Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
A volunteer reads the story of the mustard seed to a group of nine-year-olds. She asks, "What does the seed stand for?" Nobody answers. Then a boy puts up his hand and says, "My uncle planted a mustard plant and it did not get that big. So is Jesus wrong?" (an invented example)
There are several ways to meet this boy. The adult can laugh, and the boy learns that his question was foolish. She can hurry to the "right answer" and the boy learns that stories are puzzles with one key. Or she can see what he is doing. He is thinking carefully, and he is thinking in the way that is natural for his age: he takes words as they are and checks them against what he has seen. That is not a failure of faith. It is a mind at work.
This lecture is about how children of roughly seven to twelve meet a story, a picture and a word. The central claim of the course holds here. A child of this age is not a small adult who cannot yet understand the Bible. A child of this age is a whole reader who reads in a way that fits this age. The adult's work is to give the child stories to live in, and to let meaning grow without forcing it.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe, using Piaget's idea of concrete thinking as a map, how children of roughly seven to twelve often understand stories, and say what the map misses.
- Explain why a child may take a parable or a figure of speech literally, and how an adult can respond without mockery.
- Explain why meeting God in a story comes before defining terms.
- Distinguish memorising a text from understanding it, and say what each is for.
- Name the danger of turning the Bible into a quiz of right answers.
He said, “How will we liken the Kingdom of God? Or with what parable will we illustrate it?" — Mark 4:30
World English Bible
With many such parables he spoke the word to them, as they were able to hear it." — Mark 4:33
WEB
We will not hide them from their children, telling to the generation to come the praises of Yahweh, his strength, and his wondrous works that he has done." — Psalm 78:4
WEB
He arose, and came to his father. But while he was still far off, his father saw him, and was moved with compassion, and ran, and fell on his neck, and kissed him." — Luke 15:20
WEB
Mark 4:33 says that Jesus spoke "as they were able to hear it." The teaching was shaped by the hearers. Psalm 78:4 says what the generations are to hand on: the praises and the wonders, told to children. Luke 15:20 is one moment from a longer story that no child needs explained before it moves them.
1. How a child of this age often thinks
Many children in the school years, roughly from seven to eleven or twelve, become much more skilled at reasoning, as long as the reasoning stays tied to things they can picture, handle or have seen. The Swiss psychologist Jean Piaget called this period "concrete operational" thinking. A child at this stage can sort things into groups, put events in order, and see that a quantity does not change when it is poured into a different jar. The same child may find an abstract question, such as "What is justice?", much harder than a story about two children and an unfair share of cake.
Piaget's map helps us see something real. Many children in these years are strong with stories and weak with abstractions, and they are often delighted by facts, lists, rules and exact details. It also has limits, and the course asks you to hold it lightly. Piaget studied children mostly in a few societies, and later researchers found that children can do some of these tasks earlier, or later, depending on the task, the language and the way they are taught. Nothing in the map tells you what any one child can do. A child of ten may think abstractly about one subject and concretely about another. Use the map to ask "What might be going on in this child's mind?", never to decide "This child cannot understand."
2. The literal reader
Because children of this age tend to hold words close to the things the words name, they often read a figure of speech as a report. Here are three invented scenes.
A child hears "Jesus is the door" and asks which door, and whether he has a handle. A child hears that God "sees everything" and decides that God is watching the bathroom. A child hears "You must be born again" and asks how a grown man can get back into his mother, which is exactly the question Nicodemus asks in John 3:4. (these three are invented examples)
None of these children is being silly or irreverent. They are doing something we also do when we meet a new idea: they are checking it against what they already know. A wise adult takes the question as a real question. "Good thinking. It is not a real door. Jesus uses a picture. What do doors do? What do you think he means?" The adult does not rush to the meaning. The adult keeps the picture alive and lets the child walk around it.
There is a second danger, which is the opposite of mockery. It is to explain too soon. A paragraph of theology laid over a story tends to push the story out. A child who has been told what the prodigal son "really means" may remember the meaning, in the adult's words, and never feel the road, the pigs, the running father. When an adult has to choose, it is usually better to let the story do its work and ask one open question than to pass on a finished interpretation.
3. Meet God in a story before defining terms
The parable of the lost son in Luke 15:11-24 is a story that works at every age. A seven-year-old can follow it: a boy leaves, a boy is hungry, a father runs. An adult can read it for decades. Nobody has to know the word "grace" or the word "repentance" to feel the shape of what happens at verse 20, when the father sees the son "while he was still far off" and runs.
This suggests an order. A child can meet God in a story, a song, a gesture or a place before the child is asked to define any word. Definitions are not wrong. A school-age child often likes them. But a definition given first can become a wall: the child learns to say "Grace is God's undeserved favour" and may be able to recite it without ever having felt a father run. A story given first becomes a room the child can come back to, and the definition, when it comes, has somewhere to stand.
Many traditions have always known this. A liturgical community tells the story of salvation through the year, through feasts, fasts, readings and images, and children live in it before they can explain it. An icon or a stained-glass window is a story told in a picture. A free-church community may tell stories in a children's talk, a drama or a song. The advice works in both. In both, the risk is the same, which is to hurry from the story to a moral in one breath.
4. Why Jesus taught in parables, and what it tells us
Mark 4:30-34 shows Jesus asking how to describe the kingdom of God, and answering with a picture: a mustard seed, the smallest of the seeds a farmer sowed, which grows into a large plant where birds can shelter. Mark 4:33 adds the line that matters here: he spoke "as they were able to hear it." Mark 4:34 says that privately he explained everything to his disciples.
Notice two things. First, Jesus did not begin with a definition. Second, he did not give everyone the same amount. The crowd had the story. The disciples, later, had more. Good teaching has often followed this order, and so should the adult beside a child. Give the story. Wait. Let questions come. Add a little. Let the child return.
The boy with the uncle's mustard plant is a good example. The parable speaks of a small seed and a surprisingly large plant. The boy has noticed that the plant in his uncle's garden is not as big as the story says. An adult might say, "You looked closely. Jesus is not giving a lesson about gardens. He tells a story where something very small grows into something that gives shelter. What do you think he wants us to notice about God's kingdom?" If the boy shrugs, that is allowed. The seed has been planted. It may not come up this year.
5. Memorising and understanding
Children of this age are often good at memorising. They learn the names of the books, a psalm, a creed, a prayer, a long list. In many communities this is a treasure. In a liturgical community the child who knows the prayers by heart can join the whole assembly. In a community where Scripture is learned verse by verse the child carries the words into every day.
Memorising and understanding are different things, and each has its own use. Words held in the memory can be understood later, sometimes years later. A child who can say the Lord's Prayer or a psalm has something to grow into. But a child who can say a verse is not thereby a child who understands it, and a child who understands may not be able to recite. The mistake is to treat the one as proof of the other. A child who performs a text perfectly in front of the congregation has done a good thing, and we should say so. We should not conclude from it that the child's faith is advanced, and we should not conclude from a stumble that it is weak.
There is also a quiet pressure to watch for. When recitation is praised more loudly than curiosity, children learn that the safe way to be good in church is to produce the right words. Some will do it very well, and some will do it for the wrong reason: to be loved. Lecture 3-2 returns to this.
6. The Bible is not a quiz
It is easy, and often well meant, to turn the Bible into a game of questions with correct answers. Who was swallowed by a fish? How many disciples were there? A game has its place. Facts are useful, and children of this age usually enjoy them. The danger is when the game becomes the whole way of meeting the book. A child may learn that the Bible is a place where adults hold answers and children must guess them, and that wrong answers mean a loss.
One sign of trouble is that the same children always answer and the same children never do. Another is that the questions all have one-word answers. A third is that a child who gives an honest but unexpected reply is quickly corrected and moved on. Questions that open a story work differently. "What do you notice?" "Which person would you want to be near?" "What do you think the father was thinking when he ran?" "Is there anything in this story that surprises you, or that you do not like?" Such questions have no wrong answers, though they can have thoughtful ones, and they let a quiet child join in.
This course does not teach how to design a lesson; that belongs to a course on teaching. Here the point is the posture of the adult: to carry the story to the child as a gift, and not to examine the child on it.
7. Pictures, drama and the senses
Children of this age often learn a great deal through what they can see and do: drawing a scene, acting a story, building a model, handling an object, walking through a space set out as a journey. These are not lesser ways of knowing. Many communities, liturgical and free-church alike, use them: the icons, vestments and movements of a ; a map on the wall of a Sunday-school room; a dramatised reading. When a child draws the father running, the child is already interpreting.
Watch for the child who draws something you did not expect. A boy who draws the older brother standing outside the party may be thinking about something in his own life. The drawing does not need to be analysed. It needs to be received. "Tell me about your picture" is usually enough.
8. Where readers will agree and where they might not
Nearly all Christian traditions tell children the stories of Scripture, and nearly all hold that a child should be given the story and not only a rule. They differ in how much they expect a child to recite, how formal the instruction is, and when a child is thought ready for what. This course does not decide those questions. It asks only that the story come first, that the child's questions be welcomed, and that no child be made to feel foolish for thinking in the way a child thinks.
Diagram 1. Story first, meaning later: how understanding can grow
In short
- Children of roughly seven to twelve are often strong with stories and concrete detail and find abstraction harder; Piaget's map shows this, but it does not predict what one child can do.
- A child who takes a parable literally is thinking, not being irreverent; welcome the question and keep the picture alive.
- Let a child meet God in a story, a song or a picture before being asked to define terms.
- Memorising is a gift to grow into, but reciting a text is not proof that a child understands it.
- Do not turn the Bible into a quiz of right answers; use open questions that have no wrong answer.
- Mark 4:33 says Jesus spoke "as they were able to hear it"; the adult gives the story and lets meaning grow.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Concrete thinking (Piaget) | A map: many children of this age reason well about what they can picture, and find abstractions harder. It does not say what any one child can do. |
| A child takes a parable literally | Welcome it as thinking; keep the picture alive; ask what the picture might mean; do not mock or rush. |
| Story or definition first? | Story first. A definition given first can become a wall; a story becomes a room the child can return to. |
| Memorising and understanding | Different things. Memory holds words to grow into; reciting is not proof of understanding. |
One sentence to remember Give the child the story as a gift, and let the meaning grow at the child's pace.
This week's action Tell or read one Bible story to a child, or to yourself as if you were nine, and ask one question that has no wrong answer.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Recall a story from your own childhood that you met before you could explain it. What do you remember: the words, the picture, a voice, a place? How does it feel now?
- A child takes a figure of speech literally. What is your first reaction, and where does it come from?
- In your community, what is the child who recites well praised for? What is the child who asks an unusual question given?
- When did you last ask a child a question in church or at home that had no wrong answer? What happened?
- Piaget's map is drawn from certain societies. What might children in your own setting show that the map does not predict?
- What would it take, in your setting, for a quiet child to feel safe giving an unexpected answer?