Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
An eleven-year-old called Grace sits at the back of a children's group and says, almost to herself, "How do I know that God is real? I have only ever been told." The adult beside her has been asked many questions in this room, but this one has a different weight. It does not sound like curiosity about a story. It sounds like a girl who has begun to ask whether the faith she was handed is hers. (an invented example)
This is a moment that many adults dread and some adults miss. It is one of the most important moments in the years from roughly seven to twelve. A child who has lived inside a family's or community's faith begins, often quietly, to wonder what it means for them. They may start to ask hard questions. They may be moved in a way they cannot explain. They may say they do not believe, or they may say they believe with all their heart. All of these can be the beginning of first-hand faith.
This lecture is about that beginning. The central claim of the course applies: a child's faith is not an unfinished faith but a whole faith for that age. A child who asks, doubts, wonders and belongs is not a Christian in waiting. The adult's work is to welcome questions, to avoid hurrying or testing a child's sincerity, and to walk beside the child at the child's own pace. The lecture also states fairly two disagreements among Christians that affect children: whether conversion is a moment or a process, and when children are baptised, confess, receive communion, are confirmed or make a profession.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Describe what "first-hand faith" means for a child of roughly seven to twelve, and why it often shows itself first as a question.
- Explain why an adult welcomes questions and doubt and does not hurry or test a child's sincerity.
- State fairly two views of conversion, as a moment and as a process, and what this course requires of both.
- State fairly the main ways churches mark a child's entry into the life of faith, and who decides.
- Explain why no child should be hurried or shamed about timing.
But Thomas, one of the twelve, called Didymus, wasn’t with them when Jesus came." — John 20:24
World English Bible
The other disciples therefore said to him, “We have seen the Lord!” But he said to them, “Unless I see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe.”" — John 20:25
WEB
Then he said to Thomas, “Reach here your finger, and see my hands. Reach here your hand, and put it into my side. Don’t be unbelieving, but believing.”" — John 20:27
WEB
Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!”" — John 20:28
WEB
Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24
WEB
As they went on the way, they came to some water, and the eunuch said, “Behold, here is water. What is keeping me from being baptized?”" — Acts 8:36
WEB
Thomas is given what he asks for and is not sent away. The father in Mark 9 puts belief and unbelief in a single sentence and is heard. The man in Acts 8 asks what stands in the way of baptism. Churches that read this story answer in different ways, and the lecture returns to it below.
1. What "first-hand" means
In the early years a child receives faith almost entirely from others. A parent says the prayer; the child says it too. A grandmother crosses herself; the child learns the movement. A teacher tells the story; the child listens. This is not a lesser faith. It is how all of us first learn a language.
In the school years, many children begin to take a further step. They notice that the faith they have been given is one among others, that classmates and neighbours believe differently or not at all, and that they themselves can ask whether it is true. Their growing ability to think about their own thinking, to see another's point of view and to hold a question open makes this possible. We should not call it a stage that every child enters on the same day or a development that every child shows. Some children ask openly at eight. Some ask nothing until fourteen. Some ask in private, and an adult may never know.
When this begins, a child may say things that sound alarming: "I'm not sure I believe in God." "Why do we have to go?" "What if it's all made up?" But a child may also say things that sound deep: "I felt like God was near when we sang." "I prayed and I think someone heard." The adult does not need to decide quickly which kind of remark it is. Both are the child's own, and both are to be received.
This course does not say that the Holy Spirit works only through such moments, or that faith can be read off a child's remarks. Faith is God's gift and not a ladder (lecture 1-3). A map of growth can help us see what a child is doing; it does not tell us what God is doing.
2. Questions are a way in, not a way out
The father in Mark 9:24 is perhaps the best patron of this lecture. He has a sick child. Jesus has said, "If you can believe, all things are possible to him who believes" (Mark 9:23). The father does not answer with a doctrine. He answers: "I believe. Help my unbelief!" He does not separate the two as though one were faith and the other failure. They sit side by side, and Jesus answers the request.
Thomas is the other patron. In John 20, Thomas was not with the other disciples when Jesus first came. They tell him the news, and he says he will not believe unless he sees. A week later Jesus comes again, offers Thomas exactly what he asked for, and Thomas says, "My Lord and my God!" (John 20:28). Thomas is often called "doubting Thomas", a label that makes doubt sound like a character flaw. Look at what the passage shows: a man who said what he honestly thought, was not expelled for it, and was met.
For an adult beside a child, these passages suggest a few habits.
Treat the question as a gift. A child who asks "Is God real?" in your presence is showing trust. They could have asked no one. The question is a door that has opened a little.
Say "That is a good question." Say it only when it is true, and it nearly always is.
Be honest about what you know. "I don't know" and "People have thought about this for a long time, and here is what some of them said" are honest and respectful. A child who is given a confident answer that does not satisfy will notice. A child who hears that an adult also wonders may feel less alone.
Share your own faith simply. "I believe God is real. Here is why it matters to me." This is not pressure if it is an offering and not a requirement.
Do not take the doubt personally. The child is not rejecting you. The child is thinking.
Do not hurry to calm the question. A quick answer can close a conversation that needed a second turn. It is better to ask, "What made you wonder?"
3. Do not test the child's sincerity
A temptation, especially in communities that care deeply about faith, is to check whether the child "really" believes. Adults may ask, "Do you know why you are asking?" or "Have you really asked Jesus into your heart?" or "Do you understand what you are saying?" Behind these questions is often a real desire to protect the child from empty words. But they can also leave a child feeling that every sincere statement will be audited.
Consider what an eight- or ten-year-old can offer. A child's sincerity is real, but their words are the words of a child. A child may say "I want to be baptised" because a friend is, because a parent is pleased, because they are moved, because they love Jesus, or for several of these at once. An adult cannot see a heart, and neither can a ten-year-old fully read their own. So there is a rule of humility for the adult: receive what the child says as truthfully meant, and do not set an examination to prove it. Equally, do not push a child to say more than they are ready to say.
The opposite fault is also real. Some adults, afraid of pressing, say nothing at all, and the child concludes that faith is a matter nobody mentions. Silence can be as heavy as pressure. The balance is a standing invitation that never becomes a demand: "If you ever want to talk about God, or about anything you are wondering, I would like to listen."
4. Belonging before believing, and believing before belonging
A related question: does a child belong first and then come to believe, or believe first and then belong? Many children have belonged for years before they could say they believed. They sang, prayed and ate with the community, were known by name, and were missed when absent. This belonging is no empty shell. For many children it is the soil in which first-hand faith grows.
A child can also feel that belonging depends on saying the right words. A child who senses this may say them. Then belonging is bought, and the child may not know it. The wise community lets the child belong whether or not the child yet says "I believe", and lets the child's own words come when they come. That is true in a parish where a child is carried to the font and the table, and true in a free-church assembly where a child sits with the others and sings.
5. Conversion: a moment or a process
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians, especially in evangelical, Pentecostal and revivalist traditions, look for a decisive turning: a moment when a person repents, believes and receives Christ, which can often be named and remembered. They argue that the New Testament calls for a response, that a faith never personally owned is not enough, and that to leave a child without an invitation is to leave the child without a choice. Many who hold this view came to faith through such a moment and are grateful for it. Their concern is real: that no child should drift through church life never having met Jesus for themselves.
Other Christians, especially in Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, Anglican and Reformed traditions, and in some others, see faith as formed from infancy, through baptism, family prayer and the life of the church, and growing through many stages. They argue that a child who has always been in the household of faith does not need a dramatic turning, and that to press a child toward a moment may produce an anxious or false experience. Many who hold this view came to faith without any single moment and cannot name a date. Their concern, too, is real: that no child should be taught that a gradual faith is a lesser one.
Both groups usually agree on something more than they say. Those who look for a moment generally hold that the moment is the fruit of a long preparation, and those who hold to formation generally hold that each person must in the end make the faith their own. What this course requires is less than either position: do not press a child for a moment, and do not assume formation needs no personal response. An adult can leave room for a child to say yes, and can make clear that a quiet faith is not a smaller one.
6. Entering the life of faith: baptism, communion, confirmation and profession
This is a point where readers will not agree. Churches mark a child's entry into the life of faith in different ways and at different ages. We state them without ranking them, and this is only an outline, since each tradition has its own details and variations.
- , with later steps. Many churches (including the Catholic, Lutheran, Anglican, Reformed and Methodist traditions) baptise infants and later mark growth in other ways: a first confession and first communion at a stage the church or family judges right, which in some churches is often around seven or eight; confirmation or a similar affirmation later, at an age that varies widely by church and country. Those who hold this view argue that God's grace comes before a child's response, that the child is received into the community as the infants of Israel were, and that the later steps are the child's own growing response.
- Baptism, chrismation and communion together, in infancy. In the Orthodox churches an infant is usually baptised, anointed (chrismated) and given communion in one service, and goes on receiving communion. Those who hold this view argue that the child is a full member of the body from the beginning, and that the church feeds all of its members.
- . Baptist, many Pentecostal and many other free-church traditions baptise those who profess faith, and many dedicate or bless infants without baptising them. Those who hold this view argue that the New Testament pattern is a personal confession followed by baptism, and that a baptism without a personal confession is incomplete. In some of these churches a child may profess faith and be baptised at a young age; in others the church waits until the person is older. The age is decided differently from church to church.
- Other practices. Some traditions do not practise baptism or communion in the form described here. Some have rites of dedication, welcome or blessing that do not claim to be sacraments.
Who decides? The question is rarely the child's alone. It may belong to the child's parents or guardians, to the pastor or priest, to the elders or the church's own rule, and, as the child grows, increasingly to the child. Sometimes these people disagree: a child of a Baptist family may attend a Catholic school, or a family may belong to two traditions. A child may even ask for something their own church does not offer at their age.
Acts 8:35-38 is read by all these traditions. Philip tells the Ethiopian official about Jesus; they come to water; the official asks what prevents his baptism; and he is baptised. Believer's-baptism traditions see here belief followed by baptism. Others point out that it concerns an adult who came to faith from outside and does not settle what to do with the children of believers. Verse 37, which in some translations contains a confession, is not in the text of the World English Bible, so this course does not rest on it. We note that these differences of reading are real.
What this course requires is again less than any of them: state the practice of your own community honestly, name who decides, and never hurry or shame a child over the timing. Do not tell a child who has been baptised as an infant that their baptism "does not count", or a child who has not been baptised that they are "not really one of us". Do not tell a child who wants to be baptised or to receive communion that they are "too young to know", nor press a child who does not want to. If a family and a community differ, the adult's task is to talk with the family and with the pastor or priest, and not to settle it through the child.
7. What an adult can do when a child is ready to say something
Suppose a child says, "I want to follow Jesus", or "I want to take communion", or "I want to be baptised." A wise adult can follow three steps. Listen first: "Tell me more about that." Tell the person responsible: the child's parents or guardians and the pastor, priest or leader whose decision it is, so that the child is not left in the middle. Keep the child close: whatever the answer, the child should be able to see that the question was welcomed.
Suppose instead that a child says, "I don't think I believe any more." Listen. Do not argue on the spot. Do not say "You will go to hell." Do not say "That's just a phase." Say, "Thank you for telling me. I would like to hear more, whenever you want to talk." Tell the parents, if that is the community's practice and the child agrees, or, if the child has asked you not to, tell the child honestly that you will need to speak with someone and why. The child is still welcome. The door is open.
Diagram 1. Three roads into the life of faith, and what they share
In short
- First-hand faith often begins as a question or a doubt; the child is whole in faith for this age, not a Christian in waiting.
- Mark 9:24 and John 20 show belief and unbelief held side by side and met, not expelled; welcome the question and be honest about what you do not know.
- Do not test a child's sincerity or press the child to say more than they are ready to say; equally, do not stay silent.
- Conversion as a moment and as a process are both defended; do not press a child for a moment, and do not assume formation needs no personal response.
- Churches mark entry into the faith differently (infant baptism with later steps, baptism with chrismation and communion in infancy, believer's baptism); the decision is shared among family, leader, church and the growing child.
- Never hurry or shame a child over the timing of baptism, communion, confirmation or profession.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| First-hand faith | The child begins to ask what the faith received from others means for them; it often first appears as a question or doubt. |
| How to meet a child's doubt | Treat it as a gift, be honest about what you know, share your faith simply, do not test sincerity, do not hurry to calm it. |
| Moment or process? | Some look for a decisive turning; some see formation from infancy. Do not press for a moment; do not assume formation needs no response. |
| Timing of baptism, communion, confirmation, profession | Practices differ by tradition; state your own fairly, name who decides, and never hurry or shame a child. |
One sentence to remember Welcome the child's questions, let faith become the child's own at the child's pace, and let no one be shamed over the timing.
This week's action Write one sentence you could say to a child who says "I'm not sure I believe", and one sentence you would never say.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- When, if ever, did your faith become your own? Was it a moment, a long process, or something else you cannot easily name?
- What did the adults around you do when you doubted or asked a hard question as a child? What would you have wanted them to do?
- Which of the practices described in this lecture is your own community's? Which are new to you? Can you state one you do not share in a way a person who holds it would recognise?
- What does your community say, openly or without words, about a child who asks to take part earlier or later than most?
- How would you answer a child who said, "I'm not sure I believe in God"? What would be your first sentence, and what would you avoid saying?
- If a family and your community disagree about the timing of baptism or communion, how would you want the adults to handle it?