be made to carry the weight of the community's views about it.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Describe at least six different kinds of household that children in a community may live in.
- Explain why a child must not be questioned about their home and what to do instead.
- Identify words, events and forms in a community that may wound a child because of their family.
- Say what an adult does when a child's home circumstances cause concern.
- Describe how a community can welcome a family without assuming its shape.
A father of the fatherless, and a defender of the widows, is God in his holy habitation." — Psalm 68:5
World English Bible
God sets the lonely in families. He brings out the prisoners with singing, but the rebellious dwell in a sun-scorched land." — Psalm 68:6
WEB
Ruth said, “Don’t entreat me to leave you, and to return from following after you, for where you go, I will go; and where you lodge, I will lodge; your people shall be my people, and your God my God;" — Ruth 1:16
WEB
where you die, will I die, and there will I be buried. Yahweh do so to me, and more also, if anything but death part you and me.”" — Ruth 1:17
WEB
Pure religion and undefiled before our God and Father is this: to visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction, and to keep oneself unstained by the world." — James 1:27
WEB
The psalm says that God cares for people who lack a family and places the lonely in one. The book of Ruth tells of a household formed by loyalty: a widowed woman from another country binds herself to her mother-in-law and her people. James names care for those without the usual protection as the heart of a pure faith. The Bible knows families of many shapes: widows, orphans, foreigners, adopted children, households held together by love more than by blood. It treats the lonely person's need for a family as something God himself attends to.
1. No child comes from the ideal family
Begin with a simple statement and hold it firmly: there is no ideal family that the children in your community actually come from. Every household has strain, loss or change. Even a household that looks complete from outside has an illness, a debt, a quarrel or a grief. A community that speaks as if most children come from a model household, and a few come from a "problem" one, is speaking about a household that does not exist.
Scripture itself does not start from an ideal. Moses is brought up by a woman who is not his birth mother (Exodus 2:10). Ruth belongs to a family by her own choice. Timothy, in 2 Timothy 1:5, is shaped by his grandmother and his mother. The Gospels tell of widows, of a family fleeing as refugees, and of a young man whose father waits at the gate. The Bible's picture of family is wide, and its concern is for those at the edge.
2. A map of households
The following is a list, not a complete one. It is here so that you can picture the children you may be meeting. Notice that these are household situations, not categories of child. A child may belong to more than one, and none of them is a label.
- A household with one parent. Because of death, separation, illness, absence, or a parent's choice. Such a parent is often tired and carrying a great deal.
- Parents who have separated or divorced. The child may move between two homes, may have two sets of rules, and may be carrying something unspoken about the split. A child's loyalty to both parents is often strong.
- A blended household. After a remarriage or a new partnership, children may have step-parents and step-siblings, with new names, new rules and unsettled belonging.
- Grandparents or other relatives raising a child. In many parts of the world this is common, and it may be a loving arrangement and also a tiring one for an older person.
- . A child who was adopted may know it, may not yet know it, or may know it in part. The story is the child's, and the family's, to tell.
- Foster care. A child may be in a home for a short or long time, may change homes, and may have a history that is private. Details of a foster child's history are not for the community.
- Migration. A family may have moved across a border or between regions. A child may speak another language at home, may have left relatives behind, or may have parents with uncertain status. Lecture 3-4 spoke of belonging for children in these situations.
- Parents working away. A parent may work in another city or country for months or years, and the child may live with a grandparent or an aunt. The child may speak to the parent only by screen.
- Poverty or insecure housing. A family may struggle to pay for food, rent, school costs or bus fares. A child may be ashamed of old clothes or an empty lunchbox.
- A child with caring duties. A young person may be looking after a sick parent, a disabled sibling or younger children, and may be tired, late or absent as a result.
- Grief. A parent, sibling or grandparent may have died, and the child may be grieving in a way the adults around them have not noticed. Lecture 2-3 spoke about children and death.
- A household of which some in the community disapprove. Some children live with adults whose way of life is regarded by some members of the community as contrary to their teaching. The child did not choose it. A child must not be made to answer for it.
Behind each of these is a child who is, on this day, simply a child: someone who wants to belong, to be safe, to play and to be known. The lecture asks you to see that child before you see the shape of their home.
3. Words and events that wound
Communities often wound children without meaning to. The harm is not in malice; it is in assumption. Look for these.
Celebrations built around one kind of family. A Mother's Day or Father's Day activity assumes a mother and a father are at hand. A child with neither, or with a parent who has died, or with two parents of the same sex, may sit through it feeling that the day belongs to others. You do not have to cancel such days. You can adapt them: "make a card for someone who takes care of you", and let the child decide who that is. Where your tradition holds these days dear, honour them, and also plan so that no child is left without a way to take part.
"Bring your family" and "family nights". Some children cannot bring anyone. A grandmother may be too frail to come, a parent may work at night, or the family may have no transport. Say "bring someone who cares for you, if you like", and have an adult ready to sit beside a child who comes alone.
Forms and registers. A form that asks only for "mother's name" and "father's name" excludes some children. A form that asks for "parent or guardian" and for the person who may collect the child, and who may not, includes them. Keep in mind that questions about custody and who may collect a child are serious. Follow the guardian's written instruction and the community's policy, and never take sides between adults.
Family trees and "where do you come from?" An activity that draws a tree may be painful for an adopted, fostered or displaced child. Offer a choice: a tree, a map of the people who care for you, or a picture of a place that matters.
Costs. A camp, a trip, a uniform, a book, or a donation can exclude a child whose family cannot pay. Handle this quietly. The person who decides about fees should ask no child, and no adult in the child's hearing, whether they can afford it. A fund that is known to everyone and used without questions is better than a discreet enquiry.
Language. Avoid some parents "real" and others not. Avoid "broken home", "fatherless child" used as a label, "illegitimate", "only a stepmother", and any word that ranks a family. A child hears these words about themselves. Speak of "your mum", "your grandad", "the family you live with", and take your words from the child's own.
Prayer and teaching in the gathering. When you pray for "families" or speak of "the Christian family", remember who is listening. A prayer for "all the families here, in all their forms and changes" includes the child who is listening. A sermon that holds up one household as the model, however sincerely, can leave many children outside the picture. A community that holds a particular teaching on marriage and family may state it respectfully, but it should not aim it at children, and it should not let children be the ones who carry its weight.
4. Do not question a child about the home
It is natural to want to know. A child comes in without a coat, or talks about a quarrel, or goes quiet when a parent is mentioned, and an adult wants to understand. The temptation is to ask: "Where is your dad?" "Why did your mum leave?" "Are you getting enough to eat?" Do not.
There are three reasons. First, a child cannot answer for adults. The home is the adults' to explain, and a child pressed to explain may feel they are betraying someone. Second, close questions can frighten a child or push them to say what is not true, whether to protect a parent or to please the questioner. Third, a question from an adult, in a church setting, is heavy. A child may feel that the right answer matters, and may give the answer they think you want.
What to do instead is quiet and practical.
- Welcome the child as they are. Learn their name, their interests, what they like to eat and what they find hard. Treat their home as a fact of life, not a subject.
- Offer, never press. "If you ever want to tell me about home, I'm glad to listen." Then let them choose.
- Listen to what they volunteer. If a child tells you that their dad lives far away, or that mum cries a lot, answer warmly and briefly: "That sounds hard." "Thank you for telling me." Do not follow with questions.
- Speak with the adults, not about them. If you have a concern about what a child needs, talk to the parent or guardian first, kindly, about what the community can offer. Do not gossip; do not share what a child told you with other volunteers who do not need to know.
- Keep a child's information private. A foster placement, an adoption, a separation, a debt, a parent's illness or a family's immigration situation is not for a notice board, a prayer list or a conversation in the corridor.
5. When a home is a cause for concern
Most of the households above are ordinary families doing their best, and nothing in them is a cause for alarm. The shape of a household is never itself a sign that a child is unsafe. But sometimes, in any kind of household, a child may be hungry, frightened, neglected or hurt. The signs lecture 5-2 described apply here too: a sudden change in a child, a remark that worries you, a pattern you cannot ignore.
The path is the one the course has followed. Notice, stay, pass on. Write down what you saw and heard. Do not question the child closely or visit the home yourself. Tell the person responsible in your community the same day, and follow the policy about what happens next. If a child tells you something about being harmed, lecture 5-4 gives the steps. If there is immediate danger, call the local emergency number.
Some situations are not safety concerns but need help of another kind: a family without food, a parent who has lost work, a grandparent who cannot manage alone. The community may be able to offer meals, transport, practical help or a friendly visit. Offer this as a gift to the family, not as a favour to be repaid, and ask the family what it needs before deciding. Where a need is beyond the community, the person responsible may know of services in the area.
6. Welcoming a family without assuming its shape
A community can do several simple things.
- Say "the people who look after you" where you might have said "your parents".
- Learn each child's own words for the people they live with, and use them.
- Ask the family what they would like the community to know, and respect a "nothing".
- Plan for the child who comes alone, and for the child who comes with a different adult each week.
- Be especially careful with the adult who carries many roles. A single parent, a grandparent raising a child, a young carer, a parent working shifts: such a person may be unable to come on a Sunday morning. Offer another time or another way, and never call it a lack of commitment.
- Avoid comparisons. Do not hold up a household as an example in front of others, and do not hold one up as a warning.
- Be a steady presence. For a child whose home is shifting, the church may be one of the few things that stays the same. The same room, the same greeting, the same adult.
7. A liturgical community and a free church
In a large parish with many families, the temptation is to treat children as a group, to deliver a programme and never to learn how any one of them lives. A named adult for each age group, who learns each child's name and the person who brings them, gives children a place to be known. In a small assembly or house church, everyone knows the family's story, often too well. The risk there is that a family's changes are discussed at length among adults, and children overhear. In both settings the rule is the same: what is known about a child's home is held lightly, spoken of rarely, and never used to define the child.
Diagram 1. Many homes, one child: a check of the community's habits
In short
- No child comes from an ideal family; children live with one parent, two, grandparents, carers, foster or adoptive families, or far from a working parent, and each is whole now.
- Events, forms and words can wound by assuming one kind of home: adapt Mother's Day cards, family nights, forms, family trees and fees.
- A child is not questioned about their home; welcome them, offer to listen, and answer what they volunteer briefly and warmly.
- The shape of a household is never a sign that a child is unsafe; real signs of harm are passed on to the person responsible.
- What is known about a child's home is private and is not spoken of in corridors, notices or prayer lists.
- A community may hold its teaching on family, but must not let a child carry its weight.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Is there an ideal family? | No child comes from one; every household has strain, loss or change, and every child is whole now. |
| How do events wound? | By assuming one kind of home; adapt cards, family nights, forms, trees and fees. |
| Do you question a child about home? | No; welcome, offer to listen, answer what they volunteer, and do not press. |
| When a home gives cause for concern | Notice, stay, pass on to the person responsible; household shape alone is never a sign of danger. |
One sentence to remember See the child before you see the shape of their home, and never ask them to explain it.
This week's action Pick one event, form or phrase in your community that assumes one kind of family, and suggest one small change to the person who decides.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of the home you grew up in. Which words or events in church or school made you feel that it was ordinary, and which made you feel that it was not?
- Look at the list of households. Which have you met in your community? Which do you think are missing from how the community speaks and plans?
- What events in the year of your community assume one kind of family? What small change would include a child outside that picture?
- A child says, "My mum's not coming today, she's sleeping." What do you say? What do you not say?
- How does your community handle fees and costs? Could a child tell that a family could not pay?
- A community may hold a firm teaching on marriage and family. How can it hold that teaching and still welcome every child without making the child answer for the home?