Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Child Is Not a Small Adult
- Lecture 1-2: How Children Grow: Body, Mind, Feeling, Relationships and Conscience
- Lecture 1-3: How Faith Grows
- Lecture 1-4: Culture, Family and Difference
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Seeing One Age Again
- Lecture 2-1: Safe Arms First
- Lecture 2-2: Play, Body and Senses
- Lecture 2-3: Their Questions, Their God
- Lecture 2-4: Babies, Toddlers and Their Carers in the Gathering
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Hour With the Very Young
- Lecture 3-1: Stories, Pictures and Concrete Thinking
- Lecture 3-2: Rules, Fairness and Friends
- Lecture 3-3: First-Hand Faith: Questions, Doubt and Belonging
- Lecture 3-4: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Answering One Child's Question
- Lecture 4-1: A Body and Brain on the Move
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I and Where Do I Belong?
- Lecture 4-3: Questions, Doubt and Owning Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Adult Who Stays
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Before a Hard Question
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Friends and the Online World
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing a Troubled Heart
- Lecture 5-3: Families of Every Shape
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Tells You Something Terrible
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence
(An invented example.) Amina is eight. When her Sunday-school teacher asks her a question, she looks at the floor and says very little. The teacher, who was raised to believe that looking someone in the eye shows honesty, wonders if Amina is hiding something. Amina’s grandmother, who raised her, taught her that a child shows respect to an elder by lowering the eyes and speaking only when asked. The two adults are seeing the same child. They are reading her through two different childhoods.
The last two lectures gave maps of growth and of faith. Both maps have a weakness that this lecture must name: they describe a child as if there were one childhood. There is not. Who raises a child, what counts as respect, what a child may say to an adult, how much a child works, how long childhood lasts, and what a family expects of a young person all differ among cultures, families and eras. And inside every culture, children differ from one another by temperament, ability, health and experience. Some of them have disabilities or think and sense the world in a different way, and that is part of the ordinary picture of children, not an appendix to it.
The principle is the same as before: a map of growth helps us see a child; it must never be used to judge one. Here it has a sharp edge. If the map is drawn from one place and one kind of family, it will make children from other places and other families look wrong. The aim of this lecture is to help the adult see the child in front of them, and to treat the difference as something to learn about, not to correct.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Give at least four examples of how childhood differs among cultures, families and eras.
- Explain why one country’s picture of childhood must not become the standard for all children.
- Describe temperament, disability and neurodivergence as part of the ordinary range of children.
- Explain why labels such as "difficult" or "slow" harm, and what to say instead.
- Name three habits for learning about a child’s family without questioning the child.
Behold, children are a heritage of Yahweh. The fruit of the womb is his reward." — Psalm 127:3
World English Bible
They were bringing to him little children, that he should touch them, but the disciples rebuked those who were bringing them. But when Jesus saw it, he was moved with indignation, and said to them, “Allow the little children to come to me! Don’t forbid them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these. Most certainly I tell you, whoever will not receive the Kingdom of God like a little child, he will in no way enter into it.” He took them in his arms, and blessed them, laying his hands on them." — Mark 10:13-16
WEB
For you formed my inmost being. You knit me together in my mother’s womb. I will give thanks to you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Your works are wonderful. My soul knows that very well." — Psalm 139:13-14
WEB
Psalm 127:3 names children as a "heritage" and a "reward" from Yahweh, whoever they are and however they arrive. Mark 10 shows adults who knew who deserved the teacher’s time, and Jesus’ strong reaction to that. Psalm 139:13-14 says that each person is "fearfully and wonderfully made", and it does not say that only some are.
1. There is no single childhood
Try a small exercise. Picture a child at a church door. How old is the child? Who is holding the child’s hand? What is the child wearing? Is the child allowed to speak to the priest or pastor? Who did the child sleep beside last night? Who will pick the child up?
If you are honest, the picture you made had a particular country, family and time in it. Readers of this course live in many places, and each reader’s picture will be different. Here are some of the ways in which childhoods differ. The list is general, and any one of the differences can be a gift or a harm depending on the case.
Who raises the child. In some communities, a child is raised mainly by two parents. In others, grandparents, aunts and uncles, older siblings, neighbours or a whole village share the work. In others, a parent is working far away, and a relative or a boarding school stands in. In some places, a child may live with more than one household. A teacher who speaks of "your mum and dad" may be speaking to a child for whom those words do not describe the home.
What counts as respect. In some cultures a child shows respect by meeting an adult’s eyes; in others, by lowering them. In some, a child who asks an adult "why?" is curious and is encouraged; in others, the same question may sound like a challenge. In some, a child greets every visitor; in others, children are expected to stay quiet until spoken to. Many adults wrongly read these habits as qualities of the child’s character.
What a child may say to an adult. In some homes a child may argue and be listened to. In others, a child who disagrees is seen as disrespectful. In some communities, a child speaks for the family in public; in others, an adult always does. A teacher who prizes "speaking up" and a family that prizes "listening well" will each see the other’s child as lacking.
Independence and belonging. Some cultures treat a child’s growing independence as the sign of a healthy childhood: sleeping alone, choosing, speaking one’s mind. Others treat a child’s growing place in the family and its duties as the sign: helping, caring for younger ones, deferring to elders. Each has strengths. A map which lists independence as the goal, as some of the research in lecture 1-2 does, will make the second kind of child look as if she is not growing.
Work and play. In some places, children are expected to be at school and play for most of the day. In others, children also help in the home, in the fields, in a shop, or in caring for others, as part of belonging. Children’s work can be a way of belonging and learning, and it can also harm a child who is overworked, kept from school or put at risk; the line is drawn differently in different places, and the law differs by country. Our task here is not to draw the line for the reader but to say: do not assume that a child who works is a child who is not loved.
Language and belonging. A child may speak one language at home, another at school and a third at church. A child who has moved from another country may be learning a language, a set of customs and a new place at once. A child who is quiet may be thinking in another language.
Era. Childhood itself has changed. Many of today’s ideas about a long, protected childhood, and about "teenagers" as a separate group, are fairly recent in the history of many societies. Previous generations, and elders now living, may have had very different childhoods. A grandparent’s sense of what a child should be able to do at ten may come from a world that asked more, or less.
2. Not one country’s childhood as the standard
The difficulty is not that these differences exist. The difficulty is that a person who works with children is likely to use their own childhood, or their own country’s picture of a good one, as the standard, without noticing. The research behind much of lecture 1-2 was done in particular societies. The books on parenting, the programmes for children and the training for leaders are often written from one setting and exported. Each of us carries a model of "how a child should be" so deeply that it feels like common sense.
This lecture asks for a particular habit: to notice when you are measuring a child against your own childhood. When you find yourself thinking "she is too quiet", "he is too forward", "that family doesn’t help", stop and ask: "Compared with what?" Often the answer is "compared with what I was used to". That is information about you, not about the child.
This habit applies to all of us, including the writers of this course. A course in English, read in many countries, has a viewpoint. Where any example here fits your children poorly, trust what you know of them.
This is not a call to believe that everything in every culture is good for children. Some customs harm children; some families harm children; some communities do. Safety and dignity matter in every place, and a leader follows the community’s written safeguarding policy and local law when a child may be at risk. The point is narrower: before you decide that a child or a family is the problem, find out what you are looking at.
3. The ordinary range inside every culture
Even within one family, no two children are alike. A few of the ordinary differences:
Temperament. Some children are quick to approach and others slow to warm up. Some are intense and some placid. Some are very active and some are watchful. Some are sensitive to noise, crowds, textures or changes in routine. A great deal of what adults call "behaviour" is temperament meeting a setting that does not suit it. A watchful child is not unfriendly; a very active child is not disrespectful; an intense child is not "too much". Teachers and leaders have noticed such differences for a very long time, and researchers have described them. The rule here is simple: adjust the setting before you correct the child.
Health and ability. Some children live with long-term illness, pain, tiredness, poor sight or hearing, difficulty moving, difficulty with speech, or learning that takes a different path. Some children have a disability from birth, and some from an accident or illness. These children are not exceptions to the picture of childhood; they are children. They grow, they play, they pray, they have friends and they have questions. Lecture 3-4 returns to belonging for these children.
Neurodivergence. Some children think, sense and communicate in ways that differ from what most others do. Among the words used are autism, ADHD, dyslexia and dyspraxia. Families use different words, and so do countries; some families have a diagnosis and some do not, and in many places a diagnosis is hard to get. A leader is not a doctor and does not try to name what a child "has". What a leader can do is to notice what helps: a quiet corner, a clear order for the hour, fewer surprises, a picture timetable, a calm voice, extra time, permission to move, a job to do with the hands. Such things help many children, and cost little.
Experience. Some children have known loss, moves, illness in the family, hardship, fear or a hard year. Their behaviour may be a way of coping. A leader does not ask about it, probes nothing and does not guess. A leader offers steadiness, and if a child tells something that worries you, lecture 5-4 gives the way to listen and to pass it on.
4. Labels
Adults use labels all the time: "shy", "bossy", "a handful", "slow", "gifted", "difficult", "naughty", "special". A few are kindly meant and a few are meant to be fair. They all share a problem. A label describes the adult’s experience of the child (this child is hard for me) and turns it into a fact about the child. Once a label is on, people see the label first. A child called "difficult" is watched for difficulty. A child called "slow" is asked less. A child called "gifted" may be burdened with expectations.
Phrases such as "problem child" are often used. This course does not use them as teaching terms, because they place the trouble inside the child, and the child hears. Try instead to describe what you saw, and what helped:
- Not "He is a difficult child," but "He found it hard to stay seated after the long song, and he settled when he was given something to carry."
- Not "She is shy," but "She watches for a while and then joins in once she knows what is going to happen."
- Not "He is slow," but "He needs time and a picture to follow the instructions."
The second form is longer. It is also more useful, because it tells the next adult what to do. And it leaves the child free to be different next week.
5. What Jesus did with the people who knew who deserved his time
Mark 10:13-16 repeats a scene we met in Matthew. People bring children for Jesus to touch. The disciples rebuke the people who bring them. Mark adds a detail the other Gospels do not: when Jesus saw it, "he was moved with indignation." It is a strong word. Jesus is angry at the people who stand between children and himself.
Then he says: "Allow the little children to come to me! Don’t forbid them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these." And finally "He took them in his arms, and blessed them, laying his hands on them."
Notice what is not in the passage. There is no test at the door. No one is asked their age, their abilities, their behaviour or their family. The disciples may have thought they were keeping order. The passage is clear that order of this kind is not what Jesus wanted. All the children who were brought were received.
A community that wishes to follow this must ask honestly: who, in our experience, is still being kept from the door? The child with an unfamiliar language? The one who moves a great deal? The one with the loud voice? The child of a family that does not look like the family of the pictures on our walls? Each community will have its own answers. The question is not an accusation but an exercise in noticing.
6. Learning about a family without questioning a child
An adult who wants to understand a child’s world has a delicate task. A child should never be questioned about the home, and should not have to explain a family to a leader. Three habits help.
- Ask the family, kindly and in private, about the child. "What helps Ben feel at home in a group?" is a good question. Most families are glad to be asked, and know a great deal. Follow the community’s policy about who may speak with families and how.
- Learn the vocabulary of the home. Use the names a child uses for the people in the child’s life. Do not assume that "mum and dad" are the words.
- Take cultural information from the people it belongs to. Do not guess about a family’s customs from a country’s name. If you are unsure, say so and ask: "I would like to understand. How does your family think about this?"
These habits work in a large parish with a staff member who keeps a list and in a small assembly where everyone knows everyone. In a large parish, the risk is that nobody asks. In a small assembly, the risk is that everyone thinks they already know.
7. Gift and dignity
Psalm 127:3 calls children a "heritage of Yahweh" and a "reward". Psalm 139:14 says, "I am fearfully and wonderfully made." These are not only about children who find it easy to be a child in our settings. They are about every child, with every temperament, health, language and family. A community that learns to say this in practice does not do so by lowering its hopes for children. It does so by looking at each child as someone God has made, and asking, "What does this child need in order to belong here?"
Diagram 1. Before you decide what is wrong with a child
In short
- Childhood differs among cultures, families and eras in who raises children, what counts as respect, what a child may say, how much a child works, and how long childhood lasts.
- Do not make one country’s or one family’s childhood the standard; when you judge a child, ask "compared with what?"
- Temperament, disability and neurodivergence are part of the ordinary range of children, and adjusting the setting comes before correcting the child.
- Labels describe the adult’s experience as if it were the child’s nature; describe what you saw and what helped instead.
- Mark 10:13-16: Jesus is indignant at those who keep children away, and receives every child who is brought.
- Learn about a family by asking the family, never by questioning the child, and follow the written policy and local law where a child may be at risk.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The question to ask before judging | "Compared with what?" Often the answer is the adult’s own childhood. |
| Adjust or correct? | Adjust the setting before you correct the child. |
| A better way than a label | Say what you saw and what helped, not what the child is. |
| How to learn about a child’s home | Ask the family, kindly and in private; never question the child. |
One sentence to remember Every child is fearfully and wonderfully made, so before you ask what is wrong with the child, ask what the child needs in order to belong.
This week’s action Replace one label you use for a child with a sentence about what you saw and what helped.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What was your own childhood like in terms of who raised you, what counted as respect, and what you could say to an adult? How does that shape what you expect of children now?
- Think of a time when you read a child’s behaviour one way and later learned another reason for it. What did you learn?
- What labels are used in your community for children? What do they do to how adults treat those children? What could be said in their place?
- In Mark 10:13-16, the disciples rebuked those who brought the children. Who might still be kept at the door of your community, often without anyone meaning to?
- What are two or three small changes (in the room, the order of the hour, the way instructions are given) that would help many different children, not only one?
- What is a way for you to learn about a child’s family that is respectful of the family and does not put the child in the middle?