Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
(An invented example.) Two children in the same group are both nine. Samir reads two years ahead of his age, argues politely with adults and cannot yet tie his shoes quickly. Joy runs faster than anyone in the group, makes friends in a minute, and finds long passages of text hard. A leader says, "These two are very different." Another leader says, "Which one is the nine-year-old?" Both of them are.
Growth is not one line that climbs at one speed. A child grows in the body, in thinking, in feeling, in relationships and in conscience, and these do not move together. A child can be ahead in one, behind in another, and sometimes move backwards for a while. An adult who understands this is less likely to say "she is behind" or "he is mature", as if a child had one number.
This lecture offers a map of growth in five areas, and then four well-known theories that each light up part of the ground. Maps help us find our way. They do not tell us who a particular child is. Throughout, "roughly" means roughly, "often" means often and not always, and no age in this course is a deadline.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Describe five areas of growth (body, mind, feeling, relationships, conscience) and say why they do not move at one speed.
- State, for Piaget, Erikson, Vygotsky and Bowlby with Ainsworth, one thing each helps an adult see and one thing each may miss.
- Explain why much developmental research needs to be read with its society in mind.
- Say why growth is not a straight line and what an adult should do when a child seems to go backwards.
- Explain what it means to use a theory as a map and not as a verdict.
And Jesus increased in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and men." — Luke 2:52
World English Bible
For you formed my inmost being. You knit me together in my mother’s womb. I will give thanks to you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Your works are wonderful. My soul knows that very well. My frame wasn’t hidden from you, when I was made in secret, woven together in the depths of the earth. Your eyes saw my body. In your book they were all written, the days that were ordained for me, when as yet there were none of them." — Psalm 139:13-16
WEB
Luke 2:52 gave us four kinds of growth in one sentence. Psalm 139 looks at the same mystery from the beginning: a person is formed, "knit together", and known by God before any part of the growing can be seen.
1. Five areas, uneven speeds
It helps to divide a child’s growth into five areas. The division is a convenience; in a real child they are tangled together.
- Body. Size, strength, coordination, energy, sleep, health, and later the changes of puberty. A child’s body sets limits on what the child can sit through, carry, or do for long.
- Mind. Attention, memory, language, imagination, reasoning, and the ability to think about thinking. How a child understands a word, a story or an idea changes a great deal across the years.
- Feeling. Naming, bearing and calming strong feelings: fear, anger, joy, shame, grief. A young child needs help to do this; an older child does more of it alone.
- Relationships. Trust in carers, play with others, friendship, belonging to a group, getting on with people who are not family.
- Conscience. A growing sense of right and wrong, fairness, guilt and repair. It begins with what the adults around the child approve or forbid, and it slowly becomes the child’s own.
Look at the diagram at the end of this lecture, in which the five areas are shown as five lines of different lengths. The point of the picture is that there is no single "age" for a child. A twelve-year-old may think like an older child about fairness and still cry like a younger one when a pet is ill. Many adults are also uneven in these ways.
Three things follow for the person who works with children.
First, do not read one area as the whole child. A child who is quiet in a big group may be shy, may be tired, may be thinking, or may be a child whose language at home is not the language of the group. A child who is loud may be joyful, anxious or bored. The behaviour is visible; the cause is not.
Second, growth is not a straight line. Illness, a move, a new baby, a bereavement, a change of school or simply a hard week may lead a child to behave in a younger way for a time: wanting to be carried, sleeping badly, clinging, losing words. Many children do this, and it often passes when they feel safe again. The response is steadiness, not shame. If it goes on or worries you, you tell the person responsible and the family; you do not diagnose.
Third, children differ from one another in ordinary ways. Some are slower to warm up and some leap in. Some grow later in height and some earlier. Some have disabilities or a different way of learning, and lecture 1-4 returns to this. A map that fits most children is not a failure when it does not fit one.
2. Four theories as maps
The best-known descriptions of children come from researchers and thinkers of the twentieth century. We will meet four. For each one the question is the same: what does it help us see, what does it miss, and from whose childhood did it learn?
One caution applies to all four. Much of this research was carried out in particular societies, often in Europe and North America, often with families who were willing and able to take part in a study. That does not make it false. It does mean that the picture may be clearer for some children than for others, and that a leader in Lagos, Manila, São Paulo or rural Ohio should hold the map lightly and check it against the children in front of them.
Jean Piaget (Swiss, 1896 to 1980) on thinking. Piaget described how children’s ways of thinking change, and he suggested that children pass through broad phases. Very young children learn through senses and movement. Then, roughly in the early school years, children think in pictures and in the way things look, and can be fooled by appearance. Later, roughly in the school years, they reason well about real, concrete things and situations. Later still, many begin to reason about ideas and possibilities. What it helps us see: a child is not a muddled adult. A child thinks in a way that makes sense for that child. A six-year-old who says "the moon follows our car" is not being silly. What it may miss: later research has often found that children can do more, earlier, than Piaget’s tasks suggested, that the phases overlap, and that culture, schooling and practice matter a great deal. The phases are better seen as a general direction than as a set of boxes.
Erik Erikson (German-American, 1902 to 1994) on the growth of the self. Erikson described a life as a series of stages, each with a central struggle. For the years we study, the struggles can be summarised as trust against mistrust in infancy, a sense of one’s own will in toddlerhood, taking initiative in early childhood, learning to be capable in the school years, and in the teen years working out who one is. What it helps us see: each age has its own emotional task, and the people around the child can help or hinder. A child who is shamed for every attempt may stop trying; a child who is trusted may become brave. What it may miss: the stages are drawn from a particular view of what a good life looks like, one that prizes independence; in societies that prize belonging first, the tasks may look different. Lecture 2-1 and lecture 4-2 return to Erikson.
Lev Vygotsky (Russian, 1896 to 1934) on learning with others. Vygotsky stressed that children learn through relationships with others, especially in language, play and shared work. His best-known idea is the zone of proximal development: the gap between what a child can do alone and what the child can do with a little help from someone more skilled. What it helps us see: a child is not alone in growing. The adult’s task is often to stand just beside the child, giving enough help to make the next step possible, and then to step back. What it may miss: it says less about the body, and less about strong feelings and attachment. It also invites the question, "help towards what?", and cultures give different answers. This idea matters to churches, because much of faith formation is exactly this: someone stands beside a child and does the thing with them.
John Bowlby (British, 1907 to 1990) and Mary Ainsworth (American-Canadian, 1913 to 1999) on attachment. Bowlby proposed that young children form a deep bond with a few carers, and that the sense of having a safe person to return to is the base from which a child explores. Ainsworth developed ways of observing how children of about one year behave when a carer leaves and returns. What it helps us see: a child’s need for a secure, responsive person is not clinginess to be trained out but a basic part of growing. A child who feels safe explores more freely. What it may miss: the behaviours that count as "secure" were first studied in a small number of settings, and the ways that children and carers show attachment differ across cultures. Many children are cared for by several people. And attachment is not a sentence for life; relationships can be repaired and new ones formed. Lecture 2-1 takes this up carefully.
Notice that the four theories do not compete in a simple way. Piaget helps with how a child thinks, Erikson with the child’s sense of self, Vygotsky with how learning happens between people, and Bowlby and Ainsworth with the safe base underneath. Put together, they say that growth is uneven, relational and shaped by the world a child grows in.
3. Maps, not verdicts
A map is useful because it is simpler than the land. A map of a city does not show every tree, and it does not show that the road is flooded today. If you stop looking at the road because the map says it is open, you will get wet.
The same applies here, and it is the principle for the whole chapter: a map of growth helps us see a child; it must never be used to judge one. There are three common ways of misusing the maps.
- Labelling. "He is a concrete thinker." "She is in the identity stage." A description of how many children are becomes a label for a person. Labels stick, and a child can come to live up or down to them.
- Ranking. Treating a later stage as better than an earlier one, so that a child at a "lower" place is seen as lagging. A ten-year-old is not behind a fifteen-year-old.
- Deciding from the map and not from the child. "A seven-year-old cannot understand that, so there is no point explaining." Sometimes a child understands far more than the map predicts, and sometimes less. Only attention to this child tells you.
The right use of a map is as a set of questions. What might this child be working on at this age? What might be hard for a child of this age in this setting? What might I have missed? Then you look at the child, and you ask the family or the person responsible when you are unsure.
4. What the Scriptures give to the maps
The two passages for this lecture do not give us a theory of development, and it would be a mistake to read them as if they did. They do give us two things that every map needs underneath it.
The first is in Luke 2:52: growth is plural. The sentence names mind, body, a growing relationship with God, and a growing place among people. A community that cared only for what children know would have forgotten three-quarters of the verse.
The second is in Psalm 139. The psalmist says that God "formed my inmost being" and "knit me together", that "I am fearfully and wonderfully made", and that God’s eyes saw the body "when as yet there were none of them", before a single day of life. Whatever else a believer takes from this psalm, it says that a person is known before they have done anything. A child is known by God and counted before the child can recite, behave or understand. The growing that we map is the growing of someone already known. A leader who remembers this holds the maps with open hands.
5. Five areas in a community’s life
How does the map reach a Sunday morning, a class, a youth evening or a family service? Here are a few examples, each short on purpose.
- Body. A child who has been in school all week may be tired. A teen may need to sleep late. A very young child needs to move. Planning around these is not indulgence; it is honouring the body God made.
- Mind. Words that adults take for granted, such as "grace", "sin", "the Lord’s body" or "born again", may be heard by a child in a very concrete way. Asking "What do you think that word means?" often shows more than it hides.
- Feeling. A child who cries when a parent leaves, or one who laughs at a solemn moment, is usually not being disrespectful. Strong feelings need a calm adult nearby.
- Relationships. A child’s first picture of a trustworthy person is often the child’s carer. The adult in the church may be the second or third picture, and may be the only steady adult outside the family for a child in a hard year.
- Conscience. A young child often behaves well because an adult is watching and approves. Only gradually does the child hold the rule from inside. A community that watches only behaviour may miss the inner growing, which is slow and has set-backs.
These examples hold in a cathedral parish and in a house church. In a liturgical community, the rhythms of the year, the movement and the symbols already speak to the body and the feelings; the work is to make sure children are not made to feel they are in the way. In a free-church community with a lot of speaking, the work may be to make room for the body and for silence. Either way, the map does not change; what changes is where the adults need to look.
6. Using the map, step by step
When you meet a child in your care, you might take three small steps. They are the habits of this whole course.
- Look first. Watch the child in one ordinary moment, without a plan, and without naming what is wrong.
- Wonder. Ask which area of growth might be asking for attention: body, mind, feeling, relationships, conscience. Say "might", not "is".
- Ask. Ask the child, gently, and where it is right to do so ask the family or the person responsible. The child and the family know things the map does not.
Diagram 1. Five areas, five speeds
In short
- Growth happens in five areas: body, mind, feeling, relationships and conscience. They move at uneven speeds, and no child has a flat line.
- Growth is not a straight line; illness, loss or change can send a child back for a while, and steadiness is the right response.
- Piaget helps us see how children think, Erikson the self’s tasks, Vygotsky learning with others, and Bowlby and Ainsworth the need for a safe base.
- Much developmental research comes from particular societies and should be checked against the children in front of you.
- Use a map as a set of questions, never as a label, a ranking or a reason to stop looking.
- Luke 2:52 names growth in several areas, and Psalm 139 says a person is known by God before any growing can be seen.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five areas of growth | Body, mind, feeling, relationships, conscience; they move at uneven speeds. |
| What a map is for | To ask questions about a child, not to label, rank or decide for the child. |
| Zone of proximal development | What a child can do with a little help but not yet alone (Vygotsky). |
| Why read research with care | Much of it was drawn from particular societies and may fit some children better than others. |
One sentence to remember Growth is uneven, shared with others and never a straight line, so look at the child, not just the map.
This week’s action Watch one child for five minutes without correcting anything, and note which of the five areas that child is working on.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a child you know. In which of the five areas does that child seem furthest along, and in which seems to be taking more time? What might you have wrongly taken for a single "age"?
- Recall a time when a child you know went backwards for a while. What was happening in the child’s life? How did the adults around respond?
- Which of the four theories fits what you have noticed about children? Which seems to ignore something you know? Whose childhood do you think each theory was drawn from?
- Have you ever heard a child labelled, such as "shy", "a handful" or "gifted"? What did the label do to how adults treated the child?
- Psalm 139 says a person is known by God before the days of life began. How does that change how you look at the growth of a child in your care?
- Where in your community are the body and the senses taken seriously? Where are they overlooked?