FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT706E How Children and Young People Grow in Faith

Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God

Contents 31
PT706E How Children and Young People Grow in Faith
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
  1. Introduction: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Seeing Growth
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
  3. Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
  4. Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Early Years (about 0 to 6)
  1. Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
  2. Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
  3. Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
  4. Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The School Years (about 7 to 12)
  1. Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
  2. Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
  3. Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
  4. Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Teen Years (about 13 to 18)
  1. Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
  2. Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
  3. Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Life and Heart of Young People
  1. Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
  2. Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
  3. Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
  4. Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Moving On and Growing Together
  1. Lecture 6-1: Bridges Between Stages
  2. Lecture 6-2: Working With Families
  3. Lecture 6-3: Young People Serving and Leading
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Community That Grows With Its Children
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: One Step for One Age

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

A volunteer is helping a group of four-year-olds make paper lambs. One child stops and asks, in a clear voice: "Is God in the cupboard?" Another says: "God is up. He lives in the sky with Grandma." A third, with great seriousness: "When I die I will be an angel."

There are at least three ways to get this wrong. The first is to laugh, which tells the child that the question was silly. The second is to correct at length: "Well, actually, God is everywhere and has no body, and we do not become angels." The third is to freeze, because the volunteer does not know what the parents believe, and to say, "Let us get on with our lambs."

This lecture is about the better way. It begins from how young children think, which is different from how adults think, but not worse. Then it looks at some of the questions young children ask about God, about death and about what is real, and at the sort of answer that is short, honest and warm. It ends with how to respect a child's own prayers, and when to send a question to the parents.

The central claim of the course holds here. A young child's questions are not a muddled version of adult questions. They are whole questions from a whole mind of that age. The adult's work is to take them seriously and to answer in a way that the child can hold, without frightening, without lying and without hurrying.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Describe, using Piaget as a map, three features of young children's thinking (concrete thinking, imagination, and magical thinking), and say what the map misses.
  • Explain why short, honest, warm answers are better than long ones or comforting untruths.
  • Give a short honest reply to a child's question about where God is, and say what to avoid.
  • Explain what to avoid when a young child asks about death, and why parents are involved.
  • Describe how to respect a young child's prayers.

Jesus called a little child to himself, and set him in their midst," — Matthew 18:2

World English Bible

and said, “Most certainly I tell you, unless you turn, and become as little children, you will in no way enter into the Kingdom of Heaven." — Matthew 18:3

WEB

From the lips of babes and infants you have established strength, because of your adversaries, that you might silence the enemy and the avenger." — Psalm 8:2

WEB

But when Jesus saw it, he was moved with indignation, and said to them, “Allow the little children to come to me! Don’t forbid them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these." — Mark 10:14

WEB

Jesus puts a child in the middle of the room and does not say "Be like children in how they think." He says, "Turn." Readers of many traditions understand this as a call to humility, trust and receiving. This lecture takes a narrower step. If Jesus can put a child in the middle and say the Kingdom belongs to such as these, then the questions of a child are worth hearing, and the child's way of seeing is not a problem to be corrected quickly.

1. How a young child thinks

The Swiss psychologist Jean Piaget spent a working life watching how children think. He described stages. For children from about two to about six or seven (the ages are rough), he used the term "pre-operational": a time when a child can think with words and pictures and pretend, but does not yet reason in the ordered, step-by-step way that older children and adults do. He pointed to several features. Three matter for us.

Concrete thinking. A young child thinks about things that can be seen, touched and named. "God is love" is hard. "God is like a shepherd" is closer, because the child has seen a picture of a shepherd. Words that stand for ideas ("holy", "eternal", "sin", "grace") are slippery. A child will give them a picture, often a surprising one.

Imagination and pretend. A young child moves easily between what is real and what is pretend, and does not always mark the border as an adult would. A teddy may have feelings. A cloud may be a face. A story may be both true and not true, and the child is not troubled.

Magical thinking. A young child often links things that an adult would not. "I was bad, so it rained." "I wished it, so it happened." "She went away because I was cross." This is not stupidity. It is a mind that has not yet learned where causes stop. But it matters for faith, because a child may link a family event with a wrong thing the child said or did, and carry a private guilt.

What does this help us see? That when a child says something odd about God, the child is probably doing sensible thinking with the tools of that age. It helps us not to treat a child's picture of God as a heresy, a mistake to be removed, or a joke.

What does it miss? Quite a lot. Later researchers found that young children can show more understanding than Piaget's tests suggested, especially when a task is familiar and the questions are put in a way the child can follow. Children also differ widely, and a child's thinking changes with experience, language and the people around. Piaget worked mainly with children in particular societies, and his stages describe a tendency, not a timetable. Do not use the ages to say a child is "behind" or "ahead", and never to label a child.

2. Why short, honest and warm

Faced with a hard question, adults tend to do one of two things. Some say too much; they give a lecture the child cannot follow. Some say something untrue to avoid pain or to end the conversation: "God took her because he needed another angel," "Grandpa has gone to sleep," "God is watching you and will be cross."

Each fails. A long answer overwhelms and leaves the child with a few words and no meaning. A comforting untruth works for a day, and then does damage. A child who is told that Grandpa is "asleep" may become afraid of going to sleep. A child who is told that God took a sister may conclude that God takes people we love, and may be afraid of God or angry with him. A child who is told that God will be cross at bad behaviour may hear it as a threat.

The better way has three marks.

Short. One or two sentences. Let the child ask the next question. If the child wants more, the child will say so, often by asking something else.

Honest. Say what you know. Say "I do not know" when you do not. Say "People believe different things about that" when that is true. A child can hold "I do not know" better than we think; what a child cannot hold well is being lied to and later finding out.

Warm. The tone carries more than the words. A calm voice, a smile or a hand on the shoulder says, "You can ask me anything." If the child learns that questions are welcome, the child will ask again when the child is older and the questions are harder.

Often a good first move is to ask the child a question back: "What do you think?" or "What made you think about that?" A child's question may not mean what an adult hears. "Where is God?" may be about a place, or about a feeling, or about a worry that God cannot hear the child at night. The reply shows what the child is really asking.

3. Some questions and ways of answering

Here are some questions that young children ask. These are examples of the spirit of the answer, not scripts. Your own words, and your community's beliefs, will shape what you say.

"Where is God?" A short, true answer might be: "God is with us. We can't see God, but the Bible says God is near." A community that believes that God is present in the bread, the church building or the gathered assembly may say so simply. What to avoid: "God lives in the sky" (the child may look for a house), and "God sees everything you do" said as a warning. A child who is afraid of being watched is not helped by this.

"Can God hear me?" "Yes. God hears when we talk and when we are quiet." A child who talks to God in bed, with no words, in the bath, is praying. No adult needs to improve it.

"Why can't I see God?" "No one has seen God the way we see a person. But God is real, and loves us." Add: "That's a big question. Lots of people wonder about it." The wondering is a good thing to leave open.

"Did God make the dinosaurs?" Some communities read the creation stories as a plain report, some as a different kind of writing, and some in between. Here the volunteer follows the community's teaching and also the parents' wishes, and keeps it short: "God made everything, and people tell the story in different ways." Do not turn a four-year-old's question into a debate between adults.

"Is the bad man going to get me?" This kind of question may come from a film, a story, a dream, or something that happened. The first step is to listen. "That sounds scary. Tell me what you saw." Then: "You are safe here. I am here and the other grown-ups are too." If the fear seems to come from something real in the child's life, do not question the child closely; pass it to the person responsible for children's work, who knows the community's written policy. Lecture 5-4 explains this in more detail.

4. Death: Grandma has gone

A young child's questions about death come early. They come with a pet, with a fallen bird, with a funeral, and with a grandparent. They deserve special care, and they involve the family.

What a young child may not yet grasp is that death is permanent, that it happens to everyone, and that the body no longer works. Many young children ask the same question many times, as if they have not heard. That is not forgetfulness. It is the child's way of coming to understand something that is very large.

Here is what to avoid.

  • Avoid euphemisms that a child will take literally. "Gone to sleep," "passed away," "lost," "gone away," "taken": a child may be afraid of sleep or of travel, or may wait for the person to return.
  • Avoid saying that God took the person, as if God had chosen to remove a loved one for his own reasons. Whatever your tradition says about God's will, a young child can hear this as a God to fear.
  • Avoid saying "Do not cry" or "Be brave." The child's sadness is allowed.
  • Avoid long explanations. Short words are enough.
  • Avoid promising more than you know. If you do not know what happened or what will happen, say so.

What helps? Plain words said gently: "Grandma died. That means her body stopped working. She cannot come back. We are very sad. We will remember her." Then, in line with what the family believes: "We believe God is with her." Let the child cry, ask, go away and play, and return. Children often grieve in short bursts and move in and out of sadness quickly, which does not mean they do not care.

Here the community's role is limited and important. The family decides what the child is told about a death in the family. A volunteer who speaks to a child about a grandmother's death without knowing what the child has been told may contradict the parents or cut across their beliefs. If a child brings up a death in the family, listen warmly, say that you are sorry, and tell the child that you will tell the child's parents that the child is thinking about this. Then do, and also tell the person responsible for children's work. Where the family wants help, the pastor, priest or a trained person in grief support may be able to do more.

Different traditions speak differently about what happens after death: prayer for the dead, hope of resurrection, the , intercession, rest until the last day. This lecture does not settle that. It asks only that the volunteer not teach a young child something that the parents would not recognise as their own faith.

5. Respecting a child's prayers

Young children pray in many ways. They speak, they sing, they are quiet, they talk to God as to a friend, they pray for a cat, a broken toy and a grandmother in a hospital in one sentence. They may pray with their eyes open. They may pray very loudly or in a whisper.

Three habits help. First, do not correct a child's prayer. If the child says, "Dear God, thank you for my sandwich and please make my brother stop," the adult may smile, and say nothing more. The child is praying.

Second, do not use a child's prayer to teach a lesson. "Now let's remember that we should pray for others too" can turn a child's honest prayer into a performance. Teach by praying yourself in the child's hearing, in simple words.

Third, do not use a child's prayer as a way to pass a message. A child who says in prayer something about home that worries you has told you something; it does not mean you should pass it on to the group. Keep it quiet, and tell the person responsible if it seems to matter.

It is also fine to say the old words with a young child. The Lord's Prayer, a short blessing or a table grace gives the child words to hold and a sense of belonging to something older than the family. Many children learn such words long before they understand them, and that is also a way of learning.

6. The same facts in two kinds of community

In a liturgical parish, answers to children's questions often exist already in a shared form: a short , a set of prayers, an icon or a statue that stands for what the child is asking about. A volunteer can point to them: "Look at the picture. That is Mary, Jesus' mother." The risk is that the shared form answers a question the child has not asked. The remedy is to listen first.

In a free-church assembly, answers to questions may depend on the individual volunteer's own story and style. This can be warm and personal. The risk is that a child hears different things from different adults, or from one adult's private opinion. The remedy is for the people who work with young children to talk together about what they will say on the questions that come up most, and to share it with parents.

In both settings, the child needs to be able to ask, to be heard and to be told the truth in a size that fits.


Diagram 1. A child's question, step by step

A Young Child's Question: Five Steps Short, honest and warm; and know when to hand it to the family 1. Stop get to eye level 2. Ask back "What do you think?" 3. Answer one or two sentences 4. Wait let the child go on 5. Pass it on to parents, if needed What helps Short words, a calm face, a smile. "I do not know" when that is true. "People believe different things." The plain word: "died", not "gone". Telling the parent what the child asked. What harms Laughing, or a long lecture. Comfort that is not true. "God took her", "asleep", "gone away". "God is watching and will be cross." Telling a child about a death in the family. Hand it on when the question is about the family (a death, a divorce, an illness), or about what the parents teach, or the child seems frightened or says something that suggests harm: tell the person responsible.

In short

  • Piaget's map helps us see that young children think concretely, imaginatively and sometimes magically; it misses how much children differ and how much they can do in familiar tasks.
  • A good answer to a young child's question is short, honest and warm, and often begins with asking the child what the child thinks.
  • Comforting untruths and euphemisms for death ("asleep", "taken") can frighten a child and are better avoided.
  • The family decides what a child is told about a death in the family; the volunteer listens, comforts and tells the parents.
  • Respect a child's prayers: do not correct them, use them for a lesson or pass them on as messages.
  • "I do not know" and "people believe different things" are honest answers a young child can hold.
Front Back
Three features of young children's thinking Concrete thinking, imagination, and magical thinking. A map of tendencies, not a verdict on any child.
Short, honest, warm One or two sentences; true, including "I do not know"; calm and kind. Often begin by asking back.
What to avoid with death Euphemisms a child takes literally, "God took her", "do not cry", and telling a child about a family death before the parents have.
A child's prayer Receive it. Do not correct it, use it for a lesson, or pass it on.

One sentence to remember Answer a young child's question in a size the child can hold: short, true and kind.

This week's action Write down the three questions about God or death that young children in your community ask most often, and with the person responsible for children's work agree on one short, honest reply to each.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Recall a question about God or about death that you asked as a young child, or one you heard a child ask. How was it answered? How did the answer feel?
  • The lecture says that "short, honest, warm" beats both a long answer and a comforting untruth. Which of the three is hardest for you, and why?
  • Think of a phrase about death that adults in your community commonly use with children. Does the child hear what the adult means?
  • Who in your community speaks to the parents when a child has asked a hard question? Is there a way to do this easily and without blame?
  • How are children's own prayers received in your community? Is there a place for a prayer that is loud, odd or about a sandwich?
  • Matthew 18:2-3 puts a child in the middle. What would it look like for your community to put children's questions in the middle?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.