FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT706E How Children and Young People Grow in Faith

Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart

Contents 31
PT706E How Children and Young People Grow in Faith
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
  1. Introduction: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Seeing Growth
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
  3. Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
  4. Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Early Years (about 0 to 6)
  1. Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
  2. Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
  3. Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
  4. Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The School Years (about 7 to 12)
  1. Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
  2. Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
  3. Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
  4. Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Teen Years (about 13 to 18)
  1. Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
  2. Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
  3. Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Life and Heart of Young People
  1. Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
  2. Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
  3. Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
  4. Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Moving On and Growing Together
  1. Lecture 6-1: Bridges Between Stages
  2. Lecture 6-2: Working With Families
  3. Lecture 6-3: Young People Serving and Leading
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Community That Grows With Its Children
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: One Step for One Age

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

(An invented example.) An assistant who helps with the children's choir has known a boy of thirteen for three years. This term he arrives late, sits at the back, and no longer sings. When she greets him he looks at the floor. Last week he said, almost to himself, "It wouldn't matter if I wasn't here." She has been awake since then. She does not know whether she saw something serious or only a bad week. She does not know whether she should speak, or to whom, or what to say if she does.

This lecture is for that moment. It is about noticing that a young person may be struggling, and knowing what an ordinary adult does next. The answer is not "diagnose" and it is not "pray and wait". It is shorter than either, and it is the posture of the whole week: notice, stay, pass on. You notice a change. You stay, which means you remain kind, calm and available, and you listen. And you pass the concern to the person in the community who is responsible and, as the policy directs, to the guardian and to a professional who knows how to help. In a moment of immediate danger, you call the local emergency number.

Nothing in this lecture is a method, and nothing is graphic. We will not describe how a person harms themselves. We will not offer a diagnosis, for no volunteer, teacher or clergy member can make one from a few weeks of observation. We will not give legal or medical advice, because the law and the services differ from country to country and from place to place.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Describe changes that may signal a young person is struggling, and say why such signs are not a diagnosis.
  • State the steps of notice, stay and pass on, in order.
  • Explain why an adult in a faith community does not promise secrecy.
  • Say what to do when a young person may be in immediate danger.
  • Explain why prayer and professional help are not rivals, and why illness is not a lack of faith, and name ways to care for yourself afterwards.

Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18

World English Bible

But he himself went a day’s journey into the wilderness, and came and sat down under a juniper tree: and he requested for himself that he might die, and said, “It is enough. Now, O Yahweh, take away my life; for I am not better than my fathers.”" — 1 Kings 19:4

WEB

He lay down and slept under a juniper tree; and behold, an angel touched him, and said to him, “Arise and eat!”" — 1 Kings 19:5

WEB

He looked, and behold, there was at his head a cake baked on the coals, and a jar of water. He ate and drank, and lay down again." — 1 Kings 19:6

WEB

Yahweh’s angel came again the second time, and touched him, and said, “Arise and eat, because the journey is too great for you.”" — 1 Kings 19:7

WEB

He arose, and ate and drank, and went in the strength of that food forty days and forty nights to Horeb the Mount of God." — 1 Kings 19:8

WEB

Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2

WEB

The psalm says that God is near to the broken-hearted. The story of Elijah shows a person who, worn out, asked to die. The response in the story is not a lecture. There is a touch, food, water, sleep, and a second touch with the words, "the journey is too great for you." Galatians asks us to share burdens, not to watch them from a distance. Read the story of Elijah with care: it is not a medical account, and we do not know what name a doctor today would give Elijah's state. It shows how God meets a worn-out person, and it gives us a pattern of kindness that begins with body and rest.

1. Why this lecture is in the course

Some readers will think this lecture belongs to a counsellor's training. It does not, and the difference matters. A counsellor, doctor or social worker is trained for a task this course does not prepare you for, and you should never act as one. But you are often the adult who sees the young person most weeks, in a setting that is not school and not home, and sometimes you are the first to see that something has changed. If you say nothing because you are not a professional, the young person may meet no one else who has noticed. If you say too much because you want to rescue, you may do harm. The path between is narrow and well known: notice, stay, pass on.

Keep also the course's central claim in view. A young person is not a small adult, and their faith is not an unfinished faith. A young person who struggles is a whole person now, and the struggle is not a failure of faith. They need to be met at their present pace, not hurried through it.

2. What you might notice

Young people change constantly, as lectures 4-1 and 4-2 explained. A new haircut, a new taste in music, a new group of friends and a bad mood on a Monday are all part of ordinary growth. What is worth noticing is not any single change but a change that is sudden, lasting, or large for this particular young person. Here are some of the changes that many people who work with young people have learned to watch.

  • Mood. A young person who is usually cheerful seems flat, tearful, very irritable or unusually angry for a long time, or moves between extremes in a way that is new.
  • Sleep. They seem always tired, or say they cannot sleep, or sleep far more than before.
  • Eating. Their eating changes noticeably: much more, much less, or a new secrecy around food.
  • Friends. They drop old friends, are suddenly alone, or are suddenly with a group that worries you.
  • Withdrawal. They stop doing what they once loved, arrive late, leave early, or stop coming.
  • Energy and attention. They seem unable to concentrate, or seem to have given up on school or on tasks that used to matter.
  • Appearance and care of self. They stop caring how they look, or change how they dress in a way that seems to hide.
  • Remarks. They say things such as "it wouldn't matter if I weren't here", "I'm a burden", "nothing will ever change", or "I just want it to stop". Any remark that suggests a young person does not want to be alive, or may harm themselves, is to be taken seriously, however lightly it is said.

None of these is a diagnosis. Any of them can have an ordinary cause: an exam, a quarrel, a growth spurt, illness, a family difficulty, a first love ending. Many young people who show one or two of these are passing through a hard season and come out the other side. The signs tell you to pay closer attention, not to decide what is wrong. Never use a theory from this course, or any other, to put a label on a young person. Say "I have noticed that you seem very tired lately", not "I think you are depressed".

Notice also that the signs look different across cultures and temperaments. In some families and communities, young people are expected to hide distress; in others, they speak freely. A young person who says little is not necessarily fine. A young person who speaks of feeling low is not necessarily in danger. Know the young person's usual self before you judge a change.

3. Notice, stay, pass on

3-1. Notice

Noticing is a discipline of attention. Set aside your own worry for a moment and ask: what, exactly, have I seen? When, and how many times? Has it been going on for days or weeks? Keep to what you saw and heard. "She has been absent three Sundays and cried during the prayer" is a note you can pass on. "She is depressed" is not.

You may write down, for the person responsible, the date, what you saw or heard, and what was said, in the young person's own words where you can. Keep it factual, keep it private, and store it as the community's policy directs.

3-2. Stay

To stay is to remain with the young person, in the manner of a calm friend. Several habits help.

Find a suitable place and time. Somewhere private enough to talk, but not hidden: a room with a window or an open door, in a place where others can see you if not hear you. Do not take a young person alone to a closed room or to a private place, and do not meet them out of sight. The reasons are the ones given in lecture 4-4: this protects the young person and the adult.

Start with what you have seen, gently, and with a question. "I've noticed you've seemed quieter lately, and I wanted to ask how you are." Then be quiet, and give the answer time.

Listen more than you speak. A young person may say very little. Silence is not a failure. Do not fill it with advice, a verse, a story about your own youth or a fix.

Take what they say seriously, and do not minimise. Avoid "It's only a phase", "Others have it worse", "You have so much to be thankful for", and "You just need to pray more". Each of these, however kindly meant, tells the young person that their feeling is wrong.

You may ask directly. If a young person has said something that suggests they may harm themselves or not want to live, it is acceptable to ask, kindly and plainly, what they mean, and whether they are thinking of harming themselves. The usual advice from health organisations is that asking in a caring way does not put the idea into someone's mind and often brings relief. You do not need to ask for details of how. You are not collecting information for a file; you are showing that you can bear to hear the answer.

Do not promise secrecy. A young person may say, "Promise you won't tell." You cannot promise this, and you should not. Say something like: "I can't promise to keep it secret, because I care about what happens to you, and I may need to ask someone who can help. But I promise I will tell you who I am going to tell, and why, and I will stay with you." A promise of secrecy that you later break teaches the young person never to speak again. A promise you cannot keep is worse than none. This holds in every country and for every role, because what you may be told sometimes cannot be carried by one person.

Thank them. "Thank you for telling me. It was brave." Whatever they have said, the fact that they said it deserves honour.

Do not promise to fix it. You can promise only what is yours to give: to listen, to stay close, and to find the right help with them.

3-3. Pass on

You are not the person who has to solve this. You pass the concern on, and you do so promptly, because delay is its own risk.

  1. The person responsible in the community. This is the safeguarding lead, the youth pastor, the parish priest, the head of the children's ministry or whoever your community's written policy names. If there is no policy, take the concern to the senior leader the same day, and ask that a policy be written. Lecture 4-4 explained why a written policy matters.
  2. The guardian. Usually the parent or guardian should be told. The policy and the person responsible decide how and by whom, and it is not normally the volunteer alone. There are rare cases where telling a guardian might put the young person at risk, and lecture 5-4 explains this. In that case the safeguarding lead decides, not you.
  3. A professional. A doctor, a school counsellor, a mental health service or a helpline in the country where you live can assess a young person in a way you cannot. You are not expected to know the services in detail; the person responsible should. Do not tell the young person what is wrong with them. Say "I think it would help to talk to someone who knows more than I do about this, and I will help you find them."
  4. Duty to report. In some countries and for some roles, there are legal duties to report particular concerns. These differ widely. This course does not say what yours are; learn them from your community's policy and local law.

4. Immediate danger

If a young person has told you, or shown you, that they are in danger now, or that they intend to harm themselves or others, or if you cannot tell and believe they may be, do not leave them alone. Stay with them. Call the local emergency number. Call the person responsible in the community, and, once the immediate danger is dealt with, the guardian. Do not argue with the young person about whether they mean it; you do not need to be sure. It is better to call and be mistaken than not to call.

Every country has its own emergency number, and some have separate numbers for health, police and fire. Learn yours now, before you need it, and know where the nearest help is. Keep it where you can find it. This is part of being an adult who works with young people.

5. Prayer and treatment

Some communities teach, directly or by implication, that a young person who is troubled lacks faith, or has an unconfessed sin, or needs only to trust more. Others turn at once to professionals and say little about God. Neither is right.

Prayer and treatment do not replace each other. A person with a fever may pray and also see a doctor, and no one is surprised. A young person who is struggling in mind or heart may be prayed for and also be helped by a professional. The story of Elijah suggests that God meets a worn-out person with food, rest and company, as well as with a word, and Galatians 6:2 does not say "pray from a distance" but "bear". Many people of faith have received both kinds of help and found them to be one care. Offering to pray with a young person is good, if the young person welcomes it, and if it never takes the place of getting help.

Illness is not a lack of faith. A broken leg is not a lack of faith, and neither is a troubled mind. Never tell a young person, or their family, that they would be well if they believed more. Such a remark adds shame to suffering and may keep a family from seeking help. Psalm 34:18 does not say that God is near to the faithful. It says that he is near to the broken-hearted.

6. Care for the adult

Hearing a young person's pain is heavy. You may feel fear, helplessness, anger at the people involved, or guilt that you did not see it sooner. You may not sleep. These are ordinary human responses.

  • Do not carry it alone. Passing the concern on is not only for the young person's sake. It is also what allows you to put it down. Speak to the person responsible, and ask for support for yourself if you need it.
  • Keep confidentiality. Talk only to those who need to know. Do not tell friends, other volunteers or the congregation, and do not use the story as a prayer request in a public meeting.
  • Look after your body. Sleep, eat, walk, be with people who love you. Elijah was fed before he was taught.
  • Know your limits. You are one adult among several who surround a young person. If you find yourself the only one, or feel that you must save them, that is a signal to ask for more help, not less.
  • Ask for debriefing if the community offers it. Some communities have a person who supports volunteers after hard conversations. If yours does not, you might suggest one.

7. A liturgical community and a free church

In a large parish, there are often many adults, a clear structure, and a named person responsible. The risk is that each assumes someone else has noticed, so that no one speaks. Make sure the names and routes are clear and written, and that every volunteer knows who is the person to go to. In a small assembly or house church, the pastor, the youth leader and the parent may be the same few people, and friendship may make it hard to raise a concern. The risk is that the concern stays within the circle of friends. Even so, the steps are the same: notice, stay, pass on. If the person responsible is the person you are worried about, or is a close relative of the young person, take the concern to a more senior person or to an outside body named in the policy. A community that cannot do that has a gap in its policy that must be closed.


Diagram 1. Notice, stay, pass on: the route of a concern

Notice, Stay, Pass On A route for an ordinary adult. It is not a diagnosis and not a rescue 1. Notice A change that is sudden, lasting or large for this young person: mood, sleep, eating, friends, withdrawal, remarks. Write down what you saw. 2. Stay Calm, in a visible place. Ask gently, listen, thank them. No promise of secrecy. No promise to fix it. Say who you will tell. 3. Pass on The person responsible, the same day. The guardian as policy says. Help to reach a professional. Learn local reporting duties. Do not carry it alone. Immediate danger Do not leave the young person alone. Call the local emergency number. Then call the person responsible. Better to call and be mistaken than not to call. What an adult is not Not a doctor, not a counsellor, not a lawyer, not a rescuer. What an adult is Someone who sees, stays near, and takes the concern to the right person. Prayer and treatment do not replace each other. Illness is not a lack of faith.

In short

  • Signs such as changes in mood, sleep, eating, friends or withdrawal, or a remark about not wanting to be here, tell you to pay attention; they are not a diagnosis.
  • The posture is notice, stay, pass on: observe what you saw, remain calm and listen, and take the concern to the person responsible the same day.
  • Never promise secrecy; say honestly who you will tell and why, and thank the young person for telling you.
  • If a young person may be in immediate danger, do not leave them alone and call the local emergency number.
  • Prayer and professional help do not replace each other, and illness is never a lack of faith.
  • Reporting duties differ by country and role; learn yours, and do not carry a hard conversation alone.
Front Back
The three-step posture Notice what you saw; stay calm and listen; pass on to the person responsible.
Why not promise secrecy? You may need others to help, and a broken promise teaches a young person not to speak again; say whom you will tell.
Immediate danger Do not leave them alone; call the local emergency number; then the person responsible.
Prayer and treatment They do not replace each other; illness is not a lack of faith.

One sentence to remember You do not need to know what is wrong; you need to notice, stay beside the young person, and take the concern to the right person.

This week's action Write down on a card the name of the person responsible for concerns in your community and the local emergency number, and keep it where you will find it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a time when an adult noticed that you were not yourself. What did they do that helped? What did they do that did not?
  • Why might a volunteer say nothing when they notice a change in a young person? What would make it easier to speak?
  • A young person says, "Promise you won't tell anyone." Write, in your own words, what you would say. What do you want them to hear beneath the words?
  • In your community, who is the person responsible for concerns about a young person? Do all the volunteers know? Is the route written down?
  • What would you say to someone who said that a troubled young person simply needs to pray more? What would you want that person to hear first?
  • Where do you find support after a hard conversation? If you do not have it, who could you ask?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.